Zimin's Dynasty Foundation has been declared a foreign agent. This happened on May 25, but the “bell rang” at the beginning of the month, when the fund received a corresponding notification from the Ministry of Justice. The wave of indignation in this case overshadowed the reaction to the announcement of other remarkable organizations as foreign agents and united people of opposing political views. The fact is that this time they encroached on the sacred: science, enlightenment, the very idea of private charity. Evil appeared in a refined, undisguised form.
The purpose of this note is not so much to join the indignant voices, but to explain what is at stake and tell how the movement in defense of the fund is developing.
The Dynasty Foundation was created in 2001. Its entire budget consists of income from the placement of capital of Dmitry Borisovich Zimin, the founder of VimpelCom. This scheme is called an “endowment” - interest is used on the capital, which itself remains untouched. The capital, unlike most large Russian capitals, was earned without the patronage of the authorities - thanks to Zimin’s professionalism and talent. Naturally, the money is placed abroad - for the same reason that the state keeps a reserve fund abroad. This is not only a matter of economic instability, but also legal and political uncertainty.
Dynasty’s annual budget is about $10 million. This money is spent approximately equally on supporting science and on its popularization, on educational projects. This is two orders of magnitude less than the budget of the Russian Academy of Sciences, but the effectiveness of the support is enormous. First of all, grants for young scientists. This is to the point: a demographic catastrophe is happening in Russian science - the disappearance of still young, but already mature scientists aged 30-50 years. Dynasty grants to graduate students, young candidates and doctors of science allowed many of them to stay in Russia. Over the past few days, the editors of the Trinity Option have received many letters in support of Dynasty from scientists, including those whom Dynasty helped to stay at home. These letters are collected on the TrV-Nauka website, some of them were published on Meduza and on the Foundation’s website . In addition to young scientists, the foundation supports scientific conferences in Russia and trips of foreign colleagues to us.
If Zimin’s contribution to science itself is inferior to the contribution of the state, then in the matter of popularizing science and supporting enlightenment, no one stands close to him. Translation and publication of popular science books, lectures, science festivals, support for museums, teachers, libraries, the “Enlightener” competition of Russian popular science books and much more. Here, the effect of the fund’s work outweighs not only the contribution of the state, but in general everything else that is being done in the country in this regard. I participated in three science festivals organized by the foundation - in Moscow, Petrozavodsk and Kaliningrad, and during the year I gave 6 lectures under the auspices of Dynasty. This gave me the opportunity to watch the audience grow, get smarter and get younger before my eyes. I even believed in the future of the country...
What are the Ministry of Justice's claims against Dynasty? There are two of them:
Public reaction appeared at the “first stage” - when the fund received a notification, but was not yet included in the register. Petitions, collective and individual letters (in my opinion, numerous individual letters are more valuable than numerous signatures under collective ones), remarks in the media. After May 25, the wave of speeches in defense of Dynasty intensified sharply, both in the media and on social networks. The oncoming wave also rose, although rather sluggish and of poor quality. It began with the hacking of Dmitry Borisovich’s Facebook account - an aggressively offended post was posted there in his name, the fake was very inept, the vocabulary had nothing in common with Zimin’s style, the fake post did not hang for long, but managed to go viral. However, after the revelation, the uproar over this issue quickly faded away. Several vile publications by little-known authors appeared on garbage resources (sample headline: “For whom paid mourners cry”), and at least one publication of average vileness by an author of average fame, Maxim Kononenko, in Izvestia.
NTV has just unleashed a rude libel in the spirit of its signature “anatomies”. They say that Zimin financed liberals who openly discuss the benefits of the collapse of Russia, and, probably, financed Navalny, otherwise where did the latter get so much money. In general, the propaganda attack on Zimin looks helpless. This man is too tough for them.
A Facebook group has been created in support of Dynasty. The first action she organized was a series of single pickets at the fence of the Ministry of Justice. Natalia Demina’s report about this action was published on the Ekho Moskvy website. They often say that all this is useless; standing alone, the power is not impressive. In fact, it’s the same as with letters: a lot of single pickets are much stronger than a mass of people coming to one rally. This is a difficult genre - standing alone with a poster in front of a stream of passers-by, half of whom consider you an idiot and do not understand why you are hanging around here. Perhaps that is why its effect is greater - the effect is not from the impact on passers-by, it is small, but the effect from the coverage of all these stands, posters, and faces online. The pickets continue - the drop wears away the stone. The flow of statements in support of “Dynasty” continues: the Public Council of the Ministry of Education and Science, the Russian-speaking scientific diaspora, including Nobel laureate Andrei Geim. A rally in support of science in general and Dynasty in particular is planned for June 6. This will be a very important meeting: Saturday June 6 , 14:00, Suvorov Square .
To some extent, the decisive day is June 8, when the Dynasty council meets. The most likely outcome is the closure of the fund. Dmitry Borisovich has already spoken out: he will not finance Russian science under the brand of a foreign agent. Many criticize this decision: they say that there is nothing wrong with being a foreign agent, they say, you need to put aside your pride and continue your work.
There is such a very difficult problem: you are doing a good deed, and some villain makes you humiliate yourself so that you can continue this deed by dodging and getting spit on. On the one hand, if you humiliate yourself, you will be able to help people. On the other hand, by humiliating yourself, you strengthen the power of the villain. There are two guidelines here: what your self-esteem tells you and how much you do not accept falsehood. Having accepted humiliating conditions, you inevitably plunge into falsehood, violate the principle of “not living by a lie,” which changes the entire landscape for the worse. I understand Zimin’s decision well, although he also helps me and my colleagues in our affairs, which I hope are useful. Without him it will be more difficult for us. No problem, we'll get out of it.
One way or another, there is some awkwardness evident in the comments of the officials. They are, of course, no strangers to this, but they will lose part of their reputation in the eyes of their supporters due to this story. They will lose, but, as practice shows, they will not retreat. However, we must continue to stand our ground. Moreover, we need to fight not so much for the exclusion of the fund from the register, but for the repeal of the law. The Human Rights Council has already spoken in this spirit. The law, according to which Zimin, instead of gratitude, receives the status of a foreign agent, has no right to exist due to its complete absurdity and bastardism. Even if we do not achieve its abolition, a drop wears away the stone.
Boris Stern