
The Alpina Non-Fixes Publishing House represents Stephen Pinker's book “The Best in us. Why violence in the world has become less ”(translation of Galina Borodina).
Faced with the endless stream of news about wars, crime and terrorism, it is easy to believe that we live in the worst period in the history of mankind. But Stephen Pinker shows in his amazing and exciting book that in fact everything is exactly the opposite: for millennia, violence has been reduced and we, in all likelihood, have been living in the very peaceful time in the history of our species.
In the past of the war, slavery, detonation, cruelty to children, murders, pogroms, crippling punishments, bloody clashes and manifestations of genocide were commonplace. But in our reality, the Pinker shows (including with the help of hundreds of graphs and cards) that all these types of violence have been significantly reduced and are more and more condemned by society. How did this happen? In this revolutionary work, Pinker explores the depths of human nature and, combining the story with psychology, draws an amazing picture of the world, which is increasingly abandoning violence. The author helps to understand our confusing motives - internal demons, who include us to violence, and good angels indicating the opposite path - and also trace how a change in living conditions helped our good angels take the upper hand.
Delassing the fatalistic myths that violence is an inalienable property of human civilization, and the time we live in is cursed, this bold and touching for a living book will undoubtedly cause hot disputes in the offices of politicians and scientists and in the homes of ordinary readers, since it questiones our views on society.
We offer to read an excerpt from the chapter in which Stephen Pinker discusses a significant decline in crime, which began in the United States in the 1990s.
To explain the decline in crime in the 90s, we must see what norms and how have changed at this time (just like a change in the norms helped to explain the growth of the number of crimes three decades earlier). Although police reform almost certainly contributed to the rapid decrease in violence in the United States, in particular in New York, do not forget that Canada and Western Europe also saw a decline in violence (although not so significant), and they did not overwhelm their prisons and police sections. Even the most stubborn specialists in criminal statistics surrendered and agreed that the main explanation should be sought in cultural and psychological changes, which are difficult to calculate.
The great decline in violence in the 1990s is one of the manifestations of the evolution of public morality, which can be called the process of re-civilization (recovery). To start with the fact that some of the most crazy ideas of the 1960s lost their attractiveness. The collapse of attempts to build communism and the awareness of the economic and humanitarian disasters that caused by it deprived the revolutionary violence of a romantic fleur and gave doubts about the reasonableness of the redistribution of wealth under the muzzle of a pistol. Wide awareness of rape and sexual harassment made the idea "If you like it, do it!" In the eyes of people repulsive, and not releasing. The monstrous immorality of violence in poor areas - children who fell under random bullets, churches filled with armed gangsters at the funeral of murdered adolescents - could no longer be explained by the natural reaction to racism and poverty.
The result was a wave of civilizational offensive. As we will see in Chapter 7, the positive heritage of the 1960s. The revolutions of civil rights became the rights of women, children, homosexuals, consolidated in the 1990s, when the Baby-Bummers themselves became an establishment. Their intolerance to rape, beating, crimes on the basis of hatred, the pursuance of gays and cruel treatment of children contributed to rethinking the idea of the law-I-order on a progressive basis, and efforts to turn residential areas, workplaces, schools and streets into vulnerable groups of places (as in the feministic campaign of protest “We will return the night for ourselves” [1] ) made life safer for everyone.
One of the most impressive civilizational offenses of the 1990s was undertaken by African American communities, which set themselves the goal of re-civilizing their young people. As with the pacification of the American West 100 years ago, women and the church made most efforts. In Boston, a group of priests, led by Ray Hammond, Eugene Rivers and Jeffrey Brown, conducted work to reduce the level of banditry in cooperation with the police and social services. They used their knowledge of local communities to identify the most dangerous gang members and make them understand that the police and neighbors are watching them. For this, meetings were held with the gang participants themselves and with grandmothers and mothers. The leaders of local communities also helped stop the cycle of revenge: they took the special control of any member of the gang, if he had recently been insulting, and forced him to abandon revenge. The intervention was effective not only because of the threat of arrest, but also because of external pressure, which provides a way out of the situation to consider himself offended. He could retreat without losing his face - so the two clungs of the brawl allow the puny witnesses to pull them in different directions. These efforts were crowned with the “Boston miracle” of the 1990s: the level of murders in the city fell five times and since then, with some fluctuations, remains at a low level.
