Dear editors!
Since periodic reading of the media is an important part of the civic duty of each individual member of the civil society being built in our country, I try to read not only my favorite “Trinity Option”, but also other media, in particular the newspaper “Poisk”. And this is what I read in the issue of Poisk dated November 14, 2008: “To form a unified package of proposals from the Academy of Sciences on the topics of projects that are planned to be implemented within the framework of the Federal Target Program “Scientific and Scientific-Pedagogical Personnel of Innovative Russia” for activities associated with scientific and educational centers and scientific research conducted by leading scientists of Russia - this decision was made by the Board of Directors of the RAS Institutes.”
Those are the times, I thought, this is as simple as everything ingenious! Instead of fussing with competitions, evaluation of applications and other crap, worthy people will gather, sit over a glass of tea, lay out their arguments on the table and decide where is a scientific and educational center, and where - who knows what, where is an outstanding scientist, and where - a researcher suspiciously actively publishing in enemy journals. How much less bureaucracy there will be! Everything is great, just doubt in my soul is like a black cat - all the same, unnecessary paperwork cannot be avoided, they will still torment scientists with various technical specifications and compliance sheets. Why, one might ask, if everything has already been decided at the top anyway? There is still something wrong in this.
And it seems to me that there is a correct, state solution to this issue: to cancel all these soulless bureaucratic competitions that take up so much of our time and energy! All that is needed is that with a smooth movement of the sovereign’s hand, transfer money from the Federal Target Program to the leadership of the Academy, the Union of Rectors, the Association of State Research Centers, so that they themselves can decide who to give money to. And it’s even easier to spend this money on the directors of the institutes - they know better who is worth what. Let them distribute money to their subordinates, some for an entire scientific school, and some for a group led by a doctor of sciences. It is possible to organize all this solemnly and upliftingly, with the solemn presentation of the corresponding certificates of honor and badges in the assembly hall at a gathering of learned people.
Of course, there will be skeptics who will cry out about the infringement of the competitive principle, and will begin to say that the director of an institution cannot be a luminary of all sciences and will not be able to evaluate all his subordinates equally qualifiedly. And in some places, a personal attitude will contribute to this or that assessment, and in others, the director is so-so in terms of professional qualities. But these arguments, if you think about it, are not worth a damn. You need to look at life philosophically and dialectically. The director was placed on top, and from above it is clearer what and how to do. And the director sits on top, he also knows better what’s going on. Does he really have less right to decide who and what to do in his institution and what money to receive than some incomprehensible experts?
Yes, maybe the director doesn’t have a clue about your topic, so go and explain, prove that you’re doing business and not some unknown thing. It’s not for nothing that bosses are bosses; you need to be able to find an approach to them. Again, if you have any personal or scientific friction with the leadership, think about it, are you really right? Suppose you believe that there is some ethical or scientific truth that you defend, that the leader is wrong, but think about who he is and who you are? It was not for nothing that he achieved a leadership position, but what have you achieved, some kind of truth lying around, which, perhaps, is the truth only in your head? And even then, at the current level of development of science and society, and tomorrow, in view of newly discovered facts, it will cease to be the truth even for you, you yourself will think with surprise what kind of stupidity you were clinging to.
On the contrary, if you pay attention to the measured rotation of the wheels of the administrative and state mechanism, you will understand even with your frail little mind that this is a highly rational and thoughtful action. Then you will even admire how rationally life is organized; it is not for nothing that the great Hegel said that everything that is real is rational. At the top, people are not guided by some absurd “truths” or “truths” (who is interested in these children’s phantoms there?), but by national and state interests, measured seven times and then carefully cut off.
Looking at this rotation of high spheres full of wisdom, I would like to slightly paraphrase another great philosopher, our Immanuel, Kaliningrad, Kant: “Two things in the world fill my soul with sacred awe - the Kremlin stars above my head and the moral law they form within us.” If this philosophical truth is applied in practice, it means that you need to love your boss sincerely and reverently, and you will be rewarded - without unnecessary paperwork. After all, it’s clearer from above!