- Well, who is this Stalin? Have you seen him yourself?
- At the sanatorium, not so long ago. Before that, I had been sitting on the balcony for a long time, reading, and, returning to the living room, I came face to face with him. And before that we had not met for a long time.
- Didn’t you flinch?
- No, but I was surprised... They showed an old film about the 1945 Victory Parade; Walking past the TV into the room, I stood rooted to the spot and stood there for an hour, watching. I always hated stupid gossip, like, why remind people about Stalin, but now I’ve changed my mind so much about him...
was at the center of everything He . Stalin himself was shown endlessly, continuously. He stood apart from everyone else. In a compact group, lined up one to one and from a distance very similar in their jackets, stood the victorious marshals. He stood aside and watched. Voroshilov and Budyonny were hanging out next to him - two merry friends who only knew how to lose during the war, but now they are merry at the Mausoleum... There was also Kalinin, crippled by an ulcer, a poor old man doomed to death, and Stalin. I looked at him, and, I’m ashamed to admit, I looked at him with pity. He was absolutely alone, and what was happening seemed to be happening not for him. He apparently felt that he was equally the master of this event... and an unnecessary person.
A mighty army was marching past! People walked - one to one, but with such faces that you won’t find among the soldiers anymore. Those who had gone through the war walked, those who seemed to be able to do anything... A great, amazing sight! I haven’t experienced such a deep experience of fate for a long time, after which I lay for a long time, thinking: what’s wrong with me? Why did not a single unkind feeling stir in me towards this person ? From a distance, so many years later, I suddenly noticed how he stood - strange, alien... He was old and incomprehensible.
Stalin hardly smiled, but did not stand like a stone. He had an amazing face!
- “A lonely monk wandering around the world with a holey umbrella”?
- Yes, and “left to the will of heaven”... However, then he quickly recovered. I rested for several months on Lake Ritsa and - all over again! Inviting Zhukov to command the Victory Parade, he mockingly asked: are you still on your horse? But the role of the parade commander was not his; he stayed aloof and, moving away, looked closely. Right there were these two talkative girls spinning around - smiling, fresh... And Molotov with a velvet collar, in some kind of special hat - then the People's Commissariat of Foreign Affairs uniform was just introduced, and he was funny in it.
The marshals stood in a school - one to one, chest to chest, iconostasis to iconostasis. What human faces the soldiers have! It was pouring rain, standards were thrown, drums were beating... But I saw it somehow differently, not combining it with war. It’s just a pity for old Kalinin: the damned cancer apparently held him so tenaciously, all you can see is his cap and the wedge of his beard.
- When it comes to such a subject, it is difficult to be objective. Consciousness cannot be distracted from death and everything criminal that is associated with this name. Is the moralist replacing the historian in you?
- There is an important point in human development that is not fully clarified: something could have been this way, but it could have been different. Let's imagine that we are scrolling through history, like a film, from end to beginning - which, in fact, is what a historian does. And then it’s easy to begin to “see” in the early frames what is not there.
In such a situation, the philosophy of history in its preclassical form raises its voice - the one that considered facts as parables and entered into an argument with them, operating with instructive events. History is a panoramic discipline; it moves by peering into detail, into the faces of the departed. The historian is in a secret dialogue with the dead, who are transformed into the living, keeping the secret of their and our existence.
Art has the secret of overcoming this difficulty: remember Alexei German’s film “My Friend Ivan Lapshin.” The action takes place in the early thirties, perhaps shortly after the murder of Kirov. Provincial city. Fierce deeds, terrible deeds, gangs - and people fighting bandits, knowing: in order to clear the air of filth, they are allowed to stop at nothing.
You see them, wonderful people, dedicated to their work. Ordinary, strange, funny... But they, these people, will not stop even in the face of the most cruel! They themselves can fall victims of cruelty, devoid of boundaries and meaning, but they can also become its functionaries, finding meaning in it itself. And all this through the eyes of a child who lived then and now remembers these people. He knows today what a cruel time it was, but then he saw them as beautiful - in his memory the dead live, and that’s exactly what they are...
Can a historian do this? No. The historian is deprived of the rights of an artist, certainty is required of him, but he must also recognize the lessons of art, remembering that the last frames and the initial frames are not the same thing. They are often not on the same “film”!
