This money doubled the teacher's base salary, made his poverty a noble poverty, stimulated the arrival of people with a scientific degree in school, somehow kept the young and energetic at the blackboard.
Perhaps it was the “surcharges” that saved a rather thin layer of free and high-quality special schools and gymnasiums in the capital. This means that they kept at least some social elevators for children whose parents cannot pay even 18-20 thousand rubles a month to the gymnasium. Even for one. (This amount is real and not extreme.)
Where, in what grease, an educational institution, planted on the most severe monetary ration, is collapsing, one could understand from the capital's universities. They are federal. And, of course, there were no allowances. A young teacher at Moscow State University receives 7,000-15,000 rubles a month. After twenty years of such a life, all that remains is to conjure brazenly and plaintively, as at the county May Day demonstration of the 1930s: our universities are the best! And we are proud of them!
Teachers (by the way, and doctors) of Moscow subordination were partly protected from such a fate. They had no choice: to vegetate or fight with anyone for every breath.
The initiators of the reform, however, explain: in this list of city governors we are not at all those who entered the city on a white horse, burned down the gymnasium and abolished science. There will be no less money in the budgets of metropolitan schools from September 1. It's just that now the director will distribute them. The bewilderment of a professional in Novaya Gazeta is expressed by a corresponding member of the Russian Academy of Education, Alexander ABRAMOV. The editors asked questions that come to the mind of any average person and parent, beaten by the experience of our years.
"New Newspaper"
In recent days, a new system of remuneration for Moscow teachers has been very actively discussed. A staunch supporter of this system is Mayor S.S. Sobyanin, who, when he was the governor of the Tyumen region, actively implemented it. Head of the Moscow Department of Education I.I. Kalina from 2004 to 2010 de facto determined the school policy of the Ministry of Education and Science. Thus, in essence, we are talking about the attempts of the new leadership to turn Moscow into a giant experimental platform for the introduction of certain selected pedagogical innovations.
In my opinion, the discussion should not be about how the Sobyanin-Kalina Plan, which was launched from above, will be implemented in Moscow schools, but about how the authors of this plan will protect it in front of the inhabitants of the city of 12 million people.
Many questions arise.
Firstly, I absolutely do not understand why the teaching profession has suddenly become the only (!) profession in the country that has very strict requirements and assessments. Thus, the transition to the USE was motivated, in particular, by the inadmissibility of maintaining a system in which teachers themselves evaluate the results of their work. The proposed measure (a small base rate plus large incentive bonuses) puts the teacher in a position in which he must direct his main efforts every day to achieve some formal indicators. This is not very consistent with the mission of the Sowers "reasonable, kind, eternal."
The desire for order and objectivity is a good thing. But wouldn't it be better to start with another respectable profession - with officials? The results of their work are in full view. It is much easier to develop formal performance criteria than in the case of teachers. Judging by the scope of corruption and the modest growth of GDP, the problem of the quality of work of officials is a burning one, and if it is resolved positively, we will get not only very fast, but also outstanding results. Including economic ones: if the salary of teachers is noticeably lower than the industry average, then the salary of an official is much higher.
Secondly, I am very confused by the general approach to the "experiment". Already at the initial stage of the wage experiment, 125 Moscow schools were involved. Is there an experiment for this? Are there a sufficient number of school principals who are ready to work in a fundamentally new paradigm? Won't teachers perceive the new system as a direct assault on their own interests? Is there a system of formal objective quality criteria? The true criterion of the quality of a teacher is the fate of his graduates. Consequently, quick and allegedly accurate assessments in points, and even more so in rubles, are excluded by definition.
There is a very significant third question: “Who are the judges?” In the case of the introduction of the new system, the influence of school directors and higher information bodies of an unclear nature will increase sharply. Accordingly, the probability of arbitrariness and humiliation of teachers increases sharply. Hope for boards of trustees is not justified: there are practically no effective public structures in the field of education yet.
Independent teachers' unions rightly fear a noticeable reduction in teachers' salaries as a result of the abolition of "Luzhkov's allowances." The fear associated with the possible exodus of some teachers from the school and the withering away of forms of work with students that do not bring real money is not unfounded.
Alexander ABRAMOV, corresponding member of the Russian Academy of Education, in 1992-2002. - Member of the Board of the Moscow Department of Education