
“You will have to be more attentive to the soup. You will need to chew and drink very carefully. Do not move, Your Majesty. And this is not a long -term decision. " The court doctor leans over Elizabeth II and introduces her muscle relaxant. The queen has a spasm of the facial nerve: daily welcoming subjects, she stretches her lips in a smile several times a day and gracefully turns her head in a hat. Now the left cheek is petrified, the queen hurts, she needs peace, and most importantly - you need to stop smiling. But this is excluded. “I have such an appearance that without a smile I immediately has an evil look,” the queen says and looks sadly at the doctor.
This episode from the biography of Elizabeth II is described in the book of her biographer Ingrid Seward and familiar to many on the series “Crown” is the best illustration of the phenomenon, which is customary to call emotional labor, that is, the professionalized management of their emotions and ways to express them. Today, not only the monarchs are busy with this labor: the driver of the Uzra will ask if the passenger is comfortable for the temperature in the cabin; The operator of Sberbank will remember the first time and patronymic of the client the first time; Corporate HR will send an employee a scale to evaluate his mood. It seems that others have never been careful about our emotions - and we have never cared about the emotions of others.
Almost forty years ago, in 1983, Arly Russell Hokhshild, the author of the classic work “The Managed Heart” , noted that about a third of people in the American employment market work in a field requiring them significant efforts to fulfill emotional labor. Among women, this share was even higher: according to the calculations of Hokhshild - at least half. Sales managers, hairdressers, telegraphists, teachers, insurance agents, doctors - and, of course, the stewardesses, for whose activity Hokhshild watched for several years - were continuously busy managing their own and other people's emotions: to create a good mood for customers, to give them joy. Others - for example, tax inspectors, auditors or police officers - on the contrary, made efforts to intentionally cause anxiety or even fear in their visas.
In 2012, in the preface to reprint the book, Hokhshild stated that in developed Western countries over the past 30 years, emotional labor became even more ubiquitous, since the services market supplanted the production market more and more. And in the field of services with an acidic mine you can’t go far. “At the machine you can stand evil and offended,” says sociologist Ella Paneye in an interview with Medusa . - Anger and resentment will even help you if you need, for example, to beat the firewood. But when you need to write a code or stand behind the bar, draw a flower on each cups of cappuccino and at the same time conduct a pleasant conversation, and all are so sensitive and react to the slightest rudeness, then you will do this in frustrated feelings. ”
The transformation of labor practices (or even working morality) that the panies describes is also characteristic of the post -Soviet space: here emotional work also became mandatory Soft Skill in various fields. This is not surprising: the services market is growing here even faster and takes even more uncontrolled forms than in the West. From 1990 to 2013, its share in Russia increased three times - from 32.6% to 69%. According to the World Bank , in 2019, 67% of the able -bodied population of Russia were busy in the service sector. Thus, the earnings of more than two -thirds of the country's population directly depends on how successfully they will be able to “conduct a pleasant conversation”, simultaneously carrying out their direct professional duties.
The tone changes not only in commercial companies, but also in state -owned houses: they, who, recently scared citizens with lunch breaks, ventilations, bursts and smell of a sexual rag, spoke the language of “concern for the client”, “happiness” and “prosperity”. In addition, the state and its avatars (Sberbank, “State Services”, “Russian Railways”) perfectly learned to produce the so -called Happy Objects - commercial products called up, by determining the feminist researcher Sarah Ahmed , to cause a sense of happiness or his anticipation: cheerful applications for smartphones, marketing souvenirs performed in joyful tones materials.
“If 10-12 years ago, the managers' focus of attention was the competencies to achieve the result, now, along with them, relations and the ability to interact come to the fore,” says Vera Kuznetsova [1] , a specialist in management psychology, the head of the unit in a large state company. At the same time, the main tasks, one way or another related to the management of the feelings of the team or customers, as a rule, fall on the artists of the middle and lower links - that is, on the widest layer of employees.
Finally, the sphere of production of the so -called socialized goods - health and education - in Russia, like around the world, is also “optimized” under the service sector. Doctors, nurses, teachers, university professors are no longer experts in the service of the state, but entrepreneurs in the struggle for the effectiveness of their labor. In clinics and universities, employees are increasingly “caring”, almost therapeutic attitude towards “customers” - they are replacing “patients”, “students” and “students”.