- It’s hard to believe that the Stalin of 1922 does not hide the Stalin of 1930, 1937...
- This is because we all came out of the “Short Course on the History of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks)”. "A Short Course" stands on the fact that the initial frame contains in embryonic form everything to the end. And, let us note, the investigative version of the trials of 1937 is based on the same thing! They have the same historiosophy - givenness. But Lenin’s defeat, which came to its climax in the Stalinist system, is in no way similar to the manifestation of film footage or the implementation of a criminal intent, thought out by Stalin almost in Turukhansk exile!
- And what we consider “past” today - where does it come from? Fiction? Myth?
- No, only it has not yet been added to the “past.” This is a bundle of different, sometimes even heterogeneous, vectors.
The historian knows: 1931 in the field of ideology and related areas of humanitarian knowledge meant the end of the autonomy of thought. But here I am reading the memoirs of Eisenstein, who left for America after Potemkin. He returns to Moscow after a long absence, watches “Chapaev” - and is perplexed, almost horrified! And living here, did we really grasp the contradiction - the gaping chasm between the world of Eisenstein, where clots of collective will operate, and Chapaev, where a living character appears? And in the Stakhanov movement there were, on the one hand, initiatives, inspiration, on the other - ostentatious staging, this is generally a very difficult case. There were such famous Dusya Vinogradova and Maria Vinogradova (not sisters) - Stakhanovites in the textile industry; Hands are scurrying around, countless machines are whirring - tension plus dexterity: quickly tie a broken thread. They made a colossal impression on Bukharin and Ehrenburg: these are new people!
The picture is more complex than we imagine: there are no absolutely synchronous processes in it. Some powerful impulses given by the revolution are just penetrating and unfolding in the spiritual realm, others are on the wane, others have already been corrupted - and Stalinism is gushing out from everywhere. But he does not yet constitute a system. One question seems fundamental to me: was Stalin a necessary figure at all during these years? Imagine: we crossed him off the list of leaders in 1924. Well, would the other one take his place be the same? Clearly not.
- And the course of things would have become completely different?
- But I would find it difficult to say so. This is a difficulty due to the nature of history as such. We know that the course of things cannot be changed, which is why the formula “if…”. But do we truly know the true course of things, even where, as it seems to us, there are obvious things ?
On the contrary, this very course of events sometimes leaves in vain the innovations once found by history, life-showed by it - pushing them aside as archaic! It’s not possible to say, for example, that all the pre-war problems of people in 1945 were written off as history, and were replaced, from scratch, by “purely post-war” problems? People in 1945 thought so. It seemed to them that after all the nightmares of the eve of war and wartime, they had reached new horizons. And what? Were they able to find the language they needed, the solutions they needed to enter other conditions of human existence? No! They switched to the archaic language of geopolitics, created scissors between newness and old procedures - and nasty, sometimes subhuman passions burst into the gap - and this terrible helplessness of man in front of the results of his own activities.
Today we say: oh, if only!.. The question of “if only” concerns the hidden but real potentialities of the past. It is about why one possibility prevailed, while another died or went into the shadows, to the bottom and hid there. It also concerns impossibility - a very important concept, more important than possibility.
Where does Stalin come from as a figure? It’s not necessary that this half-hero, half-villain of the civil war, an unsuccessful People’s Commissar and failed People’s Commissar of the Russian Foreign Insurrection, should have grown into Trotsky’s killer and Roosevelt’s own partner!
The question is inevitable if you free yourself from the myth of the Master without falling into the anti-myth of nonentity. The rise of Stalin is the result and the other side of self-expenditure, the annihilation of NEP. It was the process of ending NEP that made Stalin the central figure in the country. Having failed as an alternative, the NEP could not survive - this is where the active self-destruction of the alternative comes on the scene and, in the end, the murder of it, disgraced and having lost faith in itself, by the victorious Stalin. But this was not just “elevation.” This was the emergence of Stalin !
