The history of the confrontation of Facebook and the American public is far from as local as it seems.

On January 4, Mark Zuckerberg announced that its main goal in 2018 will be large -scale work on Facebook mistakes. For the public and the media, this has become an important sign, because if in the past, Tsuckerberg called small tasks like reading 23 books for a year or studying the Chinese language, this time he promised to focus on solving the problems of his brainchild.
Under the curtain of 2018, it is obvious - if Tsuckerberg tried to rectify the situation, then the public did not notice this. Almost all of the last 12 months Facebook has been under fire, falling into new and new scandals, and the media continued to publish evidence of the incompetence of the top managers. All this led to the fact that the United States is seriously discussing seemingly unthinkable: the departure of Zuckerberg from the post of head and the government’s intervention into the work of Facebook.
It is still impossible to say who wins in this confrontation. The main battle will unfold in 2019, but one thing is clear for sure - this is a historical event in which the fate of the free Internet is decided.
The full list of claims to the brainchild of Zuckerberg is listed for a long time - in 2018 there are more than 20 of them. I will mention the most important points, without knowledge of which it is impossible to understand why the American public has been striking against the company for more than two years.
The beginning of the war against Facebook lies in the victory of Donald Trump in the 2016 presidential election. His victory led to a split within the United States - people were divided into those who are against Trump, and who for him. The country vying for a properly discussed how it turned out that the presidential chair was occupied by the chief outsider of the race, looking for the guilty. And found him on Facebook.
At first, the cybersical specialists, and then the media, noticed that during the presidential campaign, hundreds of posts called for vote for Trump appeared on the social network. The further investigation revealed that these targeted posts are associated with the Russian “Internet research agency” Evgeny Prigozhin, close to the Kremlin.

After that, they began to look at the social network as an involuntary mouthpiece of Russian propaganda. The leadership of Facebook was accused of missing millions of posts on a political topic with obvious manipulations. In November 2016, Tsuckerberg called this idea “madness”, but a year later the company admitted that more than 150 million Facebook and Instagram users (owned by Facebook) saw posts presumably funded by the Kremlin. It became clear that Facebook lied to people and called their doubts “madness”, and recognized the mistake only under pressure from the public, the media and the US government.
In early 2018, the situation around Facebook was slightly calmed down. Zuckerberg promised “to fix everything”, and the authorities switched attention to the Kremlin as the “main threat” of the country's cybersecurity. Everything changed in March, when it became known about the data leak of 50 million Facebook users to the analytical company Cambridge Analytica.
This organization creates “profiles” of potential voters using a larger array of data, after which it selects targeted advertising for them. Formally, there is nothing bad in this activity. The problem was that in 2014, the company bypassing the Facebook rules received personal data of 50 million users of the social network from the United States to draw up “profiles”. In 2016, Cambridge Analytica began working with Trump's election headquarters and used accumulated data. Facebook knew about the leak, but they were silent until they were pressed from the outside again.
Immediately after the history with Cambridge Analytica, the Prosecutor General of Massachusetts Mara Hele announced the start of the investigation against Facebook, and the company's shares fell by 6%. At the same time, the public connected to the condemnation - with the filing of one of the founders of WhatsApp (bought Facebook for $ 16 billion) on the Internet a hashtag #deletefacebook was dispersed. Thousands of users, including famous personalities like Ilon Mask, supported the campaign.
The boycott was hardly hit by the number of users of the social network, but the task was not to take away the audience from Facebook, but to force the company to pay attention to the holes in the safety of the social network. This was possible - five days after the scandal with Cambridge Analytica, Tsuckerberg interrupted the silence and began to give interviews to everyone, assuring that he would do everything to solve the problem. Once again, the public and the authorities saw that he reacted to the situation only under pressure.
In November, The New York Times has released a large material about the solutions of Facebook top managers, who brought the company to the crisis. It follows that Zuckerberg and Executive Director Cheryl Sandberg did not know about the problem of political advertising on the social network until the fall of 2016, although the head of security discovered traces of “Russian hackers” in the spring, to the presidential election.
Upon learning of the situation, top managers decided to hide it, believing that they risk a reputation less. Moreover, from the investigation it became known that in some cases, decisions on hiding information were made without Zuckerberg - he simply did not appear at meetings, giving Sandberg (he is responsible for the political direction in the company) to act independently.
