Solidarity, having successfully held its December congress, proved the validity of the approach that formed the basis for its creation. The abandonment of the leadership principle of management, a focus on uniting diversified groups, and an emphasis on the regional component became the key to the creation of a fundamentally new organization.
A consequence of the implementation of the fundamental principles of building Solidarity described above was its ideological versatility, which should be considered an absolute plus. Within the framework of the liberal trend, which, speaking in the most general terms, is represented by the United Front, deviations from the center occur both to the right - former members of the Union of Right Forces, who at different times left the ranks of this party, and to the left - Yabloko and social democratic-minded representatives of the human rights movement. communities. If we add up all the vectors (this addition, in fact, is the compromises that participants in the movement come to during discussions), it turns out that in total this final vector lies much to the left of the right-liberal platform of the Union of Right Forces. This was reflected not only in the historically left-wing name of the movement, but in the program and plans of the movement, for example, in the intention to build close relations with free trade unions. I would even take the liberty of asserting that the ideology of Solidarity today is closest to the traditional position of Yabloko: this is expressed in the rejection of the oligarchic past, and in the refusal to cooperate with the regime, and in the socio-economic aspects of the program. It can be considered that in the historical dispute with Chubais, Yavlinsky emerged victorious. But ironically, today the leadership of Yabloko preferred a piece of paper with Ministry of Justice registration to work in a united democratic project.
The Solidarity congress, which the coordination group prepared for more than six months, was held at a very high level. The delegates, sparing no effort, discussed the most important issues: the program of the movement, the organizational principles by which it will be built, statements in connection with the outbreak of the financial and economic crisis, etc. However, after the congress, a number of issues remained in the space of discussion; the congress delegates did not come to a clear opinion on them, which, in general, is not surprising, given the same diversification of the participants.
Meanwhile, the issues that caused heated discussion during the congress have been discussed for quite some time (you may recall my article “Three Points of Disagreement,” published in July 2008). Briefly, the problem can be formulated as follows: where is the political space in which Solidarity should exist?
First of all, it is worth emphasizing that almost everyone is sure that the space should be outside the Kremlin. Everyone who still had doubts on this issue, thanks to the cleansing actions of the Kremlin, safely settled, some in the “Right Cause”, some in the Kirov region. Only those who are convinced that the possibility of communicating with the Putin regime boils down to discussing the issue of dismantling it remain in Solidarity.
However, in further discussions in the field of political topography, many Solidarity participants differ.
Quite loudly at the congress, and even after the congress, were the voices of those who are confident in the impossibility of joint actions with the left and nationalist flank. One of the most principled supporters of the idea of refusing to cooperate with the opposition from another ideological camp, human rights activist Alexander Podrabinek, believes that by saying goodbye to the “red-brown element,” Solidarity will become the center of crystallization of democratic forces. The only question is, what will these “crystallized democratic forces” do next? We are not playing politics with the Kremlin, but with whom are we playing? Without leftist and patriotic forces, Solidarity becomes a subject of political action that has no counterparty and no political field in which it exists. It turns out that by refusing to cooperate with the Kremlin, but at the same time not agreeing to interact with leftists and nationalists, supporters of the idea of a “liberal ghetto” doom Solidarity to hang in a vacuum.
For Solidarity to exist as a political movement, there must be politics in the country. Obviously, “dialogue with authorities” cannot be called this wonderful Greek word. It’s difficult to have a dialogue when your interlocutor is a cheater, and even with a cop’s baton in his hands. But the restoration of politics as such in the country, the restoration of public dialogue, in which representatives of a wide variety of ideological groups take part, is the main goal of any cooperation with leftists and nationalists. “Solidarity” is ready for dialogue or does it just want to crystallize supporters around itself, and then by some miracle (what?) bring these supporters to power, without starting a dialogue with the rest of society (the majority!)? Even if we imagine the impossible, and this “miracle” happens, then we will get a repetition of 1993 and 1996, which will inevitably lead to a new Putin coming to power.
In a democratic, liberal society, can some ideas be more privileged than others, and can the bearers of some ideals have more rights than the bearers of others? If we are not talking about perversions and violations of the Criminal Code, then, of course, no. Why should supporters of the concept of social justice, restrictions on the rights of big capital and private property be excluded from the dialogue? Just because other bearers of the same ideas at one time showed themselves to be anti-humanists?
