
“Conversation with Vladimir Putin. Continuation ”is the main political event of the country. At the same time, there was practically no public reaction to him. The duty political scientists attended duty at duty (the “image of the father of the native” commented on the “Vedomosti” usually alive Alexander Kynev). The deputies reacted sluggishly. Communist Soloviev expectedly said that Putin mentioned United Russia six times, the United Russia was praised by the President. “The Prime Minister not only professionally and reasonably answered the sore questions of the inhabitants of many regions of our country, listened to their requests, but also spoke in detail about a number of specific initiatives in the sector of the least protected groups of citizens, the real sector of the economy,” said Boris Gryzlov.
Foreign media, deciphering signals from the “conversation” continued to reason on their favorite topic “How Medvedev differs from Putin”. The Direct Line resembled a review of Putin's achievements in 2009, ”Nyt writes. According to the newspaper, the live broadcast showed that Putin and Medvedev’s programs are varying. So, "Putin ignored the topics of corruption, innovation in the economy and human rights that Medvedev draws to." These are very expected comments on the performance of any vip from faithful people. And the expected criticism from skeptics - whether it be skeptics loyally tuned or "non -systemic".
We repeat once again ( see the question, according to the busy chair): no citizens and Vladimir Putin spoke. A large business, departments and top officials spoke with him (this is not entirely the same thing). Partly in the form of answers written in advance to pre-prepared questions, and part-directly, not embarrassing that someone will recognize them. To decrypt the signals, as the example of the Western press shows, is a rather ungrateful thing and we will deal with it - for the second time - without hunting, only because other decodings are naive, or empty. We will try to declare our own initial thesis: Vladimir Putin acted yesterday as the first number in the hierarchy of the Russian elite. Moreover, a non -alternative first number. Trivially? How to see, from this position we can well describe the Russian political regime
Putin and bureaucracy
“Officials can solve and solve many problems, especially my colleagues in the Russian government. They work a lot. I must say that these are very competent people, very professional. They really became experts in the sectors that they are engaged, without any exaggeration. There are a lot of work. I am now taking this opportunity (we have different meetings, I have a critical position there more), now I publicly want to thank them for their joint work, because they have done a lot and have done a lot so that the country has passed this very difficult period of time, I repeat, perhaps, the most difficult year over the past 10 years, with minimal losses, ”Putin protected bureaucracy.
Vladimir Putin has long been based on a team of managers, which is largely familiar to him at the city hall and is not surprising that he finds the work of the personally formed team satisfactory. As for the specifics, the prime minister approved the activities of the electric power curators (against the OGK and TGC owners, the curator of the fuel and energy complex - Igor Sechin), the Ministry of Socialist -ary -Belief (against, for example, pharmaceutical companies and numerous supporters of the redistribution of the budget), the Ministry of Agriculture (against, partly, retailers), etc. Putin here acted as a quality of quality manager of budget funds.
Those passages where Putin directly invaded the territory of Dmitry Medvedev is also interesting. The issue of army reform is under the jurisdiction of the President, to which the Ministry of Defense obeys, the government is engaged only in private issues, such as providing housing for the military personnel. However, the prime minister took the courage to praise the reform. For what? So someone also threatens her, and the prime minister with his own will and not according to formal status gave her the right to conduct to the end (it is characteristic that some “we” appeared in the wording-probably “Putin-Medvedev.” We will dwell on this a little later). Putin acted in these cases as the main hardware of the transformation engine.
In a similar way, signals were given to the governors-softly, unobtrusively, again not quite in status. Regional leaders are more responding to the president who is free to remove them, but hastened to fulfill the prime minister’s orders.
Putin and business
Our business and power are one, another completely trivial thesis. But they are united in general, and specifically, a particular business has their own interests and their own channels for delivering positions to power. Farm companies (specific, not everyone) got from the prime minister yesterday. And the retailers got a little earlier. But the most clear signals were sent to large business, which has serious problems with another large business.