Remembering the selling trainings in the mid -nineties, Evgeny Kilovsky, an organizational development consultant, the author of the book “Forks on the desktop” , says: “When we talked with sellers, smiling for a partner was a problem. They said: he had not bought anything yet to smile. And we showed them that a smile is just a sign of a friendly attitude, respect. Then it became the norm: it turned out that a benevolent attitude is profitable. You sell. So, you yourself received both the fee and the internal satisfaction from what you did. " “The new economy requires kindness,” summarizes the panies. “Psychological comfort, on which everyone is so obsessed with, increases labor productivity.”
Welcome to the marvelous good new world? Maybe - but not so fast and with much greater costs than we would like. Risking to spoil the mood of myself and readers, I will accept on myself - following Sarah Ahmed - the unprofitable role of Kill Joy , a high -horn, who always seeks on the promises of “happiness for everyone and for nothing” a well -hidden price tag. I will allow myself to stop smiling and asking a naive question: is the mass introduction of emotional labor and institutionalized care really makes a “kinder” society? Did it become better for us, was it more fun to live?
* * *
At first glance - of course, yes. Western civilization itself, according to the sociologist of Norbert Elias, is the result of a constantly complicated and developing control over emotions. It is possible to overcome the state of war against all against everyone only by suppressing affects. It’s not very good for a person to take it and love a neighbor: the neighbor smells wrong, eats wrong, praying incorrectly. The “coercion” to what Arly Hokhshild calls the “superficial performance” of feelings - that is, to a polite smile and courteous formulations - allows us to at least not ditch each other at the first “let me smoke”. And at the maximum - to create an equality interface, to “darn” social fabric in those places where it is thin and torn. The English writer Rachel Cask in her essay about the meaning of politeness writes: “rudeness in something like public nudity, which dressed fellow citizens should be treated with condescension and tact. Remaining polite with rude ones, we have a chance to return their own dignity to them. ”
However, individual effort is not enough. In order for the war of all against everyone to be replaced by a public agreement, love for the neighbor must be transferred to sustainable legal norms - into a declaration of human rights, the Labor Code, the Constitution to which it is impossible to attribute to the stump of a obscene vignet. The law is not interested in whether you love your neighbor, he just insists that you will have to hire him, deduct taxes in his favor and pay a fine for a dent in his car.
The problem of the highlander is not at all that the smiles became too duty. It is different: today, when we are observing the collapse of labor markets around the world, the growth of inequality, erosion of various legal norms, the smile of a bona fide citizen hangs in a vacuum - like a Cheshire cat. As the classic sang , "I left the law, but never reached love." And the place where we got is far from as beautiful as we would like.
* * *
Anthropologist Julu Lerner calls the widespread introduction of institutionalized care “emotionalization of the public sphere” - but, unlike Ella Paneye, does not consider it a synonym for “kindness”. Rather, for Lerner this is a symptom of "a new round of emotional consumerism."
Together with other Israeli researchers-Maria Grezki, Claudia Zbenovich and Tamar Kane-Shalit-Lerner studies emotionalization on the example of academic labor. In the modern university, obtaining education is not only the transfer of knowledge “from top to bottom”, but also a service built into the format of “personal relations”.
Studying the transformation of academic labor in the USA, Israel and Russia [2] , researchers come to the conclusion: wherever you are, teaching has largely turned into a practice of care, mentoring and “pronouncing” students' emotions. According to the surveyed professors, students not only “require teachers of emotional comfort in communication”, but also share his psychotherapists about what atmosphere and at what pace they should study with them. But how to play the role of a mentor if the criteria of “psychological comfort” are constantly changing? And most importantly - what should the criticism look like if it creates “discomfort” by default? For example, how to give grades - for the result or for "efforts"?
“The idea that the“ good ”higher education must certainly be emotionally filled, descends“ from above ”university leadership and is then introduced horizontally,” Lerner, Zbenovich and Kane Shanit noted. “The teacher today is a strange hybrid, a mixture of a state official and a personal growth coach,” says one of the Moscow professors surveyed, does not seem to be quite satisfied with his new role. The bureaucracy and the service economy - this academic centaur is clamped between the two logicians - is unusual for itself.
Doubts and ambivalence are not only connected with the fact that the views of many professors (O'Kay, Boomer!) Are simply outdated. The emotional content of pedagogical work - for example, “fascination” or “boring” of courses, the “empathy” of the teachers themselves - is directly related to the assessment of the quality of their work as a whole and, accordingly, with the duration of their contracts and with earnings. The difficulty is that, obliged - both ethically and bureaucratically - to interact with students sensitively and empathetically, the teacher himself, on the one hand, is in a tough vertical relationship between the authorities with his superiors, and on the other hand, we are completely vulnerable to the labor market, in which there are less and less permanent contracts and opportunities for growth.
