 In the Kremlin Protest as a system
 I recently stood in a regular Moscow traffic jam. On Nikitsky Boulevard, the police blocked the movement to skip a special machine, which was traveling from the center in Bolshaya Nikitskaya. This was clearly an official of not the highest rank. There was no limit to the indignation of the forced drivers. Every day of such situations, several hundred arises in Moscow.
The campaign against "flashing lights" is, of course, important. But our civil society should learn to accumulate energy to resolve the main issues. How realistic is the final effect of one -time promotions on private problems, if the political foundations of the system that generates these problems generates untouched? It happens that the power is retreating. As in the case of Baikal, when people were really ready to stand to the end, or as in the case of Shcherbinsky, when everyone understood that they themselves could be in his place. Or when thousands of cars block the port in Vladivostok, because the increase in tax duties hits the car owners who realized their interests. Power recedes, but the basics of functioning of the regime are not affected, moreover, a well -played final intervention can bring certain political dividends.
However, “flashing lights” is already a transition to another qualitative level. “Miganits” is not the interests of an individual boss, this is a kind of sign of the sacredness of the class of officials. And any attempts to "chosen" cause a well -defined reaction of power. For example, the problem of deceived investors who invested money in the construction of apartments. There is no criticism of talk that, they say, crooks from private firms stole money, and the state has nothing to do with this. It is clear that in the conditions of total bureaucratic control over everything, including the allocation of land for development, such a business can only be carried out by those who are tightly connected with the local authorities. The state official is a direct part of this mass deceit, and therefore, deceived people have no chance to solve his private issue. And there are a lot of such deceived - but they are afraid to identify their specific problems with the vices of the system. This identification seems to them dangerous and impractical.
It is important to understand that the vices of the system lead to many excesses. Even the most massive action will not correct the situation if it is aimed only at the elimination of the consequences of these vices of the system. You can try to infringe on officials, deprive them of the opportunity to earn huge funds using their official position - all this will be in vain until the basis of the nomenclature state changes.
Ustinov’s sudden resignation is a vivid example of how this nomenclature state acts. We will not now go into speculation on the topic whether the resignation of the tactical victory of the liberal wing in the Kremlin administration over the security forces is the intervention of Putin himself, to which the strengthening of the “Sechins” seemed too dangerous. There are many versions, and, probably, many of them have the right to exist. The main thing for us is the method by which one of the highest officials of Putin's Russia was removed from the Pyramid of power. It is important how the Federation Council reacted. They simply stamped this decision, without even asking Ustinov, whether he actually wrote a statement of care. A certain paper came, which, as I understand it, not even all senators read. There is paper, there is a message - and that’s it, the decision has been made. When a prominent commentator claims that the constitutional norm is not violated here, he sinning greatly against the truth. Yes, the constitution does not spell out the procedure for dismissal of the prosecutor general, but it says that the upper house appoints and dismisses the general prosecutor on the proposal of the president. This implies, it is obvious that senators should at least somehow control the activities of this official. In any case, the reasons for his such sudden resignation, and even presented in his absence, would have to cause a lot of questions from those who seem to be part of the legislative Russian authorities. But the course of events shows us that those very people who voted almost unanimously for the appointment of Ustinov a year ago, today they simply stamp his resignation. Russian legislative power has turned into a dummy. It is an appendage of the executive branch, which, however, has also long been concentrated in one office, in the hands of one person. When the decision to resign Ustinov came to Putin, we can only guess. It was accepted in a very narrow circle or even Putin alone, because even the narrowest circle can allow leaks.
The suddenness of such a decision suggests that today, as we have already seen in the situation with the transfer of the pipeline route, we went into the regime of not even authoritarian, but dictatorial administration, when the entire executive branch is really concentrated in the hands of one person. The officials built into the pyramid with this situation were probably reconciled, but, as cases with a pipe and with Shcherbinsky show, society is still capable of protest. But this protest will be truly effective only if it is directed against the entire vicious system, in which there is simply a connection between the flashing lights, the dismissal of the prosecutor Ustinov, the pollution of Baikal, deceived by depositors and other various threats steming from the lawlessness of bureaucratic and nomenclature Russia. The text is published on the website http://www.kasparov.ru
Harry Kasparov All rights to materials located on the EJ.ru website are protected in accordance with the legislation of the Russian Federation, including copyright and related rights. With any use of the site and satellite projects, hyperlink (Hyperlink) on EJ.ru is required. |