
The theme of the Holodomor in Ukraine of 1932-1933 these days sounds with particular force. During a visit to Jerusalem, President of Ukraine Viktor Yushchenko called on Israel to recognize the Holodomor with the genocide of the Ukrainian people. He also welcomed the fact that Russia supported UNESCO's decision to declare the Holodomor a national tragedy, while emphasizing that Stalin and the Communist regime, not the Russian people, were carrying a crime for this crime. UNESCO’s resolution on “perpetuating the memory of the victims of the Holodomor in Ukraine” was unanimously adopted shortly until November 25, celebrated in Ukraine as a day of memory of victims of political repression and the Holodomor. On November 15, the Ukrainian Cultural Center in Moscow opened an exhibition "declassified memory", where declassified materials of the Archives of the Security Service of Ukraine regarding the Holodomor are exhibited.
So far, 65 states recognized the Holodor with a crime against the people of Ukraine, and 13 countries consider it genocide. Now Russia is ready, as the vote in UNESCO showed, officially recognize the Holodomor with a crime, but refuses to consider it as genocide. The letter of the representative of the Russian Federation at the UN Vitaly Churkin says : “In 1932-1933, Russia, Kazakhstan, Ukraine and other republics, which were part of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, suffered a tragedy. As a result of mass hunger, predetermined, in particular, repeatedly condemned by the repressive policy of the Stalinist regime, millions of innocent citizens were killed: Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians, Russians. Kazakhs, Ukrainians, people of other nationalities. "
Indeed, the victims of hunger associated with the Stalinist collectivization were not only Ukrainians, but also representatives of other peoples of the USSR. And Stalin seemed to have never planned the complete destruction of Ukrainians. And among those who carried out collectivization and repressions in Ukraine, there were not only Russians, Jews, Poles, but also Ukrainians themselves. But the mass murder of Polish prisoners of war in Katyn in the world is recognized as genocide, although Stalin was not going to kill all the Poles and some of them were ready to endure in power in Warsaw (of course, under strict Soviet control).
At the same time, no one except the most rabid Stalinists denies the artificial character of the famine of 1932-1933 and its political orientation. The main goal of the forced seizure of grain beyond all reasonable limits was to suppress the resistance of the peasants of collectivization (and among the peasants in Ukraine there were 96%), physically destroy the most dangerous from the point of view of Soviet power. It is no coincidence that the main blow was inflicted in Ukraine and the Cossack regions of the Kuban and Don, where during the years of the Civil War and after its completion, the most fierce resistance was turned out to be red.
Stalin during the Holodomor period has repeatedly emphasized the need to eradicate the "Petliurists" and "Makhnovites" in Ukraine. The boundaries of Ukraine were blocked by the post -trees that did not allow the starving to look for salvation in the Russian regions. Real raids were arranged for peasants who fled from starvation in Russian and Ukrainian cities. Those villages where most peasants did not join the collective farm, as well as those who did not fulfill the bakery plan, were placed on “black boards”. This meant disconnection from food supply and the removal of seed grain, which condemned the population to a hungry death.
But the huge victims of the period of collectivization among the Kazakhs, when almost half of the people died, are explained differently. The Kazakhs, unlike the Cossacks, were not especially active enemies of the Bolsheviks in the Civil War. But the Stalinist bureaucrats decided to put the nomadic people on the ground overnight. The cattle of the Kazakhs have already been taken away, and they have not yet been taught to grow bread. As a result, a terrible hunger broke out, causing a spontaneous uprising, brutally depressed.
Yes, the policy of the communist regime during the years of collectivization was not consciously aimed at the extermination of individual ethnic groups. However, the victims of this policy could well perceive it as genocide, although this term itself did not exist then. And it was not easier for them that the peasants of other nationalities died nearby.
Ukraine is going to bear the issue of recognizing the Holodomor with genocide for discussion at the UN. For Ukrainian national consciousness, this is a fundamental issue. The memory of the general tragedy is able to unite the West and the East, the Ukrainian -speaking and Russian -speaking parts of the country and the people. Meanwhile, the Holodomor is really different from the Nazi extermination of Jews or from the Turkish genocide of Armenians. Perhaps disputes could stop if the 1948 Convention was supplemented by genocide, including mass repressions in this concept aimed at destroying certain social and political groups. Whereas genocide should be considered by the Soviet mass terror during the Civil War and in the 30s, and the Red Terror, carried out by the Communists of Yugoslavia and China, and a number of other events of recent history. Russia, however, seems to be worth at least clearly condemning the artificial hunger of 1932-1933 as an element of Soviet mass repressions. And declare your day of memory of the victims of the Holodomor.