
The Israeli troops, storming the residence of Yasir Arafat, a few years ago, who was present at the funeral of the Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, is a symbolic and tragic result of a peaceful process in the Middle East. All these years, the parties lived by various ideas about the future. The Israelites perceived reality in two categories - security and economic expediency. The peaceful process itself became possible precisely because the psychology of the besieged fortress began to disappear from the consciousness of most Israeli, which caused the survival of the Jewish state in a difficult confrontation with the Arab world and supported the Arabs by the Soviet Union. It began to seem that security may not be ensured by the cost of control over territories inhabited by Palestinians and used OOP as a bridgehead for terrorist activities, but on the basis of an agreement with the Arab world, including OOP. This agreement was supposed to save the Israeli society from the ghost of constant wars and terrorism and turn the country into an economic and tourist leader of the Middle East. Ideologies, as we see, are very few in these considerations - it is no coincidence that experts in the Middle East often wrote about the death of Zionism during the heyday of the peaceful process.
But the ideological component was the leading in the tactic of the relationship of the Palestinian administration - a large detachment of emigrants who came to the lands of autonomy along with Arafat - with the local population. In Israeli, the elite has existed for more than five decades - and in conditions, although a warring, albeit socialized to impossibility, but still a democratic state. The Palestinians have a new elite, who received an unprecedented opportunity to enrich themselves, letting all the financial flows of autonomy through itself, and functioning in the conditions of the dictatorial regime, free from any control by society. But as in any country where the corrupt elite accumulates in its hands all funds directed to economic development, it should explain to the company why this development does not happen. The explanation was chosen by ideological: while the Palestinians will not be able to create a full -fledged state with the capital in Jerusalem, one must think not about the economy, but about the struggle for the creation of such a state. From the most active part of the society - radical paramilitary and Islamic organizations - they were bought up, generously financing their terrorist activities and making them leaders participants in the redistribution of resources. So for some time there were two societies in close proximity to each other, one of which was primarily concerned about the development of high technologies and tourism, and the other-by purchasing weapons, the manufacture of explosives and total theft (the reader in the post-Soviet space does not need to explain that in a country where first persons steal at least any more humble citizens).
For some time (at least until September 11 last year) it might seem that all this is a temporary situation, that no other process of forming a new elite and recovery of Palestinian society after decades of life in the conditions of economic collapse and propaganda processing and it cannot be, that the arafat will ensure stability that other people will be replaced sooner or later, that the consciousness of these people will be much more modern than the consciousness than the consciousness than the consciousness than the consciousness The current Palestinian elite. Meanwhile, it was obvious that no one was thinking of recovering that for the Palestinians the desire to get such concessions from Israel that would entail the disappearance of the Jewish state from the political card (namely, the return of the multimillion -dollar mass of refugees to Israel) is not a propaganda slogan, but a part of the strategy, that leaders can become the heirs More radically configured than himself, because the leader of the Palestinian autonomy, like any dictator, has been engaged in what he got rid of all the thinking in his environment (often with the help of Israeli special services). But to notice this meant to sign in the failure of the peaceful process itself, and neither the West, nor Israel, nor the Arab countries could go.
After September 11, a new illusion arose - that the Palestinians are frightened by the identification of their struggle against world terrorism, stop terrorist attacks and agree to the resumption of the peace process. This illusion was justified only in part: the Palestinians were really so frightened by so much that after a couple of months they began to prove that they were not scared at all, with new explosions in Israeli cities. Then there was already a direct road to the war.
What happened in these months with the warring parties? They changed roles. In Israel - as a natural reaction to the atmosphere of total unsafe - the ideological component is again resurrected again. Zionism was revived - what else did he have to do? But this is another Zionism. When Javier Solan says that Ariel Sharon and Yasir Arafat must leave the political arena, losing to the initiative of the new generation politicians, he, like most Europeans, believes that it is necessary to replace the figures who connected his entire career with the confrontation. But does Solan think about who will ultimately replace the same Sharon or Piss to the politicians of "classical Zionism", who still remember life in the diaspora? Does he understand that the new Israeli leaders will no longer be leaders representing global Jewish interests, but simply to the leaders of the same small country in the Middle East, which the neighbors strive to destroy? And it is unlikely that they will at least a moment think about the consequences of their actions for the future European or American Jews. For the heirs of Sharon, the words "Poland" or "Russia" will mean as little as for the heirs of Arafat. Thus, today we are faced with “internal” Zionism - not the ideology of the revival of Jewry, but the ideology of the survival of the Israelis.
But what about the Palestinians? Despite all the slogans proclaimed by the Arafat and its close associates, ordinary residents of the Gaza sector and the western bank of the Jordan River are now preoccupied not with the struggle with Israel, but by their own survival in the conditions of the ongoing military operations on the streets of their cities. In its kind, this is also an economic interest, similar to the one that determined the consciousness of Europeans during the medieval wars: the most important thing was not to win, but to survive and maintain property. That is why, after a short time, the Palestinian administration - or the leadership of the OOP, if the structures of autonomy are finally destroyed during hostilities - will be forced to change tactics, considering new peace negotiations as an opportunity to survive the population and preserve property for the elite.
But this is only if this war is won by Israel. It was not won in the sense of destroying the structures of the Palestinian administration, the expulsion of the Arafat, the issuance of the killers of the Minister of Tourism Zeavy and the punishment of other terrorists and leaders of radical organizations. When I am talking about winning, I mean, first of all, the Palestinians understand that Israel is stronger than them and is not going to disappear that the Palestinian refugees from the time of the creation of the Jewish and not to the Arab state will never return to their native places and will not make up the majority of the Israeli population, that the United States will not support Arafata and terrorism and will be without delight, but without opposition to relate To operations on the lands of autonomy that the Arab countries will support the Palestinians only in words, but will not go to provoke the global oil crisis for the sake of the success of the Palestinian case that the European Union and Russia actually cannot help the Palestinians. In short, the gain in this war is the Palestinians understanding that indisputable fact that they will have to negotiate with strong Israel and this Israel will not be able to intimidate any terrorist acts.
If the Israel does not succeed in ending the war if the international community, especially the United States, tired of constant messages about the escalation of tension in the region, will force Israel to withdraw its troops from the territories of autonomy and leave the Arafat and its close associates if the Palestinians return to the negotiating table, having the authority of international organizations and support The Arab world, then they will not agree with the Israelis, and a few months later they will begin to blow up bombs in Israeli cafes and supermarkets. Former US Secretary of State Henry Kissinger in his recent article in Los Angeles Times claims that the parties can only reach a limited truce - each will receive less than he wants, but more than she could get in case of continuation of the conflict. And the United States, according to Kissinger, must call Israel to develop a peaceful plan and at the same time convince Arab negotiation participants that concessions also have their boundaries. However, there is, however, one of the flaws in this thesis: how the Americans will convince the Arabs, that concessions cannot be infinite and that it is pointless to intimidate Israel by explosions, until the Palestinians are convinced of this themselves - not on American words, but on their own experience? The logic of the crisis is such that the Palestinians - Arafat or its heirs - can reach a real peace agreement only with the strong, and in their own eyes, Israel. With weak Israel, they do not need any peaceful agreements.
World without Arafat - Izvestia, 04/08/2002