Corruption - 16. With hope
“What the hell is hope?! - exclaims the skeptical reader. - After all, we are talking about corruption and about us, about our country! Can something change here!? " This cry of a desperate soul is clear. In Russia, it is fashionable to say now that corruption is in our blood, that we are historically doomed. What will be a success if corruption resolves by itself, when legal and market institutions (they say alone) or even more luck will come sooner or later, the real owner will come and put all these corrupt officials to the wall (others dream).
Dreams, dreams ... And all this is Manilovshchina - and about "he will resolve", and about "to the wall." Never in history is a decrease in corruption by itself. It was always the result of either serious efforts in the field of politics (in the sense of Policy ), or serious public shifts, the result of which were similar efforts. Of course, it was another - corruption decomposed and burned in the furnace of the history of the state and civilization.
Now about our doom. This position has two sources. The first is painfully crisis. Seventy years to us (and we ourselves) inspired that we are the best and most advanced in the world, forming a kind of mania of greatness. When the state, leading all of humanity, collapsed, we fell into another form of megalomania: we began to be proud that we are the most vile, the most backward, the most criminal. It is difficult to reconcile, of course, that both - either lies or the simplest way of self -affirmation.
The second source is the vulgar "excuse", the rationale for passivity or covering your own theft. There is its own highly scientific background. The American social psychologist Leon Festinger invented, as befits a scientist, the beautiful name “cognitive dissonance” for a phenomenon well developed by novelists. We are talking about the internal conflict of a person who is aware that he is doing something immoral. In such a conflict, it is very uncomfortable to be a social animal, and therefore it is common for a person to "remove cognitive dissonance." For example, if you burn Jews in large furnaces, then you justify this by the fact that they are “subhuman”. And if you rob your country, it is very comfortable to convince yourself that “everyone is stealing”, and “always will”, and “this is in our blood”.
Well, here: all this is a lie. There are no peoples who are doomed to corruption with religion, culture, history or race. For example, today it is generally accepted that Western culture is historically less corruption than eastern. And now the facts. British colonial officials were brought to India to corruption, to which the metropolis did not pay salaries. Similarly, the Dutch infected the population of the Philippines. Corruption in Vietnam developed with the advent of the French as a result of barbaric attempts to “modernize”. One hundred years ago, as the English colleagues told me, it was possible to buy elections to the lower house of the English parliament almost everywhere. The corruption of American policemen of fifty years ago is still echoing in fiction and cinema. Then, fifty years ago, the fight against corruption in Singapore began, which has now become one of the least corrupt states. And this is not a single example. The scope of countries in the level of corruption is very great, no matter what a reasonable group of countries we take, in Asia, and in Latin America, and in Europe. You will be surprised, but the regions of our country are even more diverse in this regard, even if you reject the national republics.
So those who convince us of our doom are lying. Do not believe them. For example, I do not believe, because I know that this is a lie, and I know that you can squeeze corruption. You cannot win, this is a fact. But to make it cease to be the core of the life of power and citizens - you can. And most importantly - I know in Russia there are many people whose existence retains in me an easy admixture of optimism. Among them are businessmen, lawyers, officials (even security officers or police!), “Social Conditions”, engineers, driver ... I met them in Astrakhan, Murmansk, Kaliningrad, Khabarovsk, Irkutsk, Saratov, Volgograd, Tomsk, Perm, in North Ossetia, in other places - it is difficult to mention everything at once. Therefore, the final series of my articles is called "with hope."
But it's time to get to the matter from the sermon. However, first you need to answer one more question that readers can arise: okay, if all this is so, so what doesn’t work out and does not work out for us? There is an answer to this question, but it is not simple. Here you need another term invented by scientists: "Institutional trap." The bottom line is that our daily behavior is far from always rational, more precisely - it is "limited rational." I will use the analogy from the mechanics. We know from the school course: in order to change the uniform rectilinear movement of the body, we must attach strength. In the same way, in order to abandon the usual behavior, you need to make efforts, spend certain resources. We can consider these efforts and resources as the costs that we will suffer to change our usual behavior. Why? What do we get in return? And how fast? And how irreversible will these changes be? We ask ourselves similar questions when we decide: is it necessary to bear these costs? Will our gain exceed these costs?
We are in an institutional trap when we believe that our alleged costs are superior to the expected gain. What is the trap here? - You ask. Everything is extremely rational. But the bottom line is that it is very difficult to comprehensively evaluate both costs and winnings. For example, costs are now, and the win can not be obtained immediately. And we tend to overestimate immediate costs and underestimate the remote gain. So, corruption is a typical institutional trap.