Judging by the statements of Tsuckerberg himself, he did not even know that the Vice President of Facebook for communications Elliot Schreiga hired the DEFINERS PR-Firm, which wrote critical articles about the competitors of the company. That is, Tsuckerberg admitted that as a general director allowed his employees without his knowledge to hire PR organization to denigrate competitors-for example, Apple and Google.
For critics Facebook, the above scandals are arguments in favor of the fact that Zuckerberg, his right hand Cheryl Sandberg and the entire company’s management cannot cope with their main task - protecting users and their personal data. Moreover, they do not just not cope with this task, but publicly lie and silence the information, but admit guilt and begin to pour apologies only after they are pressed to the wall.
Throughout the year, all the largest US media have regularly criticized Zuckerberg’s actions, indicating that he could not cope with his work. Criticism comes from socio-political publications like The New York Times , Vanity Fair , The Guardian , Economic The Economic Times , Financial Times , Forbes and Business Insider . You can list for a long time, but these examples are enough to understand what opinion about Facebook is broadcasting publications with a multimillion -dollar audience, and what relation to the company is formed by readers.
On December 19, the National Association of Promoting the Progress of the Color, the Organization for the Protection of the Rights of Muslims of the United States and another 30 different public communities demanded Tsuckerberg, Sandberg and Vice President Joel Kaplan to leave senior positions.
“It became obvious that in its current form your leading group is not able to adequately solve the urgent problems of the civil rights protection communities,” the group appeal said .
The autumn observation of The New York Times indicates that the number of young IT specialists who want to work on Facebook is gradually decreasing against the background of numerous scandals. The December study of the Toluna analytical company showed that Facebook has headed the list of companies that have lost confidence. 40% of the surveyed thousands said that they would not trust their social networks.
Most likely, a similar situation occurs within the company-problems and accusations of the failure of the leadership are beaten not only by the confidence of top managers, but also by all employees. It is difficult to work in conditions when it seems that the whole public is configured against your company.
How dangerous is the criticism of the public for Zuckerberg
Minimum. Facebook is a huge company with more than two billion users around the world, and most of these people (even Americans) will not abandon the usual social network due to the critical vector of the media and the requirements of individual human rights organizations. However, the general mood of the public cannot be ignored, because the authorities look back at them.
Throughout the year, the Facebook position on the stock exchange was very shaking, and in total from January to December 2018, the price per share of the company fell from about $ 170 to $ 133. In December, the cost decreased by 8.5%. These indicators largely depend on the government’s reaction to problems in the company - the more often politicians criticize Tsuckerberg, and the Prosecutor General's Office threatens to start an investigation against the company, the worse Facebook feels on the exchange.
The fall of shares also affects the personal condition of Zuckerberg. He began in 2018 with a fortune of $ 75 billion, most of which in 2016 promised to invest in charitable projects. Now his condition is approximately 56 billion - this is the most sharp fall among other 499 people who are on the list of the richest people in the world. Forbes magazine called Tsuckerberg "the main financial loser of 2018."
How dangerous is the dissatisfaction of shareholders for Zuckerberg
The position of Facebook on the exchange really jacked, but the company itself does not experience critical financial losses. But any instability is alarming by the company's shareholders, and the large ones have the opportunity to contact Zuckerberg at least and personally express their dissatisfaction.
The shareholders are also annoyed by another feature of the position of Zuckerberg - his “excessive” power as the head of Facebook. Firstly, he is not only the general director of the company, but also the chairman of the board of directors, who own the Facebook controlling stake. Secondly, he has the right at any time and without explanation to exclude from the council of anyone who will openly oppose him.
In Silicon Valley, they unanimously say - the board of directors and shareholders has no way to put pressure on Zuckerberg. He reliably secured himself from any inner rebellion.
The idea to force Zuckerberg to leave one of the posts has been hiding for a long time. In April, the large investment group Open Mic demanded that Zuckerberg leave the chair of the chairman of the board of directors, since he could not cope with his duties, having two jobs at the same time. Although Open Mic does not own Facebook shares, in the past it coordinated the actions of the company's investors and monitors its development.
A similar situation occurred at the end of September with Tesla, Ilona Mask. Like Zuckerberg, he simultaneously held the post of chairman of the board of directors and general director, but after accusations of the securities commission in the granted and the introduction of shareholders, he left the post of chairman.
