
The performance of Freeman Dyson in Fian was programmed to leave people disappointed. Or, conversely, fascinated by amazing ideas of an amazing elderly Englishman who has long been living in the United States. However, who has how, but I had a special, albeit a little ridiculous, the reason for disappointment. She was also programmed, but about her later.
The forecast is impossible
Freeman Dyson’s current visit to Russia is far from the first. And it cannot be said that he was an unknown person with us. The words of our university lecturer in ancient student times that the first successful experience in building a calibration and invariant quantum theory of the field was carried out by Feinman, Shwinger and Dyson, for which Feynman, Schwinger and Tomonag received the Nobel Prize, none of my classmates were surprised. We were then familiar with the names of all four defendants in the case, and many of us confidently operated on by Dyson propaganda, hoping the Feynman diagrams when they solved the problems of quantum electrodynamics. And besides, the semi-popular-polar articles in the magazines “Nature” and “UMN” regularly appeared, and they were beautiful.
From what was then printed, I especially remember two plots. The first is about zero adaptation. We are talking about the distant evolution of the Universe, where its fate, from the point of view of the general theory of relativity, can go according to one of the two scenarios: either the Universe will continue to expand, more and more cooling, or begin to compress and heat up again. In the second scenario, sooner or later she will have to go through the state of thermodynamic balance, and everything is clear with life and mind here. But in the first, according to Dyson, life has a chance. Just need to get used to not breathing and generally do without an atmosphere. The speeds of all processes should rush to zero, but this is not scary - everything in the universe will have to slow down, and the whole eternity will be time.
The second plot is about Francis Crick (Francis Crick), a talented English physics. During the war, the scream began to work in the military department, where he did something connected with submarines, and he did not like it much. “Military science, ” he said once at a meeting of Dyson, “ has a little relation to science as military music to music.” After the war, the scream wanted to leave his work and not engage in physics anymore. He was attracted by biology. “You are wrong, ” Dyson tried to dissuade a scream from a rash step. - In the distant perspective, biology will become more exciting, but in very distant. The next twenty years will still belong to physics. Switching now to biology, you will be too old by the time when it finally comes forward. ” Just seven years later, it became clear that this forecast was completely erroneous.
Public lectures and popular books by Dyson, in my opinion, illustrate Maxim Mark Twain that "there is something exciting in science: you will invest some trifling number of facts, and you take a tremendous dividend in the form of conclusions, and even with interest." Perhaps it is the obvious confirmation of it in the case of a scream and the obvious errone of the made both him and in relation to the biology of the forecast pushed Dyson to build exciting and beautiful reasoning about the future life on our planet and beyond, outside the atmosphere and even, most likely, outside the solar system.
However, my thoughts about social justice and the role of science in its achievement were always close to me. “Most often, science cannot tell us that it will be about it. But science gives us a chance that it will happen that without science would never have happened. If we show wisdom and correctly use the capabilities offered by us science, then the world we leave will be a little better than the one we came to, ” he wrote five years ago. The same thought, but otherwise formulated, already sounded from his mouth earlier, it also sounded in March in Fian. Only this time, he decided to replace the words about “erroneous forecasts” with discussions about “heresies”, as if we are not talking about the free scientific knowledge of the world, but about the religious dogma.
Word and meaning
Having moved beyond the limits of the Earth and even, possibly, the solar system, the human mind will have to learn how to do without a human body. The dream of eternal life fills Dyson’s science with a meaning, but removes it from the generally accepted ideal, according to which to talk about eternity ... well, how to say it ... indecent or something. I suspect that the tendency to the discussions of indecent became the brake that did not allow the Nobel Committee to return to the question of awarding Dyson.
Although, on the other hand, this is what discovered his path to Russian mystical philosophy, known in the West under a more or less vague generalizing term “cosmism”. Dyson himself does not hide that it was the desire to find out what exactly wrote Vernadsky and Tsiolkovsky in the 20-30s, prompted him to study the Russian language. And even criticizing Brian Green for his book “Elegant Universe”, Dyson did not fail to bring Vernadsky as a positive example.
