About thirty years ago, the “Cartoons in the Metro” project was furiously discussed in the magazine “Young Technician”. A certain emenes intended to paint the concrete walls of the tunnels with huge pictures-frames, illuminate them and provide an abrupt change of phases, like in a film projector. All the young technicians were in favor, only I felt sorry for the Muscovites, doomed to consume the same adventure of Winnie the Pooh or Cheburashka every day. In response to my doubts, the editors responded to the effect that the flight of thought is important, but it still won’t come to the implementation of the project, implementation is impossible! I realized that the adult idiots were mocking me again, and, like Sartre from the Nobel Prize, I refused to subscribe.
I remembered this form of madness, once again clinging to the window of the Moscow-Tula train express. Garages-fences-fences-garages: painfully familiar graffiti, slogans, calls and curses. From unbiased to radical left. From rabid to funny. Standing apart are large black letters on the end of a five-story building somewhere behind Serpukhov: “Mikheev is a communist.” What is this, encouragement or denunciation? In any case, like Cheburashka, Mikheev is doomed to immortality. By the way, here is an excellent start to an inexpensive futuristic film: a long look through the glass of a carriage, the outskirts of a metropolis, aggressive industrial colors, expressive graffiti and slogans that explain to the viewer the structure of a brave new world, introducing the audience to the depths of the plot. But who cares about our future? For some, it’s more interesting to put another piece of crap on the past, and that’s how we live.
This time they turned on the stereo sound: behind them there was a sweet married couple, mother and son. They cooed incessantly, so I turned away from the window, closed my eyes, and surrendered to the voices. In all honesty, the radio play should have been recorded: two and a half hours of such live speech is expensive . “And who, who am I so crazy about?” - “What about who? Your mother and your aunt!” He bowed a little in front of her, quietly flattered her, and she gradually took the initiative and advanced. An investigation according to all the rules of drama: “Andryusha, you’re so secretive, so secretive!”
Classic genre play; so to speak, a mandatory repertoire. The mother masterfully squeezes her daughter-in-law out of the close family circle: “You’re so, so... grateful! She’s so, so!.. She just cooked the soup, and you’ve already bought it.” Both love and struggle; both material and spiritual; and a dead husband, and a bunch of background characters. You are not allowed to smoke in the vestibule, but they bravely set out on an adventure and smoked together somewhere between the carriages. We returned and finished the second act. And the ending is free, open to all winds. Good ones. Warm. Inventive. I learned something.
Hitchcock came to mind, of course. His cherished anthropological plot: a mother fights for her son with a young beauty. The mother is active, tough and always the biological same age as her son. North by Northwest has an elegant theme, but The Birds is all about that. But best of all is Notorious , where the frivolous Cary Grant and the complex Claude Rains can’t separate Ingrid Bergman, a beauty with a bad reputation. Raines, as if a Nazi, is strongly influenced by his mother, in whose image his need for guardianship from an older and more experienced woman is encrypted. The real plot is not the struggle for possession of the atomic bomb, but the struggle for the possession of a luxurious, flighty female. Entrepreneurial to the point of cynicism, Grant personifies liberal-democratic America, and Raines is a Nazi because he is not free enough from the dictates of his totalitarian mother, essentially his latent wife. Both the secret bomb and the obedient Ingrid Bergman naturally go to the former.
And the day before, back in Moscow, there was a different anthropological situation, no less interesting. Cinema center, Million Dollar Baby , the show has already started. A late girl and a guy sit down not far away. She's closer, just across the chair. Pretty, about twenty years old, eats and drinks noisily, reacts very directly. The behavior of the irrepressible girl really interested me. There was something unnatural and nervous about her activity. Something from another opera . Some kind of doom. From experience, both my own and that of others, I know that this is not how they usually behave. Thinner, more prudent, lighter . The cell phone rang, and she had to explain: “Yes, I’m at the cinema, with dad!” Well, of course, not a “boyfriend”, but a dad! This is where this dependence and nervousness come from, this fatal doom to lack of freedom, this cheerfulness for show. I have long been a mystic: a better commentary on the reported picture cannot even be imagined! These two were sent to the hall especially for me. It is possible that after the session they dematerialized.
To appreciate a Clint Eastwood painting, you need to relax and calmly classify all your perplexities. There is no need to place the film in the context of contemporary Russian art; our current small-town aesthetics have nothing to do with it. Firstly, back at VGIK I came up with a film, the action of which develops from beginning to end in a gym. I was talking, it seems, about wrestlers and gymnasts, and the multi-figured, near-sports history was elevated to the stage of unhealthy metaphysics. Secondly, Eastwood’s layout persistently signals the conventionality of the plot. Judge for yourself: a white old man is a coach, a black old man is an assistant and, finally, a stubborn thirty-year-old boxer , that ’s all . True, somewhere behind the scenes there seems to be the coach’s own daughter, to whom he has done something wrong and to whom he has not been able to reach for decades. The film as a whole is a dramatization of the letter that an old black assistant writes to an invisible daughter after the boxer dies and the old white trainer disappears forever. Thus, we have a double Father and a double Daughter, and boxing is needed here solely to emphasize the absurdity of the plot, so that immediately throw the viewer into the territory of social anthropology and metaphysics. She is a boxer only because it is a story about the Father and on behalf of the Father. In such an elegant way, the authors provide the narrative with a male point of view and a male intonation .
