
The new school year begins, ahead of the next passions in the exam. Under what conditions the situation with a single exam can normalize and under what conditions the teacher is able to give our children a quality education, read in an interview with Vsevolod Lukhovitsky , the teacher of the Russian language and the rights of the Intellectual Boarding School, a member of the Council of the Teacher’s Interregional Trade Union. Talked by Natalia Demina .
Now there is a reform of education. Could you make your assessment of this reform?
The reform has already passed. With school education, almost everything that the authors of the reform thought happened. The Law on Education only fixed what gradually passed the last 15-20 years. Education financing has been reduced, education is approached from the point of view of the economy - from an accounting point of view. The problems that are in education are trying not to solve some serious changes in education, but solely from the point of view of manager and manager.
I can compare what is happening now with what happened 10-25 years ago. In the 1990s, there was an absolute lack of funding, there was no money for anything, while the state for one reason or another said: “Guys, you have complete freedom.” Freedom in choosing a program, freedom of creativity, freedom of creating any schools, freedom to act as you want. As a result, in the late 1980s and especially in the first half of the 90s, the very schools that are still considered the best, which make up the pride of our education, appeared.
New approaches to education appeared, and all this - pay attention - was done without financial assistance to the state. There was little money, but there was freedom. It was precisely that Sergei Bebchuk had in mind in a lecture at Polit.ru, when he said that schools and teachers need freedom so that even a secondary teacher feels like a man.
Around 1999, we received the first information that from teachers again they begin to ask curricula, compliance of programs, dressed textbooks, etc. In the early 2000s, the nuts began to tighten in the sense of content, but at the same time they began to give money. For some time, until about 2008-2009, especially in the regions, the teachers felt that there was a budget in the regions, especially in small towns ... And they pragmatic thought: well, of course, it was disgusting to work like this, but for good money you can.
And then it turned out to be a great classic deception with the new system of remuneration, when the first six months in all schools in all regions, people get more, rejoice: cheers, we were appreciated - and then gradually salaries are reduced.
Why?
Because the new remuneration system was not made in order to abstractly increase the level of payment of teachers. The new payment system is introduced in order to, firstly, save, and, secondly, to finally divide teachers. There are a director of the director, and there are second -class people. There are people who get 6 times more than their own colleagues. Considering that it is impossible by any parameters (nowhere in the world there is no objective system of qualitative assessment of the teacher’s work!) To evaluate the quality of the teacher’s work, this makes a terrible impression. Some teachers leave, they say: we will not humiliate ourselves because of this shameful score. Others begin to frantically consider every score.
Yesterday a colleague from Belgorod called me and said: “Imagine what a disgrace, people began to subtract points from stimulating payments.” According to the Labor Code, any fines are prohibited, we do not have such a type of punishment. You can not fine the employee, for 100 years such a rule is already valid. Even in tsarist Russia, after the 1905 revolution, in my opinion, employees were not fined. What did the director come up with? They say that stimulating points are introduced, and if you have any flaws, then we remove these points. That is, in fact, the director got the opportunity to be fined, and formally this is not a fine.
Maybe this is right, because the best workers need to pay more? Are there such teachers who give the whole soul?
What is the whole soul ? How to count and transfer it to money? Imagine a teacher all day at school, all the time with children. Are you sure that its influence on children and the effect of its presence is how benevolent, as in a situation, when a person only comes, gives his lessons and leaves? Maybe in these lessons he will do much more than this teacher, who disappears at school all day? For one, a strict, harsh professional is good for one. For another, a soft aunt is good, which will help him with Zhi-Shi. For the third, it is important that he sang a song with them under the guitar, for the fourth it is important that the teacher talks to him about Buddhism once a year.
This is not to say that there is a good teacher, but there is a bad one. The teacher’s assessment can only be strictly formal. If the teacher graduated from the university, if the teacher has passed the necessary formal certifications, then there can be no complaints about him until he made something glaring. This is only for us for many years to explain to us what all teachers are dark and bad. This is the most common - yes, what to take from these teachers? Only 10% of the pedagogical universities go to school. I recently talked with people from a very decent law university. They say: by profession we work 12-15%, and everyone else goes to any firms that are not connected directly with legal work. And what, all who finish the physical faculty work strictly in their specialty? I think this is a false binding.
It turns out that there is no reason to give teachers a bonus?