Stalin is a necessary link in this evolution, which he captured and focused on. Stalin was not needed in 1924 - but the need for him grew from year to year; he built his need, asserted it. And, affirming, he gave all processes in the country such features that made him more and more necessary for everyone! His vocabulary, his way of political behavior, his style of government affairs! All this Stalinist toolkit of increasing tension in order to increase the need in extreme situations, coming out of every trouble even more indispensable for everyone. Stalin's necessity became a myth, and the myth shaped reality. The scenario of necessity, embodied in the structures of power and thinking, has tightened such a knot of consciousness, within which today everyone blasphemes the name of Stalin, without leaving the Stalinist system.
- Doesn’t the Stalinist system have a single author?
- What, is a myth an author’s work? Isn't it the myth itself that looks for its hero?
My thought is this: each missed, unrealized historical fork was included in the next one and burdened it. Thus, in 1923, they did not make a general, from Lenin’s point of view, choice on the national question. General - because for Lenin it was a question of entering the World, of maintaining the world status of post-October Russia.
The next time, in 1928, NEP Russia was handed over to be devoured: it could have become socialist, but it was abolished by proclaiming it as such!
In 1934-36, they lost the chance to humanize and anti-fascist democratize the Stalinist regime...
- Was there a chance?
- I do not rule it out, but here we have only indirect signs: each destroyed alternative burdens and weakens the next one, reducing its chances of success. Each subsequent alternative is weaker, since the one that is not embodied undermines it. Each unmade choice is part of the next one, namely, that the choice was missed - this is what gives growing weight to Stalin's monologues. The defeat of each opponent makes him stronger and more necessary, until everyone forgets the time when he was just one of many, when he, the one and only Stalin, simply did not exist!
The regression of no alternative is a chain reaction of inconspicuous forks that have not matured into the awareness of their alternative - therefore missed and unfulfilled. This series of indecisive half-truths is what made Stalin inevitable to such an extent that we, who had lost our past, sincerely relied on the miracle of him, Stalin, of eternal necessity. A miracle that he skillfully maintained, throwing out and destroying those undesirable, suspected only that they could replace him!
- It turns out that Stalin was in time with the answer before you had a question?
- Yes. He taught me to think in the “this way and no other way” mode. And he himself easily forgot his own formulations, as in polemics with the Trotskyists - more precisely, with those who were called Trotskyists. They were branded for the “bastard theory” of the dependence of Russian capital on the West - and later, in the “Short Course”, the “theory” returned to the role of orthodox. This is not cynicism or simply a calculation of mass stupefaction. Accumulating and absorbing the power of the alternatives he had abolished, Stalin distributed their problems into doses and mastered them as such.
Crushing and abolishing alternatives, he borrowed from these predecessors not only strength, power, authority - he selected and appropriated their problematics!.. Simplified, dishonored and reduced to “twice two”, it was nevertheless precisely that same energy - an alternative . The dispenser cut the alternative into fragments and spoon-fed it to us.
That is why the attempts of Bukharin and others in 1934-36 to humanize the Stalinist result are devoid of an internal appeal to the past and meaningful analysis; does this result give a real chance for humanization?
- But this, frankly speaking, seems fantastic to me: to humanize and inhabit the Stalinist Union of the 30s!
- Don’t forget - what seems to us logical nonsense, for the people of those years was a life goal and torment. You and I are now discussing their lives again, but they lived it themselves! It turns out that they knew something - both about themselves and about the people around them, they knew something that we have now forgotten about?
It was a time of internal detente in the USSR, a time of relative peace. The time for exceptional laws has passed. Why couldn’t the idea arise to streamline the conditions of human existence as they were ? This is a problem that can be translated into a task - and in those years it arose for them precisely as a real task. But Stalin also faced a task, a question: what political system summarizes the leveling he carried out? And this point is also included in the basis of the alternative, which is planned somewhere in 1932-34, and persists until the summer of 1936.
Stalin's leveling, as I have already said, was never total. And the state-legal normalization of the process inexorably turned it towards the legalization of intra-Soviet differences, naturally, taking into account all the previous breakdowns, confirming and inventorying them, but thereby limiting their scope for the future. The crown of change was the Constitution, in some respects even more democratic than Brezhnev’s, which, by constituting its presence, brought the party itself into certain shores.
