From the editorial office. The election struggle for the chair of the President of Ukraine is resigned to its end. Very soon, to decide who will rule the closest neighbor of Russia over the next few years. Accordingly, the Russian political class worries the name of the one whom the Russian government supports. But if President Dmitry Medvedev and Prime Minister Vladimir Putin evaded a direct answer to this question, then United Russia through the mouth of the deputy Zatulin named the name of his candidate. As expected, they became Viktor Yanukovych, who visited the XI Congress of the Russian Party of power as a guest . So, who will win in Ukraine and what awaits it ahead? "Russian Journal" initiates a discussion on the issue of the future of the Republic of Ukraine.
* * *
As you know, the election of the head of state is, in addition to the names of applicants, advertising campaigns and scandals, also the choice of a political course that can formulate and realize answers to the vital issues of the political agenda. These answers will be significant not only for the state in which the presidential elections are held, but also for all neighbors of this state. So, we have a reason to consider the agenda of the Ukrainian state. And having compared the list of candidates with slogans, promises and programs of Ukrainian candidates, to evaluate how much they are able to rule our country.
Endless story
Ukrainian Constitution-Topic No. 1 of the last 5-7 years. If in the inter -election period in the first place is the interpretation of its provisions and the struggle for the authority of its granted, then during the elections the topic of reforming the Basic Law is traditionally aggravated. But otherwise it cannot be. After all, the situation of dual power, when constant clashes occur between the president and the Prime Minister due to intersecting powers, and the state apparatus simultaneously goes to two opposite sides, step by step leads to the degradation of the state as such.
In accordance with the Constitution of Ukraine, the president is the head of state, has his quota for candidates in the formation of the Cabinet of Ministers (Minister of Defense, Minister of Foreign Affairs), appoints governors and heads of district administrations. In other words, he controls part of the executive vertical. In addition, the presidential quota is increasing if the political faction he represented is part of the majority coalition. This means that the president gets the opportunity to offer his candidates for posts of other ministers. For example, in the current government of Ukraine, the creatures of the Yushchenkovskaya “Our Ukraine-People’s Self-Defense”-Deputy Prime Minister Ivan Vasyunyk, Health Minister Vasily Knyazevich, Minister of Culture Vasily Vovkun. However, the Prime Minister of Ukraine, the vertical of ministries and departments elected by the Parliament, and through the allocation of budget funds has its own lever of influence on governors and district chapters. In other words, there is no clear distinction between the authority between the president of the country and its Prime Minister on a number of issues. That is why conflicts flash periodically on this basis.
Despite the fact that there is a wide range of positions on the reform of the constitution, there are only two real options-this is the Presidential-Parliamentary Republic or the Parliamentary Red Publishment in its purest form.
President Viktor Yushchenko stands for the presidential and parliamentary form of government, and suggests a new constitution to be adopted at a popular referendum. Once upon a time, the Party of Regions declared similar initiatives. But if the president moves step by step in this direction - in the spring his project was presented in the parliament, and at the moment a popular discussion is taking place, then Yanukovych did not go further than words, and today the theme of the constitution is not at all the central topic of his election campaign.
In the early elections of 2007, the Blok Yulia Tymoshenko threatened to hold a parallel referendum on the voting day in order to bear his own version of the Basic Law on it. What is the position of BYUT now? Today the topic of constitutional reform is frozen. Yulia Tymoshenko could not decide what form of government she supports-purely parliamentary or presidential parliamentary. Why, it will act depending on the development of the situation and its own prospects.
Another end of the political spectrum stands for the parliamentary republic, more attractive to the Ukrainian oligarchy. On this side of the barricades is the leader of the Socialist Party Alexander Moroz and communist No. 1 Peter Simonenko.
In any case, the fault line in this matter lies and will run between the current president and other political players. If the current president is automatically forced to fight for an increase in his influence and powers, then oligarchic clans and most parliamentary parties - teeth, horns and claws for the parliamentary version.
But not everything is so simple. In free Ukraine, where the word “democracy” is simply stuck in the teeth, there are 2 more polar positions in relation to the constitution, one of which is preferred not to illuminate.
Position No. 1, the main representative of which is the current President Viktor Yushchenko, is a referendum and the adoption of the Basic Law by the whole people.
The second idea is to solve the issue without the participation of the people-as this happened in 1996 and 2004. Another such attempt was made in the summer of 2009 BYUT and the Party of Regions, but the planned coalition fell apart even before the announcement of its creation.
In this situation, another moment is alarming. As the events of 2004 showed, the presidential election is the most favorable moment to edit the Basic Law. So, history can be repeated.
The regions are asking for fire
The new model of the “Center-Regions” relations is the fact of the last 18 years, which with the approach of the presidential and then local elections in the spring of 2010 sounded several tones louder. The situation and the presence of several conflicting centers in power is heated, which, of course, negatively affects solving local problems.
Will the governors be elected? How will local and regional councils form - according to a proportional, majority or mixed model? Suppose the regions will have the opportunity to leave part of the collected taxes and fees in their budget, and the local authorities will receive a wider range of powers, where it will not be necessary to carry out the construction of a bridge or a rural road through a bureaucratic labyrinth of Kyiv. But how will control over the activities of regional chiefs from the central government be exercised?
In the end, all regions of Ukraine differ in industrial and agrarian potential, social and national slices of the population. Roughly speaking, for the export sectors of Donbass, the issue of VAT will be extremely important, and in Crimea the local authorities will be interested in tax training camps from tourism activities. Another question is how to determine what amount of authority to transfer to the local authorities in Chernivtsi and in Kyiv? How much will this package of rights and obligations differ between Crimea and Lugansk?
