In search of support under the feet
Useless
useless
Non -nothing midnight
And the dreams that wake up
In some century, a friend.
Time?
Time is given.
This is not subject to discussion.
You are subject to the discussion, you
accommodated in it.
Naum Korzhavin, “Entry into the poem”;
Written in exile in 1952.
Today, November 2, 2012, the Simonovsky court of Moscow must finally resolve the issue of extending the detention of 28-year-old Daniil Konstantinov, the leader of the Moscow Defense League accused of murder. The day before, the court session lasted more than five hours, and at about 22:00 Konstantinov became ill. The ambulance confirmed: a hypertensive crisis, in the meeting, cannot continue to participate. It is not surprising: the prisoners have no opportunity to have breakfast in a pre -trial detention center on such days - they rise earlier to push into the car gut and take him to court, and there it is possible to eat only dry rations, if you are lucky ... surprisingly at first glance, another: the Russian nationalist Konstantinov was petitioned by the liberals Vladimir Milov, Harry Kasparov and Sergey Davidis. However, the court rejected the request for release for their guarantee ...
Today in the Basmanny court two meetings on the "Swamp case" are scheduled. At 11 o’clock on Kalanchevskaya, 11 Judge Karpov must decide on the extension of the preventive measure to Denis Lutskevich (his lawyer is Dmitry Dinze). In two in the afternoon - the same judge Mushnikova must decide on Artyom Savölov (lawyer - Farit Murtazin).
There is no reason to doubt that both of these meetings will end in extending the term of detention in the pre -trial detention center for four months, until the beginning of March.
Last week, the courts continued as the “case of May 6” was suppressed. Yesterday, November 1, until March 6, house arrest was extended to Alexander Dukhanina. On Wednesday, October 31, the detention was extended to Andrei Barabanov and Nikolai Caucasian. On Tuesday, October 30 - Student of the Russian State Humanitarian University Stepan Zimin and Vyatka journalist Leonid Kovyazin. On Monday, October 29 - Yaroslav Belousov and Anti -Fascist Alexei Polikhovich.
Meanwhile, on October 29, the court (in the extension ", but essentially!) Appeared the first accused - Maxim Luzyan, who pleaded guilty. His case is considered by the Zamoskvoretsky court, there should soon be considered by Mikhail Kosenko. The Prosecutor General’s Office intercedes “forced measures of a medical nature”, that is, Mikhail is threatened with a psychiatric hospital.
Some unhealthy connection of the time in this can be traced ... What is the point, what to do, to be or not to be? These questions pose - and partly help to answer them, make the meaning and system into the madness surrounding us two more events, two dates, which thousands of people came to recall.


On October 29, the names of those executed during the years of large terror were read on Lubyanka. Almost a thousand people survived for several hours in the cold to name the name, age, profession, and - the date of execution. Many left, not not putting: cold ...
Just 75 years ago, mass executions were going on in Moscow basements and at the training grounds near Moscow and dominated the thirty -seventh year.
And on October 30, under the icy rain on Pushkinskaya Square, a rally was held, which talked about modern prisoners.
Just halfway by 37th, 38 years ago, October 30, 1974, concluded by Mordovian and Perm camps, Vladimir prison for the first time celebrated the day of the political prisoner in the USSR-a one-day strike and a hunger strike.
For more than twenty years, this date has been officially celebrated as the day of memory of victims of political repression. But for those who came, it was again the day of the political prisoner - already in modern Russia.
In October 30, the Memorial statement stated the obvious: in a dialogue with the opposition, with society as a whole, the authorities elected the language of arrests, vessels, camps (and to whom it is not obvious - let him return to the beginning of the article!). The experience of the 20-30s is in demand, the experience of fabricating political processes. The words about the "foreign agents" and "traitors of the Motherland" sound again. However, the Caucasian experience of the last decades, the experience of kidnapping people and secret prisons was also in demand ...
“Loud” affairs - “swamp”, “anatomical”, “Pussy Rait” case - are very convincing. At the trial, you will physically have no opportunity to defend yourself, being in your right mind and firm memory: who did not know about yesterday’s trial of Konstantinov, probably remembers the details of summer meetings in the Hamsud, where the girls reached the semi -fainting state. To begin with, you can be kidnapped and interrogated “outside the process”, like Leonida Razvoszhaev. And to get into such a revolution - almost a lottery: in the “swamp” case, it could go if not every of the tens of thousands that went to the Square of May six, then certainly almost every of 650 people detained that day. After all, the investigators seemed to take into the work packs of protocols about administrative detentions, and here they were lucky ...
What does this mean - both for history and for each of us?
Now they talk a lot about the 37th year. Not sure that this is an accurate comparison.