Moreover, Stalin could not have done it here either! One should not think that the alternative was hidden from him in some underground place. Isn’t the very idea of the Constitution his, Stalin’s, idea? The alternative movement is growing even after the murder of Kirov. Old man Dalin, the late historian, who spent his allotted time in Vorkuta... I asked him what years those were - ’35, ’36... And he told me: spring!
- Vesna??
- Certainly. Following the murder of Kirov, the era of glasnost began in the USSR. Self-criticism was held in high esteem, bosses at all levels repented, meetings of non-party people took place together with party members, ministers were scolded - changes in everything, there was colossal inspiration, not to mention a noticeable relaxation of repressiveness. The intelligentsia is being consolidated, the working-class “proletarian” organizations have been scrapped by Stalin, the history of Russia has been rehabilitated... Acts were signed for the peasants for the eternal use of the land. Do you want a cow? please, here's a cow for you! The Constitution was supposed to not only consolidate the new Stalinist status quo, but also give it the character of a norm.
At first, Stalin himself seemed to be moving towards an alternative. He gives sanction to the VP Congress of the Comintern with a revision of the assessment of democracy... “Cadres decide everything”, “people must be grown like a gardener’s fruit” - this is not Bukharin, Stalin himself said it! What is all this: only Stalin’s tricks, the inconclusiveness of his choice - or the gigantic lag of the situation and the consciousness of the characters from what constituted its true, still undeciphered essence?
Everyone had to make a choice - including Stalin . Him - first of all! Stalin had the opportunity to become the initiator, the leader of the normalization that had begun. He had a presentiment that the matter would not be limited to the sum of partial measures, that the question arose precisely about the alternative . He foresees the inevitability of this choice for himself!..
And this is where, I think, Stalin’s secret complex of insignificance among the former leaders comes into play. I think he realized early on, even in a clash with major personalities in the party circle: necessity is not allowed to take its course - necessity must be created ! Non-extreme Stalin, “normal” Stalin is not sure whether he will be able to remain a leader.
He needed to become the master of all this publicity, to remain unconditionally necessary in any future turn. Democratization had to be made absolutely safe for oneself personally. It is here that the spring and secret inclination, the train of thought towards future terror are hidden.
- Didn’t hypertrophy of self-esteem save him?
- But, Gleb, this is not psychology; necessity is both a mania and the real task of politics. How was it solved? The country has moved along the path of anti-fascist normalization. As if from a cornucopia it rained: “The son is not responsible for his father”... Abolition of class-based admission to universities... expansion of private plots... reduction in the rate of industrial growth, with the promotion of group B. Criticism of leaders... And you know, these constant holidays! Orchestras were playing, people were walking along the streets, joyful. More and more reasons to celebrate - landing on an ice floe, rescuing the Chelyuskinites, meeting Chkalov... By the way, I read in the memoirs of a German communist: when Hitler came to power, a period of celebrations also began in Germany - the Weimar nightmare ended: we are no longer weak , not backward, we are strong!
He walks along the edge. Through this presumption of the sole master of democratization, mountains of corpses loom. Here's one characteristic moment for you. In June 1936, a rather prosperous year, as I already said, a plenum was held at which Kosior made a report on agriculture. He, in the spirit of Stalin's glasnost, spoke about the shortcomings in agriculture - and suddenly Stalin interrupted him: “Don’t scare us. We are already scared.” What scared Stalin and why? In 1936?!
- We were talking about paranoia...
- There is no point in representing Stalin’s behavior as games of a paranoid - millions of people voluntarily took part in the games, here and in the West! And who, strictly speaking, could know the secret of his inner personality?
Stalin was frank only with shadows from his secret scenarios, which even those close to him had no idea about. The fact that the events of this scenario “happen” exactly as he sees them is not just the suspicion of a maniac and not just one maliciously perverted interpretation of the facts. No, this is a coherent script, and Stalin is not only the author, but also a slave to the script . Something grandiose is happening in the script - to match the real thing! Many people are involved in it, and not only as extras, and enthusiastically give their lives to it. The dramatic core of the script is not always political malice against Stalin. But the secret plot of a screenplay, I think, always turns out to be something that makes the screenwriter unnecessary - and is experienced by him as a threat.
