
The story with the denunciation of the Putin Vertukhas on the leader of the Bolsheviks Ulyanov-Lenin, written by a certain academician of the Russian Academy of Natural Sciences (Ramzan Kadyrov also has also been ridiculous in this public organization), and would recently seem ridiculous. The apocalyptic picture of the seizure from the libraries of the complete works of the leader of the world proletariat, and after it and the entire scientific and educational literature of the Soviet period (because all of it was based on the mandatory abundant citation of the “extremist”) was perceived as a grotesque cartoon. However, the jokes are over. We live in an era when the offices imitating the court nonexistent in Erethia are based on the historical decisions of the Trull Cathedral. So nothing is impossible. And Russia does not look like fantastic, in which a law -abiding citizen can learn about the ideology of Bolshevism only from its specially trained critics (as Soviet citizens learned about the all kinds of "bourgeois ideology"). And the term shines for the fact that you gave someone to read the volume of Lenin.
The denunciation of the fellow Ramzan Kadyrov at the Academy is the practical implementation of the recent proposals of the press secretary of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the Russian Orthodox Church Chaplin to verify the extremism of the works of Lenin, Trotsky and other Bolshevik leaders. The Academician’s investigation committee addressed to the Investigative Committee was immediately enthusiastically supported by one of the nationalist leaders Demushkin (after the ban on the “All-Russian National Socialist Organization, the Slavic Union” He heads the “Russians” movement). Demushkin did not fail to gloatingly indicate that in the writings of Lenin "extremism" more than in the prohibited book by Hitler Mein Kampf. And from the point of view of the current Russian legislation, and especially in the light of law enforcement practice of recent times, this statement is not without reason.
The most disgusting thing is that such ideas meet sympathy in a certain part of the liberal public. The part that is ready to applaud the prohibitions of communist symbols in some "young democracies" of Europe. A few years ago, it was liberal politicians (more than solid) that already required criminal liability for "denial or justification of the crimes of Stalinism and Bolshevism," as well as for "promoting the ideas of Stalinism and Bolshevism." Those same politicians who equate the Communists with the Nazis and love to reproach that you cannot sit down with them on the same hectare. Is it now, gentlemen, to be in the same company with medieval obscurantist Chaplin and National Socialist Demushkin?
Supporters of the ban on “malleant ideologies” refer to the example of European anti -Nazi laws. Domestic holding also has long been able to appeal to universal values and experience of developed European democracies. The Soviet Vertukhai, whose hospitality I used in the same angry institution, loved to entertain myself with intellectual discussions with their guests. For example, about the admissibility of the concept of "prohibited literature." I remember well their exclamations filled with noble indignation: "So what happens - Mein Kampf also cannot be prohibited?"
Yes, you can't. One of the most vile (although not the worst) things invented by mankind is book prohibitions. Even if their authors themselves forbade other people's books, even if bonfires were made of them. The prohibitions of their books are no better than those bonfires.
The post -war European laws prohibiting the open expression of Nazi views were retribution based not on the right, but on the collective political will of the winners. They had the right to exist in the world in which people remembered the immediate mountains of the human ash directly seen. And the fact that fascism is absolute evil could be considered in this world a truth that does not require evidence.
But the "Yalta world" is no more, is it good or bad. And in our "beautiful new world", every new generation will have to prove from scratch that fascism is evil. That's just modern wrestlers with fascism seemed to do this. Prohibitive laws do not contribute to the preservation of a sports form. And in the modern world, they are only the rudiment of the past era.
From the ban on Mein Kampf to combat fascist ideology as much benefit as from the ban on the correspondence of Ivan the Terrible or the memoirs of Genghis Khan. Today this book is a literary monument and historical source, no more. And her ban is nothing more than a ritual execution over an enemy cult object, a magical rite. Only now the world will not be safe in which the fight against fascism will be reduced to magical rituals.
A warning about this, a warning to all those who hope to protect themselves from fascism by ideological prohibitions - the accusation of the anti -fascist Andrei Ivanov of inciting enmity to the social group of skinheads. Many liberal human rights activists are dumbfounded by such a plot turn. They are accustomed to believe that the current anti -extremist legislation “with proper application” should just protect society from fascism and therefore “in general” is legitimate. Well, maybe it requires a slight clarification. The very principle of persecution for "enmity" is not called into question. Here is the authorities and answers them in the manner inherent in it: either we divide the enmity into "correct" and "wrong", or the law should be the same for everyone.
Lev Ponomarev continues attempts to conduct a dispute with the authorities in their "legal field". He refers to the decision of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, which states that the incitement of enmity to the group (racial, ethnic, religious, social) is only calls for violence, discrimination or other violation of human rights in relation to its representatives. Only this decree did not prevent the depicting judge Madame Syrova to bear the accusatory sentence "based on hostility and hatred" to the holy new martyr Nadezhda, Maria and Catherine. That is, not for the "incitement" itself, but for the intention to "light up".
The motive is a difficult thing, and therefore difficult to verify. And this means that in the presence of political will and complete control of the court, it can always be proved. Today, when, under the banners of the regime of crooks and thieves, all the most reactionary gathers, there is no doubt which way this political will will be directed. Finally, I would like to ask Leo Alexandrovich: what will we do with Lenin? After all, he called the villain to violence.
Derzhimord is not interested in the protection of universal values, but a mechanism that allows prohibiting everything that is objectionable to the authorities at the moment. They are ready to do this with official zeal and personal pleasure. Until now, they were restrained only by the desire of the ruling clique to maintain some kind of visibility of solidity. Do not look completely ridiculous and funny. Do not allow yourself too sharp movements. Stay in the gray zone of undercurge and underdictature.
Today, the Putin regime has entered that stage of natural degeneration, when he cannot or does not want to restrain himself either himself or his zealous performers who receive new FAS signals from the Kremlin. And if still Kafkian episodes like recognition by extremist slogans "Down with autocracy and succession!", "Kill a slave in yourself!", "Long live the Russian riot, wise and merciful!" We were still single, you should expect a widespread expansion of such a practice.
It is the Kremlin’s policy that leads to strengthening mutual hostility and hatred in society. It destroys the very existing internal barrier in our regard to political violence. The barrier, as it turns out, is very flimsy. Confirmation of this is the readiness of representatives of almost all the ideological and political directions existing in the country to find out relations with each other with the help of the repressive legislation of the Kremlin regime. This is exactly what the regime is necessary.