If we put these questions on statements, slogans and programs of presidential candidates, we will see that no one suggested a comprehensive answer. That is, the discussion of the reform has not advanced further than slogans and promises. None of the political leaders and forces made specific proposals on the mechanism of the reform itself, the scope of the powers transferred to the places of authority, calculating the socio-economic consequences of such a step.
Best of choice
On the one hand, “open lists” are a fashionable “trick” of today's elections, and nothing more. On the other hand, the mood of society indicates that purely party lists do not enjoy the support of voters. Moreover, they cause rejection. Confirmation of this is a constantly growing number of unwilling people to go to the polls, spoiled by ballots and votes “against all”. What next - the fall of the turnout “to the plinth” and the world community recognizes the elections such that they do not reflect the will of the people and do not comply with democratic standards?
The implementation of the model, when the candidate will nominate in the district on behalf of the political party is a chance for local elites to reach a new level. The proportional election system not only led to distortion when most deputies in the Verkhovna Rada have a Kyiv residence permit. The imperative mandate made it impossible for the deputy, chosen, for example, from the Luhansk region, to lobby for the interests of local business and officials, if this is contrary to the opinion of the leadership of the faction. It turns out that local elites, even if they have a decisive influence in their Ternopol or Volyn region, are detached from influence on political decisions at the country's level.
As you can see, the new election scheme and the reform of local self -government are in a close conjunction with each other.
And again-everyone promises to introduce “open lists”. But how sincere are such promises? Over the past 5 years, the feudal form of government has finally entrenched in Ukraine. And one of its supports is a proportionate. Indeed, in fact, party lists in Ukrainian realities are only an illusion of choice. In fact, this is a mechanism when the richest families and clans delegate their representatives to the Verkhovna Rada, like the feudal lords, merchants and the third estate without any elections, according to the quotal principle, formed English parliament or French general states.
Post Crisis
The crisis, unjustifiably brutally hit the wallets and capabilities of Ukrainians,, among other things, highlighted that the economic model of Ukraine was dragging several rusty anchors to the bottom. Firstly, this is the export nature of the economy, which instantly began to fever with the redistribution of pipes, metal rolling and steel. Secondly, a weak domestic market that has been agonizing for a year due to a fall in the standard of living of a middle Ukrainian. Thirdly, manual control, which Tymoshenko’s office brought to virtuosity. And, most importantly, the oligarchic character of the Ukrainian economic model. And this means that the state apparatus is privatized by financial and industrial groups. That the government acts as a lobbying company that accepts orders with oligarchs in exchange for money and political support, working on the principle of the private office “Money - Product - Money”, completely excluding the tasks and challenges from the sphere of their interests that are facing the state as a whole. That such strategic tasks as the modernization of the industrial base, the support of new industries that will be in demand on world markets tomorrow, no one is engaged in the development of the ETC domestic market - everyone focuses on “fast money” and maximum profit at minimal costs.
The crisis will end and be forgotten. But sooner or later a point will come when the state is unable to fulfill its tasks. What will it be? Social default, when one day it will become impossible to pay even penny pensions and salaries to state employees? Separatists' speeches and the threat of the collapse of the country? Or a defeat in a diplomatic conflict with another state? Furious street protests that are waiting for us when leaving the crisis?
New redistribution?
Among other things, the presidential elections are traditionally considered as a starting point for redistribution of property and spheres of influence. The question is only on the scale - it will be point or global. Today we exist with the same unresolved problem as 5 and 10 years ago: most Ukrainians are sure that factories, factories and steamboats went to the current owners are dishonest. And this means that, in fact, in Ukraine there is still no legitimate property right, there is no legitimate owner. A change in the political layout, the loss of the “political” roof, corrupt justice - all this in the complex means that the threat of asset loss exists constantly. Moreover, it is absolutely regardless of whether this business was earned or simply parasitizes in the state -based enterprises. This problem can be ignored, but it still remains a mine with an hourly mechanism that will once tear.
But if the issue of property guarantees has not yet been resolved in the mass consciousness and in the legal field, only an option of backstage agreements remains. What can such agreements include? First of all, the issue of guarantees, which means that ownership will not be dependent on the political belonging of the owner and the change of head of state. And this, in turn, means that the enlargement of assets, as now, will occur “according to the law of the jungle” - due to small and medium -sized businesses.
Nothing happens
Ukrainians are too accustomed to the deceptive opinion that the presidential election is a matter of choice between 2-3 candidates. While this should be the choice between coordinate systems, control work, where applicants offer their answers to topical questions of the existing agenda.
And what do we see? In fact, no one proposes options for the country's development routes. It is “essentially”, because in words the majority of candidates are trying to appoint “guilty” for the economic crisis and political mess, but this is not about words and promises. Today, everyone promises reforms - from the opposition Yatsenyuk and Yanukovych, to Yulia Tymoshenko, who has been in power for two years, but in her pre -election program also wrote herself to the opposition. But for some reason, no one says, due to which, and what methods these reforms will be realized. And the most important thing that prevented him from at least trying to do this over the past 5, 10, 18 years? However, few people already believe in promises - otherwise the number of those who are not going to take part in the elections or are preparing to vote “against all” at all. From the point of view of the issues vital for Ukraine, the presidential election receive a firm “non -performance”. Only 46 million Ukrainians remain, who live with this "unacceptable". More precisely, suffer and survive. That is why the formulation of the question Yanukovych or Tymoshenko, or someone third, is relevant, but not far away.