And on TV in the Peres of Kurginyan, they continue to discuss the surge, the 1990s and desovetization. Ivan Efremov called one of his main novels “The Hour of the Bull”, because the bull is usually called the predawn time - the most dreary and depressing in the night. When hope fades, hopeless longing and horror awaken. When it seems that the morning does not come and there will be nothing better ahead than this oppressive and overwhelming hour. In the 2000s, the 1990s were nicknamed “dashing nineties”: the name was chosen quite condescendingly and correctly. Because dashing itself is not bad. A dashing guy is almost a synonym for the words “drenad”. But if the “dashing robber” or “dashing people”, then this is already bad. Everyone understood the “dashing nineties” in a different sense - “dashing robbers” and dashing, troubles, misfortunes. Although no one suggested exactly how to understand. They understood that way, because they lived at that time, and they “famously felt it.
There were “dashing bandits” and “dashing journalists”. And the dashing oligarchs - and their entire service "dashing staff". And also - “dashing democrats”, “dashing deputies”, “dashing liberals”. And all these epithets could be perceived as positive epithets. But for some reason, the words “dashing democrat” are subconsciously associated not with the words “dashing Cossack”, but with “dashing people” or even with “dashing one-eyed”.
“Echo of Moscow” came up with the contrast between “dashing 1990s or a time of hopes”! There is no contradiction: hope generally dies of the last. And in this sense, the 1990s are a time of hopes: the confident hope of some that it will never end, and the weak smoldering hope of others that this will still come to an end.
The first were very few, and it was a time of their hopes and themselves. The time of their right to meanness. The time of their right to steal. The time of their right to kill. The time of their right to betray. There were a lot of the second, and they did not always realize what the reason for the dashing dropped on them. Why were they condemned to poverty and humiliation: and not only humiliation from poverty, but humiliation is moral, since at least the first half of the 1990s is the time when all the TV channels and almost all newspapers were repeated daily, which people are flawed. And it was not just “propaganda” - it was an informational terror. What is the "time of hopes."
Now, for the rehabilitation of this “time of the bull” - the time of longing and hopelessness - a new image appears: “ In the 1990s there was also something that youth is trying not to remind you of. The incredible, tragically devoted and stalled impulse of the then Russia to a democratic ideal . ” Sentences of this kind are good in that they are beautiful and, because of this, attractive. The trouble is that it is not clear what they relate to and what they are confirmed. If there was a impulse, then rather to justice and renewal, and then, not in Russia, but in the USSR, and not in the 1990s, but in the mid-1980s. Because by the 1990s there was nothing left of him: there was a mass hysteria and the desire to disperse everyone, and first of all Gorbachev. The main mistake of the GKChP is not that they did not take the White House storm, but that on their first day they did not announce that Gorbachev was at least arrested as a traitor from the country. Instead, they stated that “ Mikhail Sergeyevich is not healthy, but he would join us yet ” - and this was their political suicide.
What is the desire for a "democratic ideal", what kind of fiction? The democratic ideal is " the power of the people, the hands of the people themselves in the interests of the people themselves ." This, in fact, is "demo." Which does not happen without "chatting" - that is, power, coercion and order. Those who fell into the hysteria of the crowds, brought by the stupidities of Gorbachev and the Yakovlevsky press to madness, which roared on the Squares , Yeltsin, Yeltsin , could become the basis of anything - autocracy, kleptocracy, fascism, monarchism, but not democracy. Because democracy cannot be based on the denial of "fraud", and these crowds did not want to obey anyone at that moment. Because democracy is impossible if the “demos” does not realize at least its immediate interests. And how these crowds were then “recognized” (not because they were stupid, but because they were under the constant information blow of manipulation of consciousness) showed what they themselves received after 1991.
