Late February is unbearable. Where is the sun, where is the hope?
In turn, I console myself with “Anna Karenina” and Wittgenstein: “The rhyme Rast (“rest, rest”) - hast (“you have, possess”) is accidental. But this is a fortunate accident, and you can discover this fortunate accident for yourself . ” If I understand correctly, Wittgenstein's lucky accidents are the same thing as what Jung called acausal synchronic connections. In a situation where February paralyzes the will to create independently, trust in reality becomes especially important. In a couple of days, three new films, two old ones, plus one memory hit my sore head. There was no conscious choice, the rhyme took shape on its own.
The integrity of a person is problematic: is it legal to collect his numerous roles, dispersed throughout his life, into one body, consolidate with one name? What does the old woman think about her young self? How does her memory work with this image of her own body, which no longer exists in the material world? Is it possible to identify with him? By splitting one destiny into roles and placing the newly-minted participants in the action under one roof, in one family, a developed culture transforms diachrony into synchrony. So, among other things, it’s more clear.
For example, for his own selfish methodological purposes, Freud slandered the “family plot” of Laius - Jocasta - Oedipus. It is customary to overlook the prehistory, but Oedipus’s pranks were preceded by the terrible sin of Laius himself, who, as is known, in response to the hospitality of King Pelops, kidnapped and took with him to Thebes his young son Chrysippus. Only after this, in accordance with the vengeful request of Pelops, who wanted the thief to be destroyed by his own son, Laia, did the gods send Oedipus to the childless king of Thebes. For what vile purpose did Laius steal the young man Chrysippus? What was that doing to him? We agree, a completely different story! It turns out that Oedipus is nothing more than the reactive conscience of the villain Laius, his youthful self not clouded by lust. He is trying to kill another “I” - an elderly sinner who, by the way, himself begged the gods for a son, probably seeking punishment in the depths of his soul. Both halves of this schizophrenic nature “forgot” and repressed the prehistory of the drama. Now Laius sleeps with Jocasta, either as a dirty libertine, or as a respectful “son.” In Sophocles, Oedipus tortures his wife: “Tell me, what was Lai’s appearance like? Was he young or old?” And she amazingly answers: “He was tall and with silver gray hair - he looked almost the same as you are now . ” Here's to you, grandma, and Yuryev's day!
It is also said that Jocasta “wept over her bigamous bed, where a husband was given to her and children were given to her as a son . ” “A husband was given to her” - because Oedipus, like conscience, was generated by the sinner Laius. “Children are the son” - because the blessing of childbearing, of course, is more logical to attribute to the young sinless Oedipus. Oedipus himself recites: “O double marriage! You gave birth to me and, having given birth, you received the same seed!” Another indication of the biological identity of Oedipus and Laius.
The above speculations occurred in my head immediately after the completion of the French film A ton image , “An Exact Copy,” with Nastassja Kinski and Christopher Lambert. The film is mediocre, weak, but methodologically important. Instead of the Oedipus complex - the Electra complex. According to psychoanalysts, it expresses the daughter’s hostile feelings towards her mother, which are caused by jealousy of the “rival” who prevents the daughter from undivided control of her father. In fact, again synchrony instead of diachrony. As a child, Kinski's heroine had problems with her parents: instead of a fashionable guitar, they bought her an archaic piano. Got married, gave birth, divorced. But she still cultivated teenage immaturity: instead of raising her son, she strummed an electric guitar, and meanwhile he accidentally fell into a well and died.
That's the background. At the beginning of the film, Kinski’s heroine has a body ready for all kinds of adult madness and an underdeveloped soul. They seek - respectively - a husband and a father. Right on the road, the heroine catches a lonely man, Lambert. It’s good that it’s right on the road: we are immediately informed about the rules of the game. Diderot and Voltaire began their philosophical grotesques just as easily: “How did they meet? - By chance, like all people. - What were their names? - What do you care? - Where did they come from? - From a neighboring village. - Where were they going? " Tradition, damn it. All that's left is to be jealous. So, Lambert and Kinski got married, but they have no children. Then he, a biologist, resorts to forgery: he creates a clone of his wife. That is, the girl born to Nastassya Kinski is not their child together, not a new creature, but an exact copy of her mother. In this moronic way, the authors achieve their noble goal: they split the heroine into a woman and a girl, into a mother and daughter. It's funny: the ethical situation is the opposite of what was in the case of Laius - Oedipus. Here the younger one is the sinner and the villainess, and the older one, on the contrary, is the righteous one. Here's a key gender difference! It ends, as expected, with the death of the villainess girl in the same well. What would that mean? It's okay: the heroine overcame her infantilism, destroyed her irresponsible daughter, and finally became wife . I repeat, the plot is stupid, but useful.
Here's a better movie: Somersault from Australia. In our box office it is idiotically called "16 years. Love. Reboot." Essentially the same Electra complex and the same splitting, although outwardly this film seems more “realistic” and detailed. Despite the fact that there is something to talk about here besides the plot, I will only focus on it: we are really bad with this, absolutely. 16-year-old Heidi lives under the same roof with her mother and her boyfriend. The key episode of the film is easy to miss: Heidi just picks up her mother at a night bar. The boyfriend sits in the car on the street and meekly waits, and meanwhile the girl sees her mother courting another guy. In the morning, while her mother is soaking in the bath, Heidi flirts with her boyfriend, left unattended by her parent. The enraged mother takes them by surprise, after which the frightened girl runs away from the house. One could say that Heidi's journey is identical to the fall of her French peer into a well.
