
I would like to collect all the books and burn them
The thirteenth anniversary of the State Emergency Committee was marked by another victory of capitalism: the liquidation of one of the largest national book depositories. On August 19, bailiffs began removing the holdings of the State Public Scientific and Technical Library from the building on Slavyanskaya Square (formerly Nogin Square) in Moscow, where they had been located since 1963. Now these books will be placed in Balashikha near Moscow. The reason for the event is that the building in the center of the capital, where the Ministry of Metallurgy used to be located, and now there is a sign “House of Metallurgist”, was in a certain era privatized by Intermetservice OJSC. The new owner defended his right in the courts for many years and finally began to implement it - he needed the space occupied by the library for completely different needs: “The cherry orchard is now mine.”
The lawyer who represented the interests of the library in all litigations, Yuri Kireev, noted : “The key problem is that the Russian Ministry of Property was on the side of the “privatizers” and does not protect federal property, which would be logical.” In any case, the executive branch had many opportunities to intervene. The privatization of an administrative building, especially one that houses the largest book depository of one of the leading national public libraries, cannot but raise questions. Was there any fraud involved, for example, in the manner of the fraud during the privatization of OJSC Apatit, for which Khodorkovsky and Lebedev are now on trial and in custody? Even if the letter of the law was on the side of a private company, the executive branch could at least impose a moratorium in the manner of a praetor's interdict: a powerful order issued by Roman magistrates when adherence to the letter of ancient civil law was clearly contrary to justice.
This story echoes the recent unauthorized seizure by the religious community of the Church of the Resurrection of Christ in Kadashi, which paralyzed the work of the Grabar Research and Restoration Center located there since 1964. In both cases, state interests suffer, the museum and library retreat, and non-governmental organizations win. At the same time, the scandal with the library began to be intensively covered by the media (mainly in neutral terms) only when the export of books had already begun and it was too late to prevent it.
It turns out that the government, personified by Putin, daily reproached for authoritarianism, in fact cares only about fiscal issues, the fight against espionage, about its own security both from the claims of big business and from the extravagant antics of individual political groups, and not at all about museums and libraries worried. Meanwhile, if Putin were a consistent statist, if he cared, in particular, about the right of citizens “to participate in cultural life and use cultural institutions, to have access to cultural values” (Part 2, Article 44 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation), then an enlightened society would forgive him for any ambiguity regarding, for example, Khodorkovsky , Sutyagin or the National Bolsheviks . Nowadays, the appearance of Russian power is acquiring somewhat barbaric features.
However, the opposition did not react in any way to the library scandal. Neither the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, nor Yabloko, nor Rodina with their daring youth organizations, nor the dashing National Bolsheviks - no one held protests, no one handcuffed themselves, no one threw themselves under the wheels of trucks transporting literature. But if a decisive action was carried out, there was a chance to turn the tide.
Buza in the name of Order
Actually, as far as the NBP is concerned , such a party, strictly speaking, does not exist in Russia. The National Bolsheviks did not have the strength to create a party that would meet the requirements of the law “On Political Parties”: at least ten thousand members in more than half of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, etc. There is an interregional public association "National Bolshevik Party", registered in the Moscow region. In principle, the law “On Public Associations” allows the activities of unregistered associations, but none of them has the right to call themselves a party without being one in accordance with the law “On Political Parties”.
The National Bolsheviks adopted new rules of the game and introduced an amendment to their charter, according to which their association should be further referred to as the “National Bolshevik Order.” But the Ministry of Justice refused to approve the latest version of the charter. And on August 21, the Moscow Regional Court began to consider the claim of the prosecutor’s office to cancel the registration of the NBP precisely on the grounds that this association calls itself a party contrary to the law. Lawyer Sergei Belyak, representing the interests of the NBP, petitioned to suspend the consideration of the case until a decision was made by the Zyuzinsky District Court of Moscow, in which the National Bolsheviks appealed the decision of the Ministry of Justice to refuse to register changes to the charter. The Moscow Regional Court agreed with his arguments and postponed the case until September 23.
So, ironically, the association, whose members became famous as the most dashing troublemakers, wants to be called the “National Bolshevik Order.” And this vividly recalls the oxymoron of slogans in Orwell's book "1984". However, the program and activities of the NBP are full of glaring internal logical contradictions.