If Tsuckerberg leaves the chair of the head of the board of directors, this will give more independence to the meeting, which, in theory, will be able to appoint or remove the top managers by voting without looking back at the opinion of Zuckerberg. It will also partially restore the reputation of the company and give critics a clear sign that Facebook strives for changes. In 2019, the Council of Directors will raise the issue of separating the posts of Zuckerberg, but the date of the meeting is unknown.
In November, members of the San Francisco municipal supervisory board made a proposal to remove the name of Tsuckerberg from the name of the large medical center of the city against the backdrop of scandals around Facebook. In 2015, the creator of social networks donated $ 75 million to the hospital, in gratitude for which she was given the name of the largest private sponsor. Now the council believes that this decision should be canceled.
In December, the Democrat and the Congressman of the Lower Chamber of the United States Bobby Rush publicly turned to the board of directors of Facebook with the demand to dismiss Zuckerberg and "all other performers responsible for information leaks and lies before Congress."
The American people are tired of excuses, lies and intentional evasion. It is terrible that they tell us the truth only after it is “pulled out” into the light. Facebook is one of the most innovative companies in the world. It is very illogical that his leadership repeatedly acted against his own consent policy and made decisions that their product was subjected to and continues to be manipulated and is used as a weapon.
From the appeal of Bobby Rush
On December 19, the Washington Prosecutor General’s Office sued Facebook, accusing the company of “manipulations of users and the inability to protect their personal data”. After this, the company's shares fell by 5% - this is a logical reaction to a government threat to Facebook. In 2019, she promises Tsuckerberg a lot of new problems, and a multimillion fine is not the worst outcome.
How dangerous is the discontent of the government for Zuckerberg
“At the moment, it is obvious that social networks cannot cope with the task of voluntary support for the confidentiality and security of their users. Congress should intervene, ” said Senator Mark Warner in December. This statement directly reflects the current mood in the US government regarding Facebook: “If its leadership cannot do its work, we intervene.”
For many years, the US authorities did not pay attention to the brainchild of Zuckerberg, allowing him to collect information about millions of American citizens. But the scandal with manipulations in the presidential election and leakage in Cambridge Analytica are perceived by politicians as a threat to national security.
Politicians are seriously discussing the opportunity to begin to regulate the work of Facebook in order to exclude "kibaghrose" from other countries.
In other words, sanctions on the part of the government are the biggest danger to Facebook. The company’s campaign will respond acutely to any new attacks from the authorities, and Zuckerberg will become more difficult to avoid pressure from shareholders. The main intrigue is how far the government will go in the fight against Facebook.
Some journalists seriously consider (and even support) an option for which the authorities begin to somehow regulate the actions of the company. In their opinion, this will limit the “permissiveness” of Tsuckerberg and will help the company return to the “democratic course” she needs (it is not clear what is meant by this). At the same time, for everyone, including supporters of this idea, it is obvious that the government’s interference in the work of the largest social network in the world is akin to censorship, and it is unclear whether this will turn into a trend in the future.
Little is known about how Zuckerberg will respond to the attacks of opponents. He gave the last great interview in the spring, where he said that he was not against a wave of criticism of Facebook. According to the author of the social network, for many years everyone treated the company extremely positively, “and if people want to focus on real problems for several years, I do not mind,” said Zuckerberg.
Then he predicted that the solution of the current Facebook errors would take about another one and a half years - that is, by the end of 2019 the situation is normalizing. But how exactly is incomprehensible. According to the sources of The Wall Street Journal, in June, Tsuckerberg gathered 50 managers of the company and announced that Facebook is in the war, and he will lead according to this position. Sources of reporters did not explain what Zuckerberg implied.

Tsuckerberg is not used to dismissing top managers under the pressure of the public, so he is unlikely to "sacrifice someone." Theoretically loud departure to Cheryl Sandberg, the right hand of Zuckerberg, can restore part of the Facebook reputation and please investors, but this will not help solve the problems within the company. Sandberg has been working with Zuckerberg for more than ten years and has good contacts in Washington, so he will not refuse her now that her connection is needed more than ever.
You should not count on the voluntary departure of Zuckerberg from the post of general director and chairman of the board of directors. Firstly, he himself said that he would not go for it. Secondly, he did not create a double control system in order to abandon it of his own free will. Thirdly, this will not solve the internal problems of security on Facebook, but only delight the audience and politicians. And when the triumph from the departure of Zuckerberg will pass, the company will again begin to criticize the old problems.
