From the editorial office. February 1, 2011 marks the 80th anniversary of the birth of the first President of Russia Boris Nikolayevich Yeltsin. The anniversary is already celebrated. In blogs, in the journalistic texts of Yeltsin, they remember with special feelings - albeit different - but always very bright. In memory of this state figure, RSA opens a discussion about the role of the first president in the formation of new Russia.
* * *
"Democracy is the worst form of government, except for everyone else"
Winston Churchill
They say that “De Mortuis Aut Bene , Aut Nihil”, therefore, Boris Yeltsin, perhaps, would be worth a silence. But the other day Tatyana Yeltsin-Dyachenko-Yumasheva spoke out in the sense that, they say, it was a “most humane person”, and therefore, like his forerunner in this hypostasis, Yeltsin and now more lively than all the living. However, it is much more important that lively, and sometimes wins his business. So we will talk not about the man Yeltsin (let him rest with the world!), But about the First President of Russia and his heritage, which we have to rake for a very, very long time.
The main trouble of all Russian history is that the reformers were absolutely not valued in it, but the revolutionaries, for whom it was important to lift Russia to a hook-for someone for the “bright future”, for someone for the “window to Europe”, were always on horseback. True reformers were either rejected by force or hopelessly late. Alexander the Second and Peter Stolypin fell victims of attempts, Alexei Kosygin quietly and unobtrusively wiped the levers of real power. The name of another failed reformer, shot in 1953 and slandered by his killers, I, perhaps, simply will not mention personal security for personal security. And when Mikhail Gorbachev tried to reform something, it turned out that it was useless and stupid to sew patches for a long time and irrevocably rotten fabric.
Therefore, the reformer Gorbachev quite naturally replaced the revolutionary Yeltsin. And this is neither his special merit nor his guilt - this happened, and history does not know the subjunctive mood. Well, we did not find our Dan Xiaopin!
Now you can guess for a long time whether there were other possibilities of leaving the pit into which the country led the country more than seventy -year -old reign of the Communists. And what would happen if the Lenin-Stalinist tragedy had not repeated in the form of a Brezhnev farce. In the end, did the Brezhnev regime need an almost total ban on trips abroad and equating any contacts with foreigners almost to anti-state activities-I'm not talking about rock music and avant-garde painting? And if the state monopoly in the economy could not cope with the satisfaction of minimal consumer demand (recall the era of the total deficiency of the late 1970s-early 1980s), would it not be worth allowing private entrepreneurship to the economy, at least in the bastard volume in which it was done in the NEP era?
Again: history does not know the subjunctive mood, but history knows the principle of analogy. And China’s experience shows that if, say, in the 1970s (and better-earlier) real reforms were carried out without revolutionary breaking everything and all through the knee, then the economy would not have come to the collapse, and there, you look, and the country would not have collapsed. But this, so to speak, reasoning in favor of the poor - this was not done, and, as they say, every nation is worthy of the government that has it.
So: that which is usually called Yeltsin (sometimes, depending on the political addictions of the speaker and the writer, Gaidar) reforms, and that there was no reforms, but was the real revolution with all the positive and negative concentrations of this term, did not at all depend on the will and desires of specific actors, but was caused The era and the depth of the pit into which the once great country fell to the second half of the 1980s. “Upper Volta with missiles” is bitter, but, alas, in many ways an adequate characteristic of the state in which the country was.
There were two ways - and both are worse: either to stay in this pit and turn into a kind of North Korea, which occupies one sixth of the land, or climb up. And it happened - in many ways by chance that Yeltsin became a public figure, personifying this movement. There would be no Yeltsin, there would be someone else, but the essence of the process would not have changed. And not because the then shock therapy was such a good thing - just everything else that could be offered real at that time was even worse.
And this characteristic of the “smallest of evils” accompanied Yeltsin throughout his reign.
1990, election of the Chairman of the Supreme Council of the RSFSR. Yeltsin resists the leader shortly before the created Communist Party of the RSFSR Ivan Polozkov. It is too funny to comment.
1991, GKChP. Nobody ever then, nor now he tried to calmly and impartially analyze the program of the puffers-these were too odious personalities to expect something worthwhile from them.
1993, the real danger of the Civil War and the coming to the power of openly fascist forces. And no matter how condemn the execution of the parliament (and this is certainly worthy of condemnation), but the alternative was even more terrible.
1996, the second term of Yeltsin. And then and now they wondered a lot: how did Yeltsin with a rating of 2% managed to win the elections? It seems that the answer is simple: the main strategic success of the entire Yeltsin team, which ensured his victory in 1996, was that shortly before this managed to hold the Communist Party of the Communist Party of the Communist Party of the Maximum Anti -Arismatical Gennady Zyuganov. If someone else was in the place of the opponent of Yeltsin, no seven-banking would have broken the situation.
The above does not mean that nothing depended on Yeltsin at all. But let's figure out what exactly became the result of the focused activity of Yeltsin and his team.
They say that he managed to make the union broke up without great blood. I do not know what the “big” and “small” blood means - for me, so the blood of one innocently killed is already a big blood. But the largest blood in the modern history of our country was nevertheless ceased not Yeltsin, but Gorbachev by putting the end of a meaningless massacre in Afghanistan.
And Yeltsin? Let's not forget that it was he who began two Chechen wars. Moreover, acting in full accordance with the domestic tradition: first create an enemy in the person of the frostbitten regime of Johar Dudaev and his gangster clique, to arm it beyond measure, and then, when there is no other way out, to give up all his strength to suppress the created enemy himself.
I’m not talking about the blood that poured on the streets of Russian cities in the “dashing nineties” or about terrorist attacks that became ordinary phenomenon precisely because in the Yeltsin years in the North Caucasus, well -fortified and conspicurated nests of the militants were created, which are still not possible to destroy.
They also tell us that Yeltsin gave us freedom. Which one? Freedom of rallies? Her people took the Java order in 1989 - 1990, when Yeltsin was not yet ours, and he was practically almost no one.
Freedom of speech? I don’t know who how, and in Brezhnev times I spoke quite freely at home or friends in the kitchen. And if now the site for statements was flowing from the kitchen to the Internet, then what does Yeltsin have to do with it? He did not create a worldwide web and numerous social networks.
And some freedom, perhaps, turned out to be superfluous. For example, freedom for the Gusinsko-Berezovsko-Khodorkovskaya (the list can be continued endlessly) chantraphs unhindered to rob my country, or freedom for all Nemtsov-lemonovs to arrange their cheerful parades on the triumphal square.
So, not agreeing with Winston Churchill in principle (absolute, and better the theocratic monarchy is still a higher form of state structure), he is forced to admit that he was right in relation to the Yeltsin era: Democracy (read: Yeltsin and his team)-it was the worst option for the then Russia, except for all the rest.