
Dirk Grainter is found guilty of the deliberate murder of his wife. The jury verdict was announced on Friday June 29 at the second hour in the afternoon.
The jury consulted a total of almost four days in complete isolation of the world around him. This fact clearly indicates the lack of a single opinion. In the case when the first voting tour does not give a result (the verdict can only be made unanimously), which are in the minority set out their arguments. Any reasonable doubt should be interpreted in favor of the accused.
Despite the huge amount of information - 70 witnesses and 475 units of material evidence were presented to the court - the charges were not able to build an indisputable version against Dirk Grinder. DNA examination , as judicial practice shows, often loses its indestructibility in the eyes of the jury. It is enough to recall the case of O. Jaeus Simpson, who was recognized as innocent in double murder despite the expert’s unequivocal conclusion. This expert, by the way, was Robin Cotton from the famous Cellmark Diagnostics Lab, who acted as a witness at the Grainer process.
The jury approached the matter with all responsibility. They began their meetings in the building of the district court at 8 in the morning, had lunch and dinner together, and together went to the hotel. It was only once to be interrupted: one of the women-puppies on demolitions, and she needed a visit to the doctor. On the third day of the meetings, the foreman of the jury demanded detailed information about the DNA examination and a line with millimeter divisions (in America, where the metric system is not in use, this is a rarity).
The last day of the process, which began on May 21 and ended on June 26, charged unpleasant surprises. The son of the accused Colin showed that he bought a box of nails in a store of hardware, where, according to the investigation, a hammer, an identical gun of the murder was bought on the same day. When the list of witnesses was exhausted and Judge Paul Chernoff announced a break in order to then listen to the final speeches of the prosecutor and the defender, it became known about the new witness. Jacqueline Sverling, who was two miles from the crime scene, claimed that on the day of the murder, approaching by car to her own house, she saw in the courtyard an unfamiliar man who was confused, sweated for a long time and, seeing the owners, immediately disappeared. Dr. Grainter in his testimony said that when he approached his wife’s corpse, a certain “shadow” flickered among the trees. The judge decided to listen to Voir Dire drilling, that is, in the absence of jury. This form of preliminary inquiry is used in cases where the court wants to make sure that the witness can be trusted. In this case, doubts are caused by the fact that Sverling was treated for alcoholism at one time. In the end, the judge left the question of the discretion of the defense. The lawyer of the accused Martin Murphy, despite the fact that Ms. Sverling completely subjected her boyfriend, who was in the same car, decided not to tempt fate and refused the services of a dubious witness.
Murphy skillfully played all the inaccuracies and contradictions of the materials of the preliminary investigation. As we expected, he built his final speech on the absence of any believable motivation for the murder. According to him, the version of the prosecution is based on "assumptions", "guesses" and "speculation". The investigation, he said, could not submit comprehensive evidence to the court, excluding a reasonable doubt. Dr. Grainter, he said, had no reason to kill the "mother of his children." "Is there at least something in the testimonies that you heard - about prostitutes, pornography on the Internet - does all this have to do with the murder of May Grainder?" he asked rhetorically. In turn, the district prosecutor Norfolk Rick Grandi referred to the severity of the evidence collected in the case, which "speak for themselves", to the contradictions in the testimony of the doctor and urged the jury not to believe the deceptive goodness of the grasp.
On top of the picture on Tuesday evening, a man appeared, who was seen by Ms. Sverling and her friend. According to him, he grew up in a house, which now belongs to this couple, and, making a morning run, decided to admire his native shelter.
There is no death penalty in Massachusetts. After a short break, the judge announced the verdict to Dr. Griender: a lifelong conclusion without the right to early release. The convict’s lawyer said that he would appeal to the Supreme Court of the state.
Modeling the flesh - Grani.ru, 06/26/2001