Almost one and a half years have passed with a “doctor for Zyuzin”, but the situation has not changed in any way. Only the prime minister is capable of breeding a conflict of interests of large businesses. In this sense, yesterday, the whole country watched how some businessmen complain about other businessmen, and Putin is trying to resolve the situation and, in his own expression, Putin, “resolve questions”.
An employee of the Tver Carbon -Building Plant requires the prime minister to oblige Russian Zhelet roads to purchase more wagons. The owner of the Transmashholding plant, its owners, according to the media, Iskander Makhmudov and Andrei Bokarev. The prime minister did not approve their request, noting that it was impossible to support all the ifnastrructure monopolies from the budget and promising help, rather, Uralvagonzavod (the enterprise actively complains about Russian Railways in recent months). This “will be you, my friend, do not need to be impudent” and was repeated with other petitioners in a more or less soft form. Thus, Putin designated himself as the supreme manager of anti -crisis programs and the head of arbitration for Russian large businesses.
Putin, party, Komsomol
Vladimir Putin twice directly correlated his person (not party events that the deputy-communist Soloviev, namely himself) with "United Russia" discovered, not once, however. Without directly mentioning. The first time - "as you know, at the party level we have a special relationship with the" Party of Regions "." And the second time, answering the question, “you said that“ we will succeed, ”just didn’t specify how,” Putin said: “You inattentively listened to what I said. At a party event, I spoke a broken hour about the ways and ways to solve the problems facing the country. We have a Russian development program until 2020. "
Between the first and second
All observers have already asked how the roles in the tandem of Medvedev-Putin are distributed. This question was asked yesterday, in the slurred formulation of "what is the relationship." A rather slurred answer “Relations are good” was received to him (in full accordance with the question). In our opinion, the question of the distribution of “roles in tandem” is unfair for the above reasons: Putin’s orientation is preserved in the entire elite, and the tandem did not work out.
On the eve of the 2000 elections, the book “From the First Person, was published. Talking with Vladimir Putin. " The transformation of “direct lines” into “conversation” in this context seems not only to rhetorical turnover, but a sign - a kind of “eternal return” or an application for the retention of administrative positions.
What is the place in the power system of Dmitry Medvedev? In the message to the Federal Assembly, Medvedev gave the government a dozen diverse instructions, which is responsible for the execution of which the Prime Minister was appointed. Putin did not mention them in a conversation with the Russians. Indirectly they appeared in the awkward “we” (for example, “we have a common position in the country's leadership” - a position on state corporations). Or, as in the case of United Russia, the intimate-patronic "we".
In general, the conversation went without Medvedev. The President was mentioned in passing in the context of continuing the fight against corruption. Twice “Dmitry Anatolievich” arose - in a conversation about the “new school” (message) and in response to the question of relations in the tandem “Medyedv Putin”. Putin did not mention Medvedev. The figure of silence is not so terrible in other lips and official performances (such a format), but Putin did not call Khodorkovsky and Yushchenko at all, accusing of all sins. It seems that Vladimir Putin values with the words, and it turns out that the co -owner of Roskuzbassiguya Andrei Bokarev is only half as much for him than the direct bosses in the person of Dmitry Medvedev. In other words: the only feeling is created that Putin Medvedev does not consider the boss and the boss.
Immediately after the election of Medvedev, we asked the president a question by which hardware “Kerzon’s Line” could go through the border between the first persons of the state (see between the first and second). Today it is obvious that the issues of the real sector of industry, macroeconomics, and serious transformations in the economic sphere remain with Vladimir Putin. Medvedev has poorly understandable innovative sectors (without a defense and scope of state corporations), a system of courts, partly governors (there, it seems, works the “principle of two keys”) and potentially - security forces.
