From the editorial office. Today, the question of the return of the Russian Federation to Afghanistan is becoming particularly relevant, because the self -removal of Russia as a player in the Afghan arena has led to the fact that our state has lost its former allies without acquiring new ones. And in connection with the recently held informal meeting, NATO ambassadors with the special representative of Russia in NATO has acquired even greater relevance.
On Tuesday, January 27, 2009, a round table organized jointly by the Institute of Demography, Migration and Regional Development, the Effective Policy Fund and the editorship of the Russian Journal was held in the Business Center, 2009. The meeting was dedicated to the "new Afghan policy of Russia." Below is the performance of the moderator of the round table , Yuri Vasilievich Krupnov.
* * *
The theme of Afghanistan unexpectedly gained greater conjunctural significance in connection with the NATO ambassadors with the special representative of Russia in NATO Dmitry Rogozin on the eve of the on the eve of the on the eve of the on the eve of the on the eve of the on the eve of the on the eve of the on the eve of it. At this meeting, serious statements regarding NATO were made. Judging by these statements, in addition to the complex and difficult to resolve the situation around Ukraine and Georgia, the central issue and one of the main directions of positive cooperation for NATO and Russia is to ensure surgery in Afghanistan.
The problem of whether Russia needs to support NATO in Afghanistan, immediately acquired a more convex character: now you can’t just talk about whether it is necessary or not, but serious arguments are needed. What is given today as arguments, for example, by the same respected Dmitry Olegovich Rogozin, of course, requires serious analysis.
However, it seems to me that these are arguments of a slightly different time, and not 2009. I create the feeling that we are again slowly returning to the fall of 2001, when, after the well -known events of September 11, we made decisions, in my opinion, not coinciding with the strategic interests of Russia. And this, perhaps, is even more important than the opportunity to solve the problem of Afghanistan.
The task of our round table is that we put out our points of view, the arguments “for” and “against” the cooperation with NATO, the “pros” and “against” NATO support that the alliance today is committing in Afghanistan. I will briefly declare my position - it is quite tough and unambiguous, not very diplomatic. But I hope that since there are more aged political scientists and even more so diplomats, even if I am somewhere too hard and unequivocal, in the end we will move on to a normal, aged and objective discussion of the situation.
In my opinion, today in the relations of Russia and NATO in Afghanistan there are several myths that determine the behavior of the political elite of the Russian Federation. First of all, the elites are not the first, but the second echelon.
The first myth is that NATO, along with the United States (I specifically distinguish the United States, although this, of course, is a key member of NATO) solve Russia's problems in fact at their own expense, spending several hundred billions of dollars together. Like, if the NATO troops, which were currently about 70 thousand people, were not in Afghanistan, then Russia would fully receive a lot of negative consequences, up to the most tragic ones.
The second myth, the same rooted, but more conspirological and more informal, is when people who claim to own the real situation and play Real Politic begin to reason like that. Yes, of course, NATO is an ambitious and very aggressive block. He is strongly tuned against Russia. Of course, we should not support NATO in Afghanistan. But we must welcome the fact that NATO is in Afghanistan, because it sharply weakens the United States and NATO, as a result of which, as one senior official told me, NATO and the USA will bent in Afghanistan - he used this word - and Russia will become the main beneficiary of this process.
Here, in my opinion, are two myths that are outwardly opposite.
Remember, until recently, the same advertising slogan was very fashionable on television: “Tefal, you always think about us.” Since this slogan, obviously, was very much implemented into the minds of our elites, representatives of the first position say: thank you, NATO, that you solve our problems for us, and it’s good that we are not touching, we can still take the position of non-interference. And the second position is that NATO is very bad there, NATO climbed into its second Vietnam, and therefore the worse than NATO, the better Russia.
In my opinion, both the first and second positions, firstly, do not reflect the real situation. And secondly, neither the position of NATO’s victory, nor the position of NATO defeat meets the long-term interests of either the world community or Russia.
Regarding the fact that NATO solves our issues for us. Of course, the main trump card is terrible Taliban. Dmitry Olegovich Rogozin in his characteristic talented and artistic manner repeated this at Echo of Moscow. Like, if not for NATO, standing in Afghanistan, then these Taliban would have gone to Moscow and, approximately like German troops in October 1941, would have already stood near Moscow. Dmitry Olegovich directly stated: imagine if NATO had not been in Afghanistan, Taliban and other extremists would have been at least in Kazakhstan and our Russian guys died in battles in Kazakhstan.
Those who know the real problem and studied the history of the formation of mass consciousness, they know very well that this design is that the Taliban will soon reach Moscow, to the Volga and pose a real danger to Russia, was born in 1998, primarily in the American media. Then the Taliban, realizing that they suddenly, unexpectedly from a special detachment that realized individual special operations, turn into the leading political power of Afghanistan and have the opportunity to become actually state -forming force, practically ceased to obey those people in Pakistan, who directly created the Taliban, and those people in the United States (primarily in the CIA), which actively participated in the creation of the Taliban. After the Taliban became an uncontrollable, the first ideological reaction was the idea that the Taliban, collecting extremists from around the world, would direct its activities primarily against Central Asia, and then Russia.