With rare exceptions. The prize is a reward for some additional load. I understand that when a person, for example, took the children on an expedition on his vacation, he must certainly give some reward for this, because he spent his additional forces. But why does the teacher, who has one of the students - the winner of the All -Russian Olympiad, should give a bonus, and not give another teacher, if his student is “only” the winner of the district stage? Well, fate was so distributed that one got a more talented student, and less. This is all an attempt by simple accounting, managerial ways to regulate what cannot be adjusted in this way.
The teacher, firstly, needs the trust of society, needs freedom and a worthy wage needs to work, which helps him to work. We conducted a survey in many regions: “What do you think that normal wages are now for the teacher?” At first we did not understand what “normal” means? And they answered: well, add 5 thousand rubles, we will live somehow. And then people began to believe that the teacher needs to go to the theater at least once every 2 weeks, he needs to buy books, the teacher cannot go into tearing, the teacher should have the opportunity to buy a ticket for rest at least once a year, the teacher should have the opportunity to read books, work with the Internet, etc.
It turns out that the average salary of the teacher should now be approximately 60-70 thousand rubles in the regions, and this, I emphasize, is not a total salary, and this is a bet, the teacher should not work overtime. At meetings with teachers, we are interested in: how much do you work per week? And colleagues answer: "Well, here we have 26 hours." And let's calculate how much you spend on checking notebooks, how much you are preparing for lessons, how much you spend on meetings with your parents, on meetings, on reports. On average, it turns out about 70 hours a week, while by law a person should work 40 hours. See the difference?
What is the average earnings?
The average earnings are striving to be average in the region. But the regions are very different with us, and most importantly, this is the wrong counting. Would the employees like any plant to be told: “You will work 2 times more, and for this we will pay you the average salary at your factory”? Recently there was a statement that in Moscow the average salary of teachers was 64-65 thousand rubles. That's right, what is the number of hours worked? On average, in my opinion, I heard the figure 25-26 hours. This means that a person deliberately ruins his health, this means that a person consciously works poorly.
And how many hours should it be to be high -quality?
There must be exactly the rate - 18 hours. This is verified, this problem has been discussed for several years. And I seriously think that teachers need to behave in the same way as Izhevsk doctors who recently organized an Italian strike. Where to get the money from? You see, I cannot fall into place of the owner. I am a hired worker, not the owner. If I were in the place of Medvedev, I would have to think something like that, where to get the money. My business is to sell my labor, my work. So, to work more bets - this means working either for wear, or obviously poor -quality.
We often talk with Moscow teachers. “How good it became for us, we get 70 thousand!” But how many hours do you have? “Oh, you know, yes, it’s a lot, it’s very difficult, I have 29 hours, I would still like to take it, but I can’t give it.” This reminds me of the early Strugatsky story, where the heroes arrive at the asteroid, on which the bad capitalist built underground mines. The workers will work on the mine for two years, earning gigantic money, fly to the ground and die there. The main characters, Gorbovsky and someone else, say to the workers: “Listen, he is mocking you, you will die after 2 years.” “Well, it doesn’t matter how I want and work, most importantly, I have more money to make more money.”
This position leads to the fact that the teacher really stops working efficiently. You can’t prepare well for the lesson if you work 70 hours a week. I have 34 years, I have passed the same course in the Russian language dozens of times. Nevertheless, each lesson is preparation from half an hour to an hour, although I have everything in the computer. And, therefore, I do not get enough sleep, but how can a low teacher work? The teacher should be able to live normally by working on a bet. I think that sooner or later we will go to the same strike as doctors. Imagine what will happen if all teachers say: we work only for one bet?
They will not say. Where will they still quickly find work for 60 thousand?
So, after all, no one will drive the teacher. Teachers are really not enough in Moscow. If the teachers had not worked at one and a half rates, then half of the Moscow schools would simply get up and could not work.
Is this a forced necessity or not?
Now this is the policy of the Moscow Education Department. It says: no part -time workers, no small loads. This is understandable, because Putin said that there should be large salaries. The easiest way to make a large salary by increasing the amount of work. They leaked schools.
How do you assess the merger of schools?
Well, look, they leaked schools, there are more students in the classroom, it became more difficult for the teacher to work. Again, the maximum number of schoolchildren should be 15-20 people. In Moscow schools, (I think no one will officially confirm this, because this is a violation of SanPiN) Now it is really under 30 people in the classroom. It turns out that for these 70 thousand, the teacher, firstly, is ready to work one and a half times more by an hour, and, secondly, with a much larger number of children, and this inevitably worsens the quality. Well, ask any friend, mother, grandfather, grandmother: in what school would you like your child to study: so that there are 30 people or 15 in the class? I think that not a single person will say that 30. That's why this association of schools is not a way to improve the quality of education, but a way to save money.