- Do you want to say that with this remark Stalin unwittingly betrayed his own condition on the eve of his plan?
- I can afford such a hypothesis. And yet he was still afraid of himself. The summer of 1936, the Zinoviev-Kamenev affair had already begun, and he suddenly went on vacation and spent the entire time in the South, not showing up in Moscow. It was an unheard of thing... Will Zinoviev and Kamenev agree to give the necessary testimony?
But my question is this: Stalin was afraid of the alternative, and they, his opponents, the smart guys, sensed it, went towards it? Anna Mikhailovna recalls how, in the days of the first capitulation of Nikolai Ivanovich Bukharin, Radek told them at the dacha: we must admit - he is a winner, he turned out to be right! They try to accept his result, giving it “proper development” - and he guesses not only the plan, but also that alternative essence of it, which they themselves do not want to think about! They still stand “on the positions of socialism,” and socialism in the USSR is “basically built.” Everything you need is already there - socialism exists regardless of the alternative!
They had already cut off their path to normalization by the way everyone behaved together at the 17th Party Congress.
- "Congress of winners"? 1934? I read the transcript, I admit, I read it with disgust...
- A terrible book, some kind of “Witches Hammer”! And the congress itself, extended over two weeks, is what is it if not a rehearsal for collective suicide? The apotheosis of Stalin, what he himself had not yet decided to be, but they roared to him: become like that!
The winter of the congress, I remember it well. Calm, harsh winter. Kirov gave a speech at the congress in honor of Stalin. The words he utters will soon become the epigraph to his obituary: “I damn well want to live and live!” These are famous words. “If you look around, comrades, you damn well want to live and live.” And then I read in the transcript of the congress (I hadn’t noticed this before) a remark: laughter . Cheerful, good-natured laughter! This is so clear to them, to the two thousand gathered at the congress, to whom else? This is for them to live and live! They are winners, they are triumphants, the right flanks of humanity: they will live and live!
Not a single person at the congress dares to say in human language: we have achieved victory, and it is ours. But we paid for it with victims, and now we have a debt to them. Instead, there is a roar of triumph plus the pragmatics of further increasing success. Plus the repentant speeches of former opposition leaders, almost identical to their future indictments.
But you know how I didn’t notice it before, that laughter ?
- But is it possible to demand from the language of the era a greater guess than is given? I sense a retrospective obligation in your reproach to the opposition.
- A follower of the alternative of the 30s was obliged to do more. But for this it was necessary to overcome the classically clear distinction between capitalism and socialism. He could and was obliged to see a new boundary in the World and put it as the basis of thought and action... But was he already able to think?
Critical thought disappeared with the renunciation of each of those who tried to give development a different vector within the post-October framework . And with these same surrenders and departures, the alternative, the need for it, the sensitivity to a different kind of thinking dried up. Stalin, on the other hand, was an intellectual winner every time! The chain reaction of unambiguity led to the fact that Stalin paradoxically each time turned out to be more audible, more confident, and more successful in his incarnations. You could rely on someone like that.
Gradually this led to a decline in intellectuality in Bolshevism. The awareness of the need to make a choice within the limits of the available grounds was gone - that is what constitutes the alternative as such. Even people who were “alternative” during Lenin’s time became Talin-like under Stalin . As a matter of fact, he was stronger than all of them in advance. Those who became Stalin-like gained nothing and lost themselves entirely. They cannot be seen or heard against his background; he, Stalin, is more powerful and enormous than them. It's really bigger!
- Why would he get involved with such small fry, get dirty with terror? Moreover, they had already lost the game and became ridiculous...
- Stalin didn’t plan everything; a lot of things came his way. This is exactly how in the mid-30s people walked towards him, towards their death - and they are happy, they want to live and live! The fact that they have corpses behind them does not bother them - and they do not sense the approach of their own death. Their hidden feelings after the terrible pogrom in the village, which they together committed with him in the early 30s, are unclear to Stalin and are already unbearable for him.
On the eve of fatal events, there is often a painful feeling as if one is getting lower and lower into the quagmire - up to the stomach, up to the throat... He seems to have a presentiment that the sum of their wills, the secret nerve of this “glasnost and perestroika”, does not bring him into personal contact with the country. The terror stemmed from Stalin's need to establish a direct relationship with Russia - a connection through death. This, in fact, is the crux of the matter.
