
Disputes about what science is and when, how, where and why it arose, it has been conducted for a long time and is unlikely to end in the foreseeable future. Some authors interpret this concept as widely as possible, considering science as almost a universal creation of human civilization (with this approach, we can say, for example, about the science of ancient China or even the science of the Aztecs). Others (the author of this article belongs to these) believe that science was born within the framework of the ancient Greek cultural area somewhere between the 5th and 3rd centuries BC. e. There are also many followers of the concept according to which science arose in Western and Southern Europe during the 16th - 18th centuries and only later became the key factor in the intellectual, technological and social progress of all of humanity.
No matter how relate to these discussions, one cannot but admit that the institutionalization of science, which ensured its continuous and progressive development up to the present day, really took place in the middle of the named era, that is, in the 17th century. The formation of this institutionalization is usually called a scientific revolution.
Scientific revolution. The use of capital letters in this case emphasizes both the historical uniqueness of this event (or rather, the process) and its difference from the transformations of individual fields of scientific knowledge, which are carried out by the forces of various specialized scientific communities.

A great many studies are devoted to the description and explanation of the scientific revolution. Recently, this collection was replenished with a monograph by a professor of history at the University of York, David Wotton, “The Invention of Science: The New History of the Scientific Revolution”. Without applying for a detailed retelling of this work, I will try to present its main ideas.
I will start with the main methodological premise of Wotton. He resolutely opens against very fashionable in the last decades of the last century and has not yet lost the influence of relativistic ideology in the history and sociology of science. This ideology rests on three whales. Firstly, the requirement can not rely on information about the current state of affairs in the preparation of historical descriptions. Secondly, the rejection of the idea of progress in general and the concept of the progressive rationality of scientific knowledge in particular. Thirdly, the call to consider successful and unsuccessful applications for new knowledge completely on equal terms and regardless of the degree of their correspondence or inconsistency with the actual data and even more so the laws of nature. Of these postmodernist attitudes, there is a desire to consider scientific theories to consider the subject of the faith of certain communities, and not more or less adequate reflection of these laws. According to this logic, the technique or deviation of scientific hypotheses and theories does not depend much on their connection with the objective reality and is determined primarily by the social status and the influence of their defenders. All these attitudes, Wotton emphasizes, turn out to be purely speculative frills of some university schools (in particular, if we talk about Great Britain, sociologists from Edinburgh and Bata Universities) and are not related to the true history of science.
Wotton sees in the scientific revolution a long and multifaceted, but in general a single process of transforming a European cultural field, which led to the construction of completely new relations between nature and civilization. He was preceded by a number of the most important sociocultural and technological innovations, which became the prerequisites for the emergence of science of the New Age. This is the birth of a book press as a reliable and universal way of spreading, copying and storing information; gradual weakening of trust in the authorities of the past and increased the role of critical thinking; institutionalization of the idea of opening and the right to its authorship; enrichment of thinking and language with such intellectual tools as the concepts of fact, hypothesis, theory and law of nature; the invention of optical devices, barometers, exact hours and other measuring instruments; The successful intellectual riot of mathematicians against philosophers, and those and others against theologians; And much more.
These innovations have prepared cultural, social and economic conditions for the emergence of communicatively related (groups that became producers of knowledge of the new (type. Participants in this production were interested in finding information about nature that did not (only allowed a test in observations of specially planned experiments, but was also opened (for free and critical discussion. During the 17th century, some of these groups received institutional design as voluntary societies and as voluntary societies and Academies that have their own resources for conducting research and publishing results, due to the activity of these groups by the end of the 17th century, not only the knowledge of living and inanimate nature was immeasurably enriched, but fundamentally new ideas about what the natural sciences should be capable of in the broadest sense of the word.
Vutton offers for the scientific revolution the exact dates of the beginning and completion - 1572 and 1704. In this, he departs from the venerable tradition, which offers to count from the output of the monograph by Nikolai Copernicus de Revolutionibus Orbium Coelestium, published in 1543 by the Nuremberg publisher Johanno Petreus. Wotton does not agree with this for two reasons. Firstly, the heliocentric (more precisely, heliostatic) model Copernicus has become a real factor in the transformation of astronomy only at the beginning of the 17th century thanks to the research of Kepler and Galileo. The leading astronomers of the 16th century recognized that it facilitates the calculations of the movement of the luminaries, but denied the presence of a physical foundation (for example, then it was believed that the Earth’s hypothesis was refuted at least because the cannon nuclei flew the same distances in any direction of the barrel). Back in the 1580-1590s, Copernicus had no more than three followers in the astronomical community, and even then one of them-German Christoph Rotmann-eventually moved to the camp of opponents. Secondly, the Copernican model completely retained the idea of the absolute invariability of the corrugated world inherited from Aristotle and ancient astronomers, which in this regard was radically contrasted with the earthly world. This concept, as you know, was completely rejected in the XVII century.