* * *
In private companies - similar processes: here also a thin ice of “care” about employees and clients covers a gaping void at the site of social guarantees and labor rights.
Well-being (or Well-Being ) of employees is one of the main items of expenses in the budget of many employers both in Russia and around the world . “Large companies are interested in employees to feel protected. Well-Being is understood not only health, but also a whole range of factors: financial well-being, medical insurance for an employee and his family, paying for sports, participation in environmental and charitable programs, events for employees, ”says Vera Kuznetsova.
It would seem-continuous Win-Win . But you can’t convince a high -beer so simply: the relationship of hiring, disguised as the relationship of “love”, arouses her suspicion. How did it happen that “medical insurance, payment for sports, events for children” from the components of the boring concept of “social protection” turned into a tool for creating a “joyful atmosphere” at the enterprise? How and when did Shurochka from the trade union committee take the place of Shurochka?
The answer to this question lies in the current idea of the employee as a subject of labor relations - and what is included in the very concept of “labor” today.
* * *
British researcher and journalist William Davis, author of The Happiness Industry , notes: in the context of classical industrial capitalism, workers put their physical strength into labor and, without a doubt, were subjected to exploitation. However, it never occurred to anyone to demand from them a more “personal”, “emotional” participation.
Alienated from the product of his work, the lyrical hero of “Capital” went from the factory home to fall asleep, go to the bathhouse, get drunk - or, finally, go to the underground Marxist circle. The next day, he really could “stand behind the Evil machine”: on the flowing roof in a rented room, on a 12-hour working day, on a blackened abscess on his hand.
Today's hired worker is most often not “blue”, but “a white collar” - it really cannot afford such liberties: he needs not only to simulate, but to feel enthusiasm and mental rise. “Love” for their activities, for their colleagues and clients is a necessary condition for work. In the words of Arly Hokhshild, the labor market needs not “superficial”, but “deep” execution of emotions - that is, a conscious suggestion of feelings, purposeful introduction of oneself into a certain state.
And there is nothing to “execute” - but a pure, unknown happiness. “Now IT has entered the IT industry that I would call“ hysterical positive, ”says Olga Pavlova, the owner of the IT company in St. Petersburg . - It is positive to be in relation to the client, the client himself must always configure also to positive ... Any reaction that is different from “how cool that we all gathered here today” is automatically described as destructive. Most of all, this is manifested in digital marketing, where the molasses are piercing. In the work, too, there is: something you are depressed, well, let's have fun-this is your job. "
At the same time, during the struggle for happiness and continuous self -optimization, the space of human life, which in the twentieth century was called "free time" is co -optical. The “deep performance” of emotions becomes an instrument of continuous monitoring of people and their own effectiveness. “Often you are required to do something that is simply impossible to do or is impossible in full. You are forced to invent different techniques, various psychological tools that will create the illusion for you that you are moving somewhere, that is, you allow you to shift the blame on yourself, ”says the sociologist and specialist in labor relations Natalya Savelyeva.
An activity that can bring happiness and joy - for example, communication with loved ones or rest - has value only to restore the body and brain and that a person can again begin productive activity. “This utilitarian rooting of corporate rationality in all areas of human life leads to the fact that even a smoke break or walk should“ optimize ” - they become a well -calculated act in productivity management,” writes William Davis.
Is it not worth the new "good economy" of the good old symbolic violence? Operation is a form of labor relations in which the employer assigns (often in a rough and insolent form) resources and labor products of an employee, making a profit from them. Today, the exploitation has been replaced by appropriation: the labor market does not appropriate the skills, resources and the product - but of the entire employee with giblets, including his feelings.
Natalya Savelyeva says: “This process of more deep immersion in the corporate“ care ”capsule can be called“ super -expansion ”. Its meaning is to compensate the employee with a shortage or high cost of socialized goods: for example, access to health and education. At work, you have a gym, insurance, trainings, delicious food - and outside the office all this is either worth a lot of money, or is not available at all. ”
Political scientist Georgy Mammadov adds: “To drink employees with free smoothies and organize them with ping-pong rooms is much cheaper and more profitable than allowing them to organize a trade union, to provide them with long-term contracts, social guarantees and pensions. Zizhek calls it “liberal communism”, when such illusory buns is created for a limited number of people, behind which nothing costs. It is like a feast during the plague, but even those people who were allowed to feast are in very praise conditions. ”
При этом считать такую апроприацию отличительной чертой исключительно «нового европейского рейха» — глубокое заблуждение. В самой жесткой и неконтролируемой форме присвоение рабочей силы возможно там, где она вовсе не обеспечена достойной социальной защитой. Например, в России, где несгибаемые вертикали власти торчат из-под фиговых листочков «заботы», как ржавая арматура.
