Somehow it so happened that the two media months before May 9 passed under the implicit influence of Mr. Brzezinski, who back in March determined the nature of the discussions that arose in this field. His questions, asked in an interview with Izvestia on March 21, were not good: “If I were a Russian, I would ask myself: “Why are most neighbors either afraid of Russia or express contempt for it?” And if I were a Russian, I I would ask myself: isn’t it in my interests and in the interests of Russia to pursue a different policy towards our neighbors?”
Actually, the reaction to Vike-Freiberga and the words of other foreigners - in connection with the results of the Second World War - turned out to be within the framework set by Brzezinski. Or it just happened because it was timely. Of course, an indirect answer to these questions arose: Putin’s words that the collapse of the USSR was a major geopolitical catastrophe hardly improved the attitude towards Russia on the part of Eastern Europeans, but this is only indirect. Now Mr. Brzezinski’s questions were specifically answered by Mr. Krylov on the Kremlin.org website (May 6, “ Russia as a chandala, or Why do they hate us? ”):
“Over the course of its history, Russia has saved several peoples from physical destruction. It has helped even more peoples to rise and develop. All these peoples now hate Russia especially strongly - these are some of our close neighbors and a number of countries that were part of the orbit of the socialist camp... In the depths All this lies in the natural hatred of Russia. Hatred precisely because they owe something to it. Russia and the Russians in Europe over the past 300 years have created a reputation as a leper, a “Chandala people”, who are so vile and dirty that even help ", received from them, insults the recipient . "
And this is an archival assessment of the situation. Moreover, for some reason it was missed that these countries, in their “natural hatred,” strove to resist even help - at least in Hungary in ’56, in Prague in ’68. Ungrateful people, definitely. Thus, we can state with satisfaction that the topic of hatred towards Russia has been covered, and we can move on to the next strategic threats. If there is articulated hatred, there should be plenty of it. In this regard, there is a statement by Ms. Serova on “Politkom” (May 6, “ Defend your victory ”):
“Preparations for the celebration of the 60th anniversary of the Victory over Nazi Germany, taking place in the context of a harsh information and political attack on Russia by the leadership of the Baltic states, under the hooting of some foreign politicians and a number of Russian public figures, as well as a number of foreign media, makes us think again about What are we celebrating and what irritates our ill-wishers so much about this holiday ?
Unfortunately, the facts of the information and political attack on the part of the leadership of the Baltic countries are not given (they have been saying what they have been saying for 15 years, or has it finally dawned on them what they are talking about?), and the topic of hooting has not been disclosed at all. It is curious that, as in the case of Krylov’s material, the conclusions are placed at the very top of the text. Moreover, this time they somehow do not quite correlate with what is in the article. And there are three reasons for the irritation of the Russian Federation’s ill-wishers:
"1. The theme of the cruelty of the Red Army against the population of the liberated territories...
2. The unjustified cruelty of Stalin and the military command towards their own soldiers...
3. The Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact and the secret Protocol supplementing it, as well as the accession to the Union of the Baltic countries, Bessarabia and part of the territory of Poland..."
The list, in general, is incomplete, especially considering that the title “Defend your victory” fully corresponds to the mentioned actions of the USSR in Budapest and Prague, not counting all sorts of little things like Berlin in 1953 or the latest Soviet stories like sapper shovels in Tbilisi and the television center in Vilnius. This is what this means: there is some obvious inconsistency between something and something. All these topics are more than known and have a long history - going beyond the scope of the three points above. All this has been discussed and recognized a thousand times - the pact with Germany, and the consequences of the pact (there, say, there was also a war with Finland), and how the Eastern Bloc with its entire socialist camp was structured. All this is known, but again it’s like starting from scratch. The assumption arises that all these experiences are already artistic experiences and, in any case, formatted: television. The battle to defend the victory took place on television.
Let's say Serova's argument:
“It is worth noting here that persistent attempts to raise the question of “thanks to whom did the Soviet Union win this war?” Thanks to Stalin or, figuratively speaking, thanks to Vasily Terkin, that is, the Russian soldier?" ("Times", ORT, 04/03/2005), objectively work to split the country, pushing people to a "convenient" solution - to blame all mistakes and crimes on the leader , and declare the people the only winner . "
Well, an analyst of an analytical publication from the Center for Political Technologies bases his analytical statement on the basis of what was heard on TV. It is curious that the expression “ORT” is used, although for at least two years this channel has been called the First, so the ORT label here already means a certain mythological entity, congruent with the essence of television as such. Or the same conclusions of the articles that precede the articles themselves: this is also a television format, where summaries to the plots usually completely retell the plot, for which all that remains is to show off the picture.
It turns out that two consciousnesses are used simultaneously. One is more or less sane, the other is television. Moreover, it was television consciousness that turned out to be the guarantor of state continuity, since the seventies. Well, yes, at least they have archives and their love for stylization is obvious. Another benefit: this consciousness is more compact, that is, more technologically advanced for the ether. Historians can clarify as much as they like that, say, there was not such a particularly successful tank battle at Prokhorovka, or that there are problems regarding February 23 as the victorious beginning of the Red Army - all this is not important, because in the television consciousness the usual ones will still remain data. It is a type of chip, ROM.
Here, let’s say, is the same theme, according to which the USSR did not occupy anyone in 1940, but brought happiness and advanced socialist technologies to the people in response to their collective hopes. The motivations are excellent: “When they say that the peoples of the Baltic became victims of the Soviet Union, they forget that the peoples of the USSR themselves became victims of the system established within the country. And the scale of damage that our people suffered from the totalitarian regime that ruled then is incomparable with the damage , which the Baltic countries suffered" (Alexei Zudin, " Russia is paying for the unification of Europe ", recorded by Lyubov Shariy, "Politkom", May 6).
