Last Monday, United Russia deputy Robert Schlegel introduced a bill to the State Duma that would change the current media law. Schlegel proposes to prohibit the transmission of any statements on behalf of persons who are wanted or convicted on charges of involvement in terrorist activities.
“In my opinion, news about militants should be reduced to reports of their destruction,” Schlegel explains his position, calling the publication of Dokku Umarov’s statements about the explosions in Moscow “providing a platform for the murderer and terrorist.” Schlegel also said that the security authorities should also take care of the activities of Google, on whose YouTube video service Umarov's appeal was posted.
Editors-in-chief of Russian federal publications have already criticized United Russia's statements and bill, seeing them as yet another encroachment on freedom of speech. Google responded by removing the video from YouTube. “The rules prohibit posting such a video. Therefore, he was removed. Google does not support terrorists,” Alla Zabrovskaya, director of communications at Google Russia, told the Russian News Service, emphasizing that the video was on the site for several days only because a huge number of videos are uploaded to YouTube every day, which moderators do not always check in a short time. succeed
As you know, a public attack on the media was launched on Friday, April 2, at a meeting of leaders of parliamentary parties with the president. Specifically, Gryzlov, speaker of the State Duma and chairman of the supreme council of United Russia, attacked the newspapers Vedomosti and Moskovsky Komsomolets. He stated that the articles in these publications and Dokku Umarov's statement are interconnected and "actually boiled in the same juice." "Criticized" the media in general and the leader of "Fair Russia" Sergei Mironov. In response, Moskovsky Komsomolets journalist Alexander Minkin gave Gryzlov a week to apologize - otherwise he would sue him.
On Saturday Andrey Isaev supported his party boss. And on Monday, Schlegel's proposal appeared. It seems that Gryzlov's associates are doing their best to prevent a possible summons of their patron to court - if the legislation is changed urgently (for example, in three readings at once, which is not the first time for United Russia), then the journalist's threat may turn out to be without a judicial prospect.
Director of the International Institute of Political Expertise Yevgeny Minchenko links this bill with criticism of the party in power. “This is another nervous and not entirely adequate reaction of United Russia. Now they are trying to classify everyone who criticizes the authorities as accomplices of terrorists, ”he said.
Indeed, the first deputy head of the United Russia faction, Vladimir Pekhtin, has already told the media that the publications in Vedomosti and Moskovsky Komsomolets are a continuation of black PR directed against the current government and, in particular, against the leadership of United Russia - Vladimir Putin and Boris Gryzlov.
Andrey Richter, head of the Institute for Information Law Problems, called attempts to reshape the media law a long-established trend. “Each time after a major terrorist attack or an interview with Maskhadov, such proposals and warnings from Roskomnadzor to publications arose.”
According to Richter, such a restriction is completely unfounded, because "in no country in the world can freedom of information be restricted because of the suspicion of a crime." Information may be prohibited from publication based on its content (extremist statements, calls for terrorism, as well as its justification), but not on the basis of who presents it. “Neither in the law on patriotism of the United States, nor in the legislation of other countries, there were no such restrictions. If they accept us, it will be Russian know-how. But I doubt it: I don’t know about any of Mr. Schlegel’s proposals that would be accepted,” Richter concluded.
The same opinion about the prospects of Schlegel's bill is shared by his colleague in the party and the Committee on Information Policy, Information Technologies and Communications Boris Reznik. “This is a desire to identify oneself, but in no way help the cause. Robert is a very young, exalted and ambitious boy. He has already become famous for the fact that at one time, just starting to work in the Duma, he introduced a project that would allow publications to be closed for libel without trial or investigation,” he recalled. - Then the committee approved, although I was categorically against it. It’s good that after passing the first reading, the presidential administration had the sense to prompt the comrades, and the plate spun in the other direction.” According to Reznik, the committee is learning from its own mistakes and is unlikely to approve this bill.
“Practice has shown that Schlegel's initiatives aimed at restricting the media are then withdrawn by Schlegel himself. That is, this is such reconnaissance in force, ”Oleg Shein, deputy of the State Duma from Just Russia, told Novaya Gazeta.