
The scandal continues around the police major Alexei Dymovsky, dismissed from the organs for a frank performance on the Internet. He was already accused of working on Western organizations, and the major himself fears for his life. Dymovsky’s incident makes us think about protest moods among police officers, as well as about a new information situation, when using the Internet you can be famous overnight and reach the Kremlin. The main tool for "social promotion" has recently become the Yandex rating of popular blog entries. The other day, the upcoming closure of this project was announced .
Pavel Chikov , Chairman of the Human Rights Association "Agora":
Of course, there is a significant protest potential inside the police. There are two main examples. The first is the activities of the trade union of the police of the city of Moscow with Mikhail Pashkin at the head. There are also trade unions of police officers in the regions of Russia, they work with varying degrees of activity and effectiveness. The second example is the activity of police officers in the blogosphere. There are several very popular blogs and forums of police officers, such as Police-russia.ru , where current police officers are condemning what is happening in the system.
There are protest sentiments, but the current employees are pressed by the uniform, but pensioners and those who quit in a voice shout about how bad everything is. If you conduct a survey among police officers who have resigned in recent years, there will be almost 100 percent dissatisfied with the system. As for those who still work, they would be happy to tell everything, but they fear serious sanctions. The law prohibits the police with any ways to protect their labor rights, except for appeals to higher authorities or to court; Broken strikes are not only unacceptable, but threatened with criminal liability.
The story with Dymovsky causes a lot of doubt. The text that he reads on camera, in intellectual depths, contrasts very sharply with professional technologies for the promotion and promotion of the video. I think that a week ago Dymovsky such as “Yetube”, “Blogosphere” and “First Process Domain” did not hear, although these are things that any more or less capable Internet user should know to lay out and promote such a video. If we conduct the psychological content analysis of what he says, it will be obvious that this says a person who is unlikely to understand the issues of Internet technologies. That is, either he has very competent assistants, or all this-originally directed by someone. I would have connected this story with the allegedly written by the appeal of Vladimir Rushailo and other prominent employees of the Ministry of Internal Affairs in defense of Evsyukov and others like him. It appeared on the Internet, then it was refuted. Someone used the technique of black PR in their so far not to the end of transparent interests.
Zakhar Prilepin , writer:
I can’t answer specifically for this major, but I myself worked for seven years in the Ministry of Internal Affairs and I can see what people think about life, myself and about politics. Most police officers feel irritation, not counting, of course, those who sit on bread places - you can’t pierce them with anything, although these feasts in the moment can say: everything is rotten with us, everywhere thieves and cranes. The police are protested, but she will never express all her claims out loud. As for this guy, Dymovsky, and dozens of one and a half such as him, these are all exceptions, of course, they are quickly dismissed, these are the rules. I personally know five or seven cops who, on blogs under other people's nicknames, will smell their bosses. But this discontent will never result in real protest actions of police, relatively speaking, trade unions, the police public. Nothing like this will never be in the police or in the army.
I know that such Dymovsky are in nature, there are not so few of them. But our police, like the army, is a worker-peasant, it does not have a sufficient degree of dignity to you have protests. There are crazy (in a good way) that are being decided, I have met those. Maybe this case is directed by someone, but this does not mean that tomorrow there is no Dymovsky.
In general, one of the riot police officers formulated the situation perfectly when the National Bolsheviks were grabbed after the next march of the disagreements. He drove them onto the bus, trampled them with his feet and said later: "Yes, I’m a corrupt cattle, yes, I am a corrupt bastard, yes, I serve the villains, so what is my fate." It was a sincere monologue of an honest person. Basically, they can say this only with each other or detained to the mud.
Igor Averkiev , Chairman of the Perm Civil Chamber:
No one can say with confidence about whether this move is directed with Dymovsky or not. But as for the protest potential inside the police, it is equal to the absolute zero. As part of the campaign for the police reform, many police officers turn to us, express their dissatisfaction, sentences, but in their words there is not a hint that they are ready to change something radically. They have such a position: there are bosses, there are more smart people, anyway I can’t change something, although I know how, if we were asked, we would tell, but no one asks.
The policemen have many forums, at the level of junior officers the discussion is very wide, but this is only a discussion, conversations. In this sense, police officers are the most clogged part of society, except that the teachers are even more clogged. As for the trade unions of police officers are some mythical organizations, it is not known what they are doing at all, but you can guess that they clearly do not have existing police officers.