What is the meaning of such an association?
Officials directly say: this is necessary in order to reduce unnecessary people, for example, the administration, and at the same time there is a reduction in psychologists, librarians, social workers, doctors, transferring everything to outsourcing, which means that again, the school as a result will not be at the hand of his medic, who can help him.
From the point of view of the economy, a large school is extremely profitable. Another thing is that pedagogy should not benefit, in general education cannot be evaluated from the point of view of economic benefit. This is a social sphere, not the sphere of services.
I can understand when some schools, having done a very serious preliminary job, decided that it is more profitable for them to unite, it was wonderful, it is very good. Some kindergarten determined that it is more profitable for him to join the school, wonderful. This has always happened.
I know the schools that started such an association 10-15 years ago. In the end, the Yamburg school is a giant school, several thousand people, but this is precisely due to the specific tasks that are facing these schools. The teams of schools themselves came to this. And now, and this is no longer hiding, the installation is underway: we should ideally remain several hundred combined complexes from 2000 schools - this is what I heard.
From the point of view of the child, studying in a complex is a very dangerous business, it is not clear what is there. And to believe that the child in a large school will definitely feel good - this is at least strange. They used to say that the child needs a microclimate . About 25 years ago they came to the conclusion that it was necessary to do an elementary school separately, then they decided to separate the average from the eldest. Then there were other ideas that high school should communicate with primary, but, in any case, the school should be such that all the children knew each other that they would feel that they are all together.
I can’t imagine how in a school, where more than 500 people, children can know each other how the director can know all the children how the head teacher can know all the children. And, in my opinion, this is absolutely necessary for the director to know every child, so that every child knows all the teachers, that the child, coming to school, feels completely protected. When there are a lot of children at school, the microclimate is immediately violated. As they like to say: “School is our house”, “School is a single family”. So - there cannot be a family in which 2000 people.
And finally, they say that the unification of schools is made so that everyone is equal, so that there is no inequality in access to education. It is already clear that this thesis does not work, because in many schools, where dozens of classes, classes for gifted children have formed for “ordinary” and, relatively speaking, “for the weak”. It appears again, and you can’t do anything about it. Rather, something can be done with this if you specially work on the problem.
Now parents go to the 57th school and think: we are immediately provided with perfect work in high school, all our children will then go to Mehmat or Fizteh. At the same time, there are ten first classes, but it must be borne in mind that out of 10 classes, maybe only one child or two will reach mathematical classes. In the same way in other schools, in itself the problem of social segregation is not solved by mechanical fusion.
They say: we will connect a good school and three bad ones, and the children are mixed. They are not mixed, they still remain, as they were, in closed groups. They go astray in heaps, while in some schools there is such a problem: “good” beat “bad”, or most often “bad” beat “good”. So that this is not, special teachers, special methods are needed, psychologists who work with each group are needed. To make a team from a heap, you need to spend years so that the children feel together.
Now 4 are being created, if I am not mistaken, the pre -wise lyceum: at the tower, at the RSU, and at two universities. I understand that in a sense this is a step back, because the tower itself was the main theoretician of equality of access to education, and it is no coincidence that they wanted to make themselves a special lyceum: everyone should be equal, and we, of course, are more equal than others. In some interview, there was an interesting statement that they did not prepare children for themselves, the children will all take the exam. However, it is clear that if they had not prepared children for themselves, these lyceums would not have arisen. There are needs for good applicants, and the search for capable and motivated children is absolutely necessary.
In your opinion, what happened to the exam this year differs from what happened in past years?
As far as I know, all types of violations that were before were this year. Maybe there are more of them, maybe less, no one measured. There is a question that this itself is inevitably provokes violations, and provokes at all levels. In violations, absolutely everyone is interested. Only university teachers against violations, because they need to teach these students in the future. Now it turned out that the only interested in an honest exam is universities. And for parents this is good, because it is very simple to solve the problem. For children, this is also good, because all children understand that the exam itself, to put it mildly, is not an ideal option for an exam.