Even if we talk about new laws or, more precisely, about the texts called laws: about rallies, about non -profit organizations - “foreign agents”, about protecting children from harmful information on the Internet, about slander, about state treason, about the insult of the feelings of believers ...
These texts can be called a “legal” basis for mass repressions.
What is common in these texts? All of them, in fact, are unconstitutional and non -legal.
Each of these laws, in theory, should facilitate the use of a particular law (or freedom) guaranteed by a particular article of the Constitution: the right to gather peacefully and without weapons, freedom of public associations, the right to extract and disseminate information ...
But each of these “laws”, in fact, excludes the free use of these rights and freedoms by citizens, seemed to be guaranteed by the Russian Constitution and international pacts signed by Russia.
Each of the “laws” contains almost infinitely stretching, rubber definitions: “rally”, “procession”, “demonstration”, “foreign agent”, “political activity”, “treason”, and so on.
As a result, if desired, these repressive “laws” can be brought to almost any person.
So what is it a base for mass repressions? At first glance - yes.
However, an attempt to use these “laws” as it is supposed to use the law, that is, in accordance with their letter, would immediately paralyze the state machine.
Imagine: the guide delays any group of citizens moving around the city for a certain purpose in an amount of more than three.
Or the picture “sailed” - the head of the FSB deputy administration checks for treason of all who flinged to Europe or Emirates.
It's already funny ... Although everything is possible in Russia.
Then why?
The first thing that comes to mind is “laws” are written for very selective, that is, for selective and arbitrary application. So?
It seems that again: not so.
Let me remind you again: the threat of applying these "laws" applies to anyone.
It’s like in the golden - for the current rulers - “stagnant” time was planted far from everyone who, in principle, could be planted.
The point is not even that, according to the installations of the KGB and the Central Committee of the CPSU, developed and adopted in 1959, for one planted in the 70th anti-Soviet or 190s, the slanderous article was a hundred “prevented” in one way or another.
More importantly, another: even the one who read the Gulag Archipelago and to whom there was nothing for it, he knew that he was doing something forbidden.
So now - new absurd laws create the space of lack of freedom.
Perhaps this is their main meaning.
Why are those times repeated in the form of a monstrous farce?
For some of our rulers, the Brezhnev time is the time of the youth of the agent or the Toptun-Stage. They were then taught, and now, forty years later, they are trying to do how they were taught. They themselves are unlikely to come up with something new ...
But it's not about them, the point is in us.
After all, the same time-about thirty to forty years ago-was a time of resistance.
Resistance, part of which was the day of the political prisoner in the USSR.
At that very Brezhnev time, many of our compatriots found the strength to live like free people in a non -free country.
Their experience, reflected in the "Chronicle of current events" and in the volumes of memories, is again important for us today.
It is worth recalling this past - because sometimes it does not give support, it helps to find it.
What?
There are only two, maybe three aspects.
The first is from experience not 75 years old, but, probably, one and a half centuries: non -violence. The memorial statement says:
“We do not appeal to the sense of the historical responsibility of our state leaders-they, apparently, are deprived of this feeling. We do not appeal to the feeling of self -preservation of the Russian power elite - in order for this feeling to work, at least an approximate understanding of reality is necessary, and this understanding of the current elite, in general, is absent.
We turn to society, hoping for his civil maturity. We do not have a ready -made recipe for not allowing Russia to crawl to new turns of revolutions and state terrorism. We must together look for forms of counteracting the crazy and suicidal steps taken by the authorities. The only thing we consider to be necessary to call all social forces, regardless of their political orientation, is to an unconditional rejection of violence in all its forms. To calmness, wisdom and resistance. We are able to protect freedom, relying on the right, not on strength. ”
How to stay in this, sorry for the banal phrase, “human dimension”? Calling and recalling everyone by name, as on reading at the Solovetsky stone. Without turning the tragedy - into statistics. Considering people not zero in large numbers, but each separately.
From here - one step towards solidarity with a specifically and separately named person.
You can write a prisoner, you can come to court and support a person.
So, as the “liberals” did in relation to the nationalist Konstantinov (the charge of the murder, in our opinion, is false and politically motivated).
We need this ourselves - each of us! - No less than political prisoners. This is a way to live and breathe in the “space of lack of freedom” prone to power. What to do if they want to intimidate us, so that in an attempt not to think about a possible threat to forget the people whom she has already touched? Do the opposite of what is imposed on us, what they are involved in.
Instead of hysteria - calm. Instead of aggression - non -violence. Instead of erosion of faces and oblivion - memory and solidarity.
Eternal memory to the victims of terror. The courage and perseverance of those who are in the ultrasound today, and those who are judged today in Moscow courts.
Author - Chairman of the Council of the Human Rights Center "Memorial"
Photos of the hedgehog