And they were not a people. Just because the people as a whole did not go to these five -minute hatred. Already in 1990, he was disgusting to look at deputies who were unable to make a single intelligible decision to the television cameras. By the way, in 1991, Yeltsin did not particularly want: in the presidential election from all voters he received only 42% of the vote. And there was no convincing alternative. And when in 1992 an experiment with Gaidar earned him, and people were forced to remember how it costs months without oil, meat and sugar, they cursed everything, and many went on the square . But what did they want? If you focus on the 1995 Fomovsky study, in the answer to the question of whether it was necessary to start perestroika at all, you can see a deep public split with a noticeable outweight of its opponents. 40% of all respondents responded positively to him, while negatively 45%, with 15% - undeniable.
Considering those who still supported perestroika, we will see not only internal heterogeneity, but also a clear predominance of supporters of the socialist system. To the question " How should perestroika be carried out ?" - 27% replied that it was not necessary to spend it at all. Another 27% believed that it should be carried out without destroying the socialist system, 2% believed that the “perestroika” had to be carried out as it was carried out, 12% - that it was necessary to move more decisively to democracy and the Western type market, 18% believed that it was necessary to advance to the market, slowly with the introduction of democracy. In a transformation to the realities of the second half of the 1980s, this meant a movement towards the market under the leadership of the Communist Party, i.e. Something similar to the NEPU of the 1920s or the “Chinese version”. 12% found it difficult to answer.
Thus, 27% of tough opponents of perestroika in the amount of from 27% of supporters of its socialist version give the majority and prevail over the sum of the supporters of its real (2%) and a more decisive Western version (12%) more than three times. Even if you add 18% of the supporters of the “Chinese path” to the latter, we have to admit that the number of adherents of socialist orientation far exceeded the number of supporters of the capitalist development version. Where is there at least in Russian, at least in English you can find a “impulse to a democratic ideal”? “Western type more decisively advance to democracy and the market” - 12%. Spend as it was carried out - 2%. Unless such a impulse was for those who did not want to go beyond the socialist system.
Here is a picture of the values of Russian societies identified in the research of Igor Klyamkin in the first half of the 1990s. Values are given in decreasing order [1] :
The world is 56%, the legality - 52%, safety - 48%, the family - 46%, labor - 42%, stability - 42%, justice - 37%, wealth - 37%, order - 36%, power - 35%, prosperity - 33%, freedom - 29%, culture - 28%, spirituality - 24%, mercy –23%, adherence to decrease. - 22%, progress - 20%, consent - 19%, democracy - 18%, professionalism - 15%, equality - 15%, patriotism - 15%, success - 15%, power - 14%, union - 14%, dignity - 13%, property - 12%, hope - 10%, market - 8%, renewing - 6%, career - 5%, activity - activity - activity - activity - activity - activity - activity - activity - activity - activity - activity - activity 5%, reform - 6%, collectivism - 4%.
But his studies in a year: conscience is 60%, labor - 57%, human rights - 56%, money - 54%(wealth - 13%), legality - 54%, freedom - 47%, spirituality - 41%(faith in God - 21%), property - 37%(privacy - 22%), equality - 25%, democracy - 21% [2] .
Where is the "impulse to a democratic ideal?"
The democratic ideal, among other things, is the ability to self -organization and self -discipline. They were not in sight. Because those who formed public consciousness in those years did not seek these goals. The goals of the destruction of consciousness and the transformation of people into a controlled and manipulated mass were set. Because those who did this had their own “democratic ideal”, saw him in ensuring that the masses obey, obey them, thought and vote as it should. “Democracy” is the power of those who appropriated the name “Democrats”. But the fact that the people and citizens then were incredibly and tragically deceived and betrayed is, of course, true.
The truth is what to say today to youth and all those who have not experienced this time, as if there was some kind of “impulse to a democratic ideal” - it means to deceive these people today. Once again and in the same purpose - to repeat the experience of total manipulation by them. And they need to tell the truth: the 1990s are a tragic and terrible time in the history of the country, the time when the country was crucified, devoted and sold. The time when the vast majority of the population had no hope, because those who did not kill her - she died.
And the main thing that cannot be allowed today is that this is repeated. So that they-the 1990s-came again. Because these were the years of the bull, when hope was dying and ruled horror and despair.
Notes:
[1] policy. 1993. No. 6. S. 44.
[2] policy. 1994. No. 4.