
With a paradoxical photograph attached to the text, Leonid Radzikhovsky, of course, would gladly illustrate his article about the late His Holiness the Patriarch, May the Kingdom of Heaven be upon him. This Kafka scene, it would seem, perfectly illustrates the lengthy reasoning of the author of the article “The Pillar” (and the statement of untruth) - an anticlerical and agnostic who undertook to interpret, alas, Orthodoxy unknown to him, in particular Russian.
Condescension towards the “priests”, the perception of the Church as a supposedly voluntary servant of first the “bloody autocracy”, then the atheistic Bolshevism and, finally, the “Putin dictatorship”. One can immediately see sympathy for the author of the blasphemous “Resurrection”.
And this is written by a “progressive” Russian intellectual, how can one not remember, forgive the rudeness, Solzhenitsyn’s “education” (“From Under the Blocks”)! How can one not remember Bazarov, “Tea Party in Mytishchi”, and even Pisarev. I met old Zemstvo intellectuals, they had the Creator in their minds, but at the same time they never set foot in church, or they believed in progress and Semipolye. Almost all of them were invited to power by Felix Edmundovich and comrade. Yagoda explained how to dream of happiness for all humanity...
I hope I’m wrong: in the author of the text “Pillar” it seemed to me almost like a reincarnation of Demyan Bedny, Emelyan Yaroslavsky and the editorial board of the magazine “Atheist”. It is unlikely that Radzikhovsky in the stagnant years was a subscriber to the monthly “Science and Religion”, where, as a teaser for Glavlit, materials on cosmogony were published with hints that the Universe was created (in refutation of “diamat”), and translations of essays by the Catholic Chesterton performed by Natalya Trauberg.
According to Radzikhovsky, is the Church established by the Synod of Peter the Great, the priesthood in the service of the throne? But didn’t three-quarters of the bishops recognize the fatal February changes, removed the oath they had taken from the clergy, and weren’t Varlam Shalamov’s father, a priest, and with him a lot of priests simply revolutionaries? Have not a considerable part of the hierarchs and clergy been tempted by the Soviet lure of “renovationism”? What kind of “servility” is there?

Before the Council of 1918, the Church was in great internal freedom, in the flowering of theology and eldership.
What L. Radzikhovsky euphemistically designates as the “persecution” of the Russian Church under the Bolsheviks is in fact the great martyrdom experienced by Christianity since the year 33, that era that the author of “The Pillar” would designate as “our era.” Nero with his circus performances, the Japanese imperial regime in the 18th century, which brutally murdered hundreds of thousands of Christians, can only admire and envy the exploits accomplished by the Cheka-GPU-NKVD-MGB-KGB at the instigation of communist atheists. And about this Church of the tortured and murdered we are told that during all the years of her suffering she dreamed only of being taken as a servant to her tormentors?! To be honest, reading such hypotheses is unpleasant.
In chess, in boxing, and in the confrontation between Good and Evil, there is a loser and a winner. From 75 years of blood and temptations, the Church, namely the Church, and not disembodied faith, emerged triumphant over Lenin and Co.
After all, it is not priests who now “go to the council of the wicked” (and in the Public Chamber it’s even good to say what you think), but Zyuganov and Zhirinovsky stand in churches as “candlesticks.” It’s unlikely that they are going to atone for sins, rather they are rather fraudulently appropriating the voices of old women, but they stand and clumsily sign themselves with the sign of the cross. Blaise Pascal said: “Perform the rituals, faith will come.” Who knows, Your ways are inscrutable, Lord, perhaps Gennady Andreevich will also soon take his place in the long line for confession behind Vladimir Volfovich?
In the late eighties, Gorbachev, coming to the Holy Sepulcher in Jerusalem, did not hesitate to exclaim: “The last socialist greets the first socialist...” Much later, the general secretary of the dissolved CPSU surprised the world by asking his beloved wife to perform the funeral service in the church. The late Raisa Maksimovna was a teacher at the department of historical materialism for decades... Arriving in Paris, she immediately visited Lenin’s apartment.
Isn’t this transformation proof that Patriarch Tikhon was right? I dare say, even Metropolitan Sergius with his Declaration, and all Orthodox Christians. The compromises they made turned out to be life-saving.
Perhaps it is not easy for Leonid Radzikhovsky to agree with this, but the Church is essentially mystical in the first place: “The gates of hell will not prevail against it.” Catholicism survived its stumbles: the Inquisition, the temptation of secular power, “Caesar-papism” - and did not cease to exist.
Yes, Russian Orthodoxy suffered through collaborationism under the Soviets as the only way to preserve liturgy and preaching. How terrible it was to write Messages for the great holidays with calls for peace in the Middle East and general disarmament, as it was given to their authors, is not for us to decide. What was it like to depend on the commissioners, on the “twenties”, on registration, to know that they were laughing at the children of priests in schools... to get married and baptized in secret, to secretly visit hospitals.
But Providence decreed in its own way: “May God rise again, and let His enemies be scattered.” According to the well-known “defeated winner” theory, the Cathedral of Christ the Savior canceled the Moscow swimming pool forever.
So I gladly give you a photo: throw stones at Patriarch Pimen, at Metropolitan Alexy, the future patriarch, and at the same time at the chief rabbi of the USSR (the Mohammedan, apparently, preferred to drink tea), clinking glasses with their persecutor. L.I. Brezhnev had no idea that these glasses contained a potion incompatible with communism.
“An alien soul is Potemkin”: we don’t know how the leaders of the Federation believe. One thing is clear: it is not the Church that hopes that the state will not finish it off, but the new government, having finally lost the Progressive Teaching, does not have anything to console the people deafened by the disappearance of guidelines and ideals. It was the authorities who called for help to the patriarchate’s mansion in Chisty Lane and offered more than generous restitution of property, assistance in construction, etc. for cooperation with it.
The above, in my opinion, is a sufficient answer to the accusations of the immanent “statehood” of the Russian Church. Let me remind you of the recently adopted Social Doctrine of the Church. It proclaims the duty of every Orthodox Christian not to carry out anti-Christian orders from the authorities. The social doctrine made a strong impression on Catholics and largely accelerated their rapprochement with the Church Abroad. What kind of nationalization can we talk about in a country where permanent priests are still not allowed in regiments, hospitals, and places of detention? In secular France, all this exists, and even the socialist president Mitterrand spoke about his craving for faith, and all other presidents go to mass.
I’ll try to answer Radzikhovsky another time about who God is, “in whose name the Russian Orthodox Church acts.” It’s a little strange to oppose a blatant neo-Tolstoyan. I hope that I did not offend my opponent, perhaps in X years we will meet with him at matins in the Yelokhov Cathedral... and then we can talk about the “Pillar and Ground of Truth” by Father Pavel Florensky.
The fruits of enlightenment are truly indigestible!
Paris