Then let’s remember the “giants of thought” - the “fathers of Russian liberalism”, who were not seen as prone to excessive humanism and were ready to sacrifice the political freedoms of citizens in the name of promoting “liberal market reforms”. In his latest interview with New Times, Chubais directly, without any equivocation, associates himself with the current regime. The National Bolsheviks’ prediction ten years ago, addressed primarily to Chubais: “Let’s complete the reforms like this: Stalin, Beria, Gulag,” came true with amazing accuracy. Today, not only are selective political persecutions underway in the country, but a legislative basis for mass repression has already been created: not only “radicals” from the United Front, but even moderate experts and human rights activists are talking about the return of ’37.
Who fought for our and your freedom: the Moscow Region National Bolshevik Yuri Chervochkin, who was killed for posting leaflets demanding free elections, or the “liberal” Leonid Gozman, carrying out Kremlin orders with undisguised cynicism?
We need to abandon the ideology of liberalism without democracy that we inherited from the Yeltsin-Putin “liberals”. No matter how correct, from the point of view of economic liberalism, the steps taken by the authoritarian government may seem, they inevitably lead the country to a dead end - not only political, but also economic: free business competition is impossible without political competition, without equality before the law, without separation of powers.
As paradoxical as it may sound, the “liberal” state of the 90s (not to mention the Putin regime) turned out to be just a reincarnation of the Soviet system with its monopoly on ideology, with its disregard for the law, with its system of suppressing dissent. Therefore, refusal to cooperate with the current “Soviet government” has as its logical continuation the acceptance of interaction with representatives of the entire spectrum of dissent. After all, this is the only way, starting with yourself, that you can destroy the traditional attitude towards ideological monopolism.
“Solidarity” chose the “Apple” based refusal to cooperate with the monopolistic regime. The key slogan of the Union of Right Forces about authoritarian modernization has been consigned to the dustbin of history. Now the new movement only has to take one more logical step, which will allow us to get out of the vicious circle of authoritarianism that we inherited from the 20th century.
The transformation of Solidarity into a political entity is only possible simultaneously with the creation of a political space. This is exactly what the UGF has been aiming for since its inception. This is precisely the main goal of the National Assembly, and not at all “friendship against Putin,” as the respected colleague Podrabinek claims. The new political space, which by definition cannot be ideologically homogeneous, nevertheless carries in its engineering design core principles that in no way contradict liberal ideology. Principles that are shared by all political entities operating in this political space: equality of all participants in political competition, openness, democracy, freedom of expression, mutual respect, etc. It is these principles that are spelled out in the liberal-spirited Charter, which was signed by every deputy of the National Assembly. Having agreed on these rules and the inadmissibility of violating them, one can already conduct tough debates regarding all other aspects of the social, economic, and cultural life of the country.
Why build an alternative political space at all? Of course, for someone who does not believe that dismantling the current regime is possible, a movement like Solidarity turns from an effective political entity into a place where you can clear your conscience with the words “I am doing even more than some.” But with such an attitude it is hardly worth getting involved in politics. If we really calculate the chances of success, then we cannot help but understand that the current economic cataclysms do not leave the ruling regime any hope for a favorable outcome. And at the moment of the political collapse of the Putin system, only joint actions of the opposition can create a stable configuration of the transitional government and not plunge the country into civil war. Only by creating a platform for dialogue between different ideological groups of society can we avoid turning disputes into the language of weapons. The task of the transitional, fundamentally heterogeneous coalition government is to prepare the country for full-scale elections in which Solidarity, as a representative of the United Democrats, will compete with other political entities. Now some of our colleagues in the National Assembly (first of all, I mean Eduard Limonov) are expressing displeasure with the participation of the UCF in Solidarity, declaring that the idea of the Assembly is being undermined. Such criticism ignores the fact that the Assembly is a political platform in which various political actors must act. In this regard, I would wish the representatives of all ideological movements represented in the National Assembly to be more actively involved in creating powerful united political entities: both for future competition in free elections, and for a more effective struggle for the very possibility of holding them.
It was with this understanding of the situation that the UCF initiated the process of uniting the democrats. The role of Solidarity as an association built on very specific principles spelled out in its program increases sharply precisely at the moment of restoration of free political competition, at the moment when the ideological and political struggle of normal political subjects, and not homunculi from the Kremlin test tube, begins. But we must understand that without joint actions with our future competitors at the current stage, we will never have the opportunity to prove the superiority of our ideas in fair and open elections.