Think about it: the terror that claimed millions of lives took place in conditions when Stalin had no enemies left in the country at all! Why - millions ?! You need to understand that logic. The incompleteness of the movement towards an alternative played a cruel joke on us back then, during the first Stalinist perestroika... Would something so monstrous have happened without this?
I internally see the investigators, the executors, all these unfortunate people who did not always start out as villains... It is more natural for them to look for enemies, being “surrounded” by them, than to understand and carry out the villainous order: go and shoot these two hundred people! How so, why and for what? Execute precisely these people as secretly hated by Stalin? No one would understand this... Stalin suddenly realized that for such people it was incomparably easier to participate in the extermination of millions on the field of man-made Armageddon. Stalin responded to this difficulty with a hint: terror.
Once I spoke with one person, a state security general; After Stalin’s death, he even spent time in a camp. As a young man, he began his career in the Leningrad NKVD, and when, after the murder of Kirov, the head of the commissariat, Medved, was arrested, Yezhov came to monitor the progress of the investigation. Young workers asked Yezhov: why was Bear punished? Then Yezhov replied: they - that is, people like Bear, ordinary Stalinists - did not understand that the enemies of Stalin are the enemies of the people .
- So, the mechanism of “large processes” has already been assembled?
- Not exactly, but Stalin had already calculated some things. For example, that he will finally decide to introduce execution among his own people. He had already tried to do this before in the Ryumin case, but lost and retreated for a while. Also, remove Zinoviev and Kamenev, remove Gorky... He dared to take full advantage of their unpreparedness, the unification of their consciousness, their inclination towards a single, focusing image of the enemy of the people - which, as a negative, forms a new positive. And then all the elements of the unborn pre-alternative were built into the mechanics of the meat grinder. Even European anti-fascism provided Stalin with justification for terror within the country and the neutrality of the left-democratic West.
- Today it is difficult to determine what the words “enemy” and “pest” meant. Is this something like the current “apparatchik”?
- In general, I notice that all eras need their own mythological scenarios. Pest is a synonymous word... It absorbed everything and everyone, it was just right for everyone and anyone. But here there was an evolution of its own: the “counter” was replaced by “saboteurs”, and after them, as my grandmother called them, “tractors” - she did not pronounce it differently, although she knew Trotsky in childhood, both from Kherson - then “ enemies of the people”, “cosmopolitans”... Moreover, it was on the rise: “pests”, for example, according to the scenarios of the era, did not kill. They only “harmed” and prepared the notorious “French intervention”, but they themselves were not considered spies. But “enemies of the people” are already “a gang of murderers and spies.” Scenario progress! It’s scary to say, but the consciousness was prepared for the appearance of an enemy of the people , and such an enemy could not be isolated. to crush the alternative That is why it was easier in the form of the destruction of millions of “enemies of the people” than in the form of the murder of a hundred or two people whom Stalin considered personally dangerous to himself.
- How to understand all this? Shouldn't we look for a simpler reason for 1937?
- I almost died looking for this “simple reason”! I’m not refuting anyone, and I don’t want to shock you. But, not forgetting for a moment about the blood of millions, I intend to find the impersonal in the personal.
I won’t say: everything should have been the way it was. But I’m sure that from some point onwards, and progressively, this could only be the case ! The more this person determined everything by himself, the more everything could be the way and only the way it happened. Stalin's choice was dictated by the Stalinist result and therefore ultimately turned against the Stalinist norm. To consolidate this result, probably only one choice was required, namely the one that Stalin made.
Of course, I will not argue that a completely different person could not have taken the place that Stalin occupied. Why? And why can’t historians discuss such a turn, for example: Hitler dies in 1937 or 1938, immediately after Munich. Who would he remain in German history? An outstanding politician who, without loss of blood, without sacrificing a single soldier, returned all of Germany's territories...
I will not turn away from a person who says: he’s banal, this Dzhugashvili! That's right - but what about the scale of the result ? What about the ability to control it?
- What about the price?
