I apologize to readers for a long break in my series about corruption. There were good reasons for this - maximum workload at work. I'll tell you now. In our Indem, he entered the finish line of a large three -year project to analyze the transformation of the judiciary - the draft unprecedented (not only for Russia) on the scale, complexity of the methods laid down new ideas. I have been proud of them, we have been healed for a long time. And now the main stream of sociological data has gone, extremely interesting, requiring immediate scrupulous analysis. I promise then to tell in the "hedgehog" about some of the most interesting results.

Now let's get back to our series. In the last article, we began to discuss the consequences of corruption. I tried to show how dangerous routine household corruption is, which is often not recognized even for corruption. In this article, we will talk about the consequences of business (economic) corruption.
First of all, it should be noted that business corruption is not limited exclusively by the field of interaction between business and power. There is also intra -final or corporate corruption. It appears when property and management are divided (current management of this property). When it comes to the corporation, the principal is its owners (in particular, shareholders). If the owner himself manages his company and, for example, steals himself, then this is not corruption, but a vulgar idiocy. So there is practically no (artificial bankruptcy - this is not at home, but with creditors). And if managers are deceiving shareholders, this is already corruption in strict accordance with our definition from the article “Corruption-3”. A typical example of internal corruption is ineffective loans issued by banking managers for bribes. The negative consequences for the principal-owner are obvious here.
But I talked about intrafirmic corruption because it has negative social consequences. This area has been studied extremely weakly, but some examples are obvious. Corruption conspiracies between suppliers and customers, for example, between coal miners and its consumers, as it was in Russia a few years ago (I don’t know how now), they inevitably lead to a rise in the cost of coal, and then to the rise in the cost of goods or services produced by such consumers. This means that, in the end, we pay extra money, we pay for the illegal enrichment of the seller and the buyer who entered into the conspiracy.
But the greatest damage is caused by corruption in large state -owned companies. The scale of the damage is determined by the fact that these companies are, as a rule, with basic functions (energy, transport, safety, etc.), and the fact that corruption in them is closed with political corruption (we will talk about this in the next article). Therefore, the state “roofs” the internal corruption of such companies, instead of controlling them. Such a roof allows these companies to do what ordinary business is not able to afford.
It is very difficult to evaluate the losses from internal corruption due to the closeness of information. But we intend to do this in the Indem. And let's go.
Now about more familiar types of business corruption. It is clear that economic corruption has, first of all, negative economic consequences that have the form of economic losses. They are divided into two categories: direct and indirect losses. Direct losses are visible directly, directly related to specific corruption transactions, their scale can be estimated. There are direct losses and damage from corruption as a social phenomenon as a whole.
Obvious direct losses are observed, first of all, in the formation of budget revenues. Typical corruption transactions in the collection of taxes, customs payments and other fees always lead to direct non -set budgets. Is it possible to estimate the scale of losses? In principle, it is possible. Let's look at one old example I received from the report of our prosecutor’s office when I collected information about corruption in the spring of 1997, while still an assistant to the president.
As a result of the prosecutor’s investigation in late 1996-early 1997, one of the customs points through which cargo with tobacco and alcohol went to our country, it was revealed that two-month losses due to the shortage of customs duties due to corruption, close to $ 150 million. In the year we get from one point of loss in the amount of about one billion dollars. Now try to spread it to the whole country yourself. As a result, only from customs corruption, the budget lost the amount comparable to the amount of the revenue of the budget. In general, the assessments of that time show that effective tax and customs administration is able to at least double our budget.
It is useful to make one important retreat here. Sometimes they say that if there were no customs corruption, then the imported products should be sold to the final consumer much more. Those. We have such corruption - in favor of the poor. Here the problem is up to the head. You and I know that corruption is always a consequence of ineffectiveness. In this case, the customs policy is ineffective, which boils down to an insolvent attempt to fill the budget at the expense of customs payments in conditions of a large number of customs positions. As a result, for example, microchips were imported into the country under the article “Ceramic tiles with a metallized pattern”. Are there any objections? Or what is the point of taxing the cars and spare parts with various customs duties? “Subtle customs regulation” was not successful anywhere, and in the country with a poor, greedy, ineffective bureaucracy - even more so. Therefore, the simultaneous simplification and reduction of customs duties reduces corruption, increases common customs income by reducing corruption and evasion of payments and, at the same time, does not create additional burden for the final consumer (for you and you).
The second type of direct losses from corruption is associated with budget execution. A powerful source of corruption is state purchases and orders. Here, corruption gains a well -known form of kickbacks. Ramps give rise to two forms of direct losses. The first form is those budget money that go for other purposes, but in the hands of an official (rollbacks themselves). Here, the assessment of losses is the size (share) of kickbacks. If ten years ago, the standard rollback is 5-15 %. Now this percentage has increased by about 3-4 times. The magazine "Expert" wrote three years ago that from the article of the R&D of the military budget of our country, approximately 80 %is creeping. The second form of loss of kickbacks is inefficient use of funds. It is known that in countries with high corruption, the rise in the cost of road construction ordered by the state is approximately 30 % of the market price. There are other grades. In the city of Milan, after conducting anti -corruption measures, the cost of building one meter or one square meter of the airport doubled. Try to fantasize what such losses are with such kickbacks.
It must be added that not only the rise in the cost of orders occurs, but also the loss of quality. During one visit to China, I witnessed (not direct, through the media) of the execution of the court of three senior officials of one province, who were convicted of receiving a rollback from a contract for the construction of the bridge. The bridge collapsed, there were victims. We also collapsed roofs of public buildings. The version of the role of corruption was not considered.
Now let's move on to indirect losses. On the one hand, they are not comparable more. But, on the other hand, far from always these losses are more or less reliable. I'll start with the case when such grades were received. It is quite obvious that large -scale corruption negatively affects the entrepreneurial climate in the country. One of the aspects (parameters) of this climate is investment attractiveness. Roughly speaking, it can be evaluated using two indicators. The first is the ability of the market to accept what the company intends to offer. The second is the scale of obstacles to the deployment of business. Any obstacles increase the cost of the project. Corruption is one of these obstacles. Some international consulting firms publish ratings with which potential investors can evaluate the scale of obstacles to their investment projects. Three years ago, I met in detail with one such rating for countries with growing markets. Until recently, Russia belonged to the number of such countries. In addition to us, Brazil, India, China, the Philippines and a couple more dozen countries included us. The rating concerned corruption in these countries only as an obstacle to investment and was calculated as a percentage of the cost of the project, which this project was alarmed by corruption. We were the leaders of the rating with thirty percent of the rise in cost of the cost of investment. Nearby was China. Three years have passed since then, Russia in about 90th place in the Transparency International rating has fallen around the 140s. Try to imagine how obstacles have grown for investment.
But what happens if the company ignores this rating and goes to our market? It happens that she is lucky and her losses are not catastrophically large, the project is implemented, the company is not in the minus. And sometimes it is different. I will retell you one story that one of the leaders of a very large company, which was going to enter our market. It was four years ago. We waged a pair with him on a business corruption of one major business forum in Moscow. His company participated in a tender and won. A few days later he was invited to one senior office of the ministry, which conducted a tender.
Doll: Congratulations.
Head: Thank you.
Sanctor: Did the tender be honest?
Head: Oh, yes! Impeccably!
Doll: Well, glorious! Now it's time to pay.
And he showed my storyteller a piece of paper, on which the amount with a large number of zeros was drawn. (But this score did not fall into the hands of a potential payer. Probably, the dignitary then swallowed him.)
"So what?" I asked. “We are leaving Russia,” he answered.
To be continued
Author - President of the Indem Foundation