Slap in the face
It seems that the religious factor becomes an integral component of the political carnival. After the action of the XXC gates with a verbal skirmish of the “gobbled” and participants in the youth movement “We” and the watering of the latter with holy water, the time has come for prayer standing in defense of the constitution, against ignorance and obscurantism. However, the preventive closure of the Moscow Center for Moscow for visiting it was prevented by this, this act in full.
The reaction of the head of the Association of Orthodox experts Kirill Frolov is symptomatic, who stated that the Orthodox would go on duty, "to stop blasphemy in legal and legal." But the enemy does not sleep. Today in one place gathered, tomorrow at three or four. No activists are enough to "stop and reason."
Therefore, from the point of view of stubborn, it is more reliable to send such shareholders to prison immediately. It is no accident that at the hearing in the Public House, representatives of the Moscow Patriarchate and the Muslim clergy directly spoke about the need to change the Criminal Code. But it will not lead, her will not lead this to anything good. It’s one thing to post a civil lawsuit, another, to send him to bars. They will look at believers like wolves. And rightly.
In this regard, it is tempting to indicate the zones of sovereignty: here, in the temple, we set our own rules of the game, here, at the exhibition, you. This proposal, which sounded from the lips of the Kremlin political strategist and halerist Marat Gelman, at first glance looks promising. But only at first glance. It doesn't work. Both the temple and the museum are public places. And if today in society, the art of protest declared about itself in full voice, it will sound, despite the Cloarrier agreements. Behind the “War” group and the “Pussy” genetically connected with it will appear others. And if, do not bring God, three young women solder the deadlines, these groups will fearlessly invade the sacred space.
Well, but there is no need to talk about cultural. They are at home. At modern exhibitions, there are many works that are quite offensive to a religious feeling. No exhibition “Forbidden Art” is necessary to make sure of this.
It may be objected to this that in imperial Russia there were enough such works, the whole thing is the tolerance of the viewer. Take the same Perov, "rural procession for Easter." On the one hand, the artist denounces vices. On the other hand, blasphemous. It is not without reason that investigators of the Khamovniki judicial site requested the Academy of Arts about the demonstration of a immoral canvas with a drunken priest. Previously, orthodox spectators suffered (and even Porov’s Dostoevsky work was praised), and now they will be suffered.
But there is still one small "but." Previously, there was always a distance between the work of art and the viewer, there was a kind of play that allows us to abstract from the content and look at the art object as a pure art. And tolerate it as such. But at some wonderful moment this play disappeared. The artist discovered that he, a coat on the canvas, could touch the brush and face of the viewer. Such neat touches are visible, say, in the “collective actions” of Andrei Monastyrsky. But still, the monastery in the Soviet underground worked, mainly with the material, rarely concerned the language of art and the viewer. The postmodern shares of the post-Soviet era are directed directly at the artist, associated with the stamps of its consciousness, with the shocking.
So the believing viewer will not be able to distance yourself from the work that offends you. And what do you order to do? Do not go anywhere? Turn into a marginal?
Probably, the answer to the Chernyshev question can be born from the inside of the artistic process. The same believers may well find adequate ways to protect in art space, excluding running around the courts. Why, I say this is in the order of delirium, not to create an art group “slap in the face”. And to reward her, purely artistically, those who provoke Christians. The same Helman, wherever he appears: in Perm, in Vienna or in the canonical territory of Fr. Vsevolod Chaplin. And on round tables, in which loves to participate so much. Vsevolod, one could discuss, say, the power of such a slap in the face. What kind of swing is permissible, and which can harm human health. Everything is better than discussing the work of Mozart. And then it is somehow uninteresting: Helman helps Chaplin hold a law on the restoration of antiquity monuments, creates support from the museum community, and Chaplin willingly plays Helman's games, and arranges joint art matters with him.
As for the protection of the space of the temple from dubious actions, in my opinion, the harsh eyebrows of the gonuters only interfere. It is better to be persecuted, humiliated than playing an inquisitorial role. Any provocations will choke if they are drowned in silence. Postmodern actions without PR are dead. And in order for this silence to come, the churches must be interceding, first of all, for three feminists - they have already received their own. Otherwise, the mission among intellectuals, which has recently been said about recently, will have to be forgotten for a long time.