In an effort to comprehend the eternal being of both Vernadsky and Tsiolkovsky - religious thinkers, although not Christian. The religiosity of Vernadsky was manifested to a lesser extent, as well as the non -Christian nature of this religiosity. And Dyson here turns out to be a more follower of Tsiolkovsky, and not Vernadsky, although his “Dyson sphere” fits into a greater extent into a series of “biosphere - noosphere - technosphere”, i.e. In a number of categories, obviously close to the followers of Vernadsky. And arguing about cosmic life and cosmic mind, Dyson never amuses himself with the thought of the resurrection of all dead and the resettlement of their souls in endless space. In this regard, the “cosmism of Dyson” in its realism is closer to the “cosmism of Vernadsky”.
In general, the religiosity of Dyson is extremely moderate, which undoubtedly attracts many to him. Even speaking of eternal life, he seeks to show its fundamental feasibility, not questioning (unlike the same scream) the possibility of its spontaneous self -generation. He explores only the very possibility of a scientific substantiation of faith in eternity in order to show, on the one hand, to each of the now living the degree of his responsibility to this very eternity, and on the other, the unexpected greatness of the dividends of even relatively small factual investments, if only they are correctly disposed of.
The factor of unrecognition
Now, perhaps, I will return to why I still experienced some disappointment from a new meeting with Dyson. Last and the first time I saw him 6 years ago, when he, together with Academician V.A. Rubakov, received the Pomeranchuk Award at the Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Physics. His laureate lecture at that time was devoted to the signs by which you can notice life on the external planets of the solar system or on the asteroids of the Kuiper belt.
After the lecture, we talked. Dyson gave me the text of his lecture, so I was able to state her main thoughts in the article for the magazine "What is new in science and technology." A modest buffet was organized for the laureates and their guests, where I met my university supervisor. This meeting upset me: he did not remember me, although I called the topic of my diploma, reminded his classmates about how he gave him a candidate minimum of theory. Alas. Nevertheless, we were pleasantly talked, and my former “chef” told me by the way, how 15 years ago he met with Dyson in St. Petersburg and how pleasantly they talked to him there.
When I told Dyson about this - immediately, after five minutes, he exclaimed with fervor: “Oh! I have to talk to him. ” And after some time, I saw how the elderly English professor crumbled about two Moscow elderly luminaries, and they did not even look at him. In the end, he went back with nothing. And after some time I tried to be near my university teachers again to find out what happened. “Nothing happened, ” the answer followed. “ I saw that he wants to talk, and I somehow forgot English.”
I don't want to judge anyone. Reaching the advanced years, a person begins to think more and more about something else and tries not to constrain himself with insignificant inconvenience. I just felt at the same time sympathy for both elderly professors-and to Moscow, who did not want to make a meaningless effort over himself, and to English, who was in a stupid position because of his friendliness. I also complained of myself, due to the fact that, having wished to make people pleasant, I put both of them in an uncomfortable position at once.
After that, Dyson and I corresponded for some time by e-mail, he sent me the text of his lecture, read at the New Jersey Technological Institute in the fall of 2004-in early 2005, its full text was printed in the same “new in science and technology”. And then Dyson stopped answering me. I think he just forgot about my existence. And having met with him after a lecture in Fian on March 23, I realized that my hypothesis was true.
... In 1986, Vladimir Gorovitz came to Moscow and Leningrad. Everyone then, of course, wanted to get to his concerts. I knew even the people who were scolding to visit both, but I could not visit any, but in my collection a concert is still stored, made by my familiar pianist directly from the hall. But when we discussed the concert with this acquaintance, he only sighed heavily: “These are just ruins!” The assessment is cynical, and I do not want to draw any parallels. But after the current performance of Dyson, I could follow the text of five years ago and note how small the supplements are.
Of course, each life has its own scale, but each of them slows down as it approaches eternity. Appearance of a great mind as much as admiration for great art. And it is not true that the great art or the great mind can remain in the past: both are an integral parameter, and, having heard again, you remember everything that you heard before. But the pace changes, and unimportant details slip away from memory. And from this a slight feeling of disappointment is born.
Dmitry Bayuk