The first victim of comprehensive inspections of NGOs throughout Russia was the Association "In Defense of the Rights of Voters" GOLOS ". The Ministry of Justice called her a foreign agent. The organization and its executive director, Lilia Shibanova, face thousands of fines. And in the future, a criminal case.
The Ministry of Justice of Russia initiated proceedings on an administrative offense against the GOLOS association and its executive director Lilia Shibanova. As stated in the official statement of the department, "according to the information of the Federal Financial Monitoring Service, the Association receives funding from foreign sources."
Where financial monitoring specialists get such information from is not specified. According to GOLOS representatives, the Ministry of Justice considered the Sakharov Prize, which the Association received last fall "for the promotion of democratic values" from the Norwegian Helsinki Committee, to be foreign funding. We are talking about the amount of 7728 euros 40 cents, which was transferred to the transit account of GOLOS.
“Because of the law on foreign agents, we decided to abandon the financial part of the award, so when the money went to the transit account, we turned to the bank with a request to return it back,” explains Deputy Executive Director of the Association Grigory Melkonyants.
As a result, the money was never credited to the account of the organization. “A vicious practice is emerging: any dollar transferred by a foreigner to the account of an NPO for the purpose of provocation can bring us under administrative responsibility. But all our accounts are in the public domain - anyone can provide financial support, and it is difficult to control this process, ”Melkonyants believes.
GOLOS lawyer Ramil Akhmetgaliev suggests looking at the situation from a different angle: imagine that a non-profit organization buys tickets for its employees from a foreign airline. For some reason, the flight did not take place, and the company returns the money to the NCO's account. “Under the law on foreign agents, this also falls under the definition of financial assistance from abroad,” Akhmetgaliev explains. - Representatives of the Ministry of Justice themselves do not deny that this is illogical, but the law is formulated the way it is formulated. And if an NPO receives damages from a foreign organization and, in the opinion of the Ministry of Justice, is engaged in political activities, then the organization is obliged to register as an agent.”
GOLOS executive director Lilia Shibanova insists: “We are not agents! Agents represent the interests of another country and carry out other people's orders. We do not represent anyone's interests and are engaged in the development of democratic institutions in Russia.” According to her, the measures taken against the Association will not force GOLOS to voluntarily identify itself as a foreign agent.
Another claim of the Ministry of Justice is as follows: an attempt to create a project to form the Electoral Code was called political activity. What is surprising here is that the law on foreign agents came into force in November last year. And any discussion and support for the draft Code ended more than a year ago. A separate question is whether a proposal for legislation can be defined as a political activity at all?
“The development of the Code is aimed not at supporting parties or individual politicians, but at the implementation of the right to vote, which is already enshrined in the Constitution. This is not a political activity. Moreover, the public and non-profit organizations are now actively participating in the discussion of legislative initiatives - this is a normal practice in a democratic society,” lawyer Ramil Akhmetgaliev believes.
Now the leadership of GOLOS, together with lawyers, is developing a line of defense: “We are working on various options, but how can we defend ourselves against delusional accusations in our country?” Lilia Shibanova is perplexed. She does not rule out that the Association will file a counterclaim against the Ministry of Justice.
According to the Ministry of Justice, the activities of GOLOS fall under Part 1 of Art. 19.34 of the Code of Administrative Offenses. On April 10, the protocols were sent to the court for consideration. According to them, the Association risks paying up to 500 thousand rubles, and its executive director Lilia Shibanova - up to 300 thousand. GOLOS does not believe in a favorable outcome: “It does not threaten anything good. Decisions in world courts are made not on the basis of the law, but on the basis of some internal concepts. Obviously, in our case it will be accusatory. And then we do not rule out a tougher option - the suspension of the activities of the Association and the initiation of a criminal case against Lilia Shibanova.
Grigory Melkonyants is sure that the ministry made a hasty decision without delving into the details of the case: “Apparently, the task was set to bring us to administrative responsibility as soon as possible. Previously, they said that the process would be gradual and multi-stage: first, NGOs would receive a warning, if they fail to comply with the requirements, they will be brought to administrative responsibility, and only then it will be a criminal matter.”
Nobody warned GOLOS - the case was immediately taken to court, and given the principled position of the Association - not to be called a foreign agent - it is possible that this will be followed by a criminal case.
The Ministry of Justice told Novaya Gazeta that for clarification "in such cases" it is necessary to send an official request, which we sent to the ministry. Novaya will publish the response after it is received and will continue to monitor the situation around GOLOS.