The Stabilization Fund created last year, which receives excess budget revenues associated with high oil prices, seems to be becoming an irresistible temptation for the country. Citizens, and especially those of them who are vested with at least some kind of power, have lost peace and sleep: everyone is thinking about how to spend money from the treasured moneybox for the benefit of the people or for the glory of the ruler, who called for doubling the GDP for the joy of the same people. If the former appeal to conscience and emotions, revealing one after another social ulcers that could be healed by spending at least a small fraction of the emergency reserve, then the latter act more sophisticatedly. They call for investing money in a business that will bring dividends, diversify the Russian economy, and develop high-tech industries, without which no respected great power today can do. There are a great many proposals - as many officials and lobbyists as there are potential “points of growth.” One of the most original ones was put forward by the Ministry of Defense. As it recently turned out, since the summer the generals have been seriously studying the issue of completing the Baikal-Amur Mainline using the railway troops with money from the Stabilization Fund. The idea, if you think about it, is rich: metallurgists and timber merchants will receive guaranteed orders for rails and sleepers from the state. And the railway troops will stop hanging around idle - well, don’t cut them, really. At the same time, the generals refer to no one but Franklin Delano Roosevelt himself, who built roads and defeated the Great Depression.
However, the completion of the BAM does not seem such a meaningless undertaking in the light of the 48 million tons of raw materials promised to China by the state-owned Rosneft: it must be delivered there somehow, especially since the money has already been received. It would be easier and cheaper, of course, to build a pipeline. But then the railway troops would have to be renamed “pipeline”, and this would be a mess. It’s a pity that supporters of the turn of the Siberian rivers, led by Moscow Mayor Yuri Luzhkov, have not yet been heard, otherwise the line for the billions donated by fate would be fully staffed.
A handful of liberal monetarists, led by Finance Minister Alexei Kudrin and presidential adviser Andrei Illarionov, are holding out with all their might, repeating over and over again that attempts to simply eat up the Stabilization Fund will not lead to anything good: no one will even have time to get pleasure, like everyone else here it will burn in the furnace of inflation. It will leave scorched earth where the non-resource sector of the Russian economy still exists today.
As for all kinds of investment projects, in addition to the inflationary jump that their implementation will lead to, we can name a whole series of arguments that are exaggerated so often that it is not worth dwelling on them in detail. It is enough to simply list: the inability of the state to invest effectively has been proven by practice and numerous studies. In addition, such measures disrupt the competitive environment, giving state-owned companies an advantage over everyone else. And in the rapidly changing conditions of a post-industrial society, only a market environment, where the most active and open-minded survive, can give the country a competitive economy.
However, Russian liberal monetarists are quite realistic people. Realizing that it would not be possible to protect the Stabilization Fund from total plunder for a long time, the Ministry of Finance decided to choose the lesser of evils - to begin early repayment of external debts. In addition to the direct economic effect (the payment of $3.3 billion to the IMF saved the country more than $200 million, which from now on does not need to be budgeted and can be spent on something more pleasant), this approach has another advantage: it solves the serious problem of excessive strengthening real exchange rate of the ruble.
For a moment it seemed that the desired calm had arrived. Not so. A conspiracy was brewing in the ranks of the allies - in the bowels of the Ministry of Economic Development. Faced with the need to offer at least something that would make GDP begin to grow at an accelerated pace, and unable to abandon liberal methods, German Gref’s subordinates, supported by Prime Minister Mikhail Fradkov, proposed a radical reduction - from the current 18% to 13% - to reduce VAT (tax on Additional cost). And the shortfall in budget revenues will be repaid from the Stabilization Fund until the economy and the tax base with it grow.
The calculation is simple: a radical reduction in VAT (and, if necessary, other taxes) will help to deploy capital that is rapidly leaving the country; investment rain will fall on Russia, which will contribute to general prosperity. Everything in this scheme is good: the country will benefit, and the liberal virginity of the reformers will not suffer. One thing is bad. There will be no investment boom in Russia, even if half of the taxes are abolished. Back in January, business made it clear that it could regain investor confidence, which had been significantly undermined by the defeat of YUKOS and tax surplus appropriations in relation to almost all large companies. Only a tax amnesty and a reduction in the statute of limitations for privatization transactions. However, the government, through the same Gref, unequivocally stated at the Davos Forum that none of this would happen. And upon the minister’s return to his homeland, a discussion began in the press about the prospects of returning to the practice of confiscation of property. What kind of investment is that?
But even if we ignore the current climate in the country, the proposal voiced by Deputy Head of the Government Staff Mikhail Kopeikin to reduce VAT to 13% using the Stabilization Fund does not stand up to criticism. If only because income from high oil prices is by no means constant and, moreover, practically unpredictable. Having reduced the tax, raising it again two years later is much worse than a stable tax system.
A tax cut is only good if it is accompanied by a reduction in government spending, and in this particular case there is no question of this - on the contrary. Is it worth recalling that the monetization of benefits, intended as the abolition of unfunded mandates, resulted in an inflated budget at all levels. The “hole” that opened up in the Pension Fund as a result of the reduction of the unified social tax will open up even more after the fire increase in pensions. It will be patched up, of course, at the expense of the same long-suffering Stabilization Fund.
There is another reason why tax cuts won't work. De facto, businesses will not pay less. A little over a year ago, it became fashionable among officials at all levels to engage in banal racketeering while talking about “social responsibility of business.” Reducing VAT will only consolidate the vicious practice of shifting functions that, by its very nature, the state is obliged to perform, onto the shoulders of entrepreneurs.