In November, Facebook creator spoke about plans to form his analogue of the US Supreme Court, which, regardless of the general director and the Board of Directors, examined the complaints of users and monitored the interaction of content on the social network. По задумке Цукерберга, эта организация не будет подчиняться ему, и он не сможет влиять на её решения.
Я полагаю, что независимость важна по нескольким причинам. Во-первых, она ограничит внутреннюю команду в количестве принимаемых решений. Во-вторых, это создаст подотчётность и контроль. В-третьих, это обеспечит гарантию того, что решения будут приниматься в интересах нашего сообщества, а не по коммерческим причинам.
Mark Zuckerberg
Я не верю, что за этой идеей скрывается грамотный план. Во-первых, Цукерберг не раскрыл никаких деталей о создании подобной организации и непонятно, как будут отбираться эксперты и кто будет ей руководить. Во-вторых, сама идея того, что Цукерберг создаст организацию, которая в теории может пойти против его мнения, звучит слишком хорошо, чтобы быть правдой. В-третьих, на формирование этого «аналога Верховного суда» нужно много времени, а его то как раз у Facebook всё меньше и меньше.
Если Цукерберг действительно хочет выйти из развернувшейся войны победителем, у него должно быть что-то получше, чем фантомная идея о Верховном суде. Есть ли такая идея у него? Возможно, но я не знаю, что она из себя представляет. Но знаю, что Цукерберг точно не хочет повторить судьбу стартаперов-ровесников, которые отдали свои детища чужим людям, и были обречены наблюдать за тем, как их полностью меняют.
Скорее всего, именно разногласия с Цукербергом по поводу дальнейшего пути привели к тому, что за 2018 год Facebook покинули авторы WhatsApp и Инстаграма . Можно вспомнить скандал прошлого года, когда основателя Uber Трэвиса Каланика вынудили оставить кресло руководителя. В том же 2017 году место главы Tumblr покинул его создатель Дэвид Карп, который так и не сработался с Yahoo!, купившей стартап.
Что объединяет всех этих людей? Они создали свои проекты в эпоху свободного интернета начала и середины 2000-х годов, когда правительства разных стран ещё только присматривались к интернету и не видели в нём такой угрозы, как сегодня.
В то время Tumblr был открыт для всех, кто искал место для публикации эротического контента, и именно отсутствие ограничений позволило проекту завоевать огромную популярность. В начале декабря руководство сервиса запретило весь контент с рейтингом 18+. Показательно, что вслед за Tumblr пуританским стал и Фейсбук, запретив любые намёки на секс в соцсети. По одной из версий, Facebook пошёл на это из-за иска по обвинению в пособничестве секс-торговле — продаже и аренде людей для занятий сексом и выполнения различных сексуальных услуг.
Что же сам Цукерберг говорит об итогах года? По его мнению , 2018 год прошёл для Facebook продуктивно, и команда достигла прогресса во многих проблемных областях.
Для понимания — эти проблемы нельзя решить за один год. Для каждой из упомянутых областей мы разработали многолетние планы по капитальному ремонту наших систем, и мы успешно движемся в этом направлении. В прошлом мы не уделяли столько внимания этим вопросам, но теперь мы гораздо более активны.
Mark Zuckerberg
В таком позитивном настрое нет ничего удивительного — как любое публичное лицо, Цукерберг должен выглядеть так, будто он держит удар, даже если, в теории, он пока не видит выхода из сложившейся ситуации.
Я слежу за противостоянием Facebook с конца 2016 года, и нынешнее положение компании и её основателя — это яркое доказательство того, что время свободного интернета проходит. Он умирает не только в России, где Роскомнадзор в попытке заблокировать Telegram уничтожает рунет, и не только в Китае, отрезанным от мировой сети цензурой, но и в технологической столице США — Кремниевой долине.
Противостояние Facebook — это историческое событие для мирового интернета, и 2019 год станет решающим в этом столкновении. Но пока я лишь с опаской задаюсь вопросом: «Что произойдёт, если Цукерберг не договорится с властями США, и они получат карт-бланш на регулирование Facebook?». Это будет знак для всех других IT-гигантов, что эпоха их независимости и свободы заканчивается, и им придётся подчиниться тем правилам, которые продиктуют власти. А с этими условиями окончательно уйдёт эпоха мирового интернета, свободного от правительственного вмешательства.
#итоги2018 #мнения #facebook #технологии