
Photo: Dmitry Dukhanin / Kommersant
New requirements of the RKN are contained in amendments to order No. 221 of July 31, 2019. The regulator plans to oblige providers to transmit and constantly update the data “On the network addresses they use, about the network addresses used by their clients” indicating the geographical location of the use of IP addresses, including in the form of coordinates, as well as information about the goals of their use. It is planned that the new rules will enter into force on September 2024.
Every day we use both the global network of the Internet and closed local networks (Intranset, or the internal network of the organization). In order for the site we need to open on request, and our messages reached a specific addressee, it is necessary that each device connected to the network has a unique identifier-IP address.
It is a line of numbers separated by points, contains information about the location of the network device, makes it accessible to communication and allows you to distinguish computers, routers and websites.
IP addresses are not random and unique. Your device is appointed by your Internet provider, which, in turn (directly or indirectly), receives it from one of the five regional Internet registrars existing in the world (RIR-Regional Internet Registry). For Russian users, all IP addresses are allocated by RIPE NC-a coordination center for the distribution of Internet resources in the European region, serving local Internet registrations in Europe, the Middle East and Central Asia.
The threat of “calculating by IP” is probably familiar to any Internet user. Allegedly, “hackers” can easily determine the person’s home address, knowing only the IP addresses of his computer, and are ready to transfer it to anyone for a small reward. For example, an opponent in a network dispute. However, in reality, everything is much more prosaic.
According to your IP address, you can find out your Internet provider, the country and maximum the city from which you get to the network. And for this you do not need to be a system administrator.
The IP geolocation option is widely used by various online stores, the sites of which are constantly trying to guess from which city you are viewing the goods. Without any illegal help, to determine your approximate location by IP can, for example, a popular 2ip service. True, it is far from the fact that it will be correct.
The sites will recognize your (or not quite yours) country, the city and the district, referring to one of the existing registers of the IP addresses created on the basis of information voluntarily transmitted by providers to the registrar. The accuracy of the definition depends on how relevant and complete information the operator of the communication reports and what kind of database the service uses.

At the moment, there are many registers of IP addresses, and each of them contains outdated data or errors. The RKN initiative implies the creation and further maintenance of the operators of communication operators by the current base of the geolocation of the IP addresses in Russia.
According to the text of the proposed amendments, Russian communication operators will be required to indicate and transfer the RCN location of the use of the range of network addresses with an accuracy to the village and the municipal district.
In the explanatory note to the project, Roskomnadzor clarifies:
“Based on the data provided, a trusted database of geolocation of IP addresses in Russia will be formed. The database will be regularly updated, communication operators and resource owners will be able to use it for the automated creation of correct access lists, its creation will make it possible to bring the digital border of the state in accordance with the physical boundaries of the Russian Federation. Citizens of Russia will gain access to state, banking and other important resources anywhere in the country. ”
However, creating such an accurate and current base in practice is unrealistic. After all, IP addresses are different and often change their “residence”. If the public, the so-called white IP address in most cases is not problematic to fix for a specific user and a certain location, then it is simply impossible to provide such an address with a network subscriber. The number of addresses familiar to us (IPV4) is limited by the range from 0.0.0.0.0 to 255.255.255.255. This means that all of humanity has only 4,294,967,296 unique IP. According to the Global Digital 2023 report, which is annually compiled by the DatarePortal service, the number of Internet users in the world as of 2023 is 5.16 billion. That is, now there are not enough public addresses at everyone.
To solve the problem of a shortage of free IP addresses, private, or “gray”, IP addresses belonging to a special range not used in the global network are used. Of the available “white” IP, the providers give users only part, reservating another part for the work of NAT server (Network Address Translation - “Converting network addresses”). This server, according to a certain algorithm, transforms the “gray” IP address into “white”, which allows several subscribers to use one public IP at once. The distribution of private addresses is not controlled by anyone.
In his commentary Forbes, the President of the Association of Cable Television Operators "Makatel" Alexei Amelkin notes that
“One IP address can share several users in different places,” and “it is impossible to track all changes in the IP addresses and report them RKN.”
In the explanatory note to the project, Roskomnadzor clarifies:
“At present, there is no trusted source of information about the country's business network, which can cause errors in the work of Russian information security and data analysis systems. For effective protection against DDOS attacks, it is necessary to use more accurate methods for determining geolocation ... Based on the data presented, a trusted database of the geolocation of IP addresses in Russia will be formed. The database will be regularly updated, communication operators and resource owners will be able to use it for the automated creation of correct access lists, its creation will make it possible to bring the digital border of the state in accordance with the physical boundaries of the Russian Federation. Citizens of Russia will gain access to state, banking and other important resources anywhere in the country. ”
If you remove the obscure desire to “bring the digital border of the state in accordance with the physical boundaries of the Russian Federation by brackets, the proposed amendments have one declared goal-increasing the effectiveness of protection against DDOS attacks.
The number of requests to the network resource, which the server is able to process simultaneously, is limited. In addition, there is a limitation of the capacity of the channel connecting the server with the Internet. When the number of requests to the resource exceeds the performance of the server or overloads the capacity of the connection, there is a complete cessation of the resource, or “refusal to maintain” - DOS (Denial of Service).

Refusal of maintenance can be called intentionally. If one device (host) is used for intentional overload of the system, we are talking about DOS-Atak; If the service or the network is overloaded with traffic from several sources-about DDOS-Atak (Distributed Denial of Service), or “distributed refusal to maintain”.
Forbes reports that, according to Stormwall,
In 2023, the number of DDOS attacks around the world increased by 63%-mainly due to geopolitical factors. Russia accounted for 7.3% of the total number of attacks, this is 7th place.
The reasons for DDOS attacks are diverse: from personal hostility and unfair competition to extortion, espionage and political motives (hactivism). For example, the number of attacks on the resources of human rights organizations in the United States in May 2020 increased 1120 times, which coincided with mass protests after the murder of George Floyd.
Will the formation of a “entrusted database of geolocation of IP addresses in Russia” allow you to more effectively withstand DDOS attacks? Of course not! For DDOS attacks, more than one host is used, but entire networks of remotely controlled devices (botnets), and knowledge of their exact geographical location does not facilitate their blocking in any way. The Executive Director of the Internet Protection Society Mikhail Klimarev* ironizes : “Suppose that the RKN will recognize the physical address where the attack is being conducted. He will be wilted at this address of machine gunners on motorcycles? "
More likely,
The register of Russian IP addresses needs RKN for compulsory closure of access to Russian sites from outside (for foreign IP), “protection” of Russian users from access to foreign resources and facilitating VPN blocking.
If “bringing the digital border of the state into line with the physical boundaries of the Russian Federation” means that due to technical errors of geolocation, untimely entering information to the next register, living in the attached territories or just leaving the country, a citizen of the Russian Federation will no longer be able to pay his taxes through “public services”, make a rent on the website of his housing and communal services operator or extend the “cinema pool” subscription with his own Parents, then we are not talking about restoring order, but about a full digital iron curtain. True, it is unlikely that it will be possible to lower which RKN.
Elena Belyaeva