We talked about the Venice Commission in May with Stanislav Stanskikh and Yuri Dzhibladze (on the Novaya website on May 28). They initiated an appeal to the Council of Europe with a request to analyze other amendments to the Constitution of the Russian Federation, as well as the procedure for their adoption. This petition has already collected more than 225,000 signatures, has been supported by the PACE Monitoring Committee, a corresponding request has also been sent to the VC, but the work there will take much more time, and so far we are talking about a narrower and separate issue.
On the other hand, it is a very delicate one – this is the question of the execution by the state bodies of the Russian Federation of international treaties and decisions, primarily of the ECtHR, which they often do not like. In fact, they have not always been implemented so far, not to mention the introduction of appropriate changes in legislation and judicial practice,
but so far, those who won cases “against the Russian Federation” have at least been paid monetary compensation awarded by the ECtHR.
The VC notes that the opportunity to declare decisions of the ECtHR unenforceable in the Russian Federation was granted to the Constitutional Court on the basis of the federal constitutional law before, however, the consolidation of this power at the constitutional level “causes concern” (paragraph 64 of the opinion).
Before Art. 79 of the Constitution allowed the Russian Federation to transfer part of its powers under international treaties, “if this does not entail restriction of the rights and freedoms of a person and a citizen and does not contradict the foundations of the constitutional order”, but according to the new version of Article 125 of the Constitution (in part 5 note point “b”) The Constitutional Court decides on the possibility of executing decisions of international bodies if they “do not contradict the foundations of public order” and “in their interpretation that contradicts the Constitution of the Russian Federation” (only the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation itself will have the right to get out of this wording).
The VC delicately notes that the powers of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation are being significantly expanded here, and we can bluntly assume that now “does not correspond to the Constitution of the Russian Federation”, for example, in terms of the “ideals and faith in God passed on to us by our ancestors” enshrined in it (Article 67 approx. ) can be recognized by almost any decision of the ECtHR.
In paragraph 66 of the conclusion, the VC also expresses concern that giving the president the right to apply to the Federation Council with ideas about the removal of judges of the Constitutional Court from office (an amendment to Article 83 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation) makes the Constitutional Court “vulnerable to political pressure” (in fact, this is a hint in the direction of the entire judicial system of the Russian Federation, since the president has the same right in relation to the chairmen of all courts above the district level and their deputies).
We understood this even before the introduction of amendments and clarifications from Venice.
In general, the Venice Commission spoke very carefully and with numerous curtsies towards the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation.
But this is not for you to block Telegram!
There is no doubt that the decision of the VC will be played up by Russian propaganda in the sense that the bodies of the Council of Europe "intervene" in the process of approving amendments to the Constitution of the Russian Federation by their "all-Russian vote", and this propaganda move may even somewhat increase the number of those who will vote behind.
But even such an approval will not save the Russian Federation from the next and more detailed Opinion regarding all amendments (including those relating to the "zeroing" of presidential terms), and not only the Venice Commission, but the PACE as a whole. Yes, and this will also be only an opinion - but of the international community, of which Russia is a member, regardless of whether it likes its housemates or not.