In addition, Eastwood plays “badly”: he always tries on the same worried face, as if he is chewing on guilt , as if he is trying to grow into responsibility . Eastwood is generally not a great actor, but here his constant mask, his awkward winks are on point. After all, this is the story of a “simple”, rude man who does not understand much. I dare say: he doesn’t understand anything. For two decades, every day he goes to a Catholic church to argue with a patient priest and finally figure it out . To cling to at least some meaning . This is the true triumph of American democratic ideals! This is why, among other things, the film was awarded a bunch of Oscars. Million Dollar Baby presents not the monologue of a arrogant, long-understood, bored, literate intellectual, as is often the case in our corporate “art,” but the inner speech of an ordinary a man from the street who, I repeat, is intensely searching for the truth and seeking forgiveness. Who starts from scratch, with total denial (see his “claims” to the priest and the Holy Scriptures). Who avoids contact with the young woman who demands professional help from him so persistently that we soon cease to doubt her right to his time and his attention (Daughter!). Who eventually learns to understand life as a situation of total responsibility.
The characters in this film exist simultaneously in two dimensions: material and metaphorical. They are naturally split in two: two hypostases of the Father, two hypostases of the Daughter. The boxer’s disgusting family, despising both her love and her dedication, point blank not noticing the old trainer, is, of course, a projection of his long-standing family, another doubling. Now it’s easy to reconstruct the Father’s own story: his wife was just as selfish, her greedy hangers-on were just as vile, her downtrodden Daughter was just as meek and doomed to their hatred. Angry, he left the family forever, leaving his beloved girl to the shameful wolves, who, of course, drank all the juices from her. The death of a boxer in the ring is a metaphor for the everyday death of a Daughter left in the clutches of her wolf mother. At least that’s what it seems to him, the Father. This is his point of view . Maybe he is wrong and his wife was much better than he now imagines? Maybe, like the blossoming and freedom-seeking girl from the Film Center, the Daughter from Eastwood’s film was burdened by the Father and his subsequent letters? Unknown, not important. More precisely, it is important, but this is the hero’s personal problem. Something else is important to us - his path . The fact that at first he deftly, technically, like a boxer, evaded, and then still recognized life as a total responsibility.
And further. Why the Daughter, and, for example, not the Son? Because there are fewer religious connotations, because with the Daughter there is no demand. In the film, she does everything her own way , contrary to the coach, whose advice she so persistently sought. A son who so defiantly contradicted the Father would deserve the title of an apostate and a moron, and a woman is forgiven for what is intolerable in a man. Thus, the responsibility of the Father is qualified as useless but meaningless stoicism.
In the finale, when the authors remove the dominant couple Clint Eastwood and Hilary Swank from active circulation, the film receives an unexpected increase in meaning . The attentive viewer discovers that the remaining Father is black and that he is not at all like the trim but straightforward Anglo-Saxon who was on the proscenium for two hours. Although, on the other hand, this black guy is writing another letter to his Daughter. However, Morgan Freeman is a different type of actor. Unlike Eastwood, he conveys the understanding gained by the soul in the process of growing up. At the same time, “black” is still, despite the dominance of political correctness, “other” (it is no coincidence that the fool named Dangerous points out this at the beginning of the film!). The white, that is, “typical” Father, finally turning into a black Father, is a change of skin, a change of fate, a change of the inner world. If you like, this is a soul charred in suffering. However, I don’t insist on this metaphor, which is infinitely attractive to me.
Last thing. The heroine does not have any personal life because we are offered the phantasm of the Father, and the Father is naturally jealous of the maturing Daughter of suitors with admirers and, in the extreme, is inclined to completely deny their logical necessity. Very good! Another hint from the author about how this work should be read, absolutely deservedly crowned with a laurel wreath and awards.
Meanwhile, for the anniversary of perestroika, our TV showed a documentary about Gorbachev. A delightful parallel montage: Mikhail Sergeevich himself and his longtime opponent, Politburo member Grigory Romanov exchange absentee compliments. Gorbachev: “But he read all the speeches from a piece of paper! What his assistants prepared for him. And then he also said: don’t forget to match the transcript, don’t forget!” The thoughts of the shy Romanov were voiced by his daughter: “These. Competent. Gorbachevs. Raisa Maksimovna, she said: “I really, really love porcelain ! ” - and everyone present slowly slid down the wall. Imagine, “porcelain ” !”
I have always, always suspected in them this level of argumentation . Agree, there is much more in common between them than there are differences. Zoshchenko, insightful Zoshchenko! “ Where, tell us, are the fathers of the fatherland?.. ” What the hell is the responsibility ? Except perhaps in front of the Russian language, which they have always feared more than the Russian people. Let it all go to waste! Gorbachev or Romanov, Mikheev or Winnie the Pooh, all the same - fatherlessness.