
On November 23, I happened to take part in the All -Russian Civil Forum “A next day for Russia” [1]. Plenary meetings, headed by Irina Yasina and Alexei Kudrin, encouraged participants to the “brainstorming”, tried to summarize some results, and the most important thing took place between the “plenaries”: several dozen “round tables” worked on this very agenda of the day for the whole country. One of the "round tables" was dedicated to the discussion of the fate of our science.
According to the rules of the game before each “round table”, it was required from a heap of problems in the area under discussion to choose two main ones to then explain their essence and the proposed solutions to one of the four moderators of the forum, so that, in turn, he managed to state them at a plenary meeting for the entire meeting - and several hundred people of various specializations were sitting in the hall.
Having sorted out at our table such problems as the unclaimed science in modern Russian conditions, the substitution of the concept of its development by mechanisms of bureaucratic control (and, as a result, the lack of a substantial state concept of the development of science and education), the increasing gap between science and education, etc., we have formulated the first problem as follows: “The lack of a substantial dialogue (feedback) between the scientific community, the system of management system science and society as a whole. "
In fact, regulatory legal acts that are directly related to the science of science are prepared without public discussion (for example, Law No. 253-ФЗ “On the Russian Academy of Sciences”) or with imitation of one (Decree No. 735, the Regulation on the Federal Agency of Scientific Organizations [2]). Despite the violent reaction of the scientific community (and not only in Russia), open letters, the collection of 120 thousand signatures, the “walks” of world -famous scientists from the State Duma and the Federation Council, followed by detention, hunger strikes, the society as a whole reacted to the news about the deprivation of the system of the Rusts of Autonomy, it was extremely restrained. Obviously, the majority of fellow citizens did not take into account the risks that arose as a result of such a “reform” either for the system of higher education or the sovereignty of the country. By the way, the not yet fully conscious result of the “reform” is that several hundred scientific institutions, divorced from the wounds and transferred to Fano, lost at least some representative, speaking in the science management system on their behalf; The Presidium of the Russian Academy of Sciences no longer plays this role de jure. Who and how will now conduct a dialogue from the scientific community?
Of course, in the scientific environment, rudiments of civilian and professional communities occurred before: initiative groups, which also created the TRV, OHR and Dissernet, and just people who honestly taught students and graduate students who are ready to stay after studying in our science. The only positive result of the “reform” today was perhaps the further “crystallization” of such informal undertakings - the July 1 club, conferences of scientific workers of the Russian Academy of Sciences, the organization of rallies and “walks” of scientists. In an effort to establish public control over the activities of numerous state bodies included in the science management system, to present them the point of view of the professional community, these initiative groups also formed a commission of public control over the progress and results in the field of science [3].
In order for the professional community to have a chance to “reach out” to the public administration system, it is necessary to develop a substantial agenda in the field of science, and the commission concluded that it is impossible to conduct a policy of development of science in Russia without answering a simple, it would seem, question: what science is actually in Russia at all?
This issue was the second problem, which was discussed at the “round table” of the forum. We do not know what scientific specializations are clearly represented in Russia; What is the level of Russian scientific groups compared to collectives of the same scientific specialization in other countries; In which departments are these scientific groups and, accordingly, what functions, except for research, perform (educational, production, expert-analytical). Without answers to these questions, it is impossible to answer the main question that interests the wide layers of society, is a tangible benefit from science, about how it can affect the development of industry, agriculture, healthcare, education systems and other spheres of public life now and in the near future.
Apparently, those who make decisions feel the same lack of information. The result of an attempt to “inventory science” (very expensive) is a “map of Russian science” [4], which the Ministry of Education and Science has released into “trial operation”, despite the fact that many experts who tested the system in a closed mode were said to predict a failure. For the jokes of the provided data on specializations of scientists and institutions, the sharp languages nicknamed it “A map of Russian science named after Ivan Susanin. "
Of course, the Ministry of Education and Science will try to correct obvious mistakes in some data (interesting, by the way, at whose expense?), But to teach the “card” to automatically answer the question of the scientific level of Russian groups and to compare them with colleagues from other countries - this cannot be done simply by the addition of leakometric indicators. An expert assessment system is needed, and it is impossible to develop it without the direct participation of the scientific community itself. Let's hope that the working group of the commission will be able to present such a system that would not only understand officials, but would not annoy the scientific community. The first steps have already been taken to this, the discussion is on the commission website [5]. Join, colleagues, who will do this work better than we ourselves?!