And it is quite likely that the competent state bodies in the near future will classify the NBP as an “extremist community” prohibited by law, whose activities are aimed at calls for a violent change in the constitutional system (“Russian revolution”), inciting hatred and enmity, etc. The NBP program, provocative, shocking, utopian, illogical, written with grammatical errors, deliberately evoking in the public analogies with fascist parties and movements in world history, provides many reasons for such assessments. This program is somewhat reminiscent of the 1990 LDPSS program, which Vladimir Zhirinovsky almost personally typed out on an old typewriter. By the way, at that time lawyer Belyak was the defender of Zhirinovsky, against whom accusations were pouring out like a cornucopia.
Of course, the principles and slogans of the NBP can be perceived as a farce, as the buffoonery of young people grouped around marginal artists and avant-garde writers whose only goal is shocking. But government agencies, by definition, are required to take every word seriously. Another thing is that the assessment of any crime expressed in words is always a subjective matter.
Insulting ten-ruble note
For example, does the expression “Russia without Putin” offend anyone? Insult, according to the letter of the criminal law, is “humiliation of the honor and dignity of another person, expressed in an indecent form.” It is impossible to find an unambiguous meaning in these same three words - let alone humiliation of honor and dignity, especially in an indecent form. A banal political slogan. Nevertheless, the FSB and the prosecutor's office of the Zelenograd district of the Kaliningrad region qualified the fact of stamping this slogan on ten-ruble bills by 25-year-old printing worker, member of the NBP Mikhail Kostyaev under Article 319 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation as an “insult to a representative of the authorities” of Russian President Vladimir Putin.
The Zelenograd magistrate reacted to this paradoxical indictment no less paradoxically. He pointed out to the state prosecution that the victim, Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin, had not been questioned and proposed to eliminate this shortcoming of the preliminary investigation. The prosecutor's office, seemingly devoid of any sense of humor, stands its ground and demands a review of the judge's decision.
Indeed, the main object of this crime is not a person at all (as is the case with a common object in accordance with Article 130 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation), but the “order of management”. Damage has been caused to the authority of the authorities as such. Therefore, according to Article 319 of the Criminal Code, only public insult is punishable and only when a representative of the government is performing his official duties or in connection with their performance. And this is a matter of public, not private accusation, as in the case of insulting a citizen of a general nature (for example, in the case of Aroyan v. Kirkorov). That is, it is not the victim who decides whether to consider himself insulted, but government bodies can and are obliged to bring the perpetrator to criminal liability, regardless of the will of the victim.
The circle of government representatives is very wide: this includes a policeman, a forester, a tax inspector, and a people’s vigilante. Of course, the President of the Russian Federation is also a representative of the authorities. In this case, the insult qualified by Article 319 of the Criminal Code must be inflicted on the president precisely in connection with the performance of his duties as head of state. That is, if someone critically and in an obscene manner evaluates, for example, Putin’s behavior as a judoka, or a mountain skier, or a dog lover, or a family man, then this cannot be qualified under Article 319 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. Such a detractor can only be prosecuted under Article 130 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, but only if Putin himself considers himself offended and files an application in court, like any citizen.
Is Putin a victim if the local authorities opened a case of insulting him as president with some inscription on a fence in a remote province? Most likely not, since according to the legal definition of the concept of “victim”, which is contained in the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation (Part 1, Article 42), “a victim is an individual to whom physical, property, and moral harm has been caused by a crime.” The inscription on the fence cannot cause any such harm to Putin if he has never even seen the fence. The harm will be caused exclusively to the authority of the authorities. Consequently, Article 319 does not necessarily presuppose the presence of a victim, like many other articles of the criminal code: “high treason”, “illegal hunting”, “water pollution”, “illegal carrying of weapons”, “illegal possession of drugs”, etc. d.
But let's return to the specific case in Zelenograd. Of course, there is no reason to involve Putin in this case as a victim. He cannot be a victim, since he did not see the “seditious” ten-ruble notes. But raising the question of insulting the authorities with the words “Russia without Putin” is extremely absurd and outrageous. Let's say without Putin. So what? Why not, in fact? What is humiliating, let alone obscene, about this? Such an excessively zealous application of the law may be reminiscent of the practice of applying Article 58 in the Stalin years and, of course, discredits the authorities.