The police and the courts, in turn, began to use criminal punishments not only as a strict means of holding back and deprivation of rights, but to confirm and strengthen the legitimacy of power - the second stage of the civilization process. The criminal justice system works properly not because the “rational agents” know that the big brother is following them in 24/7 mode and, in which case, will attack and impose a penalty exceeding any illegally acquired benefit. No democracy has neither resources nor the desire to turn society into a semblance of Skinner's box [2] . In principle, crimes can be identified and punished only selectively, and the selection of samples should be fair enough for citizens to consider the regime as a whole legitimate. A person believes in the legitimacy of power if he feels that the system is arranged so that he himself and, more importantly, his opponents have every chance of punishment in case of violation of the law, so that they all can learn how to suppress their motives, elastic attacks and self -revenge. But in many US jurisdictions, the punishment was so unpredictable that it seemed rather badly than a logical consequence of prohibited behavior. The criminals broke the trial period with impunity, failed a drug test, seeing that all this was also getting away with their friends, but once they became victims of evil rock for no reason and went to bars for many years.
Now, judges in cooperation with the police and leaders of local communities have changed the strategy for the fight against crime. They refused severe, but unpredictable punishments for major crimes in favor of modest, but adequate punishments for smaller violations, guaranteeing, for example, that a failure to appear at a hearing to pass the test term will cost the accused for several days in prison. Such measures were based on two properties of human psychology (which I explore in the chapter dedicated to our good angels). First: people, especially those who often have problems with the law, do not think about the future and react more to specific and immediate punishments than to probable and delayed. Second: people evaluate relations with other people and organizations from the point of view of morality - either as a game of winners and defeated, or as a fair and mutually observed agreement. Stephen Alm, a judge who invented the program “A test term with the provision of execution”, summed up: “When the system is inconsistent and unpredictable, when people are punished by randomly, they think:“ The inspector for supervision has disliked me ”or“ someone hid evil on me, ”but they should see that they treat all the violators of the law the same as the same as with them.”
The new offensive in order to moderate violence sought to strengthen the skills of empathy and self -control - the internal guards of the process of civilization. The Boston program was called the “coalition of ten points” in honor of the manifesto that formulates ten goals, for example: “to promote and popularize cultural changes that help reduce physical and verbal violence among black youth, initiating discussions, introspection and reflections on their thoughts and actions that slow down our development - personal and social.” The coalition also combines efforts with the program “Earth of the Cross”, developed by David Kennedy as the embodiment of the credo of Immanuel Kant: “Morality based only on external coercion is never enough.” Journalist John Sibruk described one of the events in the formation of empathy:
Once I watched a passionate, almost tangible desire to create an experience that can change the members of the gang. Her former member named Arthur Felps, whom everyone called Pops, rolled out a wheelchair with a 37-year-old woman to the center of the room. Her name was Margaret Long, and her body was paralyzed below the chest. “Seventeen years ago I shot this woman,” said Felps, sobbing. “And I have to live with this every day.” And Long exclaimed: "And I have to defecate in a bag!" - I pulled out a pawnshot from a wheelchair pocket and raised it. Young people looked at her in horror. The latter was the social worker Aaron Pullis, and when he shouted: “Your house is in fire! The whole building is on! Save yourself! Get up! " - Three quarters of those present jumped to their feet, as if they were pulled by the rope.
The civilizational offensive of the 1990s. pursued another goal - to emphasize the importance of responsibility. It is the last quality that is devoid of the life of a member of the gang. In the capital of the country, two male marchs widely illuminated in the press were held, whose participants confirmed the obligations to support their own children. In organized by Luis Farrahan [3], “Million Men” was participated in black men, in the “Mark of the Faithful Promot” under the auspices of the conservative Christian movement - white. Although both movements wore an unpleasant shade of ethnocentrism, sexism and religious fundamentalism, from a historical point of view they were part of a larger process - a return to the process of civilization. In the book “The Great Disruption”, political scientist Francis Fukuyama noticed that when the level of violence in the 90s decreased, the same thing happened with other signs of social pathology-divorces, dependence on social benefits, adolescence, exceptions to venereal diseases, traffic accidents and shootouts with an exceptions with shootouts from participation of adolescents.
The process of repeated civilization, observed in the last two decades, is not only a return to the direction, along which the West has moved since the Middle Ages. Historically, the process of civilization was born as a by -product of strengthening the state and the development of trade, while the recent decline in violence for the most part was the result of a civilizational offensive, which was intentionally undertaken to improve the conditions of people's existence. Another innovation is the gap between the external signs of civilization and the habit of empathy and self -control, which are most important to us.
[1] “Take Back The Night / Reclaim The Night) - international protest against sexual violence. - approx. scientific. Ed.
[2] Skinner's box is a laboratory device used to study animal behavior. - approx. scientific. Ed.
[3] Luis Farrakhan is the leader of the radical movement of the African Americans “Nation of Islam”. - approx. per.