
The Patriarch’s fleeting campaign ended - Metropolitan Kirill was elected the sixth Primate of the Russian Orthodox Church after the restoration of the Patriarchate in 1917. Cyril was supported by 508 delegates of the Local Council, for his only rival, Metropolitan Clement, only 169 Soborians voted.
For the first time in Russian church history, the elections were distinguished by such a strict public struggle that poured into the “war of compromises”. The success of Vladyka Cyril is associated with a successful election campaign, which was professional in nature - in her course he showed pronounced political qualities. From the very beginning, he received a “head start”, becoming a locomotor - thereby he not only headed preparations for the cathedral, but also got the opportunity to make public statements on behalf of the church. Each step in Cyril was focused on public attention - in contrast to the actions of his possible rivals. Another thing is that he took advantage of this circumstance fully. During the campaign, Cyril had to, first of all, to prove his fidelity to the Orthodox tradition - taking into account the doubts that existed in some church and near -church circles on this subject. The stages of Cyril’s campaign was a sermon in the Sretensky monastery, led by the conservative archimandrite Tikhon (Shevkunov) and a meeting with two elders-Kirill (Pavlov) and Elijah (nostril), confessors of the Trinity-Sergius Lavra and Optina Desert in the church. It is the elder, and not the bishop, in the Russian Church, is an impeccable keeper of traditional creed.
From the very beginning, Cyril resolutely translated competition into a public sphere, which was fundamentally different from a similar 1990 campaign, which was purely “subcoverous”. Moreover, there were many bright figures in his team that successfully performed the functions of agitators. For example, Bishop of Vienna Hilarion (Alfeev), the only Russian bishop who defended his dissertation in Oxford, theologian, preacher and church composer. Or Deacon Andrei Kuraev, a well -known preacher, who traveled with missionary goals a significant part of the post -Soviet space. Each of them had its own function in the campaign. For example, Vladyka Hilarion explained that the theological views of the candidate are fully consistent with the Orthodox creed. And Father Deacon was severely criticized by his brother Metropolitan Clement, Archbishop Dimitri (Kapalina), accusing him of a lot of abuse (including the “promotive” story with the suicide of several seminarians in the controlled Demetrius of the Tobolsk diocese).

One of Cyril’s main tasks was the involvement of numerous Ukrainian bishops that could have a significant impact on the election results. Here, the locomotive took into account the experience of 1990, when the supporters of Metropolitan Alexy (Ridiger) managed to divide the Ukrainian “electorate”, one part of which voted in the first round for the then locomotor Metropolitan Filaret (Denisenko; now excreted from the Church of the “Kyiv Patriarch”), and the other for Metropolitan Vladimir (Sabodan), now leading the Ukrainian Orthodox Orthodox Church (UOC -MP). However, now the situation was different: the contradictions in the Ukrainian episcopate appeared publicly back in Kyiv, at the pre -collection of delegates from the UOC. If the closest environment of the head of the UOC advocated the nomination of his own, “Ukrainian” candidate, then Cyril managed to enlist the support of influential hierarchs of the southeast of the country-the Metropolitans of Agafangel of Odessa and Hilarion Donetsk (not to be confused with Hilarion Vienna!), Supporters not only to preserve, but also to strengthen the relations of the UOC with Moscow. Agafangel has long been cooperating with Cyril, who helped him awarded the Russian Order of Honor last year, but the rapprochement of Cyril and Hilarion was a certain surprise. As a result, the Ukrainian bishop had to resolve the internal conflict, trying to prevent him from getting out into a scandal; He did not succeed in taking a consolidated position. Immediately before the Local Council, rumors went that Ukrainians would still put forward a common candidate, but at the Cyrilovets Cathedral, Metropolitan Ilarion Donetski publicly opposed additions to the list of applicants.
We add to this that the Russian state power emphasized from the elections of the Patriarch, although the supporters of the Metropolitan Cyril and Clement were not tired of hinting that the high authorities are on their side. However, Cyril was able to succeed in the “secular” sphere - he was actively supported by the Prochrevskaya youth, who gathered on the day of the cathedral from the Cathedral of Christ the Savior in order not to even allow the critics of Cyril to him. In addition, former Minister Alexander Pochinok spoke out at the finish of the campaign in support of Cyril, who announced that Cyril was not involved in the scandals of the 90s with tobacco and alcohol, but Clement, who was then involved in the Patriarchate issues of humanitarian assistance.
Thus, Cyril’s campaign was thoughtful comprehensive. But what about his opponent Clement? He initially chose to act with old trusted hardware, using his ties among the bishops. But his first attempt to use the administrative resource - to lobby for the election of his proteges by the delegates of the cathedral from spiritual educational institutions - led to a grand scandal “promoted” by the same deacon Andrei Kuraev. Clement nevertheless received five reliable delegates to the cathedral, but moral damage was much more significant than this little success. The climent failed to enlist the support of a single permanent member of the Synod - moreover, Metropolitan Vladimir Petersburg initially consistently supported Cyril, and Metropolitan Filaret Minsky lifted his candidacy in his favor at the cathedral.
Only in recent weeks before the Cathedral Clement, Clement has a little activated - in particular, the presentation of his book on the history of Orthodoxy in Alaska was organized, but this event also had its turnover. It recalled how last year the work of the Lord was not approved by the Department of Church History of the Moscow Theological Academy, where the author presented it as a dissertation research. It is not surprising that the last chance of Metropolitan Clement was the election of Patriarch with a lot, as was the case at the Council of 1917-with such an initiative, Archbishop Feodosius Polotsk, who worked in the 1970-80s in Moscow Theological Schools along with Clement. However, this proposal sounding at the last moment was rejected by the majority of the Soborians, who were already on the side of Cyril.
If Metropolitan Clement led the election campaign as an “apparatchik”, then Metropolitan Cyril as a politician. The problem is how much the Patriarch Police will be able to acquire spiritual authority from parishioners. As the new patriarch will interact with the pro -Kremlin activists, the style of whose behavior is little reminiscent of the actions of church people. How much he has enough to resolve the Ukrainian question, which tends to exacerbate. How much he can maintain the coalition that has formed before the elections, which includes the widely thinking theologians and the zealous guardians of traditional piety (including from the foreign church). Even the most successful election campaign is unable to ensure the solution to these many problems.
Author - Vice President of the Center for Political Technology