
The author of the following text is a university teacher of humanitarian disciplines. He, respectively, has no medical education. Due to life circumstances, however, in recent years he had to return to hospitals repeatedly, and he had some impressions of them, echoing with each other. This text is a brief analysis of these impressions carried out from a certain angle of view - by the one that is marked in the title that requires, perhaps, some explanations .
A person entering the hospital belongs to two realities. For several hours, he passes the procedure, passes tests, answers the questions of doctors during the bypass; It is drawn into the process of active treatment, which is the main meaning of his stay in the hospital. But there was a lunch, doctors are focused on his affairs, a person first rests, then walks along the corridors, reads, talks with his comrades (if, of course, this is not a severe patient, requiring constant attention and medical influence).
But this is the usual distribution of time in accordance with the approved schedule of the day. Why can you see some "reality", and even more so the "two"?
In the old days of the musicians (it seems, only in the old days) there was a term - "organ point". It meant an organ tone that sounded throughout the play or its part and created an active semantic background on which the melody was perceived. The second half of the hospital day and classes filling it, with their moods, impressions, conversations, forms of time organization, human and professional relations, make up such an organ point. However, for the second half of the day it is not exhausted. The impressions and relationships that have developed within the framework of such a "point" are also stained in the first half of the day, and sometimes they are projected onto all their stay in the hospital, affecting in a certain way on its results.
Today it is worth thinking about the role that such a "tone" plays. We will call it more precisely: atmosphere. Of course, the health of a person who has been to the hospital is not decided by her. Its health depends on many incomparably more important circumstances - on the orders that have developed in this area, on the administration and financing, from the qualifications of doctors, from the organization of medical work, from providing modern equipment, medicines and from many, many other things. But all these determining circumstances are humanized, become the direct personally experienced hospital reality, affect the impressions of the patient, his nerves and attitude and thereby, apparently, affect the results of his treatment, maybe even become part of it.
The field of my observations over such a "atmosphere" - thereby the content of the following story - will again be dual.
On the one hand, they will be a stay in the Moscow City Hospital #23, in the department of emergency cardiology, where I have repeatedly hit with severe heart attacks. But these impressions will gain their more complete meaning, as it seems to me, being complemented by impressions of other clinics - foreign ones, where I also had to get everything with the same heartfits - Germany (Berlin, Clinic Sharite), Spain (Torrein in the distant vicinity of Malaga, Clinic of St. Elena) - and Moscow (the first city hospital, a department of neurology). I repeat and emphasize: I want and it is important to tell you not about the actual medical side of the matter. In it, I should not be competent and should not judge it: in the listed hospitals I was cured or, in any case, facilitated my illness; This is enough to experience, first of all, a sense of gratitude. But to notice and identify those features that characterize the "atmosphere", to describe and analyze them, probably, starting, starting with the periphery of my hospital impressions abroad and focusing on their core in the above Moscow hospital. This experience, probably, can be not useful to hospital and health care as a whole, which, judging by official messages, on the materials of the press and television, is acquiring priority for our society.
Berlin. Two "atmospheric" features were remembered by me from being in Sharite.
One of them is the thoroughness and intelligence with which the doctor from the very beginning, only proceeding to treatment, reminds the patient that he "is in a democratic country" and that, accordingly, nothing can be done with him during the treatment that he would not be understood and approved. Long and rather complex explanations of the nature of the disease, logic and methods of its treatment begin. It’s good or not, I can’t judge. A sister comes more often, puts two tablets on the table and says: "You will take this one after breakfast; this one is before dinner." Can a patient always (and should) understand which organs and how these tablets affect? But in the "atmosphere" of the Berlin clinic, such clarifications are included (or in any case entered in my time) invariably, occupying a considerable place in it.
Another impression of the same clinic concerns a completely different side of hospital reality. We are talking about work in the wards of young people called up for an alternative service. These young guys in white robes come on top of the uniform for a short while, do the black work in the wards, general cleaning, but polite, attentive, warning and at the same time bring tea or coffee and fruits from time to time, offering them to the sick and visits visitors. They are offered in vain, in the form of treats on behalf of the hospital, and, I must say, a lot contribute to the softening of a harsh and often sad clinical atmosphere, introducing elements of cordial and comfort into it.
Torre Molinas. The small buildings of the hospital are located on a vast lawn, built up with small cottages with one or two rooms with a kitchen and a bathroom. These cottages surrender to patients at their request and with the permission of the doctor so that they undergo a course of treatment in the hospital, and for the rest of the time live with their family like all other resorters who come to relax in this popular coastal town. Doctors told me that this organization effectively helps the hospital financially and at the same time helps them to carry out medical work, creating a comfortable and calm atmosphere (two of them used this very word).