Quote from “Talking with Vladimir Putin”: “The work that Voloshin is engaged is quite thin. We were discussing with him who could be put in his place, we talked about Dima Medvedev. Voloshin himself said: "Let Dima work as the deputy, then, perhaps, the option of my replacement will grow and be." Now it makes no sense to make a guess. ” As a result, Dima became the head of the administration after the dismissal of Voloshin in October 2003. Vladimir Putin generally admits diminutive formulations, mainly about the close younger colleagues. “Dima” (Kozak, Medvedev and Mezentsev) from the encirclement of the second president of Russia, and remained “Dimas”, even if they publicly turned into “Dmitriev”. Total: in “Talk with Vladimir Putin,” Putin did not designate himself as a subordinate president. Medvedev, on the other hand, is the second in informal status in the elite an official, in the located resource - also the second.
Putin and elections-2012
Since we have undertook to quote the document of great antiquity, we note another important point to understand how sincere Vladimir Putin is when he claims that he has not decided on whether he would participate in the presidential election (in simple - whether he wants to be the president) in 2012. Dmitry Medyedev in Italy, he said, “Prime Minister Putin said that he did not exclude that he would nominate his candidacy. I also do not exclude this. But as we both said, in any case, we are close people who understand each other, working together. We can agree on how not to push the elbows, but to make a reasonable decision for our country. ”
Putin-2009: “You know, these are loopholes that are trying to use those who are engaged in this type of activity, in the legislation, but these loopholes are ephemeral. In fact, if you clearly follow the letter of the law, then all gambling enterprises should be closed. I think that this is also not least - the manifestation of the corruption of local authorities and administration and law enforcement agencies. We will do it separately. ”
Putin-2000: “If I stayed to work in St. Petersburg, I would still strangle these casinos. I would force them all to work for the needs of society and share my profits with the city. This money would go to pensioners, teachers and doctors. ”
Putin-2009 (about the Caucasus): “No, no, of course, the Caucasian war does not smell there. The situation is complex. It is dictated by several components. Of course, various illegal armed formations, extremist groups are still functioning and sometimes invulnerable. This is a fact, we know this, and we will continue to fight this, and to fight mercilessly, until they are completely destroyed. At the same time, we must pay more attention to issues of a social and economic nature. It is necessary to create new good, highly paid jobs, solve social problems, fight corruption - and there, unfortunately, in the Caucasus, corruption is no less than throughout the country, and in some cases, maybe even surpasses the public, national level, and with clanity. This, unfortunately, is a tradition associated with certain historical phenomena. But this should not interfere with us to solve problems on the merits. ”
Putin 2000 “Correct, first you need to finish the military operation. What does this mean? Break large gangs, that is, detachments from a dozen militants and above. In parallel, to strengthen the role of law enforcement agencies, to restore the authorities of the management. To deal with social problems - schools, hospitals. Start actively organizing jobs. ”
The unity of the images and statements of Putin-2000 and Putin 2009 is not interested in in the sense of stagnation, but in the fact that he runs some personal “software installations” through years, or even decades.
Putin 2000: “I don’t know, maybe four years enough to really do something. Everything should be natural, although for four years - a short time. ” Software installations were implemented by Medvedev in 2008, the presidential term was increased to 6 years. The question is to whom, who torments Western political scientists, is partly formal.
We turn once again to Putin 2000: “In general, Russia from the very beginning was created as a supercentralized state. This is laid in its genetic code, in traditions, in the mentality of people. ”
The Medvedev-2008 project, as once the Putin-2000 or Stepashin-1999 projects, were conceived, apparently, as projects of peaceful transfer of power, without elite conflicts or indignation of the population. An elite conflict put an end to the Stepashin project (like many other Yeltsin “successive” sends). Judging by the "conversation" of Vladimir Putin, the Medvedev-2008 project was not implemented. The elites, for a large part, listen to the prime minister, only he acts as an arbiter in the disputes of large players.
The project “Medvedev-2010” or “Medvedev-2011” will also be resolved from how successful it will be considered (as a result of a difficult search for a compromise), the issue of a possible president will be resolved. If a full -fledged transit of power will take place, the Russian prime minister will even be able to retire. In the meantime, the system is closed to Putin at its main points - “to solve questions”, “divide money”, “give instructions”. And it will “lead” it even if Putin does not do this.