
There is nothing more productive than understanding your own defeats.
Today's Moscow party is a buzzing hive. Every day invitations come to the email - to seminars, round tables, public lectures, press clubs ... Intellectual bohemia - I deliberately cancel the word "elite" - chews the disaster of politics, which is already understood at the level of its own, class loss of territory.
Yesterday, these people were politicians, leaders of public opinion, cultural authorities, "experts" who composed together the political class - the support of power. And suddenly all of them at the same time - even those who were born in the late 70s and came to politics yesterday’s schoolboy in the second half of the 90s - turned into a community of pensioners in communal cuisine, unnecessary, yesterday and powerless.
Instead of them, free -and -blessed people - partly with corns from shoulders, partly with the baths of the "owners", partly with traces of tattoos on hairy fingers - find out relations in some biological dialogue of fluids, in a fundamentally non -verbal and abusive language of feelings and instincts.
No one managed to understand how Bohemia came out so shamefully and mediocre for power - that one, its part of power, which is meant when the formulas such as "rulers of the Duma" pronounce. They, as life showed, turned out to be not powerful even over their own thoughts - what can we say about the power over the thoughts of others? Above the country's Duma?
People threw Bohemia into a landfill, handing their fate to the estate of the Mlazy; Bohemia was recorded not even in enemies, but in harmful, but non -hazardous, in essence, parasites. The nineties are a story about how Bohemia, for nothing, was virtually absolute power over the country, sold it out of cheap: for smiles and sausages - for the west, for small loot - a lads and Komsomol members, for fear - the detachments of "werewolves in uniform", for the opportunity to experiment with economic models on living people - social protests; For laziness, that is, for just like that - feudal woman, thief and impostors. And now - the seemingly eternal dumplor, from which a black, oily power, dried up, was exhausted with a fountain. Its latest convulsions are still heard - in Ukrainian, Kazakhstani, Kyrgyz, etc. elections, but it is clear that it will end soon.
When this stream still lived, but already pretty much, Naishul appeared and said: yes, all this, they say, because we do not have a political language ! That concepts for each mean their own, and we cannot agree on more than two ... And mobilization does not work, and political thought does not exist, and the newspapers all lie, and the right leve and liberalism-conservatism creates a feeling of noodles (aka PR) ...
Let me, but fifteen years ago, millions gathered in Moscow squares, without the "lands" and "kings" pulled out from the Museum of Local History! How did we manage for such a period - less than half a half - to start talking? What did it happen that a single Russian social language, in which perestroika was performed, at Bohemia flowed through the fingers, broke up into a whole assortment of tiny discursive dictionaries and dictionaries, of two or three concepts, significant only for fan clubs of several dozens of specially trained people?
"The high Russian political language of the 16th century ..." What, in general, the Russian sixteenth century for those who studied in our modern "Soviet" school created by European nineteenth and twentieth?
Only by looking at it at such an angle, you understand the whole severlessness of the actual bohemian reflection. She - Bohemia - is looking for a fictitious past, composes it no worse than teenagers from the Elf, because her real past , the genuine reality of the historical past - the taboo, rejected and supplanted zone. No one has the courage to recognize the truth and talk to each other on behalf of themselves - people formed by Soviet history. The history, the central figure of which - the most silent, mythologized and distorted - is not Lenin, Hitler, Zhukov, Gorbachev or Sakharov, but Joseph Stalin.
Psychoanalysis, rejected and spat on with intellectuals, nevertheless taught them one of an unconditionally useful thing. The fact that it is impossible to defeat the complex by simply forgetting about it - on the contrary, the crowding out of the problem from consciousness into the subconscious is the most right path to transfer it to the chronicle. It is very useful to remember to all those who have gained the habit of talking about the Soviet past in the language of a retreat pathos or a retreatment stake.
That is why the only possible point of assembly of the Russian political language lies in the same plane of taboo meanings - in the rethinking and overdo of the Soviet one. Until the apophatic perestroika glossary is put into scrap, with the help of which we operate with the history of our own fathers, grandfathers and great -grandfathers (not metaphorical, but literal), it is impossible to restore the continuity of state construction in Russia.
It is impossible to call the civil war in the 30s within the 30s of the winners of the 20s, to call "Stalinist repression" or "era of great terror"-this is a murderous self-deception, which is more likely to be by the 60th and 80s than to the 30th. It is impossible to call Stalin a "dictator", "father of the peoples", "leader of the world proletariat", etc. evaluative epithets. It is impossible to find out who attacked anyone - the USSR on Germany or Germany on the USSR. It is impossible to live, sealing some labels with others and explaining nothing in essence.
Finally, it is impossible to create a social and even more political language, without having a historical language.
This last thesis requires explanation.
Make a tongue
When they say that the generals (as well as politicians) are preparing only for the past wars, this is only a negligible part of the iceberg of truth. She herself is much wider: the whole culture in a sense is nothing more than an instrumentation of the fight against the challenges of the past. Institutes, traditions, ways are just ways to broadcast the experience of past generations by solving certain problems that once already faced people - that is why culture is always so defenseless before the future.
Power in its forced, forcibly aspects - more than anything else, is a system of overcoming time. It is very easy to notice on the example of English lighthouses created with Alexander Auzan, created with private money, but then given to the state administration. Things that are intended to combat threats that once arose and have been overcome are transferred to the authorities so that it retains them, although there are no more threats themselves - and, therefore, there is no subject that would be vitally interested in maintaining them. The authorities in this understanding are a museum, a collection of all kinds of antiquities, unnecessary unnecessary to anyone individually, or even all together - but still preserved, no matter how expensive such preservation is.