Here, however, I can only talk about humanitarian objects. Perhaps in biology, chemistry or mathematics of the exam is good. But the attitude to the exam in the Russian language, literature, social studies is as follows: teachers say: “Guys, this is stupidity, but you must get used to it. Yes, they demand to write stupidity from you, study. ” Pupils should know that in life they will receive not only smart tasks. From the point of view of education and the ability to live in society, this is also useful, of course. We say to the child: “Keep in mind that the boss may require any stupidity from you, and you must make it just because you will not get your salary otherwise.”
The most important thing is that schools are interested in violations on the exam, because the school is evaluated by the exam. Based on the results of the exam, the work of the governor in the field of education is evaluated, and, therefore, the more violations, the easier it is to get final good points, which means that the better.
You see, not only some villains and sold officials are violated for the exam. Any official is interested in appreciated him well. It would be strange if a person wanted the minister or president to think about him badly. There is a governor, he wants his region to be evaluated well. If there is such a item “Examine results”, then, of course, the governor will turn close his eyes to the best of his quick wits, hint, demand.
In any administrative system from the high authorities require reports, the high authorities are lowering this to the average level, the average to the lower, and at the lower level they are sometimes forced to falsify the data. And it turns out that those who are at the lower level are to blame, that is, those very teachers.
Why this year they raised such a noise due to violations on the exam-I can’t answer, I don’t know. There are dozens of versions, starting with the fact that all the money that was spent on developing the exam and implementation have long been eaten, and now it would be very good to cancel the exam, introduce something else-and also get a certain amount of money to this. And ending with such a version: that, they say, the truth triumphed, everyone was convinced that the exam was bad, it was necessary to urgently change it, because civil society would not pull this. Which option is correct, which is wrong - no one, of course, knows now.
What needs to be done to change the situation for the better? Is it possible to do this at all?
Firstly, you need to divide the exam into university and school. Why do we generally assume that a schoolboy who ends the school must definitely go to the university? Not necessary at all. A university is for someone who wants to get a higher education. Secondly, the governors are evaluated according to the results of passing the exam, and, accordingly, the education department, school, to cancel the presidential decree. Finally, let the examination of the exam prepare two or three independent companies, and universities should be allowed to accept both by the exam and not by the exam. Why is there corruption in universities? I did not hear that in England there was corruption upon admission to the university. Why do we have corruption upon admission to the university?
There is MGIMO, Moscow State University, Tower. They want to go there more than in some other university.
Why is this not in Oxford or Harvard? I have never heard about mass corruption in Oxford. There must be some reasons. I see a few reasons. Firstly, that our universities often go to escape from the army. If we had a contract army, I think the competition in universities would have fallen sharply, because young people, not afraid of the army, would not rush to the university. They would work somewhere, finished out, self-determined. As far as I imagine in fiction, it is completely normal that the United States has finished college, after which he works for several years, after which he enters the university. This is impossible for us, because as soon as a person did not enter the university, he goes to the army. This is one moment.
The second point is the features of our social consciousness: we are sure that a person can become only by graduating from a university. And the prestige of what is called secondary vocational education is extremely low in society. It is clear why it was in the Soviet years. Now I know in Moscow good, strong, for example, medical colleges. In a good way, everyone who wants to be doctors first needs to pass a medical college. But the guys are afraid to go there, because, firstly, they will be taken away after ending in the army, and, secondly, it is believed that this is not prestigious, it is believed that it is indecent-to study at college, and not at the university.
Are teachers now not very interested in having good students? A good teacher is always interested. I constantly hear from university teachers: “Well, who comes to us? What a disgrace! I would give us the opportunity! " Why do we think that a university teacher, if given him, will definitely take dishonest people? Why then work with them? Why do we suspect people in advance?
The same teachers participate in the training, in preparation for the exam ...
Previously, there was a rather strong contradiction between the university textbook and the school curriculum. And I think that this is not a shoal, or not only a shoal. Relatively speaking, a fool did not act on Mehmat anyway. But a smart person, capable, but in an ordinary school, who did not have experience in solving such problems, as required when entering a mechmat, needed a tutor. And I do not see anything terrible in this, just as in preparatory courses. This is bad only if people want to go to the university not to study, but in order to escape from the army.
The exam helps talented children from the regions to get into large universities ...
I'm not talking about the exam at all. I am saying that the exam should be, firstly, intensify, and secondly, there should be more than one USE option created by one team, one company, but 2-3. And Kima should be different, and the main authors are different. Relatively speaking, when there is a company A and company B, they compete for students who pass the exam from them. And the university knows the quality of these options. Suppose Mehmat takes those students who have passed in firm A, because they are strong in mathematics, and, for example, the Faculty of Art and Grandmia takes those who passed in the company in, because in this company more emphasis is on creative, imaginative thinking.