This design can be traced according to the newspapers of those years, including our, where political scientists of different orientations in unison discussed that the Taliban would soon be on the Volga - this is a literal quote. Even if any grounds for this design were in the late 90s, then the Taliban of the 1996, 1998, 2000 and 2009 are completely different Taliban, which only a person who does not understand the real situation can compare with each other.
Already in 2000, the Taliban began to comply with many requirements of international organizations and the world community. In 2001, in fact, the production of heroin and the yield of opiates at the request of the international community were reduced by 20 times - as they wanted international recognition.
Currently, Taliban is not a centralized structure uniting the entire opposition and real resistance forces in Afghanistan. "Taliban" as a single force does not exist. A very funny reflection of this is that the two very serious political scientists with whom I discussed the problems of the Taliban, two completely different people, without saying each other, said that they were calling the same phone somewhere. At the same time, no one knows where the owner of this phone is located, but he cheerfully and with great artistry tells that once again something has done the Taliban movement. In fact, he acts as an informal and absolutely no one authorized by the press secretary of the mullah Omar.
The second myth, related to the fact that NATO is bending in Afghanistan that this is the second Vietnam, where NATO will find his destruction. This is wrong. And moreover, for the American establishment, such comparisons are a joke. On January 21, in the State Department, Hillary Clinton presented as a special representative of the United States in Afghanistan and Pakistan Richard Holbruck - the most prominent diplomat, a tough diplomat who was actually one of the authors of Yugoslav’s defeat. Holbrook even joked in a small performance. At first I did not understand why people laugh. The fact is that Holbrook began his career in Saigon during the Vietnam War. He said: I see a Negroponta with whom we lived in Saigon in the same room. So, I am sure that the situation in Afghanistan will be fundamentally different than then in Saigon. And everyone laughed.
This is a very accurate indicator that no one in the American establishment is considering Afghanistan, unlike the same Iraq as some kind of black hole, which sucks everyone against the will from which it is necessary to leave faster. On the contrary, as we know, the United States officially announced the introduction of 20-30 thousand people of an additional contingent. And if we look at how the military-industrial complex is seriously supported by this war, what geostrategic and military-political tasks solve the United States and NATO, having 13 air base (of which two are Bagram and Shindand-the largest, with a runway of more than 3.3 kilometers), we will see that NATO and the USA feel great in Afghanistan.
And only the absolute ignorance of realities allows you to fantasize about the fact that they will be bad there, they will bent, and someone will receive something from this.
Thus, these two myths show, I would say that the serious inadequacy of our political elites or the unwillingness to do what today represents the nerve of world politics. Barack Obama said shortly before the inauguration that Afghanistan is a focus of all foreign American politics. The most serious people, serious forces gather around Afghanistan, is a point on the situation in which all world politics really depends. Our elite, it seems to me, is inadequate to this situation, does not understand the situation, does not know what to offer, and cannot offer anything.
When they say that NATO and the United States are very bad in Afghanistan, we see that the United States and NATO are perfectly playing this situation. And in addition to obtaining a military-strategic bridgehead-a unique, which controls the entire, so to speak, US gas station in the person of the Near and Middle East, in addition to this, thousands of issues are resolved.
I'll list the simplest. The first is a serious interaction directly in the underblying with China. After Brzezinsky’s article that the two should be formed in the Financial Times, that is, in fact, the US union and whale is not an eight, not seven, and not twenty, but a deuce - in my opinion, it became obvious that a serious interface for negotiations and long -term interaction was created in Afghanistan. And no abstract confrontation between them is such, you know, childish: these are bad, these good, these are enemies - there have not been and have not been between them in the last twenty years.
The second point is the question of the ties of the United States with Iran. Afghanistan has been a key negotter between the United States and Iran in the past six months. While we repeat all the slogans of the last year, and someone and a ten-year ago, the world geopolitical map really changes, and the Middle East, Central Asia is radically transformed, and the Americans agree with Iran through Afghanistan using this bridgehead.
I can continue these examples. The brightest, one of the most important events of the outgoing year is, of course, a terrorist attack in Mumbai. It is obvious to everyone that in this India is drawn into a situation in Afghanistan through tension with Pakistan. And thus, all the key players - Iran, India, China - actually ceased to exist in the Middle and Middle East, and hegemony is carried out in order to control primarily hydrocarbon and other resources and solving geopolitical problems.
I will summarize. I believe that the question is not whether to support NATO or not, or, for example, from tomorrow to ban the transit of NATO non -person cargo through Russia. The problem is not in these convulsive and hysterical steps, and not in endless fantasies about the fact that NATO solves our problems for us, holds back the Taliban, who will stand with Moscow tomorrow. It seems to me that from these fairy tales-I simply will not find another word, except for some more abusive-I need to proceed to a sober understanding of the situation and to detect the interests of Russia. And they are known: Russia and, in particular, Russian Siberia, Trans -Urals, to the Far East, is vitally interested in direct, close, primarily economic cooperation with the Middle East, where Central Asia is our natural bridgehead and mediator. And therefore, we must go to a new Afghan policy, solve our problems, conduct our course, and not invent myths and fairy tales in order to somehow exist in this difficult situation of the financial crisis and the changing geopolitical map of the world.