It’s like making comics out of a book, but there are masterpieces in this genre too. Of course, they are also close to the television format. Mr. Leontiev (“ Who is the main revisionist ,” Tribune, May 6): “As for the “occupation,” there was none. The Baltic states were at one time occupied by Germany, from which they were as “independent” as the Soviet republics from Moscow. Then, after the defeat of the Nazis, they went under other masters. Moreover, the number of members of the Communist Party in the Baltic republics during the Soviet period is well known . "
Of course, it is known: there were few of them there, they were imported from the USSR, including a few national personnel who were not shot in 1938. But this is particular, something else is more interesting: according to Leontyev, it turns out that, for example, comrade. Vyshinsky, who came to Riga in 1940 at the head of a 200,000-strong contingent of SA (Soviet army) troops, then, it turns out, fought liberation battles with the fascists who occupied this territory. Yes, it's telegenic. In general, the role of the Baltic countries in the development of Russian political discourse in 2005 is difficult to overestimate: almost since January, there has been regular communication about the attacks of the “Baltic dwarfs” on Russia, and, in fact, since this has been going on for six months and is still perceived vividly, it means it’s happening scale alignment. In this regard, the voice-over text for the episode of the meeting between Putin and Bush in the Kremlin on May 8 is interesting (both two are standing at the map of the Russian Federation). It was said something like this: Bush is clearly jealous of Putin... Most likely because of how huge his country is... Of course, the country's affiliation is indicated as a loyal subject, but there is still a certain complex in terms of size...
And another potential television story from Sergei Mikheev, head of the CIS Countries Department of the Center for Political Technologies: “For example, Bush will come to Moscow on May 9, and then go to Latvia. And not at all because it is on the way. Thus they want our holiday turn into our defeat . "
There would be an animated picture: a map of Europe, Bush's plane flies back and forth, during the flight it is reported that because of this route, the holiday is turning into a defeat, and the map of the Russian Federation at these words turns from pink to grey-brown-crimson... It is strange that the expert misrepresented Bush's route - he stopped in Latvia first (which is even more offensive - if you analyze it accordingly), but, probably, this was done to mislead Bush. How can he get confused and not ruin the holiday?
In general, this is also a television trick: a metaphor is selected for an event, then it replaces the event so that reasoning about it comes down to the development of a metaphor. Of course, the result of this exercise cannot coincide with reality; metaphors, they are for instantaneous correlations. But they allow you to translate the facts of life into symbols. Like the "Friendship of Peoples" fountain. It's just a different world, involving different brains. There are computers, but there are also organizers. Short mind, convenient in everyday life.
It is the television format that translates anything into symbolic form. This is its production function. You don’t always need a lot of symbols; you can use them beautifully. In this case, it was precisely the operation of history in a symbolic format that took place. What kind of revision of the events of sixty years ago can we really be talking about? This revision may only affect some symbols that are still listed as active. Yes, such a symbolic picture of the world exists only for its authors, and their task is to maintain the symbolic space, renewing it. Here it is clearly (Irina Petrovskaya, Pobednoye TV , Izvestia, May 6):
“Last week, a newspaper journalist, speaking on air on the Ekho Moskvy radio station, spoke in all seriousness about some kind of strategic conspiracy with the participation of our TV, the purpose of which is to discredit the Victory and revise its results.
When asked by presenter Ksenia Larina who organized this conspiracy, the answer was about the West and America, for whom our Victory to this day is a sharp knife and who dream and see how to take it away from us. The arguments in favor of this version are the same as those of Savitskaya: television series of dubious content, which were by no means accidental, appeared on television screens precisely in the year of the 60th anniversary of the Victory. "Penal Battalion", "Moscow Saga", "Children of Arbat"...
So it turns out that TV is being criticized for something that should be supported and praised. To be honest, I was almost sure that in the year of the Great Victory, our TV, sensitive to the current situation, would flood viewers to the very throat with molasses of leavened patriotism, producing works of a completely different kind: varnished, smoothed out, having nothing to do with real history.
Thank God that television was not afraid of reproaches and did not follow the lead of the full-time patriots. Thank God that it was not afraid to expand the boundaries of historical truth, which, as life shows, everyone has their own... In general, television, while expanding the boundaries of what was previously permitted, did not at all revise the results of the war and the fruits of the Victory . "
So everything is fine: the attacks are repelled (taking into account the nature of the television days of May 8 and 9), the symbols are preserved, the victory is protected, the battle is won. This story had to be framed somehow. But there is no fear that television discourse will completely suppress analytics. Well, what is a minute of airtime? One and a half pages of typewritten text, three thousand characters, even if you mess around with the written text. It will not be enough for the full development of the course of political science thought - well, for some time yet, in any case. Again, there are such brains, there are those, and if you don’t confuse them, then there is no problem.
But the very manner of symbolic interaction with the surrounding reality does not look very constructive. On May 10, Mr. Putin said that the main result of the Russia-EU summit “was the adoption of road maps for four common spaces of cooperation . ” Mr. Putin emphasized that “this result of the summit was achieved thanks to persistent teamwork and the ability to reach mutually beneficial compromises . ”
The territory where compromises were reached is interesting - apparently, they actually took place. It is unlikely that the Europeans took into account the peculiarities of the symbolic reality of the Russian Federation, and it is doubtful that Mr. Putin was looking for compromises with the natural hatred of individual EU members under the hooting of some foreign politicians. That is, here is the fork in the road: either try without symbols, or urgently come up with new ones. Television - facing a fatal choice. However, it will not notice him.