
Last night it became known that all active bloggers in Runet can calmly send each other, as well as all those around them, where they have pleased. So, at least, the Chuykin police captain, working in the Department of Internal Affairs of the Tver District of Moscow, decided: she refused the initiative group “Volgograd Breakthrough” to initiate a criminal case against Artemy Lebedev, a well -known Russian designer leading Tema Blog in a living magazine.
Blog Artemia Lebedeva is one of the most popular. In his LiveJournal, Lebedev tells the reader about the horrors of some aspects of Russian life with enviable frequency. For example, the author recently drew attention to how wretchedly Russian publishers draw up translated books, which were very pleasant in the original. The proposal of readers to show similar examples of “work” of domestic designers have collected more than 1300 comments. Artemy Lebedev is never shy about frankly sending all those whom he for some reason is not satisfied. At one time, he got to the members of the Fair Russia party, who wanted to arrange respect for himself in the campaign against his immorality and now he all the time in his blog is organizing the mockery of voting for “fair Russia”.
In early December, it became known that a certain initiative group of the Volgograd Breakthrough project “Speaking for the morality of the population of the Hero city of Volgograd and the whole country” decided to prepare a statement of claim to the prosecutor’s office with a request “to stop the unpunished use of non-normative vocabulary in the open access of the Internet”. It was not possible to submit a statement of claim to the prosecutor’s office, as a result, it got, as mentioned above, the police captain Chuykin, who works in the police department of the Tver district of Moscow.
We must pay tribute to Captain Chuikina. Often, deputies, officials, judges, law enforcement officers and other officials are trying to somehow influence the Internet community at all, how it works and by what laws he lives. In 2006, the justice of the peace found journalist Mikhail Afanasyev guilty of the “manufacture and distribution of products of an unregistered media”, sentenced to a fine with confiscation of the Internet site Khakasia.info. Many lawyers then fought over the method of seizing the site from the owner.
In 2008, the case of Blogger Savva Terentyev (who called on twice a day to burn on the main square of the city by the “wrong” policeman) was dismantled by the Syktyvkar court. The blogger was found guilty under the article “The excitement of hatred or enmity, as well as the humiliation of human dignity ... committed publicly or using the media,” that is, according to the very famous 282 article of the Criminal Code. In this matter, knowledgeable people were most amused by the fact that the experts attracted by the court took the definition of the concepts of “hatred” and “manipulation of public consciousness” from Wikipedia. That is, from a source that everyone who has Internet access can edit. On the basis of this “examination”, Savve Terentyev was given a deadline, at least conditional.
In the Duma, ideas constantly appear to oblige all bloggers to register their diaries as the media. Well, or at least not all, but only "thousands". True, this idea, so far, does not seem to be going to turn into a law, but its itself is very exciting Internet universality with its absurdity-with the same success, all shops on Tverskaya Street can be registered as the media, because there are much more than a thousand people a day passes a day.
So, Captain Chuykina either understands what's what on the Internet, or asked knowledgeable people, but I figured it out. The decision on the refusal to initiate a criminal case, whose scan was hung on his blog, Artemy Lebedev, it is said that a criminal case cannot be instituted due to the lack of corpus delicti. The lawyer of the Artlebadev company, which is led by the famous blogger, told the police that he could characterize the chef as a calm, reasonable person, not inclined to emotional unregulated explosions. According to the lawyer, for Lebedev, the use of non -normative vocabulary in speech is part of the image.
The policeman substantiated its decision with quite obvious things (which, in principle, would be enough for unsubscribing): the Livejournal service is not in the jurisdiction of Russia as it is physically located in the United States and is not the media. In addition to fairly obvious things, the policeman decided to paint in more detail about what is the most popular blog-platform in Russia and what is its essence (the official text has undergone some literary processing for a better understanding):
The site Livejournal.com (LJ) ... is a free community of which is the purpose of which is to provide the opportunity to express their thoughts, emotions, communicate with each other and publish their blogs under various pseudonyms (nicknames), i.e. It is a personal Internet space of each user. Based on the above, it follows that the author of the blog located at Tema.livejournal.com did not have a purposefully delight anyone, because He does not know and cannot know the personality of visiting his blog, and even more so who is hiding behind their nicknames. Moreover, during a detailed study of this page, it was found that all messages published on the above page are not addressed to specific users of LJ ..., i.e. The author of the blog exclusively expresses his personal opinion on various circumstances that occurred in his personal life. The specified page is located at a specific address ... and her visit is a voluntary will of its visitors.
It is difficult to disagree with the captain of the police Chuikina. It is hoped that such a position over time will become dominant by police officers, prosecutors, judges and deputies of the State Duma.