The concept of Aristotle received the first blow on November 11, 1572. That evening, the future great astronomer quietly noticed a bright star in the constellation Cassiopei, which had never been there before. He followed the gradual attenuation of her luster until completely fading away in March 1574. Even before that, he described his observations in the book De Nova et Nullius æVI Memoria Prius Visa Stella, which was published in 1573 and thundered throughout Europe. So the first of the European scientists found that in the sphere of motionless stars, as it was called, unexpected changes can happen. He later built the best observatory in the world and, with the help of employees, accumulated a huge archive of observations of stars, planets, moon and sun. Over time, these observations allowed Johann Kepler to strictly prove that the planets turn around the Sun in elliptical orbits, thereby correcting the main weakness of the Copernican model. When taking into account these circumstances, Wotton announces the discovery of a new star and the beginning of astronomical studies by quiet Brage the initial moment of the scientific revolution. In the final moment, Wotton proposes to consider the publications of the Newtonian “optics”, which was published in 1704.
And then Wotton traces the birth and evolution of intellectual tools that made the invention possible (recall the heading of the book!) Science. He begins with a key idea of opening and the appearance of words in different European languages for its designation. This process began in the early years of the 16th century, when Europe found out that the travels of Christopher Columbus and other Spanish navigators paved transatlantic paths not to China, but to a new giant continent. “ If the discovery of America was a happy chance, it led to an even more amazing chance - the discovery of the discovery ” (p. 61).
The “fragmentation” of the idea of opening had many consequences. It stimulated disputes about the scientific priority that began in the first half of the 16th century in connection with the search for solutions to algebraic equations of the third and fourth degrees, and then spread to research outside mathematics. “ Such disputes serve as an undoubted indication that knowledge has become public, progressive and focused on the make of discoveries ” (p. 96).
In the XVII century, the tradition of attributing the discoveries of individual authorship and, accordingly, appropriation of the discoveries of the names of their authors (eponymy) was born. Already in the XVIII century, the practice of eponymia also spread to scientific laws: for example, the first of the laws of ideal gas, which we know as the Boyle Law, received this name in 1708, and Newton's gravity law in 1713. In general, Wotton concludes, the inclusion of the idea of opening with all its additional accessories in the European cultural field has become a key factor in the emergence of systematic cognitive innovations that became the foundation of the invention of science. Historically, their first manufacturers were cartographers who described new lands. Mathematicians soon joined this process, then anatomists, botanists, astronomers, physicists and chemists. All of them used the advantages of a printing press, which made possible accurate and massive reproduction of texts and graphics. “ The result was the emergence of an intellectual culture of a new type: innovative, critical and competitive, but at the same time putting accuracy and reliability at the forefront ” (p. 107). This culture formed the basis of scientific activity.
The great geographical discoveries of the end of the XV - early XVI centuries had an end to another important consequence. Copernicus, at the beginning of his revision of the Ptolemy system (specifically, no later than 1514), considered the Earth a solid ball moving in the void, on the surface of which the land is interspersed with the seas and oceans. This point of view was then very innovative and was not divided by everyone. For example, back in the 15th century, the Earth was seen as a ball floating on the surface of a water ball of a larger radius. The inhabited land protrudes above this surface like a round island, whose shape is approaching a hemisphere, but in no case can be a sphere.
Such a “model” of land for centuries in general was agreed with the then geographical ideas. She entered into a real contradiction with them only after America Vespucci made swimming to the shores of Brazil, leaving south of the equator at 50 ° in latitude. The description of this trip became known in Europe after the publication of Mundus Novus Vespucci letters in 1503, which in just four years withstood 29 publications. On its basis, the cartographers Martin Waldsimuuller and Mattius Ringmann drew new cards in which the earth's surface looks like the surface of the full sphere (on the Valdsimuller map published in 1507, the zaatlantic land opened by Columbus is first represented as a continent and is called America). Copernicus was familiar with this concept and relied on it in his thoughts. So the new geography in this case became a prerequisite for the birth of a new astronomy. As Wotton writes, “ Copernicanism would not have taken place without Vespucci ” (p. 143).
The scientific revolution was also prepared by a new understanding of the capabilities and tasks of mathematics. Back in the middle of the 15th century, the great Italian architect and art researcher Leon Battista Alberti not only built the geometric theory of perspective, but also proclaimed the paramount role of mathematics as the foundation of both art and science. Soon, mathematics began to be mastered by cartographers, surveyors, engineers, financiers and, of course, astronomers. They paved the way to the emergence of an increasingly much mathematizing physics, which is already in the XVII century.