Let us imagine that I spoke on the Echo of Moscow ... No, it is better to Putin or, say, Medvedev-one of them performed on TV and called everyone who gives bribes, or is going to, or can, give up this vile business and never give a bribe. Probably (we imagine the vanishingly unlikely), if the vast majority of citizens responded to this romantic appeal, then corruption in the country would be clearly less. What would really happen? Almost every of us, faced with the first corruption situation, would quickly appreciate our costs of honest behavior (the rights will be taken away, the operation will not be put to the institute, etc.). And the win? Where is he? And when?
And one more important effect, which scientists called the "See Free Care." It is associated with the need for collective action. I will explain the essence of the matter on the example of a well -known parable. I don’t remember what the dispute between the shah and his vizier came to - either about the imperfection of a person, or about the limits of the Shah power - this is not the point. In short, the vizier suggested Shah to conduct a socio-psychological experiment. The shahu was proposed to issue a decree: such and such a night every resident of the city is obliged to bring a jug to the shaft of milk and pour it into the fountain. And the vizier also offered to tighten the fountain with a white blade. So they did. And in the morning we went out into the garden, took off the canvas and found that the fountain was filled with clean water. It turns out that all the inhabitants reasoned the same: “If I bring water in the jug and pour it into the fountain, then the shah will not notice anything. After all, the rest will bring milk. "
In short, when it comes to a public good, achieved by independent common efforts, a very widespread strategy. So with abstinence from bribes. Most will decide that his bribe will not be noticeable against the backdrop of general honesty, or if a person is very competent, that everyone will reason like Shah's subjects. So what to try?
Here the reader can interrupt my high reasoning and ask with indignation: “How is it?! Are we to blame? They - officials - extort and extort! To their nails! And better - to the wall, as in China. " I agree, but only by a quarter. Half I agree with the diagnosis and completely disagree with the recipe. Sorry, but you won’t get anywhere: a corruption transaction is carried out because it is beneficial (for various reasons) to both parties. Therefore, both sides are to blame for corruption, and not only for the indicated reason (I will return to this, so do not rush to criticize me). And the repressive strategy for the fight against corruption has never brought sustainable success. I will use my favorite metaphor.
The struggle in the kitchen with cockroaches with the help of chemicals leads, as you know, to the temporary effect of the visible reduction in their number. And a little later it turns out that they survived and again multiplied the most powerful, which your stain does not take. Meanwhile, housewives know that the best remedy for cockroaches is to keep the kitchen clean, not to leave unwashed dishes and floor, strewn with edible garbage.
No, of course - "a thief must sit in prison." A law enforcement car must work effectively and maintain a high risk of punishment in potential corrupt officials. But this alone is not enough. An example of this is precisely China, whose experience is so indicative that on its basis, mathematical models of cyclic growth in corruption after each campaign of a repressive struggle against it were even developed. Therefore, I will not return further to the repressive strategy for the fight against corruption.
Let us return to our institutional traps and other wisdom. Imagine a shah who wants to fight corruption, and a wise vizier with him. (Do not think that I am already moving on to the answer to the question “What to do?”. I continue to interpret about the concepts. Suppose that the Shah intends to turn to the townspeople not to give bribes, and the vizier retells him to this content of the previous text. They have a “political will” along with wisdom, and therefore decide so: since the residents fall into an institutional trap, then they need to be for them, then they need to снизить издержки честного поведения. А что для этого нужно? А создать альтернативные возможности решения своих проблем, если у них вымогают взятки. А что это такое? Да новые рабочие места для альтернативных чиновников, а это значит — издержки, но уже для шаха. Кроме того, мудро и властно рассуждают они, подданным грозит проблема безбилетника. Значит надо и тут подстраховаться. Например, можно предложить гражданам стучать друг на друга, если кто-то It does not respond to the call of the shah, and each report to pay with a small reward. And then our couple has a seditious thought: how much money should I spend? This is no longer a thought about our costs for honesty, but about Shah costs to fight for it. And then a new institutional trap appears - not for us, but for power. After all, they can also argue: is the game of candles?
These are the difficulties, and this is with a rather superficial view of the problem. But you and I did not consider another restriction. Well, how is the wise vizier not clean? And if the shah itself? (Save Allah from such a misfortune!)
Here, already very enthusiastic, the reader will shout: “Yeah! With this, it was necessary to start! We know about the vizier and about the Shah! How to win her when they themselves ... ”But I did not say that everything was simple. This means that we will have to understand both the recipes and in conditions under which recipes can help get rid of the disease.
To be continued
Author - President of the Indem Foundation
Photo of RIA News