A straw or a weight?
It happened. Leonid Radzikhovsky, who over the past years proved the hopelessness of Russian historical development and contactly ridiculed the timid attempts of individual unfinished liberals to find a way out, gained hope. Hope appeared in the image of the Russian Orthodox Church. The reason for this hope was the performance of Archbishop Hilarion, the head of the department of external church ties, who condemned Stalinism and, following the united Europe, equalized Stalin and Hitler. This, of course, is good news from the Russian Orthodox Church, that is, from the place where there are usually no good news. And this is doubly nice. But only.
But completely cosmic conclusions are made of this.
Radzikhovsky claims that Hilarion’s action was agreed with Patriarch Kirill (which is probably true) and that Cyril has a chance to become a great patriarch, no less significant for history than John Paul II. I really doubt it.
I believe that Cyril’s chance to become a mighty with the deceased dad is approximately equal to the chance of Leonid Radzikhovsky himself to become a Patriarch of Moscow or Pope. That is, there is an abstract opportunity. This does not contradict the laws of physics. But a very difficult task. The abyss that must be overcome is very great. In both cases, the probability of such a jump is so close to zero that in practical life it should be recognized as this zero equal.
The difference between our Patriarch and John Paul II in that historical genetics of our society, which the RODzikhovsky should change, according to the plan of Leonid Radzikhov. One of the main blocks of this foundation is precisely the Russian Orthodox Church.
The greatness of John Paul II is that before destroying communism, and partly in parallel with this, he began the process of self -cleaning of Catholicism itself, its humanization, humanization. It was a grandiose, no analogues in the world, the process of recognizing the Catholic Church of its mistakes and crimes. Repentance in front of the whole world, which lasted 40 years, since it began before the entry of Karol Voitla to the papal throne. He named and numbered these crimes: the Crusades, the Inquisition, the persecution of Jews, the church split, the justification of slavery, the justification of wars, the contempt for minorities and the poor.
That power of authority, that civil muscles that allowed the deceased pontiff to make a really huge contribution to the destruction of communism in Europe, was “pumped up” not only in the process of self -cleaning of the church, but also on the world hike for human rights and in the same anti -war campaign in which the pontiff was all three decades of his papacy. During these campaigns, he was not afraid to throw accusations to dictators, for example, transferred the list of political prisoners to Fidel, after which some of them were saved ...
I can’t imagine any of such actions performed by Vladimir Mikhailovich Gundyaev. I’m closing my eyes and trying to imagine: Patriarch Kirill gives Putin or Medvedev a list of Russian political zones led by Khodorkovsky. Nothing happens. For some reason, instead of Gundyaev all the time, Kasparov, and instead of Medvedev as evil-Obama.
It is also impossible to imagine the repentance of the Russian Orthodox Church for their crimes and innocent sacrifices during the church split, and during the forced appeal to the Orthodoxy of the peoples of the Volga, Siberia and the North. The bonfires of the Orthodox Inquisition burned no less hot than their Catholic colleagues. There were many victims on the account of the same Novokreshchenskaya Office at the Bogoroditsky monastery.
Orthodoxy remained the only branch of Christianity in which the saints are revered, whose cult is based on the so -called Bloody will be on Jews, that is, on medieval prosecution of Jews of ritual tortures and murders of Christians. This is the so -called The martyrs of Gabriel Belostotsky and Evstratia Pechersky. Alexander Men repeatedly and in vain, up to his death, advocated the decanonization of these saints, the cult of which creates a religious foundation of anti -Semitism and serves as an “justification” of pogroms. Catholicism and Protestantism canceled such cults half a century ago.
Psychologically, I understand that surge of hope that caused just a normal human voice that came from the Russian Orthodox Church. It really sounds painfully. After all, something completely different was distributed all the time. Calls to prohibit the film or stop the activities of competing faiths in the canonical territory.
This is the hope of a drowning man on a straw. But these hopes seem to me illusory, since the whole millennial history of our country proves: Orthodoxy and the Russian Orthodox Church as its main institution is a weight of weights on the feet of Russia, trying to crawl to progress from time to time.
Recently, in the framework of one study, I made a comparative analysis of the economic and social indicators of countries, grouping them on the basis of the predominance of a particular religion. There are 12 Orthodox countries in the world, 12 Protestant and 4 dozen Catholic and Muslim. By all indicators characterizing the standard of living of people, ahead with a huge margin - a country with a Protestant population, in second place by a large margin from the third - Catholic countries, although the center of gravity of modern Catholicism is in Latin America, a very problematic region. We, countries with a predominance of Orthodox culture, are deep in third place. It remains for us to console ourselves that the Islamic environment even less has progress than the Orthodox.
Orthodoxy is strictly built into power and it is her, and not by the flock, has a source of its authority and legitimacy. That is why the Russian Orthodox Church could not show worthy resistance to communism and Stalinism. It is no coincidence that the real, truly heroic rebuff to communism from countries captured by the USSR could only be provided by Catholic Poland, Hungary and Czechoslovakia. In Orthodox Bulgaria and Romania, nothing comparable happened to the events of 1956 in Hungary and Gdansk, with Prague in the spring of 1968, there was no “solidarity”.
Orthodoxy is a religion that blocks the isolation of an autonomous personality. Religion and a church, which has no courage to openly and honestly speak with its history and with unrighteous power. Can such an institute become an impulse of positive changes in society?
Can a centuries -old weight turn into a straw of hope?
Perhaps it can. Only a very small probability. I would look for another source of hope.
Photos Kremlin.ru