
On March 9, 2013, I had the honor to judge the final of the All -Russian tournament of young physicists (TUF). The final turned out to be dramatic, and since I myself participated in the tournament in 1991, and now I have repeatedly participated in judges, I would like to share my impressions.
TUKH - team competition. During the year, five students solve 17 problems, necessarily including an experimental and theoretical study of some physical process. The teams present their decision in the tournament in the form of a 12-minute scientific report, while the instruments-ropens act as an opponent choosing the task for the speaker and the reviewer, disputed issues are solved in the format of the discussion, and the jury evaluates the performances of participants on a 10-point scale. The points received for the report are multiplied by 3, for opponing - by 2. Winners of local tournaments participate in regional competitions, the winners of the regional are in the All -Russian Tyuj, whose winners go to the international tournament.
This year, the All -Russian tournament organized the SUNC of Moscow State University, and the final was held in the central physical audience of the Faculty of Physics of Moscow State University. Three teams competed: two - from the Moscow and Novosibirsk Suntsov, and one - the Novosibirsk team of the Pythagoras school.
The final of the tournament traditionally takes place as follows: each team selects the task for the report itself, and the draw takes place before the battle, in what order the commands will perform and who will oppose to whom, there are no reviews on the final.
The first to report to report to the Pythagoras school. The guys chose the task of the "Carousel of the Helmholtz": “Fix the New Year's Christmas balls on the carousel frame so that the holes of the balls lay in a horizontal plane. The carousel should be installed on the support using a device with minimal friction. When the sound source is turned on, the carousel will begin to rotate a certain frequency and intensity. Explain this effect and select the parameters that ensure the maximum speed of rotation of the carousel. ” He opposed them with the NSU SUNC.
Pythagoras presented a spectacular presentation that for the tournament in recent years it has already become a standard, it was perfectly structured, included video experiments, and the theoretical part was preceded by a historical certificate of the first such experience. The performance was preceded by a visual demonstration of the phenomenon being studied. The speaker strictly met the regulations. In general, all this made a positive impression on the jury, and the opponent from the NSU SUNC was unable to somehow shake it, since it remained in the canvas of the report, pointing to minor flaws. As a result, on average, the speaker received a fairly high rating, many placed 8 or 9 points. One trouble: in the report, the main issue of the task was bypassed by attention, i.e. In fact, the physicist of the phenomenon was explained, but the problem was not solved. There was no maximization of the speed of rotation, there was no study of dependence on the frequency of sound.
The next was reported by the NSU SUNC, and opposed him by the SUNC of Moscow State University. The Novosibirsk chose the task “Dancing Ball”: “If you drop the ball from table tennis to the floor, it will jump. Explore this process if the ball is filled with liquid. How will the nature of the collision depend on the amount of liquid in the ball and other significant parameters? ”
The speaker also flashed with a good presentation and a good sense of time, impressed the study of various modes of system behavior, I personally value this in the tasks of the tuf. But the opponent in the correct and friendly form did not leave a stone and stone on the stone: in addition to a qualitative explanation, there is no parameterization of the task - neither the variable input parameters had a quantitative assessment, neither the result removed from the experimental installation, and the very qualitative understanding of the process left much to be desired. This time the jury was more attentive to the conditions of the task: a deviation of the experimental attitude from the given was noted - a hole in the ball through which water was poured and through which the cumulative stream carried the pulse. As a result, the opponent from the SUNC of Moscow State University received a point higher than the speaker from Novosibirsk.
The last was reported by the SUNC of Moscow State University, the Pythagoras team opposed. Moscow boarding schools chose the task of “soliton”: “ On a hard horizontal axis at an equal distance, place a number of identical pendulums that can only experience free rotation around the axis, and tie the pendulums with weak springs. Explore the spread of indignation in such a chain of pendulums. Find the speed of the wave, including when the pendulums experience a full revolution around the axis. ”
In my opinion, it was the best report. The task was chosen by the most difficult thing that could be expected - this is the SUNC of Moscow State University! The public showed an experimental attitude and a number of experiments in the recording during the presentation. All the operating modes available for this implementation of the experimental installation were investigated, mentioned in the theoretical part of the remaining regimes that shocked my imagination that had lost the imagination from mathematical crocodiles, and I openly did not keep up with the speaker, who was also somewhat in a hurry.
The measurements were presented with errors correctly displayed on the graphs, which students do not always know how to do, theoretical graphs fell into mistakes, in general everything was wonderful. True, the volume of work itself and enthusiasm for the Matapparate did not allow the speaker to make his report understandable and meet the regulations, and, moreover, all this gave a wonderful opportunity for the opponent to establish a discussion, which the entire hall and the jury listened very carefully and tensely, despite no longer any regulations. It was a truly interesting discussion, and the opponent from the Pythagoras school was able to demonstrate a phenomenal understanding of the physics of the process, despite the complexity of the task. For which both participants received maximum grades at this competition, and the opponent’s estimates were even a little higher.
As a result, with an advantage of 0.2 points, the Pythagoras team won the tournament from Novosibirsk. 0.2 points is the procedure for the errors of calculating the final points according to the accepted method of rounding the results. But this victory is honest. The SUNC of Moscow State University is obliged to beat the halter, and the enthusiasm and good preparation of the Pythagoras school should be encouraged by sports success, which clearly smiled at them this time.
What would I like to wish for the future? The organizers need to develop a memo for the jury members on how to assess, what to pay attention to, what is important and what is not important. This will be useful for participants -it will be easier to structure both its work and its report; This will be useful for professors in the jury, otherwise they sometimes felt like in the exam for students in a profile subject, which did not correspond to the tournament format. They say that at international tournaments there is such a memo, you can just try to translate it.
It would be rational to return the review to the final of the tournament - you need to give the third team the opportunity to comment on the performance of the rivals and influence the jury ratings, summarizing the discussion of opponents. In turn, teams need to approach the final more responsibly, remember that this is a game, not a scientific report, here is an account for glasses. For the final, you need to choose a task that is very difficult to oppose, do not give the enemy extra points. This does not have to be an empirical task, but it must have the most complete solution, and you need to be sure of the physical interpretation of processes. In general, the holiday was a success! Novosibirsk - good luck at the international tournament!