“ It was inhumane, incredible violence against people, the cost of which is colossal and distorts our development to this day. This phenomenon cannot be reduced to one or another tyrannical precedent known in history. Something new was born in the crucible, moving beyond the boundaries of history. After Stalin and Hitler, the price of development becomes a spiritual factor, a leading principle of thought!
-Have you put an equal sign between Stalin and Hitler?
- We do not have data for a simple answer to this question. But for myself, I seem to have found the key to this lock: inheriting defeat . Both inherit defeats. Hitler - the original weakness of Weimar, the weakness of Germany's attempt to become different, Stalin - the defeat of Lenin...
- Do you call “the heir of defeat” a person who himself turned out to be Lenin’s defeat, who stole his victory?
- Here we should ask: what is the general role of defeats in human progress, in history? It is assumed in advance that there are defeats, that is, colossal failures, but for the philosophy of progress they are ranked lower than victories, triumphs and revolutions. I would like to reflect on the defeats that lead the World. By what scale? Certainly. Depth? Certainly. Payback? Yes! Aftereffect? Absolutely and very important. And finally, the anthropology of defeat.
Defeats, experienced in one way or another, leave a mark on human consciousness, forming anew the type of person’s relationship to the World, to himself, to action. Then my parallel becomes clearer: the defeat of the Weimar attempt to rebuild Germany and the defeat of Lenin, our domestic, attempt to build a NEP Russia and, moving from NEP Russia, to continue the transformation of the World and our participation in the World.
The Weimar Republic was simply exhausted. As for Lenin, here we are dealing with a tragedy. His defeat, which Stalin inherited, is one of those that prepared, promised and lost the World ! A world as it has not yet been and, according to established norms, could not be.
- Let me sharpen things up. Is Stalin a figure in Soviet politics or Russian culture?
- Since society in Russia did not dance, culture became a bid for ownership of human souls. But the authorities in Russia also lay claim to souls - bodies alone are not enough for them! Hence the constant attraction of people of culture to people of power, its personifications. They were significant for them precisely as people of culture.
Russian culture acts and speaks to the World within Russia as an agent of the world process and in this role, as it were, compensates for the absence of a nation. But the authorities in the person of Stalin are also trying to act in peace! The world - as “belonging” to Russia, as inherent in its new power in the name of the Revolution.
The power of Stalin was the power of a liberated country. For the great Russian artists, the collision of his success is important; it affected them so much that even Mandelstam, who directly challenged Stalin in the Voronezh Notebooks, reconsiders his challenge. The tragedy includes the country - his, Stalin's, the country follows him. A huge human mass personifies itself in him.
But the choice and pronunciation of words is a modern topic, and Stalin’s greatest strength is that he introduced into us a linked composition of words that has magical powers. Some of his words exclude any other, and the inability to look for these other words excludes the possibility of living differently.
The Stalinist regime is anti-alternative, hostile to alternativeness as a property, as a way of thinking, as a structure of language! The authorities achieve success by pragmatizing the World, then introducing it into the arsenal of their own policies and their technological means. And the ease with which Russian culture succumbed to this - not completely, which is also important, but still succumbed - is associated with the decrease in its opposing power.
This is the genesis of Stalin, his unremoved root in each of us - ready for growth! We also have this power of words, which are given to control destinies. Lead the deaths! Due to the abolition of the ability to choose, the destruction of feedback - and above all due to the fact that at decisive moments we turn our backs on the action of this mechanism. And we allow him to manage us and our choices...
- Notice that the guiding word governs spiritual affairs. Here the Russian spirit rules through native speech, and Stalin is here too?
- In Stalin, the society of power inflicted the most severe defeat on Russian culture in its entire history; It's about internal defeat. I wouldn’t call this a moral victory, but Stalin also won in the spiritual realm.
- Then it’s still a “cult of personality” again?
- Personalities - in a transpersonal context! History is characterized by the transformation of the optional and accidental into the necessary. It makes itself necessary, irreversible - and a person is helpless before the results of his own activity, which at first was entirely in his power. But man is doubly helpless in the face of the highest results of his actions.
God is said to be "invented" by men helpless before nature; I suppose this is nonsense. God is the name of man's powerlessness before what he has created, before the highest of it!