
Recently, it is often said that the weakness of the current protest movement is not only in its relative small number, but also - that the main thing is in the absence of a clear discourse, a clear language, and intelligible requirements. That emotions often prevail over the mind. And that in general you can’t pierce the wall with your head.
Everything is right. Especially about the head and wall. The walls are not pierced by their heads - this is true. The walls, as historical experience shows, collapse themselves. It would seem that it could be stronger than the Berlin wall in its ominous hopelessness. But she collapsed overnight. And the heads, especially productive ones, are usually used for other purposes.
Well, and everything is right about the language. But the language of protest is formed right before our eyes. It is formed not in academic space, but literally on the street. Language is not only verbal phenomenon. There is a language of behavioral gesture, its dictionary, morphology and syntax. And this language, I repeat, is formed in our days. In any case, some statements are often not verbal at all, the authorities instantly reacts, it must, it must be said, quickly responding in its own language - in the language of batons, auto -zaks, police protocols, amazing in their prohibitive idiocy of personnel decisions.
They say: "Well, what is the use of these wordless boulevard walks, mobile camps and frivolous white ribbons, if the meaning of these messages themselves is unclear?" So exactly what he is clear, this meaning! Otherwise, the authorities would not answer these messages as soon as she can answer.
The meaning of these statements is also that they extremely expose the discursive resource of power - miserable, tongue -tied, helpless and, in general, hopeless. “Wow is helpless,” they say, “when they have clubs, and we only have heads!” But this is precisely the point that they have clubs, and we have heads.
And they talk a lot about optimism and pessimism. And they say correctly. So my friend recently reminded me that one day I answered him in one of his arguments in one of our endless disputes (I don’t remember what, and no matter in this case). “What you say,” I told him, “is too indisputable for it to be so.” This is to the fact that today it is easier and pessimist to be easier and, most importantly, more reliable and respectable than to be an optimist. Apparently, this is why I am an optimist. That is, simply because it is risky, and therefore more interesting.