Recently, while sorting through a bookcase, I discovered the book “The Tao of Winnie the Pooh,” which was very popular at one time, and then somehow quietly disappeared from view, along with the creations of Paolo Coelho and other pocket-sized publications that were extremely simplified parables explain to their readers how to live correctly.
Usually I am not interested in such books, since I learned maxims like “good is good and evil is bad” from children’s fairy tales. But I was tempted by “The Tao of Winnie the Pooh,” because it promised to introduce me to the basics of Taoism with little blood. I didn’t manage to read the book right away, and now I decided to read Benjamin Hoff’s work.
The first chapters did not raise any questions - the author, using transparent allegories taken from Alan Milne's book, explained the principles of ancient Chinese teaching. But the further I moved, the more perplexed I became. For entire paragraphs, Hoff accuses science of failing to understand how the world actually works, and encourages readers to “learn from life itself” and listen to the mysterious “inner nature of things” rather than profess a scientific approach and analyze in detail the phenomena and processes encountered.
According to the author of “The Tao of Winnie the Pooh,” science obtains knowledge for the sake of knowledge and therefore is absolutely useless for people who want to find harmony in life. Hoffa’s symbol of scientists and science as such is the Owl, who loves to express herself beautifully (and often incorrectly) and strives to look as smart as possible, without understanding the essence of the issues being discussed. That is, the character is funny, ridiculous and even a little pathetic.
The desire to follow the path of achieving harmony is characteristic not only of Taoism, but also of many other Eastern religions and teachings. There is nothing reprehensible in this desire itself - self-contemplation and attempts to avoid evil and destruction are far from the worst way to live life. And preaching such behavior is harmless and even useful in some ways, so there are no complaints against the author here. But his attacks on science seemed to me to be groundless and harmful - one can say that, by condemning the scientific approach to life, Hoff directly contradicts the principles of Taoism that he sets out.
Most likely, the author wrote his book while sitting in a comfortable chair at the computer or at least at a desk. After the manuscript was completed, Hoff sent it to the publisher by email or regular mail, or traveled there by some means of transportation. While working on the book, Benjamin Hoff ate something - and it is unlikely that he limited himself only to wild apples and wild strawberries collected in the forest. It seems that during those months while “The Tao of Winnie the Pooh” was written, the author destroyed more than one kilogram of breeding products. There is no point in continuing this list further, since everything that surrounds people in the modern world was created thanks to the achievements of science.
Considering everything said above, it is very ugly for the author to speak so derogatory about scientists and their activities. If Hoff had kept his disdain to himself or shared it with his close acquaintances, it would not have been so bad. But he wrote a book, and a book that was especially tasty for an audience of non-specialists in the format “how to learn something complex without straining.” And the audience, with a high probability, will take away from reading “The Tao of Winnie the Pooh” precisely a distrust of science and scientists - simply because these subjects are more familiar to them than the postulates of Taoism.
But it is the money of these people that ultimately goes to support scientific research. And if taxpayers adopt the tone suggested in Hoffa's book, they might, for example, not vote for a party that wants to increase its research budget. Or they will instill in their children that they should not connect their lives with these useless scientific researches.
So, it turns out that literary fast food like “The Tao of Winnie the Pooh” is not as harmless as it seems at first glance. It is impossible to ban the publication of such books - moreover, I really hope that such measures will never be applied. A competent institute of reviewing could be a good way to cut off possible negative consequences from the somewhat biased (let’s say) opinion of some authors. But the creation of such an institute is a completely different and, unfortunately, very sad story.