Then each child, having handed over the exam in different versions many times, will get the opportunity to think: “I passed this exam, scored so many points. I will try to hand over him there. After that, I will turn to all universities, and somewhere I will be able to get something. ” Super contours are in only a few Moscow universities. In most regions there are no wild contests. There will be no wild corruption on this, there are few children now. By the way, even the employees of the Ministry of Education and Science began to talk about the possibility of passing the exam several times.
We are scared by university corruption. But corruption is not a bribe taker-doctor or teacher. Corruption is a systemic phenomenon associated with power. If the rector can still be called a corrupt official, then it is not called a corrupt official of a university teacher who took the money for passing the exam is not. In the best case, it can be called a small bribe taker. We just have these concepts consciously mixed in order to set people to the “corrupt officials”-budgets and distract attention from the corruption of power.
Was the "Teacher" trade union with proposals to power? Did you listen to you?
For the past year and a half, all our appeals to some central authorities go like water in the sand. If earlier, for example, we were discussed with us, at least pretended to talk to us ... And since September last year I felt that the officials even stopped pretending that they are talking to us. Say, chat and boot, all the same we did everything as it should, and everything will be as we want.
Is there an opportunity to influence the Public Council under the Ministry of Education and Science? Through other sites?
Well, if I thought that it was completely impossible to influence, then, probably, I would be in some underground organization. Still, the trade union operates in the legal field, despite the fact that the FSB has become interested in us. The trade union was created 2 years ago in a wake of protest in the regions, just 2010-11 is a peak of protest against new wages, normative and subsidiary financing, increasing reporting, and constant humiliation of teachers. No wonder this coincided with the fact that 2010 was declared the year of the teacher.
Remember how 2010 began? From the show of the film "School" on the "First Channel". Teachers took this as a slap in the face. Teachers came to the Constituent Assembly, mainly already known for their protest activity in different regions. It was decided that it was necessary to create a trade union, which will actually be a trade union, that is, sets the goal of protecting the labor rights of its members. We immediately started with the fact that we are constantly advising all those who are addressing us. We developed different instructions on how to behave in certain cases.
About two years ago, teachers suddenly stopped paying a “presidential” thousand for the classroom leadership, and no one said why they stopped paying. We looked, and it turned out that the whole point is that the central department did not transfer money to the regions. And it was not listed because the regions did not conclude some agreement on time. From the point of view of the employee, it does not matter, which is why this happened. We wrote a typical statement to the prosecutor’s office with reference to the legislation, hung it on several large forums. In the first week, about 400 teachers downloaded it, and then they wrote that it really worked , that is, we really helped hundreds of teachers to get their earned money.
Questions about the work of teachers during the summer holidays are constantly going on. According to the law, they should work as much as they have training hours. And there are really directors who force the holidays, independently, to work teachers from 9 to 15 hours. We also explained how to deal with this, and many people used it.
Teachers do not know the most elementary things: what is an employment contract, and where to see when you sign a piece of paper that the director gives you. He does not know what the job description is. At the same time, we worked with the texts of laws, made proposals for the draft law “On Education”. In many ways, our proposals coincided with what O.N. Smolin, and Smolin took some things from us. But all our proposals that were submitted through different deputies were rejected.
We help not only teachers. We advise parents. In May 2012, we largely helped those Moscow schools that forced to merge. Including thanks to our actions, those schools that did not want to merge, left alone. We always say to officials of different levels: “Let's talk”! But you can talk only when you see that the second side is ready to listen and adequately react.
At a meeting at Polit.ru , Deputy Minister Igor Remorenko all the time nodded and said that he would take into account the offers of teachers, but, as I understand it, not a single recommendation, not a single proposal was then implemented in any way. And then no one called the teachers who came there. The authorities in every possible way shows that it will do without us, but we still "eat everything."
Well, it is.
So it is until teachers resort to measures, which are the main way to protect labor rights. Until people are striking ... As soon as people show that they are actually ready to stop the work, negotiations begin immediately with them. I think that in the future academic year, when the situation will become serious (from September a new law on education finally comes into force), we will see different options for strikes.
Why will teachers be forced to do this?