However, the difference in sanctions is colossal. After all, a person guilty of “insulting a representative of the authorities” faces, in the worst case, a fine of forty thousand rubles. Ironically, public insult of a citizen in general (Part 2, Article 130 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation) is estimated to be twice as expensive: eighty thousand rubles. Kirkorov, as we remember, his verbal intemperance cost sixty thousand rubles.
Another thing is that the National Bolshevik Kostyaev put this stamp on banknotes during the presidential election campaign. Consequently, he committed an administrative offense - “production or distribution of anonymous propaganda materials” (Article 5.12 of the Code of Administrative Offenses of the Russian Federation). A citizen guilty of this offense is fined in the amount of one thousand to one and a half thousand rubles. In order to comply with the requirements of the law prohibiting anonymous campaigning, he should have written, for example: “Russia without Putin”, edition of 67 copies, produced and ordered by Mikhail Ivanovich Kostyaev, Kaliningrad region, Zelenogradsk, st. Lenina, 1, apt. 13". But in the case under consideration, it is also impossible to bring Kostyaev to administrative responsibility, since the FSB established his identity only in May. Consequently, by that time the two-month statute of limitations established by law for bringing him to administrative responsibility had expired (Article 4.5 of the Code of Administrative Offenses of the Russian Federation).
Plato's torment
Medical forecasts, it must be said, are also always subjective. On August 19, the defense of Platon Lebedev, accused of fraud and other crimes before the Meshchansky District Court of Moscow, once again began to struggle to ensure that the stiff-necked jailers, exhausted by a serious illness, were handed over to the hands of doctors. According to lawyer Evgeniy Baru, Lebedev is on the brink of the grave and can only be saved by the help of skilled overseas physicians who are rushing to his aid from everywhere. But this requires suspending the trial and releasing Lebedev from custody.
Natalya Chopin, a correspondent for the Ekho Moskvy radio station , who was in the courtroom, noted that the dying Lebedev looked completely normal, but, according to lawyers, he has an iron will and knows how to hide his unspeakable suffering. The heroism and nobility of Platon Lebedev extends even further: since March, he has refused a medical examination in a pre-trial detention center, “so that prison doctors would not be subject to pressure from the prosecutor’s office.” As a result, Baru got an ambulance summoned to court for his client. The doctors from the emergency room stated that Lebedev had high blood pressure and that after the injection he would be able to continue participating in the process.
The next day, August 20 , and then August 23, the first witness was questioned - the former general director of Apatit OJSC Anatoly Pozdnyakov. According to the prosecution, Khodorkovsky and Lebedev took over the Apatit plant through fraud. To the delight of the defense and to the chagrin of the prosecutors, the witness told how bad the plant's business was before it was bought, and how then it became good. As for the failure to fulfill the investment program, they say that the investor, when buying the plant, did not know how bad things were and took on investment obligations in the heat of the moment. But in any case, Pozdnyakov clearly confirmed that the plant was actually purchased not by JSC Volna, but by Khodorkovsky’s structures. The question arises: why did Khodorkovsky need to hide behind some kind of “Volna” if there was a legal transaction without a shadow of trickery?
Sutyagin and litigiousness
Likewise, it is not clear why foreign citizens Nadia Locke and Sean Kidd would hide behind the non-existent British consulting firm Alternative of Futures by regularly communicating abroad with Russian military expert Igor Sutyagin , if they were not foreign intelligence officers? So it is not surprising that on August 17, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation upheld the verdict against Sutyagin, passed on April 7 by the Moscow City Court based on the jury’s verdict. 39-year-old Sutyagin was found guilty of high treason in the form of espionage (Article 275 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation). He was sentenced to 15 years in prison.
Sutyagin’s defense (carried out by four lawyers led by the eminent Boris Kuznetsov) emphasizes in his justification that Sutyagin, being the head of the sector at the Institute of the USA and Canada of the Russian Academy of Sciences, did not have access to classified information and analyzed only open sources, drawing information of a military-strategic nature mainly from newspapers. The prosecution, on the contrary, claims that Sutyagin also used secret information, although he did not have legal access to it. After all, a classic foreign spy usually does not have such access, but he obtains information. However, this whole dispute is not so significant. For, according to the legal definition, which is contained in Article 276 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, “espionage” is the collection, storage and transmission of not only secret information, but any other information, if this is done on the instructions of foreign intelligence.