Unhappy and offended among police officers - 100 percent. Everyone is unhappy: both more or less honest, and those who are engaged in the trials. A corrupt policeman does not mean a pleased policeman. I think that at the same police forums, a policeman, taking bribes and engaging in assault, willingly complains about life for a company with colleagues.
In history, there has never been such that the army, police or special services change themselves from the inside, this never happens at all - neither we nor in the West, for this, there is always an external demiurge. Therefore, to wait for any initiative in this regard from law enforcement officials naively and unpromisingly.
Irina Yasina , head of the club of regional journalism:
The fact that blogs have become a way of bringing to society and the authorities of their position, a way for each person to make the news himself is obvious to everyone. Yandex’s decision should not significantly affect this process, there is some other service-this is a market competitive environment. Yes, for some time it will be inconvenient, but this is not fatal.
If the police still have normal people, they should have protest moods. The more protest moods, the more normal people in the police are a directly proportional dependence. I do not think that the video message of Dymovsky is someone's provocation. There are a lot of such dissatisfied majors throughout the country, and everyone knows this.
Alexander Plyushchev , Internet browser:
We have built an unrequited vertical in which citizens cannot through their plenipotentiary, elected representatives to exercise their rights-to somehow influence domestic policy. And it remains for them to look for some gaps: these are either performances in the media that are considered opposition-“Echo of Moscow” and others, or (since opposition media pay less and less attention, especially the authorities, since these publications exist more for the release of steam, and not as a mechanism for making some decisions), gaps of the Internet type remain. Major Dymovsky took advantage of one of these cracks. Blogs and everything connected with them is still new and popular, and even Dmitry Anatolyevich Medvedev is an advanced blogger, well, or at least pretends to be interested in the latest technologies.
As for whether this mechanism of influence on the information policy will close, I do not think that the top -jandex on blogs will play a key role here, especially - and I agree with Yandex in this - the nuts were twisted into it who wanted to make an instrument of influence in one or another side. It so happens that we like it if the blogger’s point of view coincides with ours, and I do not like it when the opposite is true.
It seems to me that Yandex did the right thing that covered this bench. But the country still needs such a mechanism of information influence-another thing is that it should be somehow protected from this kind of wraps and attempts to use its influence for someone’s purposes.
As for how to reach the authorities, the water will always find a gap and leaks: now it is YouTube, tomorrow it will be RUTUBE or something else. I think there is a way one way or another, especially with the current technological advancedness of not only the country as a state, but also the population. If the last major - himself or with the help of acquaintances - can make a page and lay out the video on YouTube, then the rest of the population can. Another thing is whether the authorities should overlap all channels, because less perverted mechanisms are much less dangerous. When the water tries to break through the cracks, it then destroys the entire structure entirely.
Evgeny Chernousov , lawyer, retired police colonel:
I worked in the police for 29 years and I can say that earlier material support for employees was much better. Now the salary is small, and the police do not receive apartments, and the volume of work is large. Major Dymovsky was boiling, an emotional surge occurred, although he did not essentially say anything new, such conversations are among other employees in all regions of the country.
Why did he do it publicly, via the Internet? He could turn to a higher management in Krasnodar, but did not turn, because he knew that he would not find the truth there. After all, there is a service of its own security of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, but it is inside the same department, it is subordinated to the chief of the Central Internal Affairs Directorate, so she decides nothing herself.
In Soviet times, when I worked in the authorities, the KGB carried out supervision of the police, now no one is controlled by the police, the negative management is not interested in the publicity of publicity. I believe that the Security Service, which is located within the structure of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, should be taken beyond its borders, for example, to the supervisor under the president, so that people have to contact, where to defend their rights. There must be a separate structure that would monitor all violations. In America, these are departments of an internal investigation.
The own security service was created to combat violations within the Ministry of Internal Affairs, but it turned out the other way around. If this service does not give back, it is necessary to carry out reform. In all countries, the police are more efficient in many ways because it knows that there is a supervisory authority over it that is constant observation.
The fact that Major Dymovsky took this step says that inside the police not everything is exactly, that the employees analyze the situation, she does not suit them. It is necessary to raise salaries to police, you need to provide some benefits to their families, is it possible to live on a salary of twelve thousand?
Sergey Konstantinov , activist of the Free Radicals movement:
If after some time we find out that Alexey Dymovsky entered a certain party, or we will hear the hot response of the president, on the basis of which the next pseudo -reform of the police will be initiated, then, probably, it will be possible to say that this bold act was just a provocation while it was too early to judge. I think there are units of such rebels in the police, and in those similar moods are not due to civic duty or other high motives, but by personal position, the standard of living of this particular person.