Firstly, due to the fact that their rights and social guarantees are significantly reduced in the new law. In the new law, an article about the working hours of teachers is very poorly spelled out. Secondly, because the new law involves per capita financing and a new payment system. Thirdly, because the new law all the schools rowing under one comb and does not allow a small school to survive. Teachers, first of all, want to teach children efficiently. But the case is more and more about paid education, more and more is going to reduce the opportunity to learn. When per capita financing triumphs, when there is little money, a small school, it means that we cannot give them a good education in full.
And most importantly, the new law transferred all powers to the regions. The region determines how much money to education. The region determines what the standard will be. In Moscow, the norm is good. I think that if at least a quarter of this standard were assigned to all the schools of Russia at least a federal law, it would be really useful. And so teachers or parents, complaining, are very fond of writing to the ministry, but now it’s not at the address, now we all depend on the region, and in the region these people are much more dependent on their small boss, they are afraid of him much more than a high boss. And fighting your, local boss is much more difficult.
So I think there will be a lot of conflicts. The main thing is that the parents do not turn against the school. When parents come to school on September 1 and find out that there will be no free circles, electives in their class, I hope that parents will not think that this is the school’s decision and that the class teacher of their children decided to cash in. It is necessary that parents understand: this is a systemic matter, not a school is to blame for a reduction in educational hours. So the law is arranged, so our education policy is arranged.
And something positive is happening? Distance education?
Remote education does not give the child any socialization. Remote education is a certain addition to school education. I think parents need to unite and demand from their regional authorities the normal financing of schools, normal freedom at school. Then at their school, it will probably be better.
It depends on specific parents, specific children. Suppose I don't like something at school, what should I do? Who should I unite with?
Yesterday, one dad filed a lawsuit against the Department of Education for violating the girl’s rights to education and the right of parents to information, because without his consent (and he is a member of the managing council) their kindergarten was leaked with some incomprehensible school. He demands to cancel the order of the department. In my opinion, there is reason to decide the court in his favor.
Parents are terrible power, a huge force. Any parent can destroy any school. It is to the parent that they turn always and everywhere, and the authorities look only at parents, and not at teachers. Therefore, just parents, I think, can do much more than teachers. Various parental movements are now much more active than our trade union, for example. They are very solid, respected, conducting interesting, creative actions. The faster parents think that for them teachers are natural allies, and teachers will figure out that for them parents - allies will be better. I only have hope, as they said 100 years ago, to the consciousness of the workers.
"Minister Livanova - Resignation"?
I don’t care about Minister Livanov, because such a policy in the field of education began not even with the past, but with the updated minister. So, the point is not in Livanov.
The case is in the Kremlin or what?
I don’t know, I can't say. The Kremlin - yes, a number of negative changes are associated with them. To say that it was they who deliberately did it? It may well be that they just tried to do everything so that it was as painless as possible. After all, all power is closed, we do not know what the true views of the president, the prime minister. Maybe he is just sympathetic to small schools in his soul and does everything possible to keep at least something.
What do you think of officials managing the Moscow education?
In the year before last, there was a situation when we sent Kalina a certain list of proposals - he did not react in any way, we sent S. Sobyanin. I know for sure that Sobyanin imposed a resolution "to figure it out and start working." We honestly waited for them to work with us, but did not wait. My colleagues, when specific schools defended, participated in negotiations with Kalina, it was normal - it was clear that there was a specific subject for conversation. I do not want to demonize anyone, it is not a matter of personalities, but in the existing approach to education.
And he is such that the authorities do what he wants? What is the main principle of this approach?
He is economic, he is accounting, this is an approach to education in terms of the effectiveness of the company. The plant should work, give the product. The restaurant should work effectively, collecting money. And they expect the same from the school - money. And society should, together with the authorities, formulate that there is a current social order for the school, which we want to educate, whom and how. The form of training and the content of learning depend on this.
Here, look, what is the exam paradox? First, the exam was invented, and then began to redo the standards. It should have been completely the opposite. The logic is this: first standards are written, then programs are written on them and textbooks are created, and then the questions and tasks of the exam are written on these textbooks. And we got exactly the opposite. У нас стандартов толком нет, если они и приняты, то в них нет никакого содержания. ЕГЭ существует сам по себе, учебники – сами по себе. Это реальная проблема, и ее надо было бы решать, а не проблему слияния школ. С точки зрения содержания, слияние не проблема. С точки зрения содержания, есть проблема педагогического образования будущих учителей. Чему учить педагогов? Но только не закрывать институт (как это сейчас делают повсеместно), а продумать, что необходимо для обучения будущих педагогов, и начать это делать. Но, к сожалению, об этом же даже речь не идет.