
Russia is a country with an unpredictable present. Here the Fano working group in the disputes prepared the regulations and criteria for assessing the effectiveness of scientific organizations [1] , and a decent document turned out, and at that time Bonaparte crossed the border - that is, A.A. Fursenko wrote a letter to V.V. Putin about how science really needs to be reformed. After the publication in the “Trinity version” [2], only the lazy one did not criticize these proposals [3, 4] , but the authorities said: “It is necessary!”, The other authorities took under the visor, and Fano's proposals appeared to enlarge academic institutions [5] . Well, then competitions in the national sport began - who will be the first to run with his proposals to the right ear.

The first was the main scientific secretary of the Presidium of the Russian Academy of Sciences Igor Anatolyevich Sokolov, who proposed to create the Federal Scientific Center for Information and Communication Technology by merging three institutions of the Russian Academy of Sciences - led by the academician of the Sokolov Institute of Informatics, as well as the Institute of System Analysis and the Institute of Management Problems. Surprised? I don't. Last year, participating with Igor Anatolyevich in the same television program [6] , I noticed what arguments he protects the wounds. He said that everything is fine at the Academy, she herself conducts the necessary changes, RAS as a system of organization of science is ideal. “We should not reform, but we must reform us,” he said. For some reason, it was obvious that the fate of the Russian Academy of Sciences, and the institutes and laboratories, and in general, he was somehow not very worried about Russian science, as soon as he would be made “under it”. And it turned out.
The plan of Academician Sokolov is simple and elegant. Three institutes merge into a new center. The building of one of them, Isa, is transmitted to Sberbank - more precisely, not the building itself, but the land under it. The fact is that the central office of Sberbank has long been closely in its building on Vavilov Street, and Isa is just nearby. Of course, Sberbank will not sit in the building of the 70s, but in its place you can build something modern. ISA employees will be transferred to the IPU building, previously cleaned from tenants; How much will fit, the rest in the consumption. So what, that the director of the IPU is academician S.N. Vasiliev learned about this perspective from third -handed - no one really asks him. And the goal was chosen well not only geographically, but also politically-for Isa in his current state and it is somehow strange to intercede, except for separate decent groups, well, they will retain them (I hope).
Once again, according to syllables: this operation was planned and conducted by the chief scientific secretary Pran . Is this not an example to follow? Now it is clear how the reform will actually take place. Look carefully around: no one runs anywhere? Nobody wants to attach you to your place? Who needs you then?
It is useful to understand that such mergers are not just a change in the sign or move. Institutes completely lose independence, because the legal entity will be one at the head center. The brand of the Russian Academy of Sciences disappears, the newly created centers will no longer be.
Finally, the most important thing, we are no longer about the meaningful assessment of the scientific level of institutions and units, but only about the administrative resource that this or that director has.
Not that the project of Academician Sokolov was obviously bad; Perhaps he is intelligent. But, it would seem, the position in the leadership of the Russian Academy of Sciences suggests something more than the opportunity to quickly snatch a fat piece. It is accepted that the captain was the last to leave the drowning ship. Rats are the first to run.
Mikhail Gelfand
PS The editors sent this article I.A. Sokolov a few days before the publication, he was invited to publish his comment. At the time of release of the newspaper, no commentary from I.A. Sokolova, alas, was not received.
1. The working group of Fano Russia agreed on a draft methodology for assessing the effectiveness of scientific organizations. 07/28/2014 ( www.fano.gov.ru/ru/offcial/news/index.php?id_4=22370 ).
2. TRV-hunger, No. 158. 07/15/2014 ( http://trv-science.ru/2014/07/15/dokumb-8/ ).
3. “Chef, everything is gone” // Trv-hunger, No. 158. 07/15/2014 ( http://trv-scieence.ru/2014/07/15/shef-vsjo-propalo ).
4. Gelfand M. Why did the Kremlin come up with a “sovereign” Russian science // Forbs. 07/22/2014 ( www.forbes.ru/mneniya-column/vertikal/263237-zachem-v-kremle-pridumali-suverennuyu-rossiyuyu-nauku ).
5. Fano: proposals for structuring the network of scientific organizations subordinate to the Fan of Russia. 08/14/2014 ( www.saveras.ru/archives/10154 ).
6. Reform of the Academy of Sciences: Is an alternative possible? // In the meantime, with Alexander Arkhangelsk ( http://tvkultura.ru/video/show/brand_id/20905/episode_id/63231 ).
