
Will a single history textbook appear in Russia? Does he need it? About this, as well as about freedom of choice, students and teachers are reflected by Dr. East. sciences, professor, head. Department of International Relations and Foreign Regional Studies of Volgograd State University, Visiting Scholar University of George Washington (USA) Ivan Kurill .
School textbooks of history attract the attention of society and politicians much more often than literature textbooks, and is incomparably more often than textbooks on natural sciences. The situation when the heads of the state regularly discuss the content of the textbook, say, in chemistry, it seems impossible. Therefore, it is probably worth starting with reasoning about what society expects from historical education at school.
While naturalists teach the “Fundamentals of Sciences”, historians bring to schoolchildren a coherent story about the historical past, primarily about the past of their country. This story “rhymes” with monuments and toponymy surrounding children, and creates a general “cultural field”, allowing the inhabitants of Russia to consider themselves a single nation, dating back to the common ancestors who survived the same tragedies and have won joint victories. On the presentation of the “basics of science” of history, the textbook usually remains introductory paragraphs and - sometimes - tasks for independent work with sources.
Such a story goes back to the era of the formation of nations, the first half of the 19th century, - the period when, in fact, historical science appeared. It was the view of history as the most important tool for creating a nation that predetermined such attention to the historical textbook by politicians, this logic prompted the need to introduce a “single textbook” for the school.
Why is the idea of a “single textbook” outdated?
However, I see exactly three grounds in order to consider the task of creating a “single textbook” by an anachronism.
Firstly, today the very problem of the “formation of a nation” does not look at all like in the XIX century. Then the task of creating national states on an ethnic basis on the site of medieval empires seemed as progressive (another word of the era) as the expansion of democratic management methods. However, by the second half of the 20th century, ethnic national states themselves were perceived as an anachronism. Not only Americans, but also Europeans have to create “civilian nations”, including immigrants of various origin, who do not abandon their own - very different - the past.
Russia, which has not managed to become a national state at the time when it was a global trend, today has even greater problems with the awareness of a single past. The Russian “civilian nation”, if there is a temptation to build it on the general past, risks staying with the only event uniting the people - the Great Patriotic War. It was the war that became a common tragedy and a common victory, which all (or almost all) residents of the country consider their own. But even here there are alternative stories, for example, about the eviction of peoples or about collaborators.
If you “dig deeper”, it turns out that “a single narrative”, as it is built in most existing textbooks, is the history of the emergence and development of the Moscow principality, which gradually won the East European plain, and then Siberia. Many, in connection with the task of creating a “single textbook”, recalled the capture of Kazan, which is difficult to describe so that this corresponds to historical memory of both Russian and Tatars. But even in the nearest Ryazan to Moscow several years ago, a monument was erected to Prince Oleg, whom the “Moscow” tradition revered a traitor. Looking in history, we see that neither the Moscow state, nor, the history of one ethnic group can become the unifying of the Russian “civilian nation”. It must be built around the future, not the past.
Secondly, historical science today does not set its task to create some single narratives or the selection of “important facts”. History is a continuous dialogue of modernity with the past, in which the knowing subject asking the past questions is not a single whole. Modern society is difficult, as they say, by definition; Different questions are asked by the descendants of the winners and defeated, men and women, Russians and Circassians, peasants and workers, residents of Siberia and Smolensk. The creation of a single textbook as an instrument of unification of the nation rests on the need to already have such a single nation to create a textbook.
Thirdly, the textbook itself has already lost its authoritarian potential. Children - if they generally do homework - are free to look for material on the Internet, which represents much more freedom and diversity than a printed publication. Perhaps it is true that the importance of the textbook is exaggerated by parents, for whom the book retained the meaning of the “approved” authoritative knowledge.
If you put the task of learning “the basics of historical science” before the history textbook, then from my point of view, it would be the most true, from the sections that set out various explanations of the same event: political, economic, sociocultural; From the perspective of the state and society, nationalists and liberals ...
Perhaps, when supporting such a textbook, a historical explanation itself is problematized in the course of training, and graduates will better understand what history is and how society works. In fact, in the 19th century, the physics textbook included only Newtonian mechanics, and today it is difficult to imagine it without sections about electricity, the theory of relativity and the structure of the atom. These sections did not cancel the mechanics, but added other measurements to our understanding of the world.