So again, synchronicity. Another novel of education, the transformation of an aggressive teenager into a wife! The scene in the bar presents us with the initial aggression and irresponsibility of the mother. After this (bravo, authors!) realism only masks total convention. Now Heidi is playing out the heroine's teenage qualities. In the scene of the morning seduction of the boyfriend, nothing special happens: that half of the mother, who is called the “wife,” suddenly saw the other half, the “whore,” from the side and screamed in anger. The daughter who ran away from home and indulged in all sorts of evil is a soul growing up in the metaphysical wilds. In the film, this qualitative growth is done very well, subtly. At first, Heidi gives herself to the first guys she meets, lying on her back and spreading her legs indifferently. But later she begins to distinguish between men. Only after learning to love, having suffered and cried, does she unite with her adult half and, apparently, die as unnecessary.
The old (1979) David Cronenberg film The Brood , which suddenly jumped into your hand from a stack of unwatched tapes, goes even further. Here, not only the social roles of a person are physically formed - even abstract feelings like hatred are associated with certain anthropomorphic creatures. The husband and wife hate each other and cannot share their daughter. At the same time, the insidious psychotherapist Raglen regularly works with his wife. Using the science of psychoplasmics, he materializes a woman’s anger directed at her daughter, at her husband, at her mother and father, at her daughter’s teacher, with whom her husband carelessly drank a cup of coffee. Cronenberg is primitive to the point of genius: first, anger manifests itself in the form of blisters, then the blisters enlarge into a special kind of sacs, from which vile little men, “children of wrath,” simply demons, ultimately emerge. Pretending to be preschoolers, the dwarfs wander around the city and beat to death everyone their mother hates. Saving his daughter, the hero destroys his queen bee wife, but in the finale, boils, these promising clusters of anger, appear on the girl’s body. By the way, the Greek word “epigon” means “born after”, “descendant”.
In the comedy "Meet the Fockers" there is no synchronization signal or synchronization code. The situation is not dramatically tense. That's why so many virtuoso actors were needed: to save the producers and screenwriters. One family delegated the groom to the plot, the other family delegated the bride. Each character is equal to himself. It's funny in places, but overall it's a typical "insufficient work", hack job.
Having accidentally seen the television version of Georgy Tovstonogov's famous play "Philistines" on "Culture", I admit: synchrony is not necessary, historicism is not useful. "Physticians" appeared on the stage of the Bolshoi Drama Theater in the second half of the 60s, the adaptation for television dates back to 1972. It turned on gradually, but by the end of the first episode it was howling with complete delight. It turns out that Tovstonogov, long ago and in all its glory, presented that generation, that collective subject of our history, against whom I have been grudges for a long time. Evgeny Lebedev in the role of old man Bessemenov - in essence, King Lear, betrayed by his children. The aggressive workman Neil, the henpecked Peter, some rabid girls - all these worthless youth trample the responsible Father, on whom the big House rests, into the mud. The director draws the line consistently, harshly! Elena, the cheerful widow: “You are my nice boy!” Peter, passionately: “I’m not a boy, no! I thought a lot . ” This is the argument. Oh yes Gorky, oh yes son of a bitch. However, Gorky just gave a cliché, a scheme for all times. Next, an interpretation that is in tune with the current moment is required. Tovstonogov placed terrible accents : those who are 25-35 at the time of production will irritate the House, humiliating both those who are older and those who are younger.
A memory immediately crept into my brain. 1974: I, a second-grader, was selected to a gymnastics school, where I achieved some success. One day, a coach publicly announced to my friend Seryoga Z.: “Of course, you will be a champion, but first you need to work on your elbow joints. You have a curvature here. Do you live in a private house? No? Oh, grandma in a private one! So, bring water to grandma from the column. In buckets. The elbows will be reshaped. Come back in three months."
Seryoga moved in with his grandmother, tried hard, moved hundreds of thousands of buckets, and was eagerly interested in my training process. When he showed up three months later and showed his elbows, the coach didn’t even look at them. But I heard in the locker room how the coach, openly telling his colleague about the slow-witted, stupid guy: they say, in such an unobtrusive way he tried to weed him out, unpromising, but for some reason he believed and showed up again. Day after day, as suggested. Now he looks trustingly into the eyes: “The elbows have changed shape , right?!”
I came home. Shocked, the eight-year-old said: “Mom, I won’t do gymnastics anymore. My back hurts. My vision is getting dark.” I don’t remember their faces, but I still hear their mocking, self-confident voices. Five days ago I recognized these people in a play by Georgy Tovstonogov. In 1974 they were barely over thirty, but to me they seemed very mature, very responsible people. The sports career ended, consumerism and accompanying cunning began. The coach hoped that sooner or later Seryoga would break. The coach is right in his own way. But in my opinion, no. Plastic human crap. Gymnasts. Nothing significant has yet been said about the era of the 60-70s. Even the magnificent Vampilov is not enough. But Tovstonogov’s Gorky is just right.
Once in the second grade, I could do the splits with ease. And now this traumatic memory serves as a silent reproach to me. Slipped and fell. It's a shame. But I still have the strength to rise and the words to curse.