Wotton throughout the book turns to the description and analysis of various discoveries, and this is natural. According to his concept, the recognition of the self -worth of new knowledge gained on the basis of observations and experiments has become the cornerstone of the collective psychology of the nascent scientific communities. For example, he examines in detail the telescopic observations of Venus made by Galilee from summer to winter 1610. In June, the planet seemed a light disk, but by October, half of the disk was darkened, and by the end of the year only a thin sickle remained from Venus, reminiscent of the sickle of the moon near the new moon. Galileo perfectly understood that such phases of Venus simply did not have the right to exist in the Cosmogony of Ptolemy, but naturally explained by heliocentric theory. In the Ptolemye model of Venus's orbit, either inside the solar orbit is located or lies outside it, and then observations did not allow making a definite choice between these options. In the first case, the bright part of the Venusian disk cannot exceed its half, and in the second, the disk must remain almost completely lit. In the Copernicus system, on the contrary, the orbit of Venus lies inside the earth's orbit, so that its disk can be completely lit and completely darkened, like the disk of the moon. It was such a change in the phases that Galileo observed, which he informed Kepler and Professor of the Roman Academy of the Jesuits of Collegio Romano in December to the famous astronomer and one of the creators of the Gregorian calendar Cristofor Clavius. After these observations in May 1611 were confirmed by the colleague of Clavius Odo Van Maelcot, “ no competent astronomer could defend the Ptolemy system ” (p. 226). As Wotton emphasizes, such a reaction of the astronomical community very clearly shows how far a scientific revolution managed to go.
Analysis of the opening of the phases of Venus allows Wotton to play an important position in a dispute with supporters of relativistic historiography of science and, in particular, with Thomas Kun. All of them consider scientific knowledge by the subject of the faith of certain communities engaged in its production. It almost automatically follows that carriers of different “symbols” of scientific beliefs (according to Kun, supporters of alternative paradigms) have little chance of reaching consensus. Therefore, the change of paradigms is associated with conflicts within the scientific community, which Kun calls scientific revolutions. According to Wotton, “ after the Kunov“ structure of scientific revolutions ”, historians of science focused on the study of internal scientific disputes; This trend arose from the assumption that such disputes inevitably are generated by each major scientific discovery and that the replacement of the scientific theory is not inevitable in any case ”(p. 246). However, the discovery of the phases of Venus turned out to be exactly the inevitable consequence of the invention of the telescope. Thanks to this discovery, the astronomical community without delay, almost entirely and without special discussions, abandoned the theory of Ptolemy. As Wotton emphasizes, such situations are quite typical. This means that in contrast to relativistic ideology in the historiography of science, experience can be (and, as a rule, serves!) The decisive factor in the progressive evolution of science.
Wotton also considers other intellectual tools of the scientific revolution. So, he describes in detail the processes during which the inculturalization and institutionalization of the discovery concept led to the emergence and consolidation of the idea of actual description as an adequate language representation of new information. It turns out that the concept of fact in its modern meaning was included in Latin, French and Italian languages only in the 16th century, and in English it was fixed only by the middle of the 17th century. This innovation was also reflected in the official slogan of the London Royal Society founded in 1660 (the full name since 1663 - The Royal Society of London for Improving Natural Knowledge ). From the very beginning, it set its goal to obtain actual knowledge about nature, which was also reflected in its slogan Nullius Un Verba - not to take any words on faith. A huge role in the spread of facts was again played by printed books, and then magazines that began to be printed since 1665.

Another most important tool for the scientific revolution is an experiment. Wotton illustrates this conclusion on the example of a mercury barometer, who in 1643 was invented by a student of Galileo Evandzelist Torricelli. The barometer was the first device in the history of physics, which became a standard tool for a great many experiments. From 1643 to the beginning of the 1660s, at least a hundred natural scientists in different countries of Europe, “ became the first geographically distributed community of experimental scientists ” (p. 340), used it. В частности, с помощью модифицированных ртутных барометров был открыт первый закон идеального газа, который не совсем справедливо называют законом Бойля. Эта неформальная сеть последователей Торричелли, продолжает Вуттон, знаменует начало институционализации науки как коллективной деятельности, которая стала важнейшим компонентом Научной Революции.
Вуттон рассматривает историю еще нескольких интеллектуальных инструментов Научной Революции — гипотезы, теории, закона природы, корпускулярной философии, опытных данных. Все они были освоены в ходе практики исследовательских сообществ в течение XVII века и опять-таки стали важнейшими составляющими процесса, который Вуттон называет изобретением науки. Он также прослеживает связи между барометрическими экспериментами и изобретением первых паровых машин, протягивая нить от Научной Революции XVII столетия к Промышленной Революции XVIII века. Однако всего не перескажешь, поэтому ограничусь заключительной цитатой: «Наша жизнь буквально пронизана последствиями изобретения науки, и, скорее всего, так будет и в дальнейшем. Однако мы не просто пользуемся технологическими благами, которыми ей обязаны. Современное научное мышление настолько вошло в нашу культуру, что сейчас очень трудно представить, как наши предки жили в мире, где не было возможности говорить о фактах, гипотезах и теориях, где знание не основывалось на опытных данных и где природа не имела законов. Научная Революция для нас стала почти невидимой именно потому, что оказалась фантастически успешной» (стр. 571). И этот урок не стоит забывать.