But such a textbook is seen to me by a matter of a distant future. In the meantime, the dispute is about a “single textbook”, which will reflect some single approach to domestic history. If even the “twenty best historians” write it (here we recognize their names), it is obvious that alternative narratives will not fall into it, which means that they will remain a source of public conflict.
If even the “twenty best historians” write a single history textbook (here we recognize their names), it is obvious that alternative approaches to it will not fall, which means that they will remain a source of public conflict.
There is such an objection to the situation of the multiplicity of textbooks: but it is not a schoolboy that determines the textbook on which he will study, but his teacher or school, so what kind of freedom of choice we are talking about? However, this is an apparent contradiction. It is important that the presence of different textbooks retains the possibility of choosing a society as a whole (although not always a specific child). I will try to show a little below that the choice of the teacher (to no less than the choice of a child, who should just be taught to make a conscious choice) is a value that should be fighted for. In addition, the teacher’s choice can be influenced, for example, with the help of the parent committee - and the conscious procedure for choosing is the most important element of the education of a citizen.
Two approaches to teaching
Nevertheless, it seems to me that the dispute about a single textbook (about its introduction or maintaining the situation with many books) takes us away from a more important problem. He is a good indicator of how the state sees the process of school education; It seems to me that this look is erroneous. From the picture drawn by the discussion of this problem, the teacher completely falls out - a person on whom the success or failure of all the efforts of the state and society depends on the desired result.
You can formulate two approaches to what is an education: in accordance with the first, it is assumed that teaching is conducted on behalf of and at the state level, and the teacher is only the performers and conductors of this teaching state truth. Ideally, each class must be put on a large TV, from which a lesson will be conducted. Teachers should only monitor the discipline and check their homework. From the standpoint of this approach, the textbook is very important - it carries the knowledge that must be taught.
The second approach suggests that the teacher is not a gear link, but the most important participant in the education process, that it is he who is a source of assessments for children and personifies the science that he teaches. In this case, the textbook remains only one of the manuals along with the Internet, television, newspapers, photographs - all that the teacher uses in the teaching process. The teacher in this paradigm does not convey ready -made answers to the children, but teaches questions [1].
The logic of the state is based on the first performance - in my opinion, incorrect. But the actions of the state, dictated by this logic, are aimed at combating the teacher's ability to carry out the second option. The struggle for a single textbook fits into this approach. As a result, the quality of teaching catastrophically falls, and the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation, in response to this fall, takes further steps towards turning the teacher into a transmitter with someone else trained educational complexes. This is the road to nowhere.
Based on the second logic, which seems to me more optimistic, a state that wants to improve the quality of education should not be invested in a single textbook and unification of the approaches to teaching, but in the teacher, in improving its qualifications, the possibility of a decent life, and improving the status of a profession in society.
If now, as an objection, someone will think about the unfortunate clogged “teachers” who cannot teach anything themselves (they say, “let them better convey other people's smart thoughts”), then, firstly, such a state policy made them with such “clogged”, and, secondly, to convey the thoughts so that someone would not be able to learn, the “clogged teacher” also will not be able to. This, in fact, is a more severe psychologically task - to arouse interest in your students not in your personal, but in someone else's text.
Let us also recall that history teachers receive higher historical education [2], which means that at universities they are taught nevertheless to science, and not the methods of patriotic education. Does the unification of the textbook mean that teachers should forget about what they themselves were taught and turn into translators of the concepts of the “twenty best historians”?
Only free discussion during the lesson of various historical approaches can be considered the teaching of the “Fundamentals of Historical Science”, this is the only way to study Russian history in Vladivostok and Grozny at the same time, and only such a discussion will prepare a school graduate for life in a complex modern society. There is no need to be afraid that the presence of different approaches to studying history at school means supporting separatism or some other terrible political sins.
In the end, these problems are either solved by the simple preservation of scientific examination of textbooks, or - not solved by administrative methods in general. And certainly a “single textbook of history” is not the right way of the consolidation of the modern Russian nation. But the freedom of choice by the teacher of the history textbook (along with other manuals and materials for its study) is one of the important criteria for assessing the freedom of society.
Notes:
1. I immediately clarify for possible critics: the formulation of the question suggests and requires knowledge; We are not talking about a refusal of consistent study of topics - only about the possibility of a discussion “with an open ending” in the history lesson.
2. As a result of recent reforms, however, in pedagogical universities, all education becomes "pedagogical." - Now they are not preparing “bachelors of history”, but “bachelors of education”.