Вернемся к российским университетам: здесь идеология «заботливого» преподавания и «чистки» среди политически неугодных профессоров и студентов внедряются по одним и тем же каналам. Одни и те же люди оценивают «эмоциональное содержание» работы профессора — и вычитывают его фейсбук на предмет нелицеприятных заявлений в сторону власти. Safe space и «личные границы» приходится строить в окружении людей с сильно запотевшим забралом. Пока ты укачиваешь на ручках закомплексованного первокурсника, кто-то другой может за несколько часов лишить тебя контракта, имени, репутации, банальных гражданских прав.
И именно поэтому хамство в России пока неизбывно. Этот тезис прекрасноподтверждает исследование культуры коммуникации в системе здравоохранения , проведенное Европейским университетом в Санкт-Петербурге : «С хамством в медицинских институтах сталкиваются все, включая самих врачей. Они признаются, что чувствуют себя беспомощными в условиях российской системы здравоохранения, совмещающей крайности: недостаточно обеспеченные государственные больницы в регионах и дорогие частные клиники в столицах. В первом случае врачам мало платят, а во втором именно потребитель получает ситуативное доминирование. В результате в условиях платной медицины врачи сами могут становиться объектом хамства со стороны пациентов или пациенток».
Врачи и таксисты, преподаватели и банковские операционистки, кассирши и официанты — в сегодняшней России, как и во всем мире — должны соответствовать нормам «экономики доброты». Однако их эмоциональный труд осуществляется в вакууме: он изо всех сил пытается компенсировать собой зияющие дыры гнетущей, экзистенциальной неуверенности. По словам Натальи Савельевой, «разные психологические инструменты, все эти ухищрения по работе над собой — это замена возможности как-то реально менять свою жизненную ситуацию».
* * *
Возможно, именно эта постоянно маячащая рядом прекарность и мешает счастью и энтузиазму на рабочем месте, а в отсутствие коллективных форм борьбы возникают формы индивидуальные. Бич сегодняшнего рынка труда — это не рабочее движение и не социалистические идеи, а банальный burn out , то есть так называемое эмоциональное выгорание. Например, «самой распространенной проблемой, с которой IT -специалисты столкнулись в пандемию, оказалась потеря радости от работы», пишет российский Forbes . «Сопротивление капитализму сегодня выглядит не как баррикадное насилие — а как скучающий зевок, апатия, хроническое отсутствие энтузиазма», — отмечает Уильям Дэвис. Герой сегодняшнего рабочего движения — не герой романа «Мать» Павел Власов, а мелвилловский писец Бартлби с его извечным девизом «I would prefer not to» .
По данным Международного экономического форума , эмоциональное выгорание обходится глобальной экономике в 322 миллиарда долларов — это сумма, сравнимая с совместной прибылью от Apple , Alphabet и еще десятка ведущих американских компаний. Согласно другой публикации в Forbes , сотрудники, теряющие трудовой энтузиазм, стоят компаниям на треть дороже, чем вовлеченные и жизнерадостные.
И никакие практики «производства счастья», делающие из работников субъектов уже не трудового, а психосоматического управления, не могут компенсировать прекарность труда, непрозрачность системы управления, тревогу о завтрашнем дне. Евгений Креславский утверждает: сам термин «эмоциональное выгорание» неверен. «Проблема не в том, что люди эмоционально выгорают, а в том, что у них есть постоянное ощущение, что они непрерывно вкалывают, а никаких достижений нет, — говорит Креславский. — Разрешить эту проблему наймом “менеджера по счастью”, как это делают многие компании, невозможно: нужно менять систему управления и систему коммуникации. Это не индивидуальная вещь».
От улыбки хмурый день, безусловно, светлей. Но в старой детской песенке ей предлагают делиться — а не торговать. В лицо тем, кому управляемые позитивные человечки удобнее свободных граждан, можно и нужно просто ухмыльнуться.
Редактор: Михаил Ратгауз
[1] По просьбе моей собеседницы имя изменено.
[2] T. Kaneh-Shalit, J. Lerner and C. Zbenovich. Changing Meanings of University Teaching: Emotionalization of Academic Culture in USA, Israel and Russia (готовится к выходу в журнале Emotions and Society , май 2021 года ).