Another feature of this, it seems, is the ordinary Spanish clinic in the national diversity of the composition of nurses. They came to my ward in order to carry out medical procedures, except for two Spanies, an Englishwoman, a Swede and Belgian. Their work made the impression of friendly, effective and well -coordinated, which, too, could not but help the creation of atmosphere of calm trust and sympathy in patients. Answering my questions, the sisters said that such an exchange is widespread and brings positive results, leading to the borrowing of procedural techniques, in the nursing schools of this country are few well -known. I note that this principle will also spread in our other priority region - in university education. I mean the so -called Bologna agreements that provide for the exchange of teachers and students and the mutual recognition of diplomas between Russian and Western European universities.
Moscow (first Grad Hospital). On the atmosphere of this hospital (at least the neurological department), the most unusual way for me was the presence in the wards and in the corridors of the nuns (or, perhaps, parishioners of the nearby church). As they explained to me (I don’t know how reliably), the hospital has an agreement with them, according to which they, in the order of fulfilling the Christian duty of mercy, constantly go here and provide assistance to those patients who need it - of course, not medical, but related to everyday life and departure. As in previous cases described, this helps to create an atmosphere of philanthropy and readiness to help in the hospital.
The review speaks of some trends manifested in modern hospital life - trends, in the opinion of the patient undoubtedly positive and, perhaps, requiring discussion and distribution. The impulse to such a review, as the above, was the author’s experience accumulated in the department of emergency cardiology of the Moscow City Hospital #23, where such trends are represented, as it seems, especially expressively.
Pargeon people, apparently, fall into this department in the same way as in all other hospitals, but there is one feature here, which is found, however, in other places, although, it seems, not so often. The department has a special service of television facilities (this service is also called "Care"). Leaving the hospital after a cure, having signed up among the patients of this service, you get a miniature device that allows you to remove your cardiogram yourself and transmit it to the department in an encrypted sound form. From 9 a.m. to 9 pm, the doctors are taken on duty. Their main task is to immediately determine whether the threat of heart attack is visible on the cardiogram, or, God forbid, it has already occurred. In this case, the doctor immediately agrees with the ambulance, which takes the patient and delivers him to the 23rd hospital. Usually the situation is not so tragically, and the violation that reflected on the cardiogram is eliminated: you called because you are very alarmed. In this case, it is not the responsibility of the doctor on duty in this case, he only insures you from heart attack. But the atmosphere here is such that you will still be provided with help, you will still receive a brief and most desired advice, and this, I say from my own experience, is often a very great relief - both for you and your family.
But everything was not the worst way, and you, having spent the necessary time in the resuscitation department, are putting into the ward, where four or five people are already lying. Usually this situation is not easy. Sartre once wrote that "hell is a small room in which three people are locked forever." We will not get involved: hell is not hell and not at all forever, but unwell and therefore vulnerable, nervous people who are constantly experiencing the need for care, meet considerable difficulties in establishing contacts with each other. I do not know how this turns out in the 23rd hospital, but, according to my observations, the composition of patients in the ward most often turns out to be relatively homogeneous from the point of view of the habit of behavior, communication and the cultural level. Disputes due to an open or closed window, someone turned on or turned off the radio receiver and too high-profile conversations with visiting relatives, if they spoil life, then there are few people. And this is undeniable another achievement of the heads of the department.
Near each bed on the wall, a sister call button is strengthened. Having arrived for the first time, the sister explains to you that up to her appearance, you should not let go of the button. In other words, her arrival cannot be deposited more than a minute - another. She, to the best of her competence, provides assistance to the patient, who called her, and if one goes beyond her competence, invites the attendant - or the duty officer - a doctor. He prescribes a cardiogram or the corresponding procedure that is carried out immediately, the results are reported to the doctor who prescribed the procedure, who, if necessary, is consulted - immediately or the next morning - with his colleagues or higher specialists. Both professors leading this department control every similar case. During the bypass, both of them, talking with each specific patient, are completely aware of what happened and taken measures. Probably, in this sequence of actions there is nothing unusual, but a strong impression makes the clearly perceived coherence of all links of this chain, interchangeability and mutual assistance of employees of each level, their noticeable benevolence not only to patients, but also to each other, effective democracy of the entire system.
Finally, about what, probably, it should be started. Entering the department that professors E.Yu.vasilieva and A.V. Shpektor are in charge, you immediately fall into a special atmosphere not only in the metaphorical, but also in the literal sense of the word - well -ventilated corridors, breathtakingly and several times a wiped floor and walls, two foye with green plants and soft sofas, where walking patients are talking. With their visitors, the paintings hung along the walls - abstractions, rhythm of lines and color spots of which acts soothingly.
Thomas Mann has an article "On the Spirit of Medicine" (1925). “The goal of that variety of humanistic science called medicine,” says it, “no matter how deep it is to study the disease and death,” a person and a person remains, the restoration of the human idea in all its purity. ” This goal of humanistic science is achieved diverse. Including - through an organ point, which sounds more and more, we hope, today in stationary medical institutions. We tried to present their brief review, hoping that his sounds would grow stronger and spill wider.