In this sense, we always very strangely understood democracy. It seemed to us all the time that the sovereignty above the ground belongs only to the totality of the now living. Those who lived on it before us are always excluded from the list of copyright holders. According to this logic, the Bolsheviks demolished the temples and built in their place to sortes - on the grounds that "now" the cult structures are already irrelevant. The simple idea that your great -great -grandfather who built this temple for decades in order to pray to God here is also entitled to claim to participate in resolving the issue of this place, never occurred to it. But the Bolshevik system, in fact, positioned itself from the very beginning as antiquity, the state-owned state that is being built from the future, and not from the past, and therefore opposed to it.
Human economic expansion, permanent reconstruction of the world to him - always anarchist thing; It is always a rebellion, adventure, overcoming everyday life. But the most difficult task in such a case is to separate what needs to be reorganized, from what needs to be preserved in invariability; Pass through the time. The totality of the preserved and is the culture - the space of images and samples, the eternal standards from which momentary copies for the day of the day are all the time. So, using some word, we create and use, consume such a copy - the original is stored in the collective memory of the community of native speakers and is changed by centuries and generations. The creation of new words is not just inventing, but their introduction into the collective memory of society - there is a cultural act, creativity of timeless.
In this sense, an actual political and wider, social language is exactly the same copy from a historical language. Speaking about the political “now”, we apply images from timeless “always” our collective memory for the current political moment - and only in this case we get the technical opportunity to meaningfully engage in politics.
Even the dead, artificial, decisively explaining the political language of European democracies of the New Age, all these “right” and “left”, “liberalisms” and “socialisms”, “conservatism” and “modernisms”, even the “authoritarianism” and “democracy” - there are concepts existing exactly to the extent that they are filled with living history, even anxdods, even anxdos. - "Who was sitting in parliament on the right hand of the king, and who is on the left."
For some reason, it seems to us that the political language can be created artificially-it is simply to develop, like Esperanto: to come up with a dictionary, write texts on it, "promote" somehow-and went and went! Actually, the whole Bohemia, in his free time from the sale of power, was engaged in this, breaking into circles and groups of interests - composed and published dictionaries: “liberal”, “conservative”, “patriotic,“ left ”, etc. ... However, all this word -making never withstand the test of reality, because it is impossible to come up with a name - it is only possible to give a name to what is .
And there is only in one place - in the historical reality of their own country, existing in its collective memory. And as long as the living history of the Russian twentieth century will be taboo, and in fact, it is given to mythology, we will exist in the "bad infinity" of social bustle. In the kitchen.
New historicism
One of the main problems of bohemia, which makes it impossible, including conversation about history, is the exhaustion of genres. We can endlessly comment on the news, write articles and large essays, give and take interviews, even compose and publish books - any such impulse stalls, because even the book, with the current turnover of the printing market, has an too short temporary horizon of active action today.
Apparently, solving this particular problem, Gleb Pavlovsky rejected the new -old genre, publishing a collection of his conversations with Mikhail Gifter - " History Training ." The text itself is a book of questions where each plot unfolds in ten others, operating in the framework of dialogue formats and open to it. In other words, “training” is not a book, but a genre: what is now more than ever necessary for everyone who dreams about the Russian Social Language project is an elongation of temporary horizon of thinking through regular, systematic training on history.
Gifter and Pavlovsky in the book are alternatives in relation to the alternative itself, dissidents from Dissent. The language, which this position allows us to describe the drama of power and the category of Russianness, turns out - even then, in the second half of the 80s - “different” both in relation to the Soviet and in relation to anti -Soviet and all remarks on it. A book that begins with a recognition of readiness to sign under the notes of the dog - dog death, which the Chekists laid in the pockets of the executed Kamenev and Zinoviev, and ending with the manifesto of Russia's decentralization, the project of the Russian world as the “countries of the countries” - looks like a provocation even now; It is easy to imagine how this would sound in the 89th. However, then it was simply nobody to read.
Now, having trapped the word "globalization" from all sides, we are not scared of the way of thinking, in which the whole world is in a sense of Russian territory. The world is built from Russia and it is exhausted by it, and any Spanish or Chinese event is also its own universalist Russian. At the same time, the consciousness of the Russian Jew Huffter is arranged so that for him formal control of the national or imperial administration over the territory and its inclusion in the world are different things; He is not afraid to think about Russian in diasporas, understanding the flexible mind that power can be carried out in a variety of ways and, according to Churchill, "prefers the essence of power to its form."
Another feature is that the "Russian" for Hifter is a civilizational, not the national category. In other words, there are Russian Armenians, Russian Jews and Russian Ukrainians; However, there are no Russian Russians - there are Russian Donians, Russian Siberians, Russian northerners and so on. His vision of the future disclosure of Russia is a cultural, liability and administrative regionalization while maintaining the unity of central government - which, however, is not engaged in unification, but to increase and harmonize the diversity of territories.
Gifter resolutely hacks one of the main taboos, preserved even in the modern consciousness practically untouched since the 20th Congress - a taboo on Stalin’s neutral assessment. His Stalin is “not the Georgian punks, bursting into the Silver Age Temple”, but the first number of the list of creators of the world history of the end of the millennium. More fiercely, he attacks contemporary to him perestroika-slaughterhouses of tyranny precisely for the Stalinism that was not overcome inside themselves.
Actually, this is the main power of the “training” genre - the ability to operate with history for their own purposes precisely as the past, and not as endlessly repeating (“Happy New Year” - so they speak from the time of Brezhnev). The formula of new historicism - the present can be reconstructed only from the past, restoring the connection with it in all its continuity, recognizing it entirely, without a single seizure.
I am waiting for new history training.