
*Our land is rich in
There is only no order in it.*
A.K. Tolstoy of Russia has never been a shortage of conversations about its arrangement. There is no now. Everyone represents the future of the country in its own way, but today, as a rule, the majority reckons itself to the conservatives and converges that Russia should be, firstly, the empire and secondly, to go in a special way that is different from the West. This path, in their opinion, will lead it to prosperity. The magazine "Expert", for example, devoted this topic to the entire first number of the New Year, calling it "Russia. Five Age of the Empire."
Further, the historian Dmitry Volodykhin, who described the model of " space Orthodoxy ," went further in his vision of the Russian future. In his dreams, "the Russian Empire restores economic power, goes into space expanses and acts as a great power, absolutely independent in its policy." It is against the entry of Russia into the world community "with all the rules of the game accepted there", which, as he believes, is "a dull import that is only a lot of our country," although it admits that "the empire may include more or less democracy, but still not democratic principles (at least the principles of classical Western democracy) constitute the political basis of the Russian future." The political ideal for him is when "society is controlled authoritarian."
In all these reasoning, in fact, there is nothing new: for several centuries, Russian intellectuals tried to substantiate the special messianic role of Russia in the world. In the "New Publishing House" is preparing for the publication in my translation a new book by Richard Pipe "Russian conservatism and his criticism." It has a lot of quotes from the works of various Russian conservatives. Even Leontyev was in the 19th century. However, those authors wrote before the 1917 revolution, which in a matter of days brought down the Russian Empire and thereby proved the failure of their reasoning. The current ones write about the same as if there was neither the October Revolution with a bloody civil war, nor the Soviet Empire, built by the price of millions of human lives and also collapsed in three days in August 1991. No analysis of errors and crimes. No conclusions. On the contrary, the authors of the editorial article in the "Expert" are convinced that "if any of the great world powers is worth" repenting and correcting ", then Russia last, and in Russian history there are much more than the dark ones."
The current conservatives are sure that only they really love Russia and are its unconditional patriots. Her critics, respectively, Russophobes and Nepriots. In reality, these people do not love the country, not its people, but the Russian state, power. There are direct statements that "Putin’s power system and Russia are one and the same ... Russia without Putin is geopolitically impossible today."
Freedom for a Russian person in their representation is to serve the authorities. As one of the authors of the "expert", who took the right to speak on behalf of the noble estate, "if freedom was expressed in the right to not obey for the Polish Shlyakhtich, and for the English lord, the right to control what goals the taxes paid by him are, then for the Russian nobleman, freedom was expressed in the possibility of taking part in the great construction of the empire. And judge who had more freedom, the Pole, the Pole, the Pole, the Pole, the Pole, the Pole. Whose disobedience, whose fee does not affect anything in general, or in Russian, whose readiness to serve made him a co-crew of world history? " How many nobles died under the wreckage of the collapsed Russian Empire, the author did not consider it necessary to say.
As you can see, there are no talk of any learned lessons from the past of Russia and the people are again offered to serve the authorities and be “material” for the construction of a new empire. At the same time, this refers to the ministry of the authorities, absolutely closed from the people and not controlled by him, the authorities and plans of which are still unclear. It is again proclaimed that in Russia people for the state, not a state for the people. And Russian despotism, Russian lack of freedom is presented as the highest achievements of Russian history!
If you really love Russia, and not its power, then, on the contrary, you will wish it to break out of the strong bonds of its historical fate and to get out on the road to Western civilization, because humanity has not yet come up with anything better than a democratic state structure.
However, the concept of "democracy" in Russia in recent years has been so discredited and vulgarized that it is difficult to imagine how and when it can return to it. In the representation of Russians, democracy is not an order and law, but a mess and lawlessness. Russian politicians most likely themselves do not understand the actual meaning of the concept of "democracy", because they ignore its essence - a legal state, meaning that the country has strict rules by which not only people live, but also officials and the highest power. The duty of the people is to pay taxes to the state, and they have the right to ask where they are spent. In the legal state of the branch of power - legislative, executive and judicial - are separated from each other and any official can become an object of judicial persecution, not excluding the president, who is also just an official in the service of the people, and not a demiurge determining his fate. In the legal state, the people are not afraid of the police. Business does not depend on the state, and officials serve to help a person who wants to open his own business, and not to hinder him. In the legal state, the opposition is a legally existing institution that has the right to free criticism of state policy. And already as a result - elections: governors, parliament, president. In a democratic country, the state serves the people, not the people of the state.
Adherents of democracy are not against authoritarian government for Russia, given its size and scale of problems. But they are for authoritarianism, which directs the country on the way to the legal state, freedom and democracy, and not to dictatorship. They are for authoritarianism, cultivating Western values, and not refusing them. Does the current president lead Russia along this path? Which of the current Russian politicians is generally able to pursue such a policy? Which of them at least understands what the concept of the rule of law means? Do you think that such an understanding of the state and law was taught at the Law Faculty of Leningrad University?
Nevertheless, a special responsibility for today's mindset of Russian society lies with the so-called elite, which, in the words of Vasily Grossman, "everything is still buzzing in the Lakes." Her representatives today, taking into account the discovered knowledge about our history, in theory should know more, understand deeper and see further. At least not to lie that "Russia had no choice - to be an empire or to be a" normal European democratic state. "There was a choice - to be an empire or be a colony."
The cost of this kind of intellectual exercises can again be human life, not to mention the future of the country. Russia is sick, and it must be treated for a long time - treated with freedom, observing the law, instilling in the people legal consciousness, and not seduce it with new imperial utopias. Russia will not withstand the new despotism and the new empire, and the collapse will be no less impressive than in 1917 or 1991. The calls to the new empire actually contain an answer to the question of what the apologists of "sovereign democracy" think: about the future of Russia or the service of the momentary interests of the current government.