Of course, not a single intelligence service in the world recognized Sutyagin as its agent, but it would be ridiculous to expect this. On the other hand, if the convict’s foreign employer, who paid him a thousand pounds sterling a month for analytical notes not intended for publication, had been a legal structure, he would have appeared long ago and defended his employee. That did not happen. And the scientist himself previously admitted that he guessed: in front of him were foreign intelligence officers. But Amnesty International came out in defense of Sutyagin. This international human rights organization included a Russian convicted of espionage on the list of political prisoners, which surprised even his lawyer Boris Kuznetsov.
So, most likely, Europe will help Sutyagin - through the Strasbourg court. He can predict the fate of the Romanian “urban partisan” Ilascu: freedom and monetary compensation loom ahead. But first, Sutyagin must have to suffer in prison for several more years, as 50 thousand cases from different countries are waiting in the European Court of Human Rights.
Divide and rule
Of course, the Supreme Court of the Republic of Dagestan, for example, works more quickly, which began on August 20 to consider a criminal case against eight Chechens from Ruslan Gelayev’s detachment. Four of them were captured in battle in Dagestan in December, and four others were later handed over to Georgia. Everyone is charged with this fight as an “attack on the life of a law enforcement officer” (Article 317 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation), which provides for punishment in the form of imprisonment for a term of 12 to 20 years or life imprisonment and even the death penalty, which, however, is subject to a moratorium , imposed by the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation. It would seem that there could not be a stricter sanction, but as a makeweight they were also charged with “participation in an illegal armed formation” (Article 208 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation) and even “inciting hatred and enmity” (Article 282 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation).
At the same time, Russian President Vladimir Putin demonstrates his special affection for the “peaceful Chechens.” First of all, to the late President of Chechnya Akhmat Kadyrov, born on August 23, and his clan. The Moscow government, acting on an unofficial request from the Kremlin, decided to name a new street in Yuzhny Butovo after Kadyrov. The pre-election nature of this “distribution of carrots” is not difficult to discern even without glasses. Putin follows the rule of the Roman conquerors in Chechnya: Divide et impera (divide and conquer).
The Moscow branch of the Yabloko party considered the naming of a capital street after Kadyrov a reason to be outraged, citing the fact that the Moscow law was violated, according to which streets can be named after prominent citizens only ten years after their death. However, in reality, Yabloko cannot challenge the relevant resolution of the Moscow government in court, as was announced. This is the prerogative of the prosecutor's office. The only thing Yabloko can do is make a corresponding request to the prosecutor's office.
Don't throw a journalist into a thorn bush
At one time, the chairman of the board of directors of the Russobit concern and at the same time the chairman of the intellectual property committee of the Russian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Oleg Gordeyko, resorted to the help of the prosecutor's office. Based on his statement, a criminal case was opened under Part 2 of Article 129 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation - “slander contained in the media” against 24-year-old correspondent of the Computerra publishing house Dmitry Korovin.
On November 18, 2002, Korovin published an article “Only one should remain...”, in which he argued that Russobit was piracy, and since Gordeiko simultaneously held a post in the Chamber of Commerce and Industry, he could monopolize the market. The maximum that Korovin could face was a fine of up to 120 thousand rubles. If the opposing party brought a civil suit against him and the publication in defense of honor, dignity and business reputation (under Article 152 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation), then it could demand at least a million dollars as compensation for moral damage. Moreover, the plaintiff’s chances of winning such a process would be quite high, and the journalist would not have to count on the sympathy of his colleagues. These are the stereotypes of public perception: the criminal process is associated with Siberia and shackles, while the civil process is perceived neutrally, no matter how ruinous the court decision may be for the defendant.
Almost the entire journalistic workshop rallied around the young colleague: “We won’t give up our Bukharchik!” The famous lawyer Larisa Polyakova took over Korovin’s defense. For some reason, the press saw sophisticated deceit in the victim’s behavior: they say, he was afraid to quarrel with a reputable publishing house and attacked the boy. Meanwhile, it was foolish to assume that Computerra would maintain a good attitude towards someone who prosecutes its employee. The result was quite expected: on August 17, the Simonovsky District Court of Moscow issued an acquittal. And while the process lasted, Korovin managed to give out so many interviews and become the hero of so many favorable publications than he himself, perhaps, wrote in his entire career.
The motivation for the verdict is quite obvious: without going into establishing the reliability of the facts stated in the publication, the court stated that correspondent Korovin had no slanderous intent. Because everything he wrote is a compilation of what he read in other media - it doesn’t matter that there are no links in the article itself. Consequently, if the young journalist’s statements do not correspond to reality, then he could be honestly mistaken. If the court had considered the issue from the perspective of civil law, then everything would have looked completely different: the journalist would have to take on the burden of proof (onus probandi) and prove that the facts correspond to reality, which is usually very difficult. Responsibility would be placed on the author and the editors regardless of whether there was intent in their actions. The court simply would not find out.
Noble character
There is also no complete clarity regarding the misadventures of German Galdetsky, a 19-year-old student from the Moscow region, who was wounded on March 25 in a fight with two men near the capital’s Yaroslavsky railway station. On August 20, the young man arrived in Vilnius. It turns out that his mother is a citizen of Lithuania.
Since Galdetsky was known as a whistleblower of police officers serving in the Moscow metro, the story of his injury came out extremely loud. The investigation of the case was undertaken by a team of the Investigative Department of the Moscow Main Internal Affairs Directorate, headed by a major general, and the Minister of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, Rashid Nurgaliev, took this issue under his control. And soon it was officially announced that the police officers had nothing to do with this crime.
Allegedly, Galdetsky became the victim of a domestic quarrel with his drinking buddies. Allegedly, he came to sort out relations “with the gypsies who deceived him.” The dispute escalated into a fight, during which Galdetsky used his Osa barrelless pistol with a traumatic charge. However, the enemy grabbed the pistol from him and shot Herman in the head with it. The consequences turned out to be so serious that the young man spent a long time in the Sklifosovsky Research Institute, where he underwent several operations. By the way, "Wasp" is a civilian self-defense weapon that came into fashion this spring. No special permit is required to purchase and carry it - not even the same as for a gas weapon. However, from this story it follows that in terms of destructive power, the Osa will give odds to a gas pistol.
The actions of the policemen whom Galdetsky exposed resemble an erotic thriller. According to his version, law enforcement officers detained young attractive women under the guise of checking documents and forced them to perform acts of a sexual nature. In turn, the police officers who suspected the young man allegedly explained to him that these were not random ladies, but prostitutes. The Department of Internal Security of the Moscow City Internal Affairs Directorate, having checked the facts stated by the student, stated that they were not confirmed. A number of criminal cases initiated recently and sentences passed irrefutably indicate disorder in the police serving in the capital’s subway, as well as the fact that the police leadership is not at all going to hush up the facts and condone criminals in their ranks. However, the fact that those responsible for wounding Galdetsky have not yet been identified is a little confusing.
As for Herman Galdetsky, his Lithuanian roots allow us to draw a parallel with his fellow countryman Arturas Sakalauskas. It seems that in both cases, the traditions of the proud Polish-Lithuanian gentry pushed young people to actions that were unconventional for Russian reality.
On February 23, 1987, a private of the internal troops of the USSR Ministry of Internal Affairs, Sakalauskas, who was escorting prisoners from Leningrad to Siberia, shot all eight of his colleagues who were in the carriage with him. This happened when the train was passing through the territory of the Vologda region: oh, the Vologda convoy doesn’t like to joke! The reason for the execution of his colleagues was hazing, and the last straw was the attempted rape of a young man by two old-timers. The Lithuanian reacted to the shame like a Roman legionnaire. However, he did not put the last bullet into his own forehead, but grabbed the weapon, the belongings of the dead and went on the run. He did not feel sentimental: on the way he could have robbed the people who sheltered him.
In Leningrad, the guy was arrested. A jury today might have acquitted him. But then either execution or an “eternal bed” awaited him. The second one came out.