The expanding global financial and economic crisis is seriously affecting the prospects for the development and financing of science and education in different countries. The editors of TrV are trying to keep track of this news.
Last week, the US Congress began discussing a bill to further stimulate the economy in connection with the crisis. We are talking about approximately $800 billion in government spending over the next 2-3 years, in addition to the country's budget, which now amounts to more than $3 trillion a year. The bill, already approved by the lower house of Congress by a vote of 244 to 188, includes $13.2 billion in additional spending on research and development. The amendments being discussed in the Senate reduce this figure to $11.9 billion, but in any case, federal funding agencies such as NSF, NASA, DOE, NIH, NIST will receive several billion dollars more to fund already supported and new projects when, as The bill is expected to be signed by President Barack Obama and take effect by mid-February.
While the bill is still being refined and amended in Congress, academic administrators at universities and grant agencies are already urging grant applicants to be prepared to submit applications in an exceptionally short time frame and quickly begin work on new projects. Significant emphasis is placed on investment in scientific and technical projects to develop energy-saving and environmentally friendly technologies, to free or at least ease the dependence of the American economy on the import of hydrocarbon raw materials. In particular, it is expected that from these additional billions, funding will be renewed for many fundamental scientific projects on non-carbon energy (Basic Research for Solar Energy Utilization, Basic Research for the Hydrogen Fuel Initiative, Basic Research for Advanced Nuclear Energy Systems), grant competitions for which were already conducted in 2007-2008, but were not supported in a timely manner due to significant cuts in the Department of Energy (DOE) science budget in the last year of the George W. Bush administration. However, the main emphasis in the bill is still placed on additional funding for scientific infrastructure, shared use centers and other large investments, with the obligatory condition that they can be carried out in a very short time (no more than 18 months), but which could then provide returns for many years .
In his first radio address to the country as sworn-in president, Barack Obama urged Congress to quickly send the bill to his signature and outlined several key provisions that he believes the legislation should contain. Other measures designed to stimulate the economy by supporting science and innovation include a proposal to triple the number of scholarships for undergraduate and graduate students in the exact sciences to speed up the training of the next generation of scientists and engineers.
In addition, the bill provides for the allocation of significant additional federal funding to individual states, including in order to prevent a reduction in state spending on higher education in the context of a crisis reduction in their budget revenues. The new federal law explicitly prohibits states from spending less than the average amount allocated in the previous five years to develop and maintain their colleges and universities, and even imposes significant financial penalties on states that make larger cuts to their education budgets.
Meanwhile, one of the largest research-intensive companies in the USA - IBM - began to offer laid-off employees in the USA and Canada (more than 4 thousand since the beginning of the year) a new alternative: not to go straight to the labor exchange, but to find a job within the company, but only abroad. The list of countries is quite extensive and includes Argentina, Brazil, Hungary, India, China, Mexico, Nigeria, Poland, Russia, Romania, Slovenia, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Turkey, South Africa and the United Arab Emirates. The company emphasizes, however, that assistance in finding a new job, resolving possible visa issues and paying for relocation will only be provided to those employees subject to dismissal who worked satisfactorily in their old place and are ready to agree to work in a new place under the conditions of this local labor market. IBM declined to confirm or deny whether this means that the relocated employees will be paid local market wages and will be subject to full local labor laws.
Back in November, the EU Commission approved a package of measures to bring the economy of united Europe out of the crisis, which also affects the scientific and technological complex. As in the United States, the emphasis is on research and innovation in clean technologies, increasing energy and transport efficiency, and accelerating investment in energy, transport, high-speed digital communications and broadband Internet infrastructure.
The EU Research Directorate held a special seminar to discuss the impact of the economic crisis on the European scientific and technological complex. The seminar participants noted that there are actually two global crises happening simultaneously: a financial and economic crisis in the relatively short term, as well as an energy and climate crisis, which is much more long-term. Since both of them are closely related, it is impossible to overcome one of them without paying attention to the other. It is also noted that the impact of the crisis is also positive, stimulating innovative activity in deteriorating economic conditions. At the same time, it is stated that the crisis will not radically change the dynamics of centers of research activity: Asian countries and the United States still have significant advantages here, although the new “blue card” program should help attract more talented students, graduate students and researchers to Europe.
The recommendations formulated by the seminar for EU science and technology policy in times of crisis include, among other things:
• additional stimulation of innovative activity by simplifying the rules and procedures for entering the market and increasing government orders;
• special support for young innovative companies (start-ups), which are the most vulnerable in a crisis;
• strengthening cooperation between corporate research departments and universities;
• increasing funding for higher education and basic science, with greater emphasis on climate change issues, “green technologies” and other socially significant scientific and technical projects;
• facilitating access for foreign students and researchers to study and work at EU universities and research organizations;
• fuller use of the advantages of a united pan-European market operating under common rules;
• establishing closer interaction between scientists and legislators;
• stimulating the development of flexible regional specialization instead of an emphasis on heavy industrial policy;
• encouraging national governments of EU countries to increase investment in education and scientific and technological development.
The response of the Chinese Academy of Sciences to the growing economic crisis in the country and the world was the decision to invite more than a thousand researchers from abroad to the country over the next five years to work at the Academy. The announcement of this decision follows the CPC Central Committee's call for state-owned enterprises and academic institutions to involve more leading foreign scientists in their research and development. The President of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, Lu Yong-hsiang, said that in addition to the main funding of this project by the government of the country, the Academy is counting on investments from regional authorities, companies and foreign organizations. According to the CPC Central Committee, to successfully build a more open and competitive economy, China urgently needs to attract high-quality Chinese talent from around the world, especially in advanced breakthrough fields of science and technology. The resolution emphasizes the need to ensure proper reception of invited specialists, good prospects for developing a scientific career and living conditions of everyday life. “We must learn to think even more freely, to part with or change outdated rules and guidelines in order to fully understand and trust them, to make fullest use of their talents in the interests of the country,” the resolution says.
Currently, 81% of the members of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and 54% of the members of the Chinese Academy of Engineering are “returnees” from abroad, and 72% of National Key Projects are led by scientists who have returned from abroad. It is expected that the new project to massively attract talent from all over the world will help China quickly overcome the scientific and technological gap in many new areas and significantly strengthen the country’s position in the context of global scientific and technological competition.
According to a survey of 20 of 39 Australian universities published in The Australian Higher Education newspaper, the vast majority are experiencing 10-15% growth in the number of international students. University administrators explain this by the fact that in Asian countries, where the main flow of foreign students to Australia comes from,
In Australia, education is an expense item that families are willing to sacrifice for even in times of economic crisis. There were 178 thousand foreign students studying at Australian universities in 2008 (compare, for example, with 624 thousand foreign students at US universities).
On the other hand, in Malaysia, private colleges are expected to benefit significantly from the global economic downturn as far fewer citizens will be able to afford to study abroad. The only way for them to still obtain a more prestigious foreign diploma is to participate in partner educational programs with foreign universities, which are offered by Malaysian educational institutions, or study in branches of foreign
universities recently opened in the country. In addition, Malaysian universities hope the economic downturn will make their education services more attractive to many English-speaking students from African and Asian countries seeking a more affordable education than is available in Australia or the United States.
To some extent, these hopes are confirmed by data from South Korea, where a sharp depreciation of the local currency is putting an end to the dreams of many Korean students to study in the United States or other relatively “expensive” countries. On the one hand, this has already led to a noticeable increase in graduate school enrollment in South Korea itself. However, at the same time, the number of South Korean students seeking an English-language education at less expensive universities abroad, including Australia, Malaysia, the Philippines and South Africa, is also increasing.
Andrey Kalinichev
Based on materials from AAAS Policy Alert (USA), Commission of the European Communities (EU), The Chronicle of Higher Education (USA), The Australian Higher Education and Xinhua News Agency (China).