In the article “Features of the Current Moment” (“Rossiyskaya Gazeta”), Alexander Pyzhikov, an expert at the Center for the Development of the Information Society Foundation, made an attempt to analyze the development of political life in Russia since the collapse of the USSR.
The author compares the processes that took place in Eastern Europe after getting rid of Soviet influence and in Russia after 1991. The countries of the “Soviet bloc” existed in the same political model - and the collapse of this model gave rise to processes that were mostly the same. The same bias towards abstract collective values took place - but this time with an emphasis on democracy and liberalism. The abrupt beginning of the era of market relations, “wild capitalism,” inevitably entailed a rupture in society and, as a consequence, the “red restoration.” The return of the communists - this time more moderate, infected, to some extent, with liberal ideas - seemed inevitable, including for Russia.
The author’s statement that “broad layers of Russian society expect... a full-scale... leftist project” is not indisputable. For broad layers, stability is more important - and for the most part it does not matter under what sign. Of course, the left must have equal access to power. But the introduction of a “leftist project” into power could artificially return the country to the chaos of the 90s. In general, eliminating the erosion of the left wing, its deradicalization, are necessary for normal political life.
Historical realities turned out to be such that the CPSU was dead even before the collapse of the Soviet bloc - and the “rebirth” of the Communist Party in the form of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation turned out to be only a pale shadow of the past. The author overestimates the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, considering it the direct heir of the CPSU. In fact, this was just an attempt by the party apparatchiks to restore the previous mechanism, to use the same resources - but for this they did not have enough experience or charisma. The victory in the 1995 parliamentary elections, followed by a serious decrease in the number of supporting communists, shows the real reasons for the “Zyuganov phenomenon” - nostalgia for Soviet times, Soviet aesthetics. It is aesthetics, and not communist ideology, that is the source of the few young recruits in the ranks of the Communist Party. The author also ignored the aspect of serious stratification of the left movement, and this is necessary for analyzing the prospects of the left project, because the completely amorphous but loyal Communist Party of the Russian Federation was replaced by ultra-radical movements.
The fact that the left, having formally won the 1995 elections, did not actually gain power into their hands, was one of the reasons for the country’s slide into the pit of lawlessness. It was the short period of the “red restoration” that allowed liberals in Eastern European countries to come to their senses and adjust public policy, focusing on social aspects. In fact, in Russia, the “red renaissance” carried out in 1995-1999 would most likely have prevented the catastrophe of 1998 and, moreover, would not have given the opportunity to oligarchic groups to seriously influence the government. Unfortunately, the author does not disclose this scenario in his article. The realities turned out to be such that society acquired a persistent rejection of both liberal reforms and the concept of “liberalism” in principle.
One of the main tasks of the current moment is to integrate the left wing of Russian political movements into a unified model of political life. The “Left Project” should become a guarantee of calm in society, a transition to civilized political life. The elimination of radical sentiments in society, combined with the formation of a full-fledged left party, similar in strength and authority to the right-wing United Russia, may become the most